Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T19:44:03.384Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Onset and length scales of wall modes in confined magnetoconvection with a vertical magnetic field

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 January 2026

Xin Tao
Affiliation:
State Key Laboratory for Strength and Vibration of Mechanical Structures and School of Aerospace, Xi’an Jiaotong University, Xi’an 710049, PR China
Xiaojue Zhu
Affiliation:
Max Planck Institute for Solar System Research, 37077 Göttingen, Germany
Ming-Jiu Ni
Affiliation:
School of Engineering Sciences, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, PR China
Yi-Chao Xie*
Affiliation:
State Key Laboratory for Strength and Vibration of Mechanical Structures and School of Aerospace, Xi’an Jiaotong University, Xi’an 710049, PR China
*
Corresponding author: Yi-Chao Xie, yichao.xie@xjtu.edu.cn

Abstract

Using linear stability analysis, we study the onset and formation mechanism of wall modes in confined magnetoconvection cells with the degree of confinement characterised by the cell aspect ratio $\varGamma$. We first outline the phase diagram of the dominating factors that determine the critical Rayleigh number $Ra_c$ for the onset of convection in the $\varGamma -Ha$ phase space, with $\textit{Ha}$ being the Hartmann number. Our study shows that $Ra_c$ is primarily determined by geometrical confinement, and bulk convection onset occurs with $Ra_c = 1090 \varGamma ^{-4.0}$ for $\varGamma \lt \varGamma _{c_1} = 1.21 \textit{Ha}^{-0.48}$. No wall modes form and $Ra_c$ depends on the strength of both the confinement and magnetic field for $\varGamma _{c_1} \leqslant \varGamma \lt \varGamma _{c_2} = 4.07 \textit{Ha}^{-0.53}$. For $\varGamma _{c_2}\leqslant \varGamma \lt \varGamma _{c_3}=0.99 \textit{Ha}^{-0.10}$, wall modes emerge and $Ra_c$ drops below the bulk onset Rayleigh number for magnetoconvection. When $\varGamma \geqslant \varGamma _{c_3}$, wall modes become fully developed with an onset Rayleigh number for wall modes $Ra_{c,w} \approx 65 \textit{Ha}^{1.5}$. In this fully developed regime, the radial velocity profile and $Ra_{c,w}$ become independent of $\varGamma$. Through analysing the length scales of wall modes and their interaction with spatial confinement, we show dynamically how wall modes emerge in confined cells: while the first layer with a characteristic length scale $\ell _1 = 1.04 \textit{Ha}^{-0.56}$ forms when $\varGamma \geqslant 5.39 \textit{Ha}^{-0.58}$, the second layer with a characteristic length scale $\ell _2 = 4.94 \textit{Ha}^{-0.56}$ emerges when $\varGamma \geqslant 9.07 \textit{Ha}^{-0.53}$. These scaling relations provide practical guidelines for experimental and numerical studies of the wall-mode dynamics.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Critical Rayleigh number ($Ra_c$) and azimuthal mode number ($n$) obtained for different values of $K$ and $M$, with $\textit{Ha} = 100$. Note in each data entry, the first value denotes $Ra_c$ and the second value denotes $n$.

Figure 1

Table 2.Critical Rayleigh number ($Ra_c$) and azimuthal mode number ($n$) obtained for different values of $K$ and $M$, with $\textit{Ha} = 1000$. Note in each data entry, the first value denotes $Ra_c$ and the second value denotes $n$.

Figure 2

Figure 1.The critical Rayleigh number $Ra_c$ vs $\varGamma$ at $\textit{Ha}=0$. The dotted line marks $Ra_c \sim \varGamma ^{-4}$ fitted to the data with $\varGamma \leqslant 1/10$. The horizontal dashed line presents $Ra_c=1708$ for $\textit{Ha}=0$ in an infinite layer with no-slip boundaries. Circles and triangles denote DNS and experimental data from Ren et al. (2024), respectively. The blue solid line shows the theoretical prediction from Shishkina (2021).

Figure 3

Figure 2.The critical Rayleigh number $Ra_c$ vs $\textit{Ha}$ for different $\varGamma$. The solid lines are results from the present work. The red and blue dashed lines represent the results for an infinite layer with free-slip and no-slip boundaries, respectively, from Chandrasekhar (1952). The red and blue dotted lines indicate the asymptotic solutions for cylinders with $\varGamma =1$ and $\varGamma =2$, respectively, from Houchens et al. (2002). The black dash-dotted line corresponds to an asymptotic solution along a straight vertical sidewall in a semi-infinite domain with free-slip top and bottom boundaries from Busse (2008).

