Philip Ridley has made a career of courting controversy in his work for the stage, from the claustrophobia and anxiety of his first play, 1991's The Pitchfork Disney, to the sprawling, ragtag Karagula, whose one-star review in the Telegraph led with the provocative headline, “Is Karagula the Worst Play of 2016?”Footnote 1 But perhaps no play in Ridley's oeuvre has attracted as much notoriety as 2005's Mercury Fur, an intense, unrelenting, “interval-less two-hour piece”Footnote 2 whose premiere divided critical opinion and provoked walkouts. Paines Plough, the company that commissioned the play, reports that “at least ten audience members a night left every show, unable to take the atmosphere of threat and violence portrayed on stage.”Footnote 3 Mercury Fur is set in a futuristic English dystopia whose aimless youth find their grasp on history—and their own memories—slipping away as they become addicted to hallucinogenic butterflies released upon the populace by an ambiguous invading power. While the protagonist, Elliot, ekes out a living peddling butterflies in an ice cream van, he and his brother, Darren, make their real money from throwing “parties,” clandestine meetings for rich clients who pay exorbitantly to fulfill their most violent and murderous sexual fantasies. The play, performed in real time, sees the frantic preparation for—and eventual botched execution of—one such party for a City of London executive (the Party Guest), whose Vietnam War–themed fantasy involves torturing and killing a child Elvis Presley impersonator (the Party Piece) with a meat hook. Unsurprisingly, given the subject matter, moral outrage attended Mercury Fur’s initial run, with Faber, Ridley's longtime publisher, going so far as to refuse to print the play. But a number of critics and spectators rose to defend the integrity and artistic merit of Ridley's work, a position I extend in this paper.
The ethical questions Ridley poses in Mercury Fur are, I argue, embedded in a thoroughgoing examination of the British political economy and the legacy of Thatcher-era neoliberal reform, which manifests both formally and thematically in the play's compression of space and time: geographical distance collapses, and the acceleration of time estranges the present from its temporal antecedents, trends that are in line with geographer David Harvey's formulation of neoliberalism in his landmark book, The Condition of Postmodernity. This essay examines Mercury Fur—the conditions surrounding its production, the local permutations it undergoes in international revivals, and the play's sprawling implications for a theatre always enmeshed in networks of neoliberal capital—in light of Harvey's work, in order to consider the play's radical compression of time and space in service of its critique of global capitalism. I pay attention to the play's original production in 2005, with recourse to unpublished typescripts of earlier drafts of the play and archival production materials, as well as to a 2015 revival in New York, which purposefully participated in the play's condensation of geographical space. What Mercury Fur accomplishes in its stagecraft, destabilization of place, and telescopic treatment of history and time is a remarkable theatrical translation of the political, economic, and cultural forces Harvey observes at work since the end of the Second World War. If space–time compression is, as Harvey asserts, the hallmark feature of global capitalism, its dramatization in Mercury Fur speaks to the ubiquity of neoliberal thought in our daily lives, holding us always in thrall to its spatiotemporal illogic and contorting us in accordance with its characteristic flexibility. My aim, then, is to dislocate Mercury Fur from its knee-jerk association with controversy, graphic violence, and walkouts, in order to reinterrogate the play as an ultimately hopeful expression of resistance to the machinations of neoliberal consensus politics.
Achieving the Neoliberal Consensus
In The Condition of Postmodernity, Harvey synthesizes a wide-ranging series of changes to economic policy and labor control that have inaugurated a gradual and pervasive shift toward what he calls “flexible accumulation … rest[ing] on flexibility with respect to labour processes, labour markets, products, and patterns of consumption.”Footnote 4 This flexibility has fundamentally restructured capitalism by unyoking it from the centralization of the Fordist model that dominated the first half of the twentieth century. As a result of a number of substantial changes—deregulation, the rolling back of union power, the replacement of the gold standard with the floating exchange rate—volatility has become the chief characteristic of the neoliberal economy, and symptomatic of this transition to flexible accumulation, according to Harvey, is the compression of time and space: “the time horizons of both private and public decision-making have shrunk, while satellite communication and declining transport costs have made it increasingly possible to spread those decisions immediately over an ever wider and variegated space.”Footnote 5 The increasingly rapid rate of technological innovation thus condenses geographical distance, renders the world infinitely more traversable, and accelerates the circulation of capital, bending everything within reach to a spatiotemporal logic that is experienced as illogic at the level of labor and cultural life.
Harvey wrote the book in the thick of the Right's wholesale reconfiguration of the British economy and published it in 1989, only two years after Margaret Thatcher delivered a third consecutive electoral victory to the Conservatives on a platform that rested heavily on the achievements of her two previous terms: rampant denationalization, an assault on organized labor and trade union power, and the so-called Big Bang of 1986, which deregulated the City of London and introduced unlimited foreign direct investment in the London Stock Exchange. In the meantime, a fractious, splintered Labour Party suffered successive defeats at the polls as it struggled to regain purchase in a country that, under Thatcher, largely embraced the Tories’ rejection of social-democratic consensus politics. Labour's failure to articulate a viable alternative to the neoliberal project—for the Keynesian model was so effectively pilloried by the Conservatives that it came to resemble utopian romance rather than feasible policy—meant that the Right was free to run roughshod over any and every facet of the welfare state that had once been taken for granted.
