Hostname: page-component-74656f9884-j7cmm Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-08T19:05:58.592Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Wake transitions and scaling laws of a streamwise-rotating angular particle in an inertial flow

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 October 2026

Guodong Gai
Affiliation:
IMFT, Université de Toulouse, Toulouse INP, CNRS, Toulouse, France
Olivier Simonin
Affiliation:
IMFT, Université de Toulouse, Toulouse INP, CNRS, Toulouse, France
Anthony Wachs*
Affiliation:
Department of Mathematics, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada Department of Chemical & Biological Engineering, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada
*
Corresponding author: Anthony Wachs, wachs@math.ubc.ca

Abstract

Content of image described in text.

The wake dynamics and regime transitions of a streamwise-rotating angular particle in an inertial flow at moderate Reynolds numbers are investigated by particle-resolved direct numerical simulations, with particular focus on a rotating cube. We first identify the mechanisms of vortex generation on the front edges and the rear face, showing that rotation-induced vortex merging governs several key regime transitions. A previously unreported spearhead regime is uncovered, characterised by a helical near-wake and a steady filamentary far-wake structure. We demonstrate that it originates from the partial merging of edge vortices and the central rotation-induced vortex. Streamwise rotation is found to moderately stabilise the wake, and to induce a quadratic scaling of both the drag coefficient $\overline {C_d}$ and the streamwise torque $\overline {T_x}$ with the rotation rate $\varOmega$. The evolution of the lift coefficient closely mirrors that of the recirculation length $L_r$. For the rotating cube, the streamwise torque data collapse onto a single curve when expressed in terms of the rotation Reynolds number ${\textit{Re}}_{\varOmega }$. Frequency analyses reveal that the fundamental transverse-force frequency is set by the number of rotational symmetry folds $n_{\varOmega }$, while higher harmonics reflect the nonlinear nature of the flow–particle interaction. We further extend the analysis to general angular particles in their dual angular positions. Particles in dual configurations (sRCV, denoting a rotating cube with one vertex facing the incoming flow, and sROF, denoting a rotating octahedron with a front face facing the incoming flow) can display nearly identical regime transitions, as they share the same rotational symmetry folds and comparable vortex-pair strengths. Hydrodynamic responses remain strongly dependent on particle shape and orientation. Their frequency signatures likewise collapse when organised by $n_{\varOmega }$.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BYCreative Common License - NCCreative Common License - ND
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided that no alterations are made and the original article is properly cited. The written permission of Cambridge University Press or the rights holder(s) must be obtained prior to any commercial use and/or adaptation of the article.
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1. Figure 1 long description.Computational domain and representative wake structures for the flow past a rotating cube (sRCF) at Ω=0.4$\varOmega =0.4$ and Re=200${\textit{Re}}=200$, with the fourfold rotational symmetry aligned with the x$x$-axis. Vortical structures, identified using the λ2=−1$\lambda _2=-1$ criterion, are coloured by the streamwise velocity ux$u_x$ (red indicates high velocity and blue low velocity). The right-hand panel illustrates the adaptive mesh refinement on the x$x$–z$z$ plane, with two slices perpendicular to the flow highlighting the streamwise vorticity distribution (red, ωx>0$\omega _x\gt 0$, and blue, ωx<0$\omega _x\lt 0$) in the near wake of the rotating cube (blue box, x=xp+0.8$x=x_p + 0.8$, and green box, x=xp+1.6$x=x_p + 1.6$).

Figure 1

Figure 2. Distribution of Lagrange multipliers (white dots) on the surfaces of two Platonic polyhedrons: a cube (ϕ=0.806$\phi =0.806$) and an octahedron (ϕ=0.846$\phi =0.846$). A sphere (ϕ=1.0$\phi =1.0$) is included for reference. Specific dual angular positions and their rotation axes are marked with colour-coded arrows: green for (sRCF, sROV) and white for (sRCV, sROF). The associated numbers of rotational symmetry folds of the rotation axes (nΩ$n_{\varOmega }$) are depicted.

