Is alternative medicine a recent thing? Roberta a Bivins argues that it is much older than the seemingly recent trends; however, as it is known in the West, alternative medicine has a date of birth situated some time in the early modern period. No medicine can be ‘alternative’ until an orthodoxy has been established. Consequently, the possibility of alternatives could emerge only as medical pluralism was eclipsed. This book is not a straightforward narrative of the rise of the new pluralism, nor does it pretend to be a comprehensive account of period and place. Rather it presents case studies about a selection of interfaces between differing systems over the course of the last three and a half centuries. It is well written, concise yet wide-ranging, and could be useful in teaching.
A short introduction reviews the theory and practices of several rival systems of medicine. Then four chapters – each capable of being a stand-alone essay – trace encounters of observers with new medicines. Stories of initial scepticism and later conversion abound. Chapter 1 presents the motivation in seventeenth-century ‘customer dissatisfaction’ that led to explorations of moxibustion and acupuncture by travellers to Asia. In Chapter 2 special attention is given to mesmerism and homeopathy as two European alternatives. Acupuncture returns in Chapter 3 as an object of assimilation and experimentation in nineteenth-century medical science. Chapter 4 examines the advent of so-called orthodox medicine in non-Western contexts as a tool of imperialism and control, with a special focus on germ theory. The conclusion addresses the recent return to pluralism among elite consumers and practitioners and the implications of the supposed euphemism of ‘complementary medicine’. Endnotes document direct quotations, but instead of a full bibliography, an essay for ‘further reading’ accompanies each chapter.
The numerous lengthy and engaging quotations stem from diverse sources, most derived from works of historians and other scholars. Bivins herself admits that the book is based on secondary literature. Nevertheless, one strength of this book is the wide array of sources mined to create a ‘meta-analysis’ of scholarship on several systems in many places. Bivins reports having experienced a multiplicity of medicines during her childhood in Nigeria. Different though the modalities were, all preceded a recovery – whether or not they had caused it. Her background fosters the balanced and tolerant approach for which she strives, as if all systems are true, effective and deserving of respect within their natural contexts. She notes that well-intentioned European translations tended, through the enthusiasms and doubts of the interpreters, to introduce distortions of rigidity and narrowness. She incorporates interesting ideas about ‘patient-pull (and consumer networks) and physician-push (and professional networks) as engines of “medical multiculturalism”’ (p. 68).
On the back of the dust jacket, Roger Cooter pronounces this book a ‘brilliant foil to the privileging of Western medicine’. As he implies, the system that suffers most in the analysis – and perhaps inadvertently – is medical orthodoxy, which is sometimes held responsible for the abuses that have been made of it by some of its clients, practitioners and historians. It is occasionally characterized as static and monolithic – flaws that Bivins rightly decries in accounts of non-Western medicine. The interesting notion of modern biomedicine as an alternative within other cultures is recognized (p. 190) but beyond the scope of the study. Bivins reminds us that orthodox medicine could be a successful tool of imperialism only where it enjoyed a perception of usefulness among at least some of the colonized – just as consumers today turn to acupuncture or other cross-cultural systems, motivated by the perennial failings of modern medicine.