That the publication of The Condition of Postmodernity coincided with the tenth anniversary of Thatcher's premiership well positioned Harvey to reflect on the myriad changes to political and cultural life that the neoliberal agenda had instantiated in the preceding decade. Too, Harvey correctly predicted neoliberalism's tenacity, for, five years later, Tony Blair would take the helm of the moribund Labour Party and perform an unlikely resurrection, rechristening the party “New Labour” and laying to rest its traditional commitment to the social welfare state, a decisive shift to the right that led many to accuse the party of abandoning its principles.Footnote 6 Nonetheless, Blair delivered a landslide victory in 1997, and his strategic realignment of the Labour Party with Conservative economic policy concretized neoliberalism as the political consensus in Britain (a move that saw its analogue in the United States, where Bill Clinton's administration took up the reins of Reaganomics).
If Blair's premiership represents the neoliberal model's entrenchment as political hegemony, it too emblematizes a mounting disillusionment with politics at the turn of the millennium, the bleak realization that beneath the guise of political choice were merely variations on a theme. And Blair's enthusiastic cooperation in the invasion of Iraq—the stain of which has only darkened over time, especially after the publication of the Chilcot report in 2016—contributed to the cynical conclusion that political machinations operated unperturbed in spite of public sentiment. Indeed, as Harvey refined and updated his analysis in the years after The Condition of Postmodernity, he diagnosed widespread ignorance of neoliberalism's insidious yet fundamental class dimension, which has only abetted its ascent to hegemonic dominance. In A Brief History of Neoliberalism, published in 2005, he argues, “The possibility … that the ruling ideas might be those of some ruling class is not even considered, even though there is overwhelming evidence for massive interventions on the part of business elites and financial interests in the production of ideas and ideologies: through investment in think-tanks, in the training of technocrats, and in the command of the media.”Footnote 7 The spotlight Harvey focuses on class here is, of course, germane to his argument about neoliberalism on the whole, which he asserts has “all along primarily functioned as a mask for practices that are all about the maintenance, reconstitution, and restoration of elite class power,”Footnote 8 and it is this orchestrated redistribution of power and wealth—a siphoning up rather than a trickling down—that produces the disorientation and spatiotemporal illogic that afflicts cultural life in the neoliberal state.
T/Here
Such illogic permeates Philip Ridley's controversial Mercury Fur. Commissioned as part of Paines Plough's thirtieth anniversary season, Mercury Fur joined plays by Enda Walsh, David Greig, and Douglas Maxwell to “think about English as a language and how it shapes our identity.”Footnote 9 And the season's title, “This Other England,” is telling.Footnote 10 Combining the proximity of the demonstrative this with a modifier that seems to point somewhere else (and that these adjectives are capped by an evocation of national identity) produces a curious kind of friction that destabilizes our sense of space. This other country, the title suggests, exists simultaneously within and without, its various representations limning the margins of English identity—and the language so fundamental to its constitution—both now and there, here and then.
Ridley's play undoubtedly offers an alternative vision of a “nightmarish contemporary England,” per Lyn Gardner's words in her review for the Guardian, “a bitter place where memory and all sense of history have been so eroded that the young think the second world war [sic] was caused by Kennedy fighting Hitler over Marilyn Monroe.”Footnote 11 And language has been irretrievably eroded, too, Michael Billington noted in his review for the same paper, observing that the characters’ speech is reduced to “a scatalogical mix of four-letter words and racist abuse[,] … the vocabulary of hate,”Footnote 12 likely referring to Elliot's favorite insult, a potpourri of racial slurs strung artlessly together: “you nigger, Paki, wop, spic, chinkie, Muslim, Christian cunt!”Footnote 13 Notably, some of this racist language, published in the version of Mercury Fur collected in the Methuen anthology Plays: 2, is replaced with rather different imagery in the 2012 Bloomsbury edition (cited here throughout): “a polished bullet up a nigger's arsehole”Footnote 14 becomes “a polished bullet up a napalmed arsehole” (14), and “a million miles of Paki afterbirth”Footnote 15 becomes “a million miles of machine-gunned afterbirth” (16). The racist violence that saturated the play's language thus gave way, over the course of revision, to images of military brutality, mapping a direct correlation between racism and war in their shared project of dehumanizing the other as an instrument of domination. And the inference that military violence is apparently commonplace enough to be woven into casual insults adds to a disturbing portrait of this other England perhaps not so far away.