Figure 2

Table 1. Flow regimes of the streamwise-rotating cube (sRCF). Descriptions give the temporal behaviour followed by the defining wake structure; examples show representative structures (λ2=−1$\lambda _2=-1$, coloured by ux$u_x$).Table 1 long description.

Figure 3

Figure 3. Figure 3 long description.Regime map of flow past a streamwise-rotating cube with a face facing the flow (sRCF) at 60≤Re≤500$60 \leq {\textit{Re}} \leq 500$ and 0.02≤Ω≤1$0.02 \leq \varOmega \leq 1$, with representative wake vortex structures illustrated in the corresponding regimes: steady vortical (SV, mathematical equation), straight filament (SF, mathematical equation), wavy filament (WF, mathematical equation), spearhead (SH, mathematical equation), periodic vortex shedding (PS, mathematical equation), weakly chaotic shedding (WCS, mathematical equation) and chaotic shedding (CS, mathematical equation) regimes.

Figure 4

Figure 4. The vortex generation process on the surface and in the near wake of a slowly rotating sRCF cube at Re=200${\textit{Re}}=200$ and Ω=0.02$\varOmega =0.02$. Panels I–IV show the evolution of surface vortices with increasing distance from the rear face, leading to the streamwise vorticity pattern in panel V. The vorticity field of a fixed cube at Re=200${\textit{Re}}=200$ is shown in panels VI–VII. Red and blue regions indicate positive and negative ωx$\omega _x$. The lower diagram summarises the regime transition sequence for the rotating sRCF at Ω=0.02$\varOmega =0.02$ compared with the fixed cube.

Figure 5

Figure 5. Figure 5 long description.Visualisation of streamwise vortex generation and merging in the near wake of the rotating sRCF cube, shown in the y$y$–z$z$ plane at x=xp+0.6$x = x_p + 0.6$. Red and blue indicate positive and negative streamwise vorticity ωx$\omega _x$ and streamlines are superimposed to highlight the wake topology. Flow regimes are delineated by colour-coded boxes, and the projected outline of the cube on the y$y$–z$z$ plane is included for reference.

Figure 6

Figure 6. Vortical structures identified by λ2=−1$\lambda _2=-1$ in the wake of the sRCF: (a) at Re=220${\textit{Re}}=220$ and (b) at Ω=0.4$\varOmega =0.4$, shown in the x$x$–y$y$ plane. Red and blue denote positive and negative streamwise disturbance velocity, u~x=ux−Uref∈[−0.1,0.1]$\tilde {u}_x=u_x-U_{\textit{ref}}\in [-0.1,0.1]$, respectively. In-plane streamlines highlight the three-dimensional wake topology, colour-coded boxes mark different flow regimes, and the downstream region spans L0/2$L_0/2$.

Figure 7

Figure 7. Figure 7 long description.(a) Time-averaged drag coefficient Cd¯$\overline {C_d}$ versus Ω$\varOmega$ for flow past an sRCF at 60≤Re≤500$60 \leq {\textit{Re}} \leq 500$; darker circles denote larger Re$\textit{Re}$, and dashed curves show the corresponding correlations. (b) Plot of Cd¯$\overline {C_d}$ versus Re$\textit{Re}$ over 0.02≤Ω≤1$0.02 \leq \varOmega \leq 1$; darker circles denote larger Ω$\varOmega$.

Figure 8

Figure 8. (a) Norm of the mean lift, ‖Cl¯‖2$\Vert \overline {C_l}\Vert _2$, as a function of Ω$\varOmega$ for flow past a rotating sRCF cube at 60≤Re≤500$60 \leq {\textit{Re}} \leq 500$. Representative cases of Cl¯$\overline {C_l}$ evolution across the regime transitions are given in the inset. (b) Time-averaged magnitude of the instantaneous lift, ‖Cl‖2¯$\overline {\Vert C_l\Vert _2}$. The increasing darkness of the circles represents higher Re$\textit{Re}$.

