When historians of American religion talk about evangelicals and radicals, it is often to note that evangelical Protestants detested communists, socialists, or leftists of any kind. William Kostlevy's spryly titled history of the Metropolitan Church Association (MCA), however, suggests that this assumption needs examination. A holiness sect characterized by strident social conservatism and charismatic worship, the MCA split from the Methodist Episcopal Church at the dawn of the twentieth century. Drawing on previously untapped archival sources, Kostlevy argues that the MCA's departure was as much a protest against mainline Christianity's affinity with the acquisitive individualism of industrial capitalism as a schism over doctrine. Historians, he suggests, have overlooked these strains of evangelical political liberalism in emphasizing evangelicalism's social and theological conservatism. To Kostlevy, the MCA, like many holiness associations throughout the turn of the century, was as radical as it was evangelical.
By “evangelical,” Kostlevy, following Mark Noll, means that the MCA emphasized personal conversion, holy living, and ecclesiastical creativity. However, the appearance of the term in the book's subtitle is somewhat misleading. Though the implications of Kostlevy's work are broad, the book is a social and cultural history of a single denomination that emerged from a particular strain of holiness theology. With their belief in a “second blessing” that made believers sinless, these forerunners of Pentecostalism add a number of caveats to Kostlevy's broader definition. Moreover, as Kostlevy ably demonstrates throughout the first four chapters of the book, by the time of the MCA's formation in 1890, many holiness associations were fighting a dual-front war not only with modernist theologians but also with a growing contingent of radicals who argued that the communal sharing of the Biblical apostles was a model for the modern church. The MCA's founders were of this latter camp. To them, the magnitude of Christ's commission to save lost souls meant that to own property was to withhold from God. MCA leaders and members sold their possessions to finance the revivals, camp meetings, and publishing ventures that transformed them from a loose association of pietistic Methodists into their own denomination. Finally, in 1906, MCA leaders established a commune in Waukesha, Wisconsin, where over a thousand residents surrendered their possessions to work to advance the cause of Christ.
According to Kostlevy, this renunciation of private property and the worldly comforts of mainline churches made the MCA “radical.” Radicals, to Kostlevy, are associations who embody those “discontinuous and seemingly contradictory impulses associated with the American Left” that advocated a new social order and yearned for “a more equal distribution of wealth” (viii). The book's final four chapters delineate the ideological framework of the MCA's radicalism by charting its institutional growth and theological development. On one level, Kostlevy finds the MCA's radicalism in its adaptation of secular practices. Its journal Burning Bush, for instance, “adopted a full-fledge muckraker format” with stinging exposés of mainline churches and sensational cartoons of prominent ministers—of which Kostlevy provides stunning examples (94). Kostlevy is at his most insightful in exploring the theological sources of the MCA's social radicalism. He invokes the understudied concept of “stewardship” to explain the MCA's rejection of private property (109). A simple, yet profound notion that individuals are but caretakers of the property granted them by God, stewardship not only informed the MCA's perfunctory decision to list God as the proprietor of its publishing enterprises but also its critique of America's obsession with the acquisition of things. Alhough the MCA ultimately fractured over the logistics of such a communal theology, Kostlevy finds the presence of MCA activists shaping the emergence of early Pentecostalism. A testament to his extensive research, Kostlevy charts the presence of MCA defectors at formative events in the growth of Pentecostalism like the Asuza Street Revival and missionary endeavors in Asia.
Unfortunately, however, many of Kostlevy's most stimulating propositions are also some of his least satisfying. The extent and nature of the MCA's “radicalism,” for instance, needs far greater development. Wobbly Joe Hill's “The Preacher and the Slave” serves as the book's epigraph, and Kostlevy highlights how the MCA and the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) both used mass meetings, repurposed tunes, and sensational publications to reach the masses. “Instead of looking to Marx,” however, Kostlevy argues the MCA looked “to Jesus' teachings . . . for examples of communal sharing and the rejection of private property” (7). Still, to imply, as Kostlevy does, that these tactical similarities somehow makes the IWW and the MCA commensurate is a stretch. Though both “anticipated a fundamentally altered social order,” there are radical differences between the separatist communalism of the MCA and the direct actions of the IWW (8). Kostlevy never considers how these differences should shape understanding of MCA radicalism, and he never notes the MCA's exact position on other forms of social action. In fact, with the exception of temperance, the MCA's perception of the major issues of the Progressive Era is never examined. The denominational records Kostlevy uses may not address labor rights, women's suffrage, immigration, or Jim Crow, but such an absence is itself a fact worthy of interpretation.
These shortcomings, however, should not diminish Kostlevy's important contributions. Richly written, Kostlevy's book is a welcome innovation for a field that tends to look on all things evangelical as a precursor to the Religious Right. Kostlevy convincingly shows that the Progressive Era was an epoch of political diversity among conservative Protestants. “Most holiness Christian groups remained attached to private property,” Kostlevy concedes, but the MCA suggests that “many, perhaps most, saw themselves as enlightened progressives reformers who were comfortable with the moderate evangelicalism of the early social gospel” (10–11). What those politics actually were and how they became subsumed under the free market theology of the Religious Right, however, has yet to be explored.
Holy Jumpers requires too much background knowledge to be suitable for most undergraduate classes but offers much for scholars interested in evangelicalism, Pentecostalism, or religious politics in the Progressive Era generally. Although Kostlevy claims an interest in the margins of religious history brought him to this project, his rich study of this small, but eccentric, denomination suggests that the fringe may reflect the mainstream in ways yet to be understood.