Like all of Ridley's plays before it, Mercury Fur folds geographical specificity into its opening stage direction—“A derelict flat in a derelict estate in the East End of London” (9)—though the myriad references to places like Bethnal Green Road and Victoria Park that pepper The Fastest Clock in the Universe and Ghost from a Perfect Place are, here, less pervasive. In spite of its East End setting, however, the play also manages to seem geographically unfixed. Like Sarah Kane ten years earlier, whose Blasted smashed together the “here” and “there” of 1995—that is, a posh hotel room in Leeds and the war-torn streets of Srebrenica—Ridley limns the reach of military atrocities in 2005, collapsing the distance between Blairite London, the Middle East, and central Africa (though, of course, the “there” of both plays is merely suggested, never explicitly stated).
This spatial coalescence is conspicuously literal, as characters repeatedly allude to a sandstorm that coincided with the addictive butterflies’ first appearance. Lola, Elliot's lover, recalls, “In the morning I looked out of my window and saw … sand. A layer of sand over everything. […] You see, the storm—somehow—had sucked up sand from some desert thousands of miles away. And this cloud had travelled all the way here and … rained sand” (61–2).Footnote 16 The desert has quite literally come to London, and, with it, the wartime atrocities so comfortably demarcated as “there” and, therefore, far away. This meteorological phenomenon is, of course, not entirely fictional. The Met Office, Britain's national weather service, dubs it “Saharan Dust,” explaining that “wind can blow strongly over deserts—whipping up dust and sand high into the sky. … Once it is lifted from the ground by strong winds, clouds of dust can reach very high altitudes and be transported worldwide, covering thousands of miles.”Footnote 17 As in the play, seemingly discrete places cease to appear separate, and national—even continental—barriers diminish in their ability to demarcate space.
The sandstorm recalls an instance in Ridley's childhood, which he relates in the introductions to the Methuen anthologies of his plays. Consisting of a chronological series of autobiographical fragments, the introductions narrate Ridley's life, from his cloistered childhood to his beginnings in the theatre, and they are rife with images and motifs that crop up in his plays. Of course, Ridley wrote the volumes’ introductions long after the premieres of the plays published therein, but he insists on the legitimacy of their autobiographical content and the relationship between these events from his personal life and their later iterations in his work for the stage:
What I decided was … because a lot of people have always thought of my work as far fetched [sic] and fantastical etc., I wanted to show them that, on the contrary, it was based on something real. Something from my life experience. That my work is all very personal. That I take events and, yes, sometimes I turn the colour up and make them more intense … but no matter how sci-fi or fantasy they end up becoming … they are emotionally true. Now … that's not saying I didn't exaggerate and turn all the colours up in the autobiographical episodes. Of course I did. But in spirit they are sort of what happened. Sort of. I suppose the best way to describe them is as ‘autobiographical hallucinations.’Footnote 18
In the first fragment of the introduction to Plays: 2, Ridley, like Lola, describes waking up one morning to find the East End covered in a layer of sand: “Everything in the street; the pavement, cars, dustbins—it all appears a little faded, like a sepia photograph.”Footnote 19 Consider this evocative image's interplay of space and time: the transported sand collapses geographical distance, just as the old photograph crystallizes the past and carries it into the present moment. It is precisely this spatiotemporal compression—the chief characteristic, per Harvey, of cultural life in the neoliberal state—that configures both the style and the substance of Mercury Fur, whose political and theatrical stakes are bound up in its simultaneously vast and claustrophobic messiness.
This relationship between space and time—their mutual condensation, their inextricability from one another—manifests at every level of the play, even beyond the dramatic text, as it did in John Tiffany's original production at the Drum Theatre, Plymouth and then the Menier Chocolate Factory in London. Before reaching the auditorium, spectators were led by flashlight through an antechamber that was deliberately designed to unsettle the audience in anticipation of the horrors that were to follow. In her (favorable, it should be said) review for the Independent on Sunday, Kate Bassett warned her readers of what they were in for: “Groping towards a distant torch beam, you pass through a wrecked child's bedroom into the main space: a sea of litter, broken toys and upturned armchairs.”Footnote 20 While this might appear, at the outset, as a gratuitous capitalization on the play's macabre subject matter, the antechamber served a significant function at the play's climax: it was the room in which Naz, a young drifter who naively volunteers to help the brothers throw their party, is tortured and nearly killed when he is forced to surrogate for the Party Piece, who dies before the Party Guest's fantasy is enacted, and the offstage scene was accompanied by a grisly soundscape perhaps more imagistically evocative than any mimetic representation possible onstage. And integral to this moment was the collective spectatorial memory of having passed through the very room in which such unimaginable violence was occurring: “even if the violence took place out of sight, we remembered its look, feel and smell.”Footnote 21 The original production's climax thus compressed time and space even on a small scale, relying on the audience's memory—its ability to deliver the recent past into the present—to condense a currently unseen but vividly remembered room into the unoccupied playing space.
