In 1911 the University of London had the honour of hosting the First Universal Races Congress. Delegates discussed the relations between the so-called peoples of the East and West and decreed that hierarchies between them should be contested. It was also agreed to contest the ill-defined concept of ‘race’. Yet, as we know, in the eyes of some, notions of racial difference and hierarchy have persisted. By mapping the propagation of the pseudo-science of phrenology across the nineteenth century and into the early twentieth century, and within the context of movements to abolish slavery, this book offers insights into how and why this is the case.
The phantasms of phrenology, or the study of, and attribution of meaning to, cranial forms and bumps on the head, are the subject of the six chapters and extensive epilogue of Materials of the Mind. In this interdisciplinary work, histories of materiality and technology, science and geography meet to narrate how this shallow study of forms was understood to be indexical of a person's character and intelligence. James Poskett presents the material features which made and conveyed the topography of phrenological knowledge: Kandyan and Inuit skulls; casts of French slaves; lithographs in books such as Samuel George Morton's Crania Americana (1839); letters, periodicals and photographs which illustrated William Elliott Marshall's A Phrenologist amongst the Todas (1873).
The narrative demonstrates how certain people and institutions in one part of the world devised a system of knowledge that, to their minds, justified the subjugation and exploitation elsewhere of other peoples – in life as well as in death. Tracing phrenological practice to the German physician Franz Joseph Gall in late eighteenth-century Vienna, the story moves on as Poskett penetrates the Edinburgh Phrenological Society, the Melbourne Phrenological Museum and Public Library, the Calcutta Public Library, the Asiatic Society of Bengal, the Bombay Cercle littéraire, and the Société ethnologique de Paris and the Norfolk Island penitentiary in New South Wales. From Europe, the Upper Savage Islands of the Arctic, Civil War-era America, southern Africa, the Caribbean and India to the book's conclusion in twentieth-century China, phrenology specialized in making perceived parts stand in for perceived wholes. This is particularly well illustrated by the caste of Eustache, the French San Dominguan slave whose physiology and character were much scrutinized and taken as representative of an overall African character.
Hastened by technological innovations such as cheaper steam printing, the reach of phrenology expanded. Texts about ‘the doctrine of the skull’ held a powerful market appeal and outsold publications such as Darwin's Origin of Species (1859). The lack of standardization of its practices facilitated its transmission so that it did indeed, at least in name if not entirely in practice, become global. However, the object lessons of Poskett's chapters are less about a continuum of remediation than about various geographically particular, discontinuous and consistently idiosyncratic artifices of objects’ curation and evaluation. The urgent rewriting by Morgan of parts of his Crania and Edward Burnett Tylor's criticism of Marshall's Todas flesh out this tale about the duplicity of objects and the faith which humans around the world project onto them.
What were deemed to be ethnic, racial and national, but also geographical, identities were debated and negotiated in the language and community provided by phrenology. Lucretia Mott the American abolitionist spoke out against phrenological theories. Frederick Douglass, once a runaway slave, was also quick to identify and denounce phrenology's undergirding of slavery. Phrenological representations, he said, were exaggerated in order to link physiology to perceptions of African mental capacity and slavery (p. 129). That these dangerous fictions were mutually sustaining is troubling reading that historians can neither ignore nor forget. However, travel transforms. Poskett's close analysis of the instances in which these notionally scientific illusions were turned against their originating offenders gives hope. Such moments of contestation include that of the Sri Lankan rebel Kandyan chief Keppetipola, whose decapitation illustrates diverse forms of headhunting for political purposes, including by the British forces. Cally Coomar Das, a founder of the Calcuttta Phrenological Society, advanced Bengali-centred Indian nationalism via the Pamphleteer journal of the society. As its editor, Das effectively debated inherited versus environmentally fashioned phrenological differences and criticized both the Hindu caste system and the East India Company (p. 181).
That this book is about the universality of human suffering should not be overlooked. Whether bought into by patients or perpetrated by practitioners, phrenological ideas were peddled as a salve for individual woes and dreams, and for the latter it was a bandwagon on which to advance themselves. Materials of the Mind is also about the fallacies, and historical and geographical particularities, of human and non-human forms of knowledge that are too vaguely defined as scientific. The injustices and wickedness perpetrated in the name of science and empire went by the name of phrenology. This insightful and richly illustrated book therefore invites questions about the challenges and responsibilities that come from attempting to write histories of actors’ categories, and of constructs of science, the global and race. It forms another chapter in the enduring inexactness and changeability of knowledge and the often inadequate and deceptive material forms that its proponents have harnessed in order to convince others of its authority.
The thesis from which this book is drawn may more deeply problematize the histories and world views which have made violent distinctions between human populations and non-human materials. This geographer's eye read it as an important milestone in bridging the gap between wholly geographical entities. Another important story therefore underlies Materials of the Mind. Phrenological narratives ensnared human beings in a web of deceit. Yet they were also agents in engendering the conception of not one global consciousness, but multiple global consciousnesses.
