In 1661, a contemptuous broadside rejoiced in the downfall of the godly Presbyterian clergy of London:
Some twenty years after its first delivery, Meroz Cursed, Stephen Marshall's sermon on Judges v, verse 23, remained the characteristic political sermon of the 1640s.Footnote 2 Preaching before the House of Commons in February 1642, in the shadow of the Irish rebellion and the king's flight from London, following his failure to arrest prominent leaders of the parliament, Marshall urged his hearers to avoid the curse on the people of Meroz who had acted as ‘neuters, who stand aloofe off’ and ‘came not to the help of the Lord against the mighty’. Marshall urged his congregation that ‘many great things are yet to be done, much rubbish to be removed…Ireland to be relieved, Religion to be established’; and he clearly raised the prospect of military action. Prayer would do much but it might be that men would be ‘called, as souldiers, to spend your blood in the Churches cause’.Footnote 3
For sympathetic contemporaries, also, Meroz Cursed was a memorable civil war sermon, as the poet Anne Bradstreet, writing from distant New England had it:Footnote 4
The hostile broadside, however, took its title – The Downfall of the Ark or the Morning Exercise at an End – from what might be appear to be a different mode of 1640s preaching. The Morning Exercise was a regular series of short sermons preached over a month in a single London parish and presented by its orthodox godly or Presbyterian backers as an uncontroversial pastorally focused enterprise. The royalist broadside, however, did not distinguish between the exercise and the more directly ‘political’ preaching of the parliamentary fasts, smearing all Presbyterian preaching as support with ‘lips and hands’ for rebellion. This paper seeks to place the high-profile parliamentarian preaching within a broader context, by relating the fast sermons to the more routine preaching available in London in the 1640s and 1650s, and by stressing reception as much as delivery. It will return to the preaching at the Morning Exercise by way of conclusion.
I
Within modern scholarship, discussions of the parliamentary fast sermons, amongst which Meroz Cursed looms large, have dominated studies of preaching in the 1640s and 1650s. Between February 1642 and February 1649, the parliamentarian regime kept the last Wednesday in the month as a solemn fast throughout the kingdom with two high-profile sermons preached before the Commons and, from October 1644, two in the Lords. There were also ad hoc or special days of humiliation and thanksgiving that marked conflict, setbacks and defeat on the one hand, or victory and reconciliation on the other.Footnote 5 After 1649, the regular fast days were abandoned for a variety of reasons: fear of giving preaching opportunities to London Presbyterians and other opponents of the new regime; radical Puritan anxieties that the fasts had become merely ‘formal observance’ and perhaps sheer exhaustion. A newsletter reported in April 1649 that the fast days had ‘almost wearied all the Preachers and Hearers of England’.Footnote 6 Nonetheless, days of fasting, humiliation and thanksgiving continued throughout the 1650s, and in all there were more than 130 of these days of special worship in the 1640s and 1650s.Footnote 7 Some provincial sermons were printed, and more of those delivered in prestigious London churches, while as many as three-quarters of all sermons preached before the Commons reached the press. Not to be printed was in itself worth notice, the London bookseller and collector George Thomason writing on his copy of the sermon given by Stephen Marshall at the thanksgiving for the miraculous victory at Naseby, ‘Mr Vines not printed’.Footnote 8 The majority of the preachers before the parliament were members of the Westminster Assembly, mainstream Puritans or Presbyterians, although Independents or ‘Congregationalists’ were also represented in the early 1640s, and increasingly prominent from the later 1640s. Of the men denounced in The Downfall of the Ark, the Essex minister Stephen Marshall preached most often before the Long Parliament, acting on twenty-two occasions before 1649 with sixteen of these sermons printed; Richard Vines was almost as prominent, preaching eleven sermons, of which seven were printed, while Simeon Ashe had four out of his six parliamentary sermons printed, and, as chaplain to parliament's general, the earl of Manchester had brought news to London of the victory at Marston Moor in 1644.Footnote 9
