As its title suggests, Revenge versus Legality sets out to explore the connections and tensions produced by the possible responses to wrongdoing represented by a ‘vengeful’ reaction in preference to a ‘legalistic’ response. The exploration is supported by examples drawn from literature and film, hence the – rather unlikely – subtitle ‘Wild Justice from Balzac to Clint Eastwood and Abu Ghraib’, and as such is what might be called a ‘law, literature and film studies’ or ‘law and culture’ text. The text comments upon links between revenge and legality following an initial introductory chapter; Chapter 2 considers Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's Charles Augustus Milverton, Agatha Christie's Murder on the Orient Express and Susan Glaspell's A Jury of Her Peers; Chapter 3 discusses supernatural revenge in Sheridan Le Fanu's ‘Mr Justice Harbottle’; Chapter 4 looks at conspiracy and justice in Honore de Balzac's Le Pere Goriot; Chapter 5 explores justice, race and revenge in Mark Twain's Pudd'nhead Wilson; Chapter 6, imperialism and justice in E. M. Forster's A Passage to India; Chapter 7, race, sex, fear and revenge in Richard Wright's Native Son; with Chapter 8 entitled ‘State Terrorism and Revenge in André Brink's A Dry White Season’; and a final Chapter 9 looking at ‘Rogue Cops and Beltway Vigilantes’ and subtitled ‘Torture, Redemptive Violence and “American Ideals”; Justice Goes to the Movies; Dirty Harry, Death Wish and the Politics of Torture’. In terms of genre then, the texts consulted represent a range which spans classical and popular European literature as well as more modern American film, whilst topics include the blackmailing criminal, conspiracy, the diversion of evidence in the interests of private interpretations of justice, responses to individual and institutional racism, and vigilantism.
The introductory chapter begins with a quotation from Sir Francis Bacon's text of 1625, ‘On Revenge’, stating ‘Revenge is a kind of wild justice, which the more man's nature runs to the more ought law to weed it out’, alongside quotations from Oliver Wendell Holmes and a character, Jimmy Marcus, in the film Mystic River. This is followed by a brief excursus on the range of sources and viewpoints pronouncing upon the idea of revenge and retribution, from Mahatma Gandhi and Martin Luther King to Joseph Stalin, the Bible, anthropology and Hollywood, referencing along the way Verdi, Shakespeare and Weber, and taking in discussions of films from Mystic River to Clint Eastwood's Unforgiven. A key observation is that:
‘certain kinds of crimes, mysteries, injuries and transgressions seem to incite extralegal responses particularly strongly. Whether they occur in historical or fictional circumstances, these are the crimes or injuries that appear so mystifying or disturbing that ordinary, conventional legality – the usual, normative police procedures, judges’ rulings, lawyers' motions and jury verdicts – seem inadequate.' (p. 4)
Dividing such ‘special crimes’ into four categories, the Introduction explains that the ensuing chapters explore: (i) the ‘special crimes’ relating to ‘locked rooms and magic bullets’, where ‘fictional detectives solve their cases with exemplary certainty and this certitude contributes to the moral authority they exercise by deciding that the homicides that occurred were justified and the victims deserved to die’ (p. 5); (ii) those relating to ‘crimes against kin’, where intimate relationships lead inquisitors to seek revenge without care for their own safety; (iii) crimes against symbolic places and persons, considered ‘so significant a part of a community's identity that an attack on them is considered an assault on the entire community itself’ (p. 6), noting that ‘if one adds race and sex as “sacrosanct” topics of discourse, then certain crimes against women, such as rape, take on a strongly symbolic significance’ (p. 7) (these themes are subsequently explored in Chapter 6 through examination of E. M. Forster's A Passage to India and in Chapter 7 in Richard Wright's Native Son); and (iv) a final category of ‘special crimes’ relates to ‘the police as criminals’ – ‘when position, privilege and prejudice are allied with power and force, including lethal force, how can injustice be avoided or injuries be avenged?’ (p. 8).