Figure 4

Figure 3.(a,d) The critical Rayleigh number $Ra_c$ vs $\varGamma$ at $\textit{Ha}=100$ and $\textit{Ha}=1000$, respectively, for different azimuthal modes $n$. The minimum $Ra_{c,n}$ for each $\varGamma$ forms the $Ra_c$ curve highlighted with a solid line. The black horizontal dashed line indicates $Ra_{c,b}$ for the onset of bulk convection for comparison. (b,c) Flow structures for $\varGamma =2$ and $\varGamma =3$ at $\textit{Ha}=100$. (e, f) Flow structures for $\varGamma =2$ and $\varGamma =3$ at $\textit{Ha}=1000$. The colour represents the contours of the normalised vertical velocity $U_z / \max {|U_z|}$.

Figure 5

Figure 4.(a) The $Ra_c$ vs $\varGamma$ curves for different $\textit{Ha}$. The horizontal dashed lines mark $Ra_{c,b}$ for the onset of bulk convection. (b) Phase diagram showing the dominating factors that determine $Ra_c$. In regime I, $Ra_c = 1090\varGamma ^{-4.0}$ and is determined by $\varGamma$. In regimes II and III the co-action of geometrical confinement and magnetic field determines $Ra_c$ with no wall modes in regime II and wall modes developing in regime III. Regime IV is the wall-mode-dominated regime with $Ra_c=Ra_{c,w} \approx 65 \textit{Ha}^{1.5}$, determined by the magnetic field. Refer to the main text for the meanings of the remaining symbols.

Figure 6

Table 3.Summary of LSA results for the critical Rayleigh number $Ra_c$ and azimuthal mode number $n$, evaluated at representative Hartmann numbers $\textit{Ha}$ and aspect ratios $\varGamma$. Note in each data entry, the first value denotes $Ra_c$ and the second value denotes $n$.

Figure 7

Figure 5.Flow visualisations in different regimes at $\textit{Ha}=300$ with varying $\varGamma$: (a,e) geometry-dominated regime, $\varGamma =1/20$; (b, f) coupled regime, $\varGamma =1/10$; (c,g) wall-mode developing regime, $\varGamma =1/2$; (d,h) wall-mode-dominated regime, $\varGamma =1$. In (a–d), half of the cylinder is removed to reveal the interior structure, where velocity vectors are indicated by arrows and colours represent normalised temperature fluctuations. In (e–h), the contours of the normalized vertical velocity $U_z/U_{z,max}$ at the horizontal cross-sections with $z=1/2$ are shown.

Figure 8

Figure 6.The azimuthal mode number $n$ in the $\varGamma$–$\textit{Ha}$ phase space. The symbols mark the transitional aspect ratio between successive $n$. The black solid line with ${\sim} \textit{Ha}^{-0.05}$ is plotted as a line to guide the eye.

Figure 9

Figure 7.(a) Radial profiles of the normalised vertical velocity $U_z / \max {|U_z|}$ for various $\varGamma$ at $\textit{Ha} = 100$ with $n$ being the azimuthal wavenumber. (b) Variation of the locations of the maximum positive ($\delta _1$) and minimum negative ($\delta _2$) vertical velocity profiles with $\varGamma$ for $\textit{Ha} = 100$. The horizontal lines indicate the characteristic length scales of the two-layer structure, $\ell _{r_1}$ (red-dashed line) and $\ell _{r_2}$ (blue-dashed line). The vertical dashed lines mark the minimum $\varGamma$ required for the formation of each layer, denoted as $\varGamma ^*_1$ (red-dash-dotted line) and $\varGamma ^*_2$ (blue-dash-dotted line). (c) Dependence of $\ell_{r_1}$ and $\ell_{r_2}$ on $\textit{Ha}$. The solid lines are power law fits to the data with $\ell_{r_1}=1.04Ha^{-0.56}$ and $\ell_{r_2}=4.94Ha^{-0.56}$. The inset shows the ratio of the velocity amplitudes between the inner and outer layers as a function of $ \textit{Ha}$. The solid line is a power law fit to the data with $-U_z(\ell_{r_2})/U_z(\ell_{r_1})=0.28Ha^{-0.23}$. (d) Variation of $\varGamma ^*_1$ and $\varGamma ^*_2$ with $\textit{Ha}$. The solid lines are power law fits to the data with $\varGamma_1^*=5.39 \textit{Ha}^{-0.58}$ and $\varGamma_2^*=9.07 \textit{Ha}^{-0.53}$.