The texts of these printed fast sermons – the words on the page in about 250 small tracts – have proved attractive sources for political scientists, historians, theologians and literary scholars. A lively and still influential article by Hugh Trevor Roper elucidated the ways in which the preachers engaged with specific and immediate polemical contexts, ‘tuning the pulpits’ to justify particular parliamentarian initiatives. Stephen Marshall is defined as parliament's ‘clerical tribune’, and ‘if Marshall holloa’ed the parliamentary pack onwards into war in 1642, [Hugh] Peter in 1647 would holloa the army onwards into revolution’.Footnote 10 If this judgement is commonly now regarded as overly conspiratorial, scholars continue to explain how theological exegesis and scriptural narratives, accounts of God's purposes for his chosen people, had an undisguised relevance to the pressing political and religious dilemmas of the 1640s and 1650s, rallying listeners to the parliamentary cause in the early 1640s, or intervening in intra-parliamentarian divisions.Footnote 11 The printed texts have been used, for example, to debate the relative importance of religious and political frameworks for parliamentarian justifications of resistance.Footnote 12 Most recently, the literary historian Achsah Guibbory has shown how ‘a deepened sense of the historicity of the narratives of Biblical Israel’, an empathetic identification with the Israelites combating the idolatrous Canaanites, or struggling to rebuild the Temple after the Babylonian exile, enabled the preachers to offer complex constructions of the English nation as a chosen people.Footnote 13
This is a rich and still relevant body of work, but the seductive power of these easily available printed texts obscures broader understandings of preaching in the 1640s and 1650s. There has been relatively little discussion of the fast sermons themselves as events or experiences; rather the texts are used unreflectively as sources to elucidate more general issues.Footnote 14 How did ministers, whether confident and well connected like Marshall, or initially inexperienced provincials like Charles Herle, prepare to address their eminent auditors? Herle desired readers of his first fast sermon ‘to pardon the want of Quotations, for that (being a Stranger) he had neither Bookes or Notes by him at the penning of what followes’.Footnote 15 Herle's sermon was preached on 30 November 1642 and available in printed form by Thomason on 22 December; we need to know more about the printers and publishers who made this rapid production possible, and about how hasty and almost automatic printing affected the relationship between the sermon as oral and as printed communication. The histories of print culture and the book that interrogate how the words came to be on the printed page in particular ways have had relatively little influence here. We do not know enough about how fast sermons were apprehended by readers of the printed sermons or by hearers at their delivery, beyond very general assumptions of enthusiasm or indifference. Fast sermons were clearly not routine occasions, but there is no systematic work on how, for preachers and hearers alike, they took their place amongst more everyday preaching in parish churches. This is a demanding agenda for long-term research, and some preliminary and particular findings are presented here. My focus is on London preaching, particularly as recorded by broadly Puritan hearers sympathetic to the parliament; I explore how conscientious sermon goers located the parliamentary fast sermons within their own contexts of preaching attendance and personal piety. The general impact of the fast sermons and comparisons with royalist fast sermons during the civil war are both vital topics, but they await further research.Footnote 16
II
In London, the parliamentary fasts inaugurated distinct experiences of time and space, an intermixture of mobility and contemporaneity. Popular preachers moved from pulpit to pulpit through one exhausting day; although lay people were supposed to observe the day in their own parish, many chose more exciting or more congenial preachers. For the London radical and future Leveller, William Walwyn, fast days were occasions for sociability and intellectual recreation. ‘It fell upon a Fast day in the morning’ that Walwyn and two friends ‘hastned abroad’, discussing religion as they went. They first heard the Presbyterian James Cranford at Christ Church, but finding him not to their taste, they ‘went at last to Basing-shaw Church, it being where my Lord Mayor was to be, as expecting to hear some excellent man there; being there some time, we found the matter so lamentable, as we were all three weary of it…so we all three at once together went away, but so as we could give no offence to the congregation, being not in the body of the Church’. Walwyn denied that he and his friends had ‘been from Church to Church’ but he implied that many others in the city did.Footnote 17 The Presbyterian wood-turner Nehemiah Wallington, in contrast, confined himself to preaching at his parish church and experienced fast days as a mixed blessing, occasions for morbid reflection and exhaustion as much as inspiration. In May 1643, following some benefit from his parish minister, Henry Roborough:
when the next man had gone on a while I began to grow weary and wished he had done for faine I would be at home and there was no more expected to perform any more. But Mr Ash being come (weary in) not makeing acount to have don any thing yet with much parswasion did goe up which did grive & was ierksome to my carnall & unregenerat part.