Figure 9

Figure 9. Figure 9 long description.Evolution of the recirculation region with Ω$\varOmega$ for 60≤Re≤500$60 \leq {\textit{Re}} \leq 500$. (a) Recirculation region (green) at Re=160${\textit{Re}} = 160$ for Ω=0.02$\varOmega = 0.02$ and Ω=0.6$\varOmega = 0.6$ in the x$x$–y$y$ plane, with vortex structures identified by ωx=±1$\omega _x = \pm 1$ (red and blue) and λ2=−1$\lambda _2 = -1$ (semi-transparent white) shown for reference. (b) Recirculation length Lr$L_r$; darker circles denote larger Re$\textit{Re}$. Black stars: Lr$L_r$ of sRS at Re=100${\textit{Re}} = 100$ (solid), 250$250$ (dashed) and 300$300$ (dotted) digitised from Kim & Choi (2002). (c) In-plane streamlines in the y$y$–z$z$ cut-plane at x=xp+0.1$x = x_p + 0.1$ within the sRCF recirculation region for Ω=0.4$\varOmega = 0.4$ and Ω=0.8$\varOmega = 0.8$ at Re=380${\textit{Re}} = 380$ (a,c) and Re=440${\textit{Re}} = 440$ (b), coloured by u~x$\tilde {u}_x$ (red, u~x>0$\tilde {u}_x\gt 0$; blue, u~x<0$\tilde {u}_x\lt 0$). The corresponding three-dimensional wake structures are also shown for reference.

Figure 10

Figure 10. (a) Time-averaged torque Tx¯$\overline {T_x}$ as a function of Ω$\varOmega$ of the rotating sRCF cube over 0.02≤Ω≤1$0.02 \leq \varOmega \leq 1$ at 60≤Re≤500$60 \leq {\textit{Re}} \leq 500$. (b) Scaling of the streamwise torque, shown as Ω2/Tx¯$\varOmega ^{2}/\overline {T_x}$ plotted against ReΩ${\textit{Re}}_{\varOmega }$. The colour of the symbols indicates the flow Reynolds number Re$\textit{Re}$. The golden yellow line represents the empirical correlation, with a coefficient of determination r2=0.9944$r^2 = 0.9944$.

Figure 11

Figure 11. Figure 11 long description.(a–c) Frequency spectra of vortex shedding from the rotating sRCF cube at Re=100${\textit{Re}}=100$, 220$220$ and 500$500$. Here I$I$ is the normalised FFT spectral amplitude, shown on a linear scale in each panel. (d) Strouhal numbers Str$\mathcal{S}tr$ of the primary and secondary peaks over the considered Ω$\varOmega$ and Re$\textit{Re}$ ranges. The blue curve gives the model prediction for the primary peak, Str1=4Ω/π$\mathcal{S}tr_1=4\varOmega /\pi$, equation (5.5); the red curve shows the imposed rotation rate, y=Ω$y=\varOmega$; the grey curve indicates the first harmonic of the primary peak; and the yellow curve corresponds to the fixed-CF-cube value Str0=0.11$\mathcal{S}tr_0=0.11$ (Gai & Wachs 2023b). These characteristic frequencies are marked by dashed vertical lines of the corresponding colours in panels (a–c).

Figure 12

Figure 12. Flow past streamwise-rotating angular particles at Re=200${\textit{Re}}=200$ and Ω=0.4$\varOmega =0.4$, with wake vortices identified by λ2=−1$\lambda _2=-1$ and coloured by ux$u_x$ (red, high velocity; blue, low velocity): (a) sRCV with a threefold axis, (b) sROF with a threefold axis and (c) sROV with a fourfold axis. All panels use the same colour range.