That the compression of time and space figures so prominently in the play's subject matter as well as in its theatricalization should come as no surprise given Ridley's concern with late capitalism's penchant for indiscriminate commodification. In the neoliberal state, seemingly anything (and anyone) is eligible to be bought and sold. Ridley has said that “the play began by asking, ‘What's the logical conclusion?,’” referring to the increasing accessibility and ubiquity of violent pornography: “Well, the logical conclusion,” he determined, “is that you don't just watch it, you enact it.”Footnote 22 The conceit, of course, is that unbridled visual consumption reduces the onscreen body to a thing, renders it an object of pleasure, and obscures its personhood. The extreme consequence of this objectifying gaze is the conflation of the human being with its filmic simulacrum, so that the Party Guest fails even to conceive of the (aptly named) Party Piece as anything other than a necessary bit of equipment in his elaborate sexual fantasy. Anna Harpin argues that, in this sense, Mercury Fur articulates a call to accountability for our visual consumption, what she calls the “ethical gaze”: the play “actively invites an audience to take responsibility for the act of looking.”Footnote 23 And Tiffany's production countered precisely the distancing gaze produced by perspectival staging, opting instead for a traverse stage that Sam Marlowe described as “so insistently, nastily involving that the viewer feels uncomfortably complicit in the horrors enacted.”Footnote 24 Harpin, too, found that the traverse staging “rendered the performance incredibly loud and impossibly close,”Footnote 25 ultimately locating the audience “within the disoriented landscape as opposed to on its perimeter.”Footnote 26 The New Group's 2015 production in New York followed suit, seating a number of spectators on the onstage furniture so that the parallel banks of seating seemed to bleed into the playing space. Both strategies emphasize the act of seeing—as you watch the play and watch others do the same, you become simultaneously aware that you, too, are being watched—bringing the audience collectively and uncomfortably closer to the performers in order to “prompt[ ] a sober, portentous and ethical embrace with (an)other life.”Footnote 27
The staging of the New Group production thus militated against the possibility of distancing oneself from the play's action, a strategy that Ridley intends for all international productions of Mercury Fur. In addition to the Romulus Linney Courtyard Theatre's uncomfortably intimate seating plan, changes to the performance text served to localize the action, swapping out references to Victoria Park and the British Museum for more pointed allusions to Washington Square Park and MoMA, locations that strike considerably closer to home for a native New York audience. Ridley explains that he purposefully emends the text for every production outside of London, providing local references to situate the play's disturbing action as immediately as possible to the spectator's lived experience: “This is the only one of my plays that I allow this to happen with. The reason is, I don't want to allow the audience the luxury of ‘distancing’ themselves from the events[,] i.e. of saying, ‘Oh, something like that could never happen here. It can only happen … over there.’”Footnote 28 Of course, Ridley has taken aim at this sensibility in other plays, too. Recall Anita, in Vincent River, who responds to her son's anguish over the Vietnam War by articulating precisely this politics of distance: “I said, ‘You've got nothing to worry about Vincent. That happened miles and miles away. No one's gonna hurt you here.’”Footnote 29
Accordingly, the New York production of Mercury Fur precluded this possibility of geographical dissociation by abandoning the language and style of London's East End in favor of more locally recognizable nuances: the accents were American, “brov” became “bro,” and Spinx, the group's de facto leader, traded in his fur and bling for denim and leather.Footnote 30 Here, then, is the geographical compression emblematized by Saharan dust, violently swept up over there and making its way here. An international audience is denied the comfort of gesturing vaguely to London, to somewhere other than here, as a site for the kinds of violence and trauma Mercury Fur thematizes. The reconfigured text ensures that this violence and trauma—and our bristling, uncomfortable proximity to it—happens in every city in which the play is performed.
Remember?
Of course, geographical space is not the only site of compression in Harvey's formulation of flexible accumulation. Hand in hand with the collapse of physical distance is the acceleration of time, a consistent facet of capitalist development, “[s]ymbolized by clocks and bells that called workers to labour and merchants to market.”Footnote 31 These “new rules of temporal discipline,”Footnote 32 Harvey reminds us, reveal “capitalist modernization to be very much about speed-up and acceleration in the pace of economic processes and, hence, in social life.”Footnote 33 Space–time compression thus emerges in Harvey's discussion as the central feature of the neoliberal economy, accelerating time while simultaneously emphasizing and effacing the specificity of geographical place. He observes, however, the emergence of a “contemplative memory,” hopelessly out of sync with neoliberalism's frenetic temporal logic, as only a tenuous corrective to capitalism's ramifications for social life and identity, “a generator of a sense of self that lies outside the sensory overloading of consumerist culture and fashion. The home becomes a private museum to guard against the ravages of time–space compression.”Footnote 34 But neither the home nor the museum fares well in Mercury Fur.
In Ridley's play, the destabilization of time takes the form of a fragmented past, a history that characters fail to recollect with any modicum of coherence. When Darren recalls his brother's childhood aspirations—“Elliot wanted to be something when he grew up. […] It had a name. He wanted to be someone who … digs up old things. Like bones and stuff”—Naz replies, “Never heard of that” (35). Archaeology, the professional practice of cobbling together a coherent sense of history through the remnants of its material culture, has become obsolete; the characters thus forget not only the past but also that there once existed ways to document and remember it. In this way, the play's present circumstances become unfixed from any kind of historical antecedent, a fracturing of temporal logic that reflects the postmodern fragmentation of time.
