Scholars who have closely examined William Walker's forays into Latin America (there aren't many of us) have largely agreed on the following crucial facts about the nineteenth century's most famous filibuster. First, the former newspaper editor was a skilled rhetorician who understood the power of the media and fine-tuned his message to suit his audience. When selling newspapers to the largely anti-slavery residents of San Francisco he published articles opposed to slavery. Not long after seizing power in Nicaragua in 1855, Walker established a bilingual newspaper in which he proclaimed himself the ‘Grey-Eyed Man of Destiny’ foretold in Nicaraguan legend, along with other lies designed to increase his power at the expense of his opponents. After his expulsion from Nicaragua and his return to the United States he published a radically pro-slavery narrative supporting his return to Central America as the best way to extend Anglo-Saxon hegemony throughout the hemisphere. Second, Walker's highest principle was opportunism, a fact made clear when he reintroduced slavery into Nicaragua because doing so appeared to offer a means of gaining US support. Third, Walker, like the country that produced him and his many violent expansionist brethren (men who killed Indians and Mexicans in pursuit of a supposedly manifest destiny that appeared nearly boundless in the late 1840s), was bad for Nicaragua. His destruction of the colonial city of Granada, which he set on fire when fleeing the isthmus, has come to symbolise the toxic nature of his reign. To this day, Walker's name is synonymous throughout Central America with US rapacity. Nicaragua's most important national holiday celebrates the first native victory over Walker's army.
Michel Gobat's compelling account of Walker's empire offers a radically revisionist reading of both Walker and his impact on Nicaragua that demands that readers reconsider all of these points. In Gobat's words, historians who have focused on the ugly side of manifest destiny, like the atrocities committed by Walker's army and the spectre of race war that was never far below the surface, have engaged in ‘a tyrannical regionalism’ that has obscured the role that antebellum imperialism played in ‘an international conversation about “progress”’ (p. 11). The true importance of Walker's empire, according to Gobat, is that it provided the international origins of US liberal imperialism.
Gobat's narrative starts with a consideration of the impact of the transit of Gold Rush settlers through Central America in the early 1850s. While other scholars have focused on the disruption ‘ugly Americans’ produced on the isthmus, Gobat makes a strong case that the US presence produced more support for Americanisation than opposition. Nicaraguans valued the entrepreneurialism of these visitors. They embraced US cultural forms, read US newspapers, learned English and voluntarily formed sexual liaisons with travellers from the United States. They particularly celebrated US technological advances. At the start of the 1850s, elites in Nicaragua were united by the belief that annexation to the United States would bring liberal institutions to the country as well as a US-financed canal that would ensure their prosperity. The presence of successful African Americans in Nicaragua also allowed liberals to envision a different kind of Americanisation. It was this widespread support that led Nicaraguan liberals to invite Walker and his armed US supporters to help them overthrow the Conservative Party government.
After military victory, Walker proved unwilling to share power with the men who had invited him. He quickly solidified control over the levers of government and won the presidency in a rigged election. With promises of free land and effortless prosperity, Walker lured thousands of US residents to settle in the country before being expelled by a coalition Central American army in 1857. Gobat points to the presence of anti-slavery reformers and African Americans among those settlers to support his argument that Walker's promises of uplift and liberal institutions were sincere.
Empire by Invitation is grounded in research conducted on three continents, with results that rival the very best transnational history. For example, by detailing the extent to which European settlers in Central America were financed by the private sector, Gobat convincingly explains why Nicaraguans leery of US annexation were willing to embrace Walker, despite the US dismemberment of Mexico a decade earlier.
But Gobat's account is at its strongest when he looks closely at the society Walker built in Nicaragua during his brief rule. Drawing on astoundingly detailed research, Gobat's description of Nicaraguan bureaucracy under Walker is notable as much for its masterful historical reconstruction as for its subversive argumentation. By fully revealing the manner in which Walker's government relied on local collaborators and institutions and engaged in ambitious financial and infrastructure projects, Gobat convincingly reveals how the Walker state was a ‘harbinger of liberal state formation’ (p. 188). The many maps and illustrations throughout the volume also deserve praise.
Gobat is less convincing when evaluating Walker's intentions and actions. Most considerations of Walker's filibustering career devote considerable space to his 1854 invasion of Mexico. With an army of just 200 men, Walker landed in Baja California and proclaimed himself president of a republic encompassing an area known for its rich mineral wealth. He legitimised his actions on the grounds that Mexicans were ‘an indolent and half civilized people’ (p. 61) and immediately adopted the Louisiana civil code, legalising slavery. The filibusters were quickly driven from Mexico, but when a jury of his peers acquitted Walker of violating US neutrality laws, his fame as a filibuster was established. Gobat devotes just two paragraphs to Walker's Republic of Lower California and dismisses both his virulent public racism and notable choice of civil code on the grounds that, after returning to San Francisco, Walker continued to denounce pro-slavery expansionism to Californian audiences. His attempt to justify Walker's decision to reintroduce slavery into Nicaragua is equally dependent on accepting Walker's rhetoric at face value. This is unfortunate, because making a convincing argument that Nicaraguans embraced Walker because they idealised US progress does not require showing that Walker's views were as uncorrupted as his followers imagined. Walker was ultimately just one man. One of the greatest strengths of Empire by Invitation is how it illuminates an invited empire that was not only more significant than scholars had previously realised, but far more capacious than the filibuster at its helm.