Figure 13

Figure 13. (a) Dual symmetry of the (CF, OV) and (CV, OF) pairs, with corresponding dual faces shown in the same colours. (b) Vorticity generation by the (CF, OV) and (CV, OF) dual pairs at Re=100${\textit{Re}}=100$ in flow along the x$x$-axis. Fixed angular particles and their dual counterparts are superimposed and centred at dual orientations. Coloured vortical regions denote positive and negative ωx=±0.8$\omega _x=\pm 0.8$ generated by each particle, with the colour code shown for the two dual angular positions. Axes are shown locally for each view.

Figure 14

Figure 14. Flow-regime map for streamwise-rotating angular particles at Re=100${\textit{Re}}=100$, 200$200$ and 300$300$ over 0.02≤Ω≤1$0.02 \leq \varOmega \leq 1$. Horizontal bars give the wake regimes for a given particle shape and orientation, with colours denoting the corresponding regimes. Configurations are arranged as dual angular pairs: (sRCF, sROV) and (sRCV, sROF).

Figure 15

Figure 15. Wake vortical structures of the dual pair (sRCV, sROF) at Re=100${\textit{Re}}=100$ and 0.1≤Ω≤0.6$0.1 \leq \varOmega \leq 0.6$ coloured by the streamwise velocity ux$u_x$ with the corresponding values of Ω$\varOmega$ indicated above each case.

Figure 16

Figure 16. Figure 16 long description.Vortex pair formation near the rear surface of the dual pairs (sRCV, sROF) and (sRCF, sROV), shown in the y$y$–z$z$ plane at x=xp+0.6$x=x_p+0.6$. Red and blue denote positive and negative ωx$\omega _x$, respectively, with in-plane streamlines superimposed to highlight the wake structures. Colour-coded boxes outline the corresponding flow regimes, and the projected angular particle contour in the y$y$–z$z$ plane is shown for reference.

Figure 17

Figure 17. Effects of particle shape and angular position on the hydrodynamic forces: (a, b) Norm of the time-averaged lift coefficient ‖Cl¯‖2$\Vert \overline {C_l}\Vert _2$ at Re=100${\textit{Re}}=100$ and Re=200${\textit{Re}}=200$, respectively. (c, d) Time-averaged drag coefficient Cd¯$\overline {C_{d}}$ at Re=100${\textit{Re}}=100$ and Re=200${\textit{Re}}=200$. Results are shown for the four face/edge angular positions (OF, CF, OV, and CV). The response for a streamwise-rotating sphere is plotted for reference (black dashed line).

Figure 18

Figure 18. Evolution of the recirculation length Lr$L_r$ behind streamwise-rotating angular particles at Re=100${\textit{Re}} = 100$ over 0.02≤Ω≤1$0.02 \leq \varOmega \leq 1$. The solid line denotes the streamwise-rotating sphere (sRS) as a reference.

Figure 19

Figure 19. The Strouhal number of the primary and secondary peaks as a function of Ω$\varOmega$ for (a) sROV, (b) sRCV and (c) sROF. The blue curve represents the model prediction (5.5) for the primary peak Str1$\mathcal{S}tr_1$, while the red curve corresponds to the prescribed particle rotation rate Str=Ω$\mathcal{S}tr = \varOmega$. The grey/olive curves indicate the higher-order harmonics of the primary peak. The yellow curve denotes the characteristic Str0$\mathcal{S}tr_0$ of the corresponding fixed particle: a fixed octahedron Str0=0.12$\mathcal{S}tr_0=0.12$ in panels (a) and (c), and a fixed cube Str0=0.11$\mathcal{S}tr_0=0.11$ in panel (b) (Gai & Wachs 2023b).

Figure 20

Figure 20. Validation of Cd¯$\overline {C_d}$ versus Ω$\varOmega$ for flow past a streamwise-rotating sphere. Solid lines show the present numerical results at Re=100${\textit{Re}}=100$, 250$250$ and 300$300$, compared with the colour-matched data of Kim & Choi (2002).