In the event, the ‘unexpressable love of my God to me his pevish & unworthy Childe’ melted Wallington's heart and Ashe's sermon was ‘sweet & profitable unto mee so that the time did seeme short’.Footnote 18
The bustle and variety of preaching on a London fast day was less characteristic of provincial England, but the high profile given to fast days through print and parliamentary proclamations meant that provincial supporters of the parliamentary cause felt a sense of identity with their more prominent comrades. In December 1646, for example, a Coventry preacher planning his theme for a day of humiliation praying for God's forgiveness following a ‘great judgement of rain and water’, imagined his fellow-ministers doing likewise: ‘my thoughts led me, That others of my Brethren, as their lot fell, would rouse up their Auditors, Whether the Princes, or the People of the Land, some to take better notice, some to reform, and some to repent of these disregarded Sins’. Bryan's response was a rousing defence of the parliamentarian regime, defending high taxes as necessary to the defence of ‘Lives, Liberties, Priviledges, Estates and Religion’, and cautioning against a precipitous peace with the king.Footnote 19 On the other hand, the city Presbyterian Francis Roberts, in the only sermon of the four preached before the parliament to be printed, offered the Lords a bitter denunciation of the delays in establishing a reformed national church: we ‘languish, faint and dye under those cursed diseases of error, heresie, blasphemy, licentiousness, divisions, disorder and confusion, horrid Atheisme, and all manner of prophaneness?…Whither are we falling?’Footnote 20 The degree to which the programme of national fasts achieved a shift, albeit partial and temporary, in what David Cressy has termed ‘Calendrical consciousness’ and in spatial awareness would repay further examination.Footnote 21
The importance of fast days, as repeated experiences, and of the sermons as a series, is evident in their printed character. Some bookseller-publishers deliberately presented fast sermons to readers as a series, appending chronological lists or ‘catalogues’ of all those preached to date at the end of an individual sermon, noting those not printed. These lists were often in sermons preached late in December so that the previous year's preaching could be summed up, and lists were sometimes highlighted on title pages.Footnote 22 Individual printed sermons were relatively cheap, and perhaps ephemeral publications but although fast sermons were usually printed, and often acquired singly, they were avidly collected and preserved by readers.Footnote 23 The later seventeenth-century book auction catalogues of ministers prominent in the 1640s and 1650s reveal them as indefatigable collectors of each others’ sermons which they organised as a special category. Thomas Jacombe's library included a ‘Compleat Collection of Sermons preached before the Houses of Lords and Commons in the time of the late civil wars bound in eleven volumes’, while Thomas Manton had organised his alphabetically by author: volume 36 of ‘pamphlets bound together in quarto’ included ‘17 sermons preached by Mr Stephen Marshall before the two Houses of Parliament upon several occasions’ while volume 42 covered preachers whose names began with ‘S’ with sermons by Obadiah Sedgwick, William Strong, Henry Scudder, Lazarus Seaman, William Spurstow and John Strickland between 1644 and 1647.Footnote 24 Amongst laymen, George Thomason and the iconoclast William Dowsing had near-complete collections of printed fast sermons. Thomason added the occasional endorsement – ‘this sermon I heard preached’ on Herle's November 1642 text, or the note that John Ley's The Fury of Warre, and Folly of Sinne, preached in April 1643 was the gift of the author.Footnote 25 For Dowsing, we have suggestive evidence of repeated, thoughtful engagement with the printed texts. He purchased some 158 printed sermons preached to the Long Parliament, almost all of those preached before the Commons at the regular fast days from 1642 to 1646, along with twenty-eight sermons on special occasions and a smaller number of sermons before the Lords. Dowsing accumulated his collection through ‘piecemeal’ purchases usually paying 5d a sermon, sometimes buying shortly after publication but often much later. He noted dates of purchase, and of first reading, applied any errata and added biblical references, marginal emphases and occasional comments. The sermons were bound into six systematically arranged volumes in October 1646, and Dowsing then reread them all again.Footnote 26
Dowsing's active response to the fast sermons indicates how much the study of preaching in the 1640s and 1650s has to gain from the enormously productive scholarship on Tudor and early Stuart preaching associated with Ian Green, Mary Morissey, Peter McCullough, and especially Arnold Hunt. This work insists that sermons were events as much as they were texts, and that the responses of hearers are as important as the aims and methods of preachers. Analysing printed sermons alone and in isolation limits attempts to understand ‘the two-way relationship between the preacher and his audience’, in Arnold Hunt's words. Sermons, in this framework, were at once speech acts, performances and public events; moving oral encounters between preachers and hearers.Footnote 27 A fuller understanding of such encounters in years of political upheaval, civil wars and religious fragmentation is particularly pressing, yet has been rarely attempted.Footnote 28