The text indicates that responses to this dilemma exist in the form of ‘carnival justice’, a term inspired by the writings of Bakhtin,Footnote 1 where, in contrast to the legality of the public sphere, which is monitored by rational public opinion and tries to keep law ‘separate from politics, passion and public resistance’ (Gewirtz, Reference Gewirtz, Brooks and Gewirtz1996, p. 135), carnival ‘expresses public or communal feelings that can take many forms and sometimes be highly irrational and/or political’ (p. 11), relating such responses in particular to the long-running attempts to indict Pinochet for his crimes against the Chilean people. In addition to ‘carnival justice’, ‘justice narratives’ also work to reveal and challenge failures in formal systems of justice; such narratives may be characterised by the inclusion of ‘Just Closures’, of ‘Redemptive Violence’ or ‘Cyclical Revenge’, the last encapsulating ‘the worst kind of ending’ where a ‘politics of vengeance’ gives rise to cycles of vengeance ‘which repeat through the generations and cause nations and communities to split along ethnic, sectarian or racial fault lines’ (p. 23).
These brief explanatory categories in the Introduction lead into a quite separate reflection on a litany of violent political events around the world from the last several decades, focusing in particular upon the post-9/11 American ‘War on Terror’ and its use of secret agencies and prisons such as that of Abu Ghraib. Ending with the view that such government activity is a ‘vigilante mentality disguised as legality’ (p. 27), that ‘the vigilante mentality has its virtues but they are romantic virtues, the charismatic loner obeying his own code rather than the law … ill-suited to heads of state who are expected to enforce laws, not circumvent or subvert them’ (p. 27), the Introduction sets the tone for the remaining chapters, using literary and film sources to illustrate a kind of register of instances of vengefulness reflecting such individual weaknesses, or resorted to where the law appears to offer an inadequate response to the reasonable expectations of citizens. Though earnest in the desire to highlight the intensity of instances of injustice in the ‘real’ world and combine such highlighting with engaging references to literary and cultural sources, the Introduction, like the remainder of the text, becomes caught in its own plethora of cross-referencing, awkward juxtapositions and uneasy analogies.
Thus the potential strength of this text is rather disguised by the form and presentation, for while the chapters could present an interesting and useful examination of critical themes, such themes become somewhat diluted and lost by the rather haphazard and somewhat passive approach undertaken. Taking just one example, the first substantive chapter, Chapter 2, ‘Revenge and the Detective Tradition’, which looks at texts by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and Agatha Christie, concluding with Glaspell's ‘A Jury of Her Peers’, might have recognised that the themes of detection and revenge hold somewhat less consistent linkages between the texts than the theme of material evidence as a forensic tool in the jurisprudence of the times. Furthermore, the uncritical and passive acceptance of the detective story genre as somehow contrived in order to make a profound point about the realities of justice overlooks the extent to which the original authors contrive, or fail to contrive, the plots. On the one hand, Agatha Christie is motivated by the desire to create an entertaining puzzle: Murder on the Orient Express is primarily entertainment and not meant as a credible murder story or comment upon justice, nor should it be treated as such. On the other hand, Revenge versus Legality fails to mention that Glaspell's ‘A Jury of Her Peers’ is based on the real-life murder of John Hossack, whose wife Margaret was unsuccessfully tried twice for the murder, her status as prime suspect indicated by her proximity to the crime (she claimed that she slept through her husband being bludgeoned next to her) and by the indications of her subjection to domestic abuse at his hands. Though Glaspell was a reporting journalist on the case in 1900, her subsequent text, hailed by some as a kind of feminist perspective given its treatment of women as sharp-eyed and subtle covert ‘detectives’ who dupe the professional, male counterparts, is perhaps a rather feeble account of a provoked wife. Revenge versus Legality notes:
‘Each new revelation about Minnie Wright and her marriage that tells why she finally killed her abusive husband is accompanied by an increasing sense of empathy and solidarity between her and Martha Hale and Mrs Peters. Looking at the Wright's stove, says Glaspell's narrative persona, Mrs Hale was “swept into her own thoughts, thinking of what it would mean, year after year, to have that stove to wrestle with,” and Mrs Peters supplements that insight with the comment, “A person gets discouraged – and loses heart” … The most powerful moment of empathy with Minnie Wright occurs after they discover the dead canary. Mrs Peters, who had wavered between her sympathy for Minnie Wright and her responsibility to what she calls “the law” suddenly remembers and tells a story from her own past about a kitten that tips the balance to empathy …’ (p. 44)