Figure 21

Figure 21. Visualisation of streamwise vorticity pattern in the wake of the sRCF in y$y$–z$z$ plane at x=xp+1.5$x = x_p + 1.5$, with red and blue regions representing positive and negative ωx$\omega _x$, respectively.

Figure 22

Figure 22. Figure 22 long description.Side view of vortex shedding and suppression behind the rotating sRCF cube over 0.02≤Ω≤1$0.02 \leq \varOmega \leq 1$ and 60≤Re≤500$60 \leq {\textit{Re}} \leq 500$. Isosurfaces are identified by λ2=−1$\lambda _2=-1$ and coloured by ux$u_x$ (red, high velocity; blue, low velocity). Colour-coded bars on the left of each panel indicate the flow regimes.

Figure 23

Figure 23. Vortical structures identified by λ2=−1$\lambda _2=-1$ in the wake of the sRCF at Ω=1$\varOmega = 1$, shown in the x$x$–y$y$ plane.

Figure 24

Figure 24. Figure 24 long description.Probability density function f(h)$f(h)$ of helicity density h$h$ in the vortical region defined by Q>10$\mathcal{Q}\gt 10$ for sRCF. (a, b) Effect of Re$\textit{Re}$ on hf(h)$h f(h)$ at Ω=0.2$\varOmega =0.2$ and 0.6$0.6$. (c) Effect of Ω$\varOmega$ on f$f$ at Re=100${\textit{Re}}=100$. (d) Heat map of the mean helicity density ⟨h⟩$\langle h\rangle$ computed from the PDF over the full (Re,Ω)$({\textit{Re}},\varOmega )$ parameter space.

Figure 25

Figure 25. The ωx$\omega _x$ pattern in the near wake of an angular particle, red for ωx>0$\omega _x\gt 0$ and blue for ωx<0$\omega _x \lt 0$: (a) sRCV, Re=100${\textit{Re}}=100$, Ω=1.0$\varOmega =1.0$, x=xp+1$x=x_p + 1$; (b) sROF, Re=300${\textit{Re}}=300$, Ω=0.3$\varOmega =0.3$, x=xp+1.8$x=x_p + 1.8$; (c) sRCF, Re=180${\textit{Re}}=180$, Ω=0.4$\varOmega =0.4$, x=xp+0.8$x=x_p + 0.8$; and (d) sROV, Re=200${\textit{Re}}=200$, Ω=0.8$\varOmega =0.8$, x=xp+1.1$x=x_p + 1.1$.

Figure 26

Figure 26. (a) Evolution of Cd¯$\overline {C_d}$ as a function of rotation rate 0.02≤Ω≤1$0.02\leq \varOmega \leq 1$ at Re=100${\textit{Re}} = 100$, 200$200$ and 300$300$ for a streamwise-rotating sphere, cylinder (cS$cS$) and cube. (b) Effects of the cylinder aspect ratio χ$\chi$ on the Cd¯$\overline {C_d}$ evolution at Re=200${\textit{Re}}=200$. (c) Effects of the cylinder aspect ratio χ$\chi$ on Cl¯$\overline {C_l}$ at Re=200${\textit{Re}}=200$. (d) Near-body vortex structures of the streamwise-rotating cylinder cS$cS$ (top row) and the sRCF cube (bottom row) at Re=200${\textit{Re}} = 200$: front view and perspective view at Ω=0.4$\varOmega =0.4$, and perspective view at Ω=0.8$\varOmega =0.8$. Isosurfaces identified by ωx=±1$\omega _x = \pm 1$ (red and blue) and recirculation region (green). (e) Wake structures of the rotating sphere, sRCF and sRCV cubes at Ω=0.2$\varOmega = 0.2$: isosurfaces of ωx$\omega _x$ (semi-transparent) and λ2=−1$\lambda _2 = -1$ coloured by ux$u_x$.