III
Recent studies of early modern preaching have made illuminating use of manuscript sermon notes made by hearers: ‘Sermon noting is one of the keys to understanding how lay people “consumed” preaching in post-Reformation England’, as John Spurr remarks.Footnote 29 Robert Baillie, one of the Scottish representatives to the Westminster Assembly, was rarely impressed by the religious practices he found in 1640s London, but he was nonetheless struck by the enthusiasm of the English for taking notes at sermons: ‘the most of all the Assemblie wrytes, as almost all the people, men, women and children wryte at preaching’, he declared in January 1644.Footnote 30 This was presumably an exaggeration of the literacy standards of Londoners as well as of their zeal for sermons but his opinion is supported by other witnesses, and by the survival of many contemporary examples of sermon notes.Footnote 31
Note-taking was not an exclusively Puritan practice, as Spurr's recent analysis of John Evelyn's notes demonstrates, but in Alec Ryrie's words: ‘the importance of sermon-noting for earnest, literate Protestants would be hard to exaggerate’.Footnote 32 Books of advice on listening to and noting sermons were a popular printed genre in seventeenth-century England; and training in the effective recording and memorialisation of oral discourse was an essential element in grammar school and university curricula. Printed shorthand manuals, a distinctive English genre, were targeted at conscientious sermon attenders.Footnote 33 Hearing the word preached was crucial to salvation; recalling, repeating and meditating on sermons heard was central to zealous Protestant sociability and piety. Notes come in many forms from brief summaries to very full reports, based on a prior short-hand record; some are barely legible, others finely written. Writers may be anonymous or known only by name, while others like Samuel Pepys and John Evelyn are very familiar. Most valuable for my purposes are notes by identifiable individuals about whom enough is known to assess how their sermon notes connect with other aspects of their lives and opinions. The following discussion is based on six examples, five men and one woman, all broadly Puritan, with some sympathy at least for the parliament. Educated men from the middle and upper ranks of society predominate, predictably, given the value of a grammar school education to effective note-taking, but the most familiar example is socially the most humble: Nehemiah Wallington, who kept at least four notebooks of ‘precious sermons’ from the ‘book with a black cover, which I have written many precious sermons, which I did give to my wife, 1636’ to his fiftieth book, begun in 1654 of sermons heard at the Morning Exercise: ‘the Lord make me humble and write it in my heart’.Footnote 34 Wallington's initial enthusiasm for parliament waxed and waned through the later 1640s and 1650s as his highest hopes of religious reformation were thwarted and opposed. My second example, Walter Boothby, like Wallington, was a supporter of Presbyterian initiatives in the city. Elected as a common councillor in 1642, Boothby was active in furthering parliament's war effort in the city, and although he was a Presbyterian activist in the mid-1640s, he accepted office as an alderman in 1652.Footnote 35 Boothby's massive commonplace book, ‘A Nosegay of Everlasting Orificall Flowers Gathered out of Heavens Paradice’ drew on city sermons, especially by Presbyterians, preached from the 1630s to the 1660s.Footnote 36 John Harper, a citizen and fishmonger, living in the small parish of St Margaret Moses, made notes on sermons he had attended throughout his adult life, and at some point in the mid-1650s, he created a further fair copy of his notes (or some of them) in a volume of almost 600 pages.Footnote 37 Harper was a conscientious servant of his company, his parish and his ward, but no parliamentarian zealot. Unlike Boothby, Harper refused to serve the republican regime as an alderman, although he acted as a common councillor for Bread Street Ward from 1658 until his death in 1667.Footnote 38 Finally, members of the provincial gentry, with parliamentary connections and London residences, kept volumes of sermons in the 1640s including fast sermons preached at Margaret's Westminster or in the Abbey church. Walter Yonge junior, the son and namesake of an MP and parliamentary diarist who noted sermons between 1642 and 1644, was from a committed Puritan and moderate parliamentarian family.Footnote 39 Successive generations of the Gells of Hopton, Derbyshire, were conscientious recorders of sermons in London and the country from the 1640s to the end of the century. Three volumes covering 1644–6, kept by John Gell, the son of the notorious parliamentarian commander Sir John Gell, and his wife Katherine, have been used in this analysis. Katherine Gell, the daughter of a leading Westminster Puritan and parliamentarian, John Packer, and her husband were noted patrons of Presbyterian ministers throughout their lives, and associated closely with political Presbyterianism in the 1640s and 1650s.Footnote 40