If, as Harvey suggests, the home is a private museum that leverages memory in order to safeguard against the destabilization of time, Mercury Fur sets out in its opening stage directions a devastation of this vital space, so intimately linked with the past: “Layers of peeling wallpaper (many cleaner patches where framed photos once hung), several pieces of old furniture (armchairs, sideboard, shelves, etc.), well-worn carpet and smashed ornaments” (9). The original production's stage plan, too, indicates that the “timber cupboard interior” has a “couple of lonely hangers, mothballs[,] […] doors hanging off.”Footnote 35 And the British Museum has fared no better—“Big building up West. Glass roof. They set fire to it” (29)—though Naz, who has looted the museum for artifacts with which to barter for drugs, clearly fails to understand the building's cultural significance (or even recognize it, for that matter). This destruction of cultural history is, in Ridley's assessment, fundamental to neoimperialist strategies of social control, a phenomenon he observed at work in the United States–led invasion of the Middle East:
Now of course that is stage one of an invasion for any imperialist force. That's what America did in Iraq. That's why no one was stopped from looting the museums in Baghdad. The Americans just let it happen, let the Iraqis destroy their history because they'd be easier to control. And Mercury Fur is about what happens to people when you take away their history.Footnote 36
Here, in addition to the devastation of culturally significant spaces, these vital reservoirs of historical memory, the concerted dismantling of history is accomplished by the dissemination of habit-forming butterflies that “bit by bit […] take away people's memory.”Footnote 37 And the difficulty of accessing one's memories—even the most seemingly banal fragments of recollection—is demonstrated early in the play. When Darren, a frequent butterfly user who struggles to retain new information, pronounces, “I remembered the wooden guns,” his unexpected success at recalling a moment from his childhood is remarkable enough that “Elliot stops what he's doing” (17). Darren feels around for additional details—“The wooden guns. Dad made ’em. Remember? He carved our names in the handles” (17)—and his repeated invitation to Elliot to join him in actively recalling their past (“Remember?”), perhaps to corroborate his own memory, becomes a refrain that Darren articulates with increasing urgency throughout the play, as he seeks recourse to a shared memory of the past in order to make sense of the present.
Naz, too, has only fleeting memories of his childhood, but he manages to recount the beheading of his mother and rape of his sister (though he fumbles vaguely over her name) in a supermarket—an episode Lyn Gardner explains is “based on a similar event that took place in Rwanda,” citing Ridley's “scrapbooks in which he has documented news from around the world”Footnote 38 —and he relates the traumatic episode with a calm, almost indifferent, demeanor, recalling more easily the rapists’ choice of drink than his own sister's name, itself an acid sign of consumer culture: “He sticks his cock in her. One of the others fucks what's left of her mouth. They all drink Coke. They fuck Stace and they drink Coke” (39).Footnote 39 But the disturbing clarity of this recollection appears anomalous, as the rest of Naz's childhood memories elude him. When he struggles to describe his father to Elliot, he confesses, “you know, I can't remember anything about him at all,” before concluding, “It's the butterflies, ain't it?” (63). Elliot's terse reply confirms the correlation, but his own recollection of the sandstorm that introduced the butterflies in the first place—and Ridley encourages us to trust Elliot's memory, since he resolutely refuses to consume the drug himself—points to a more sinister origin for the hallucinogenic insects, in line with Ridley's broader political observations: “It's planes! There's so many of them. They're way, way up. Their lights are all twinkling. Then I feel it. […] On my face. Like dust. […] It's sand. And … something else. […] A cocoon. A butterfly cocoon. […] I keep hearing planes. I keep seeing sand and cocoons. But I don't see or hear any fucking storm” (66). Here, then, is the confirmation of what we have feared all along, that the sandstorm—“A freak of nature, the telly said” (62)—was, in fact, phase one of an orchestrated invasion, designed to obliterate cultural memory and subdue the populace, “an idea,” Dan Rebellato asserts, “drawn from persistent stories that the CIA flooded black neighbourhoods with drugs, as a means of destabilising the emergent civil rights movements.”Footnote 40 Thus, Andrew Wyllie's assessment that “the absence of memory that lies at the heart of the play … serves as a portrait of the fatal dangers of allowing cultural and personal memory to become obscured”Footnote 41 is perhaps in want of nuance. The erosion of memory and history in Mercury Fur is less a choice, passively permitted by its characters, than a top-down governmental strategy of neoimperialist domination.