Not only does it seem odd not to advert to the real-life stimulus for the text, it is particularly so given that Revenge versus Legality is a critique of the relationship between the world of law and that of revenge. Furthermore, there is no critique of the narrative and character treatment itself – as the above passage makes clear, the reference to the stove and the dead canary are hardly compelling examples of the kind of vicious cruelty driving such women to fatal acts. The shortcomings here epitomise an aspect discoverable throughout the text, that of a lack of evidence of extensive research in support of each theme, especially in relation to those concerning to the law. There is in fact a close study of the relationship between Glaspell's fiction and the real trial in an article, also not mentioned in the text, by Patricia Bryan (Reference Bryan1997), an article which undertakes a careful and comprehensive survey of the relationship between the law and the literature of the tale, recognising in particular the irony inhering in the fact that evidence at trial of Margaret Hossack being a victim of domestic abuse was deployed as a motive for murder by prosecuting counsel, forcing the defence to mount an assertion of domestic harmony in response. For Bryan, the trial of Margaret Hossack and Glaspell's subsequent fiction together create a complex discourse upon the relationship between empathy and the development of justice. Through reading both:
‘We can become more aware of our own biases and expectations, which affect the way we see other people, as well as the biases and expectations that influence the stories lawyers tell and the way judges and juries interpret them. We can begin to achieve a more realistic sense of community, appreciating our similarities to other people, as well as our differences. We can, I believe, enrich and expand our perspective in a way that contributes to our ability, as a society, to define and achieve justice …’ (p. 1363)
This is a conclusion which seems much more sophisticated than the concluding gloss in the chapter in Revenge versus Legality that, by having the female characters in ‘A Jury of Her Peers’ conceal evidence, the women ‘subvert the official, male-dominated legal system’ (p. 46), so that ‘[o]nce again silence allows a “just” revenge’ (p. 46).
Though clearly motivated by a genuine desire to give expression to concern about past and current failures of international politics and law, such superficial treatment is evident in other parts of the book. There are elements of strength: for example, Chapter 6, concerned with ‘Imperialism and justice in E. M. Forster's A Passage to India’ (and rather clumsily and unnecessarily titled in addition ‘The Empire Strikes Back’) provides a lively and accessible discussion of Forster's text and the contextual issues of imperialism, inequality and the impact upon the possibility of justice. Even here though, research and referencing could ideally have been much more comprehensive. The rich possibilities raised by the text – the existential crisis for the individual, society and justice posed by the mystery of the event in the Marabar Caves, the complex, layered critique of legal process discoverable through the motifs of social and juristic organisation – could have been paid more extensive attention, as for example they are in an article by Kieran Dolin (Reference Dolin1994). The final chapter in Revenge versus Legality, ‘Rogue Cops and Beltway Vigilantes’, undertakes a survey of recent, mainly American, failings in politics and foreign policy, with a rather uneasy recourse to discussion of the development of American films dealing with violence and revenge, particularly Death Wish and Dirty Harry. Though the intention is clearly constructive – to highlight the need to preserve utmost respect and adherence to due process and the machinery of the law – the message does not spring readily from the combination of ideas and sources.
Overall, three major flaws seem evident in the construction of this text. First, the key notions of ‘revenge’ and ‘justice’ are not dealt with in any depth; it may be that this problem is created in part by the attempt to cover such vast themes in a relatively short text and amongst such a range of subtexts and topics. Though seminal texts relevant to the notion of revenge are flagged, such indications are fleeting and somewhat disorganised. More significantly – perhaps because the authors are scholars primarily of literature rather than law – the ideas of ‘legality’ and ‘justice’ receive less than adequate attention. ‘Legality’ needs careful treatment if it is to have any meaning, either within or outside the legal academy, whilst the jurisprudence of justice is philosophically complex and definitionally variable. Second, the organisation of the material fails to highlight the true potential themes indicated by the texts. Third – and this follows from the preceding points – the movement between long descriptive accounts of plot detail, which do not necessarily contribute to the larger philosophical questions, and sometimes superficial homilies on recent or current political events in the context of rather chaotic juxtapositions of topic and textual sources, produces a rather haphazard and thinly theorised series of observations. As a primer for students at an elementary stage of higher education, the text may well prove a useful starting point in familiarising them with basic fields of discourse across literature, politics and law. Certainly, the strong criticism of the response of the Bush administration to the events of 9/11 and the illustrative comparison with examples of ‘vigilante’ behaviour and rhetoric in films would provide colourful and accessible sources for such students, stimulating platforms for debate. As a resource for beginning discussions upon deeper themes, such orientation may, even inadvertently, be helpful; as a collation, far less a commentary, upon such themes, it misses the mark.