The notes vary. There are summaries, apparently from memory, such as the five numbered paragraphs in which Boothby summed up a sermon by Edmund Calamy in 1646 on ‘Whether Christs death be effectual to all’, or the longer notes made by Wallington in November 1643: ‘And because I would never forget it, I have here set down those few broken scraps which I brought home with me, the Lord of his mercy wright them with the finger of his holy Spirit in the Table of my heart.’Footnote 41 Both Gells and Yonge constructed relatively full accounts of many sermons in small notebooks apparently used in the church, Yonge occasionally resorting to a simple short-hand and idiosyncratic abbreviations. Harper's single, long notebook incorporates a variety of techniques: two of Harper's versions were paragraph-long summaries written from memory when he got home, while the lengthiest notes may depend on privileged access to the preachers’ own texts, but most of the sermons are endorsed, `Written this sermon from my note books from the mouth of him when he preached the same’, indicating a prior short-hand record.Footnote 42
There is a half-submerged tendency in some of the literature on preaching to assume that hearers’ notes give a more authentic account of the sermon as preached, or at least a more accurate account than the printed text. But as John Spurr has cautioned, it is important to be clear about the ‘original context’ for note-taking. Although some took notes for directly instrumental purposes, such as to publish a printed version, with or without the minister's cooperation, for most lay people, the notes were part of a ‘a personal regime of piety’.Footnote 43 Furthermore, all sermon notebooks have particular material forms, indicative of specific textual characteristics and histories.
Walter Boothby's notebook is the most generically complex. As Spurr has noted, it is ‘in the process of mutating into a commonplace book’, while the latter sections of the volume are a letter book. Notes from a November 1648 sermon by the eminent Presbyterian Edmund Calamy, ‘How we may know our interest in Jesus Christ to be reall & good’, are dispersed with much cross-referencing into sections on Christ, on love (of God), on Merit and so on. Notes from sermons are also deployed in Boothby's letters, sometimes decades after they were preached, Boothby reminding his sister in May 1662 of ‘that grave advice which Mr Callamy gave you & I in a sermon preached 1641’ in a letter dealing with their hopes of heaven, with sin and the need to avoid playhouses.Footnote 44
The more conventional sermon notebooks reveal their enduring value for individual reflection. As John Harper noted from a sermon preached by William Jaggard at St Margaret Moses in February 1650, ‘it is not how many sermons you heare, but what you remember at those sermons, and how you labour to work them upon your soul’.Footnote 45 Similarly, a Derbyshire minister counselling Katherine Gell on the spiritual distress to which she was too often subject, explained, ‘the usefullest excercises of all piety, its a soules preaching to itselfe, without which the preacher from the pulpit doth little good’. Working through sermon notes helped a soul to preach to itself: ‘to helpe you may use any book or sermon notes you have upon that subject you would meditate on’.Footnote 46 Katherine and John Gell often took notes on the same sermons; their books show signs of mutual checking and revision, and the couples’ notebooks became precious and enduring family heirlooms. Their godly daughter Elizabeth read over her parents’ notes in the 1670s, adding systematic lists of preachers. The volumes were listed in the inventory of her possessions taken after her death in 1705.Footnote 47
Wallington's sermon notes were part of a life-long project, a perpetual construction, examination and renewal of his godly life, within his family and community, through an exhausting programme of writing, meditation, letter collections, tracts and treatises, frequently reread and revised: ‘my chiefe aime and ende of my writting of those books was for the praise and glory of my God’.Footnote 48 The notes served for personal reflection and for the characteristic practice of ‘repetition’ within Wallington's family, as with the ‘broken scraps’ of November 1643:
This sweet word of God revived me and was profitable unto me: yet in the Afternoone I was somewhat barren & could get but little benifet by Gods Ordinance: yet at night when we ware all parting to our beds Some words of exortation I spake to my family not to forget the instructions which God hath made knowen to us but to remember them all the weeke Longe.Footnote 49
Like the Gell's volumes, Wallington's notebooks passed down the generations. ‘The groth of a Christian’, a volume mostly of sermon notes focused on effective preparation for the sacrament was begun in January 1641 and completed in December 1643, read over in spring 1658, and in his son-in-law's possession after Wallington's death later that year.Footnote 50
From internal evidence, Harper's volume was constructed from earlier notes in the mid-1650s, almost certainly in the early stages of hearing a long sermon series on ‘severall heads of Divinity’, the fundamentals of the Christian faith preached by his parish minister Benjamin Needler. A sense that these fundamentals were under attack in the 1650s seems to have prompted Harper to copy out the extensive notes he had made in his youth from the sermons of Needler's father-in-law and predecessor, the moderate Calvinist Richard Culverwell’s, along with other ‘brief notes’ into a single book. The reasssertion of his orthodox upbringing brought reassurance in a period of division and dispute.Footnote 51