I turn here, only briefly, to a more recent Ridley play, 2016's Karagula, another ambitious study in space–time compression that indexes even more explicitly the dystopian affinity between political statecraft and its erosion of cultural memory in the service of rewriting history—a preoccupation that sizzles with renewed topicality in the “posttruth” era of Brexit and Donald Trump. More than any other of Ridley's works since 2005, Karagula revisits the macropolitical thematic resonances of Mercury Fur and picks up in many ways where the earlier play leaves off. Its structure, described by one reviewer as a series of “seemingly disconnected snapshots, which begin to knit together, dislocated in time but rippling into each other,”Footnote 42 lurches forward and back through a vast nonlinear chronology and sprawls out over an unknowable geography. In an early scene, characters observe an unusual insect—the play's namesake, finally—and its description and mysterious origin, for those familiar with Ridley's oeuvre, immediately ring a bell:
Libby: The wings are gold!
Dean: You see the stripes on the body? Black and red.
Libby: Where'd it come from?
Dean: Perhaps that storm a couple of nights ago blew it from … somewhere.Footnote 43
Karagula offers a fragmented future history of civilization besieged by one successive invasion after another (like the one that closes in on Elliott and Darren at the end of Mercury Fur), each coup bent on erasing and rewriting the historical memory of the culture it displaces. In this world—our world, certainly, even if its setting might at first appear unfamiliar, as when Libby observes that “[b]oth the moons are full!”Footnote 44 —truth is malleable, and the populace is held dangerously in thrall to its unpredictable protean mutability.
When Dean, for instance, hesitates to participate in a cultural ritual that will virtually guarantee his death, the newly appointed Grand Marshall, Mitch, exiles him and effectively unwrites him from history: “‘Parents’?! Did I hear him say parents? Who can he possibly mean? … Oh!—You don't mean Mr and Mrs MacKenzie? […] Know anything about them having a son?,” to which Mitch's henchman responds, “A son?! Mr and Mrs MacKenzie? They're childless.”Footnote 45 And this erasure is wholly dependent upon the coerced cooperation of the citizenry. Later on, a kitchen-table chat grinds to a halt at the slip of a tongue, rending a tear in the mercurial “truth” that must be immediately sutured:
Dana: Well, perhaps that dashing son of theirs Dean might require a—
Everyone freezes.
Pause.
What was I thinking? Mr and Mrs MacKenzie haven't got any children.Footnote 46
Here, then, the success of the state depends upon the calculated erasure of dissidence, and the strategy returns with even more unsettling force generations later under the oppressive governance of a new political regime. Names are replaced by numbers, and “[t]he bond of family no longer disturbs and distorts us”; indeed, photographs—especially those from before the coup, dubbed Year Zero—are contraband, as the state is “diligent against anyone lapsing into nostalgia or melancholy thought.”Footnote 47 This dismantling of family thus operates as an instrument of the new regime's systemic initiative violently to displace cultural memory and history itself. As Ridley writes in a monologue titled “Press Conference,” included in the Bloomsbury edition of Mercury Fur, “Just don't forget, when the time comes, we will write the history. They … won't.”Footnote 48
Karagula’s more overt dramatization of such oppressive political strategies—and their stake in what constitutes truth—perhaps helps us retrospectively parse more clearly the deterioration of memory and history at work in Mercury Fur. For Ridley, in both plays, the devastating consequences of this erasure of memory represent, once again, a contemporary trend taken to its logical conclusion. He laments that the “majority of the younger generation have got their sense of history completely skewed and if you start to lose your sense of narrative then you start to lose your sense of identity, and then you start to lose your sense of morality. And all of those things for me are tightly connected.”Footnote 49 This intersection of history, identity, and morality lends a different color to Darren's memorable discussion of assassinated American president John F. Kennedy—or “Dallas splat head Kennedy” (43), as he calls him—a speech that reveals the extent to which history and cultural memory have been irrevocably fractured:
He used to be President. He was married to this blonde tart called Marilyn Monroe. They went to Germany for a visit and they met this guy called Hitler. This Hitler liked blonde people so he tried to give it to this Marilyn Monroe up the arse, didn't he. Kennedy got the right ’ump. […] He declared war on Germany and started dropping all this napalm and stuff all over the joint. […] All I know is Kennedy won the war. I think he dropped a couple atom bombs or something and turned all the Germans into chinkies. (43)
Darren's disordered synopsis of the twentieth century exemplifies what Rebellato calls the “characters’ persistent scrambling of modern history into a peculiar amalgam of misplaced fact, rumour and pornographic fantasy.”Footnote 50 The speech might elicit laughter, given its implausible mosaic of historical events and unwittingly clever associations (Marilyn Monroe as Hitler's ideal Aryan love object, for instance), but Darren's splintered rendering of recent history disturbs more than it amuses. In collapsing the rise of the Third Reich, the nuclear attacks on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, Kennedy's rumored affair with Monroe, and the atrocities of the Vietnam War, Darren accomplishes a staggering compression of time and space that obscures historical fact and narratively divorces it from the present. No lessons can be learned from this history folded in on itself. Thus, the speech's racist inflection and salacious preoccupation with sex index a general acceptance of the racial and sexual violence that is ubiquitous in the play.