The sermon notes made by these conscientious hearers place the immediate, dramatic, polemical fast sermons, tied to particularly urgent conjunctures in the fortunes of the parliament and nation, within more personal, more enduring contexts. These hearers were not necessarily opposed or resistant to the more political or controversial messages of the sermons (although Harper probably was) but these were not necessarily the most relevant elements for the purposes of personal note-taking.Footnote 52 Fast sermons were but part of the preaching available in London in the 1640s and 1650s. The notebooks of Harper and the Gells help us identify how listening to high-profile sermons on special public occasions took place within complex patterns of preaching attendance. It is not clear whether there was more preaching than ever in the city under Puritan rule. The usually gloomy Wallington was optimistic here, but modern scholars are more cautious. Against the regular fast days and the preaching exercises that flourished in some parishes, we must set the disruption of routine parish preaching in a city where 96 per cent of parish clergy were ejected in the early 1640s, and where revival of parochial religion was delayed and disrupted in many parishes by lack of ministers and increasing religious conflict and fragmentation.Footnote 53 The sermons Harper noted included thirty-four sermons preached on special occasions, including some dramatic fast days at St Paul's Cathedral (as he continued to call it) in the 1640s and 1650s: he heard William Gouge on heresy in March 1647, Stephen Marshall on peace negotiations in September 1648 and Edmund Calamy in March 1656 as the English fleet sailed to the Caribbean, but most of his notes are extended versions of more conventional, pastoral sermon-series preached in his own parish by Needler and Culverwell, the latter taking up more than half the volume. There is only one sermon from the parish noted between 1641 and 1650, whether this is because of disruption to parish life, or of Harper's choice of what to copy from earlier notes is impossible to say.
When in London, the Gells lived mainly in Twickenham, where they usually kept the major fast days, but they also spent time at Westminster with Katherine's parents. Stephen Marshall's preaching was precious to Katherine Gell in particular; as she explained to Richard Baxter much later, she had been converted by Marshall in the early 1640s and had subsequently ‘received much comfort from him’ through personal discussion and reading his books as well as through his preaching.Footnote 54 The three 1640s Gell volumes examined here confirm Marshall's reputation as an indefatigable preacher in and around Westminster, beyond the well-known fast days. But this was rarely the Marshall of Meroz Cursed, for the Gell notes (like some of Harper’s) highlight rather his ability to deliver vivid and elaborate explications of biblical texts, and to present a sensitive pastoral message. In a volume covering November 1644 – May 1645, John Gell noted seventy-eight sermons, some three a week, almost half of them (thirty-three) given by Marshall. Some were fast sermons at St Margaret’s, but more were from the pastorally focused morning lectures given in a rota by Marshall and other preachers at Westminster Abbey. In these weeks, Marshall was preaching on preparation for taking the sacrament from 1 Corinthians chapter 11.Footnote 55 Similarly, in two overlapping notebooks from 1645–6, Marshall is again a favourite. John's ‘begun at Westminster June 27 1645 and ended at Wirksworth in Derbyshire Sept. 6 1646’ records forty-five sermons; seven out of some twelve London and Westminster sermons were preached by Marshall – all but one on John 8.36. The sermon notes focus on salvation and on love of Christ.Footnote 56 Katherine's notebook (‘begun at Westminster March 1 1645[/6] and ended at Darly in Darbyshire July 29 1646’) includes notes on fifty-nine sermons in this shorter period; again there are twenty-four in Twickenham, against twenty-two in Westminster or London, with twelve in Derbyshire at the end. Over half (twelve) of the metropolitan occasions feature Marshall, and the majority (seven) look like a pastorally focused series on sanctification, based on 1 Thessalonians 5.23.Footnote 57 The most difficult issues indeed are noted from the provincial sermons of Martin Topham in Wirksworth, defending jure divino Presbyterian church government in the summer of 1646.Footnote 58
Harper's notebook offers similar conclusions: the predominance in his notebook of parish-based sermon-series on the fundamentals of the Christian faith in itself suggests a relative lack of interest in doctrinal debate or overtly political preaching. Harper's notes on two unpublished fast sermons include controversial material within a broader, more conventional emphasis. His notes on Edmund Calamy's sermon in St Paul's Cathedral, at the fast to bless the expedition to the Indies (March 1656) registered Calamy's frank comments on the Lord Protector:
As God tould David, Because he was a man of blood, that had made great warres, therefore he should not build him an house, 1. Chronicles 22.8. So it may be God hath not appointed this our Governour to setle a reformacon bec(ause) he hath shedd much blood, and hath made great warres.