But the alignment of graphic violence with sexual pleasure, thematized most obviously by the climactic party for which Elliot and Darren fastidiously prepare, inheres earlier in the play, too, just after Darren's impromptu history lesson to Naz. As he describes his favorite butterfly—“Red with silver stripes,” which leads users to hallucinate political “[a]ssassinations. […] You see political leaders snuff it” (42)—he recounts that morning's butterfly-induced high, wherein he witnessed Kennedy's assassination through the subject position of Jackie Onassis, in her iconic pink Chanel suit, brought to orgasm in the back of the car by the spectacle of blood and gore: “My cunt is getting juicy and creaming up. I fiddle with the bone and brains on me dress. I'm gonna cum. I feel it. The sun. The heat. Bone. Brain. Blood. And then—gushhh! My cunt sprays cunt juice all over the car” (44).Footnote 51 This eroticization of violence—of violent death, even, Darren's word “snuff” surely chosen purposefully—speaks precisely to Ridley's preoccupation with the sexually commoditized human body, its personhood negated, its status as object reified. Recall the meat hook central to the Party Guest's fantasy, not to mention Paines Plough's promotional material, which depicted the Party Piece, dressed in gold lamé, standing in front of a butcher shop window with carcasses of meat hanging overhead.Footnote 52 Indeed, when Naz casually suggests that he and Darren masturbate one another—“Let's wank each other off, yeah?” (44)—he attempts to arouse him by eagerly taking Darren's direction in a role-play scene that, again, aligns sexual pleasure with the infliction of pain: Darren instructs him to “get down on the floor. […] Your hands—they're tied behind your back. […] You're moaning […] like you're being hurt. And move about a little bit” (45), before he disengages, not sufficiently in the mood.
Cruelty and/as Compassion
It is in this context of sexual sadism that Ridley most pointedly introduces the class element so central to his critique of global capitalism, signaled by the arrival of the Party Guest, a twenty-three-year-old financial type who “wear[s] a neatly cut, shot silk suit, white shirt, top button undone, loose tie” (93) and “work[s] in the City” (94). His aggressive boasting, “When I see something I want—I go for it with all I've got. […] This my fucking moment! I deserve it!” (100), expresses a sincere belief in his entitlement to the Party Piece's prepubescent body—indeed, his life—for his own sadistic sexual pleasure, merely by virtue of his privileged economic status. And this attitude is driven home in an earlier draft of the play when the Party Guest aggressively reminds Darren and Elliot, “Listen, you cunts, who's paying for this?,”Footnote 53 flagging up the authority that inheres in his purchasing power (though the line was cut from the published text and performance). The Party Guest thus emblematizes the nonempathic spectatorship that Ridley seeks to carry through to its logical conclusion, a kind of consumption—initially visual but finally fatal—that negates human dignity and personhood. Moreover, this nonempathic spectatorship, Ridley seems to suggest, is part and parcel of a certain class privilege, made possible by capitalism's unfettered marketization and the reconstitution of elite class power that Harvey identifies as neoliberalism's structuring principle.
While the Party Guest's entitled sensibilities and clear economic privilege confirm the class status suggested in his initial entrance, he finds his inverse representation in the Duchess, who, at thirty-eight years old, appears as a relic from the past—Spinx muses, “Look at those lips, Naz. […] You don't get lips like that any more. The Duchess is from another time. A prehistoric time when they knew how to kiss” (88)—and her outward appearance is soon revealed to be jarringly out of sync with her alleged social position: “She is wearing a dress (covered with ice-blue sequins and rhinestones) and a white fur coat. Pearl earrings, diamond rings, necklace, bracelets, and a sparkling tiara,” but Ridley swiftly follows by advising us that “[e]verything about her seems fragile and damaged. She is blind” (74). The Duchess's physical and emotional frailty—we witness her fainting spells and anxiety attacks, hear of the frequency with which she soils herself—renders her fully dependent on Spinx, who dotes on her with genuine affection, offering her champagne and feeding her cheese and pineapple on cocktail sticks (an improvement, no doubt, over the “bloody, offal-looking meat […] Monkey brains”Footnote 54 he serves her in the early typescript of the play). Naz's response to these starkly different snacks is telling: where the monkey brain prompts an excited “Me favourite!,”Footnote 55 he asks, “Can I have a taste?” (89) of the cheese and pineapple in the published text, signaling the peculiar class distinction to which Spinx aspires in his careful treatment of the Duchess.