But Harper was more concerned with sanctification (a preoccupation of the pre-war Culverwell notes), and with Calamy's exhortations to the city magistrates (Harper amongst them) to religious and moral reformation.Footnote 59 Similarly, from the sermon Harper (on a rare visit to St Margaret's Westminster) heard Stephen Marshall give in August 1648 on Isaiah 28.29, ‘to implore of God a blessing on the Treaty of peace, with the King’, he did include a paragraph on ‘the present business of our meeting’ but most of the four pages of notes were taken up with Marshall's account of the Old Testament context, and more general pastoral and moral ‘uses’.Footnote 60
The early 1640s notebooks of Walter Yonge are more preoccupied with the political messages in monthly fast sermons and 5 November commemorations. In autumn 1642, an unnamed preacher at All-Hallows, Lombard Street, recalled the ‘Egyptian darknes’ when ‘a tradesmans goods, a gentlemans lands, a ministers liberty to preach & to serve God, could never be exercised by reason of monopolyes, ship money, star chamber, high commission, popish superstitions, ceremonye’. The following spring a Mr Broom at St Peter's Cornhill insisted there could be no safety for those who wished ‘all the Roundheads had but one neck to strike’. Perhaps Yonge was more interested in noting political allusions than Gell or Harper, or perhaps issues were more starkly expressed in the early 1640s when enemies were more easily identified and parliamentarian hopes undashed. Yonge ‘gadded’ to more parishes than the Gells or Harper. But Yonge's notebooks, like Gell's or Harper’s, all made extensive notes on more conventional series of sermons, by the prominent future Presbyterians William Jenkins at Christ Church and James Cranford at St Christopher’s, not here in polemical mode but preparing for the sacrament in Cranford's case and painstakingly interpreting the Song of Song in Jenkins’.Footnote 61
IV
John Gell, Yonge and Harper all took notes on sermons that found their way into print, and their efforts confirm the recent studies that suggest a conscientious, trained hearer could produce a recognisable account of a sermon as delivered (or at least one that is recognisable from the printed version). There was a productive interaction between preaching styles and note-taking culture, with the characteristic structure of sermons, organised around scriptural texts, doctrines and uses, facilitating concentration and effective note-taking.Footnote 62 Both contemporaries and modern scholars have pondered the complex relationship between hearers’ notes, and a printed version, and the ‘intractable’ matter of how either version represents what was delivered.Footnote 63 Juxtaposing a manuscript and a printed version nonetheless offers some suggestive insights. One example must suffice here: John Gell's notes on Marshall's fast sermon, 30 April 1645, published shortly afterwards. Gell's is a decent summary in the main: he does not note a technical analysis of the Hebrew text (which might have been added for the press), and he drastically abbreviates the biblical stories which surely Marshall did give at length, confining himself to brief comments, such as ‘thus David did’. More remarkably, however, he misses most of the overt contemporary references to England, Germany, Scotland and Ireland, to focus more specifically on the purposes of prayer in aiding reformation and comforting God's people in distress. Gell included Marshall's general exhortations on the necessity of the Saints’ prayers to the building of Sion, but he was not struck by a passage in which Marshall bemoaned the lack of zeal in fast days: ‘Thus follow him with a mourning heart, a melting eye, do it constantly, doe it daily, I confesse these monthly fasts are grown to a most wretched formality in many places, the Lord of heaven teach us how we may be more quickened in this great work of prayer.’Footnote 64 It would be odd for Marshall not to make this point to his immediate auditors; perhaps Gell did not see these remarks as applying to him.
V
The paradoxes of these years can be illustrated in conclusion by returning briefly to the initial broadside's evocation of the Morning Exercise, that itself attracted lively and often inter-connected manuscript and printed commentary. Founded by the Presbyterian Thomas Case in response to the royalist sack and capture of Leicester in spring 1645, the Morning Exercise might be seen as a pastoral alternative to the politically engaged sermons of parliamentary fast days, a programme that Elliot Vernon has described as a combination of ‘evangelistic outreach and catechetical instruction’, whereby over a whole month in a different parish a succession of ministers preached a brief early morning sermon.Footnote 65 The approach of the exercise to nearby parishes in March 1654 prompted Wallington to reflect enthusiastically on transformations in London preaching, on ‘the many thousands of sarmons that have been preached and yet no lesse in this Fountain of the word which stremith forth so long as the world continueth’. He looked forward to the ‘sweet profitabl veriety of the word’ such an exercise afforded, and noted that the exercise would come in April 1654 to St Andrew Hubbard, ‘a parish where my Father [lived] VIII yeers and never heard one sarmon where I here many a one in a weeke’.Footnote 66 Wallington's notes on the exercise have not survived, but three sets of notes (two of them known from printed books) suggest qualifications to Wallington's straightforward enthusiasm for their evangelical character. In 1648, a hostile hearer from John Goodwin's Independent church took notes of the Presbyterian ministers’ denunciations of the army and the parliament during their preaching at the exercise, reproducing them in angry capitals in a printed pamphlet.Footnote 67 Presbyterians in response claimed that ‘constant and conscientious hearers’ found the sermons ‘as hony to their tasts and marrow to their bones’, rising early for them, ‘winter and summer, wet and dry’, while accepting that one of their aims was ‘to discover the evills and errours of the times impartially, that Gods people may be humbled for them, and avoid them’.Footnote 68
By the mid-1650s, Presbyterian hopes of a reformed national church were dashed, and even a man like Thomas Case, arrested for royalist plotting in 1651, had come to terms with the Cromwellian regime; passions were less heated and to some extent Wallington's view of the Morning Exercise as a uncontroversial pastoral initiative focusing on personal reformation is supported by other evidence. Case published brief accounts of the sermons preached in St Giles in the Fields in May 1655, based in the main on ‘notes being taken from the Pulpit to my hand’, framed by his own introduction and a final sermon in which he offered ‘a summary rehearsal’ of the intervening ones (in the manner of pre-civil war Spital sermons).Footnote 69 In January 1659, the Morning Exercise finally arrived at John Harper's own small parish, St Margaret Moses, and in a manner characteristic of his moderate Puritan, parish-focused piety, Harper preserved his notes on at least six of them. Both Case's printed version and Harper's manuscript notes combine conventional, pastoral exhortations and references to God's providences with more pointed, controversial matter, unavoidable and unmistakeable traces of the divisions and perplexities of the times. In Case's concluding sermon, he insisted that amongst the dispensations of God was the sending of thirty properly ordained ministers to the parish to preach the word: ‘he hath not sent gifted brethren among you, he hath not sent loose and debauched men of wretched principles, to speak to you the vision of their hearts’.Footnote 70 Harper's notes stressed the need for Christians to devote themselves to ‘meditation of things above; examination of mans owne heart, mortifying of sinnes &c’ and to avoid the hypocrisy of being ‘a Saint in the Church and a cheate in his shop’ . But he also recorded ‘That it is the duty of Christians to have noe communion with hereticks, from such turne away’ and warnings about the dangers of sinfulness amongst apparently godly ‘professors’.Footnote 71
It turns out that simple contrasts are unhelpful and that conventional, pastoral preaching and the set-piece, high-profile, controversial sermons are difficult to untangle in the records of hearers. Notes on fast sermons do not stress the immediate political imperatives of the day, whereas, particularly from the perspective of a very moderate hearer like John Harper, we can see that no routine, allegedly uncontroversial preaching could evade the religious conflicts and fragmentation of the 1640s and 1650s, as the dilemmas of a religious marketplace penetrated the most routine and didactic sermons on the fundamentals of the faith or at a Morning Exercise. It might be argued that that tendency of note-takers to underplay the more immediate, political references in the fast sermons is evidence for their overall failure as propaganda or inspiration, but this would be to ignore the specific character and lasting purposes of sermon noting. On the contrary, the dynamic parliamentary fast sermons of the revolution may well have worked to rally hearers to the parliamentary cause (or versions of it) precisely because they could also be absorbed and understood on a variety of levels, as enduring prompts to personal piety and reflection, or as arresting explications of biblical history. A distinctive revolutionary Puritan culture – the culture of fast days and Meroz Cursed – allowed for complex engagements and drew on long-standing practices of strenuous Puritan piety in hearing, recording, reflecting on and discussing sermons.