Fragile and damaged, too, is the Duchess's grasp on history and her own past (which militates against the possibility that we misidentify the play's loss of cultural memory as generational, merely an aberration of drug-addled youth). But the Duchess's fragmented sense of history—her circuitous, interrupted storytelling, her narrative lapses—seems less a symptom of butterfly consumption than a scotomization of trauma. When prompted to recount her life, she shrinks, childlike, deferring to Spinx for legitimacy—“When I was a child … —Is this right, Papa?” (89)—and, only moments later, her story dissolves into a panicked flurry of unsettling historical references: “I'm all lost again. How did I end up here? Fucking blackshirt fucking Nazis! Distant bombs. People being cooked in ovens. Lampshades of human skin” (91). Her recourse to an adverb of place, “here,” to interrogate a temporal, rather than spatial, location underlines the thoroughgoing coalescence of space and time, the confrontation of here and then, that persists throughout the play. Too, the Duchess's clear allusion to World War II reminds us of Darren's earlier muddled account of the mid-twentieth century, and the parallel is significant: in his review for the Jewish Chronicle, John Nathan reminds readers that, although “[s]uch ignorance may seem ridiculous, … according to recent statistics, nearly half the [adult] population of Britain has never heard of Auschwitz,”Footnote 56 echoing one of the chief concerns Ridley sought to explore in writing the play.
But the narrative associations that connect the Duchess to Darren signify for other reasons, too. It becomes clear that the Duchess's biographical narration borrows not from her own lived experiences but from those of Maria von Trapp, the protagonist of the Rodgers and Hammerstein musical The Sound of Music (which provides the context for her anachronistic memories of the Holocaust). Certainly, this interpolation functions as an instance of space–time compression in its own right: the Duchess condenses the musical's geographical and temporal settings into her own biography in a way that cannot cohere. She recounts her time in a convent (with Spinx supplying narrative prompts—“You're not a good nun, are you, Duchess? […] Always late for prayers” [90]), before she was sent to a “castle … it belongs to a man … I marry him. We have children. Two boys. I sing to them. ‘Do-re-mi.’ We are all so happy. ‘Do-re-mi-fa-sol-la-ti-do!” (91). Of course, hers is a slightly corrupted version of the musical—the governess, the widowed captain, and his seven children are, here, rendered as a married couple with two sons—but these details, incongruous with the source material, indicate a measure of autobiographical legitimacy.Footnote 57 They, too, catalyze a startling moment of recognition, calling up Darren's fleeting childhood memories at the start of the play, his nostalgic recollection of watching Robert Wise's film adaptation of The Sound of Music with his family: “Know what I liked the best. Watching telly late at night. That musical Mum and Dad liked. The mountains and all those kids going, ‘Do, re, mi.’ Running up and down mountains and going, ‘Do, re, mi.’ Remember that, Ell?” (18). The revelation amplifies the resonance of Darren's allusion to “Edelweiss. […] That's the tune. On the ice-cream van” (27), and it explains Elliot and Darren's shared horror when they learn that Spinx is set to arrive with the Duchess in tow. Darren's panicked insistence, “I can't do it, Ell. The party. Not with the Duchess here. Can you? Can you do it?” (72), is followed by three instances of the same telling stage direction, “Elliot and Darren look at each other” (73), as the Duchess is heard approaching the stage.
The Sound of Music (though never mentioned by name) functions as a key intertext that is vital to our understanding of the shattered family dynamics at work in Mercury Fur. It not only identifies the Duchess as Elliot and Darren's mother but also serves as the linchpin that draws together the boys’ fragments of memory with the Duchess's, enabling us to cobble together a coherent narrative of their past. Thus, the physical damages that Elliot and Darren bear on their bodies—Elliot “walks with a limp” (9) and sporadically “[c]lutches his leg” (15); Darren shows Naz a dent in his skull from a hammer blow that “happened ages ago. […] When I was twelve or something” (46)—take on a poignant resonance, another chill of recognition, during the Duchess's anguished account of the trauma that led to her blindness:
My husband is attacking our children! […] Our boys! He wants to kill our boys! He wants to kill them to save them! To save them from this terrible place. […] My husband is hitting them with a hammer. He's hitting my eldest on the leg. It's all smashed. And the little one—the little one's been hit on the head! No! No! There's so much blood! Oh, the look in their faces. How can Daddy do this? I grab my husband round the neck. He hits me on the head. Everything goes dark. I … I … can't see. (92)
This is the family Darren and Elliot so affectionately recalled near the start of the play—greasy pizza and wooden guns and movies on TV—violently splintered at the end of a hammer, their father dead by self-immolation after his failed mercy killings and their mother no longer able to recognize her own children. Significant, too, is that the Duchess relates this trauma not as a past event but as something occurring in the present tense, consistent with her earlier muddling of spatiotemporal logic. She transports herself, becoming increasingly agitated and unstable, as she delivers the past into the present moment and relives it so vividly that she needs to be sedated.
But, where the Duchess's story unsettles and disturbs, it unexpectedly comforts, too, a Ridleyan trademark of excavating genuine, human tenderness and love from the rubble wrought by violence and unspeakable brutality. When Naz surmises that the person who dented Darren's skull “must've hated your guts,” Darren defensively maintains that “[i]t wasn't hate! It was the opposite of hate. They hit me ’cos they loved me. Okay? They loved me so much they wanted to save me from … bad things. That sort of love don't exist any more. It's prehistoric” (46), the same word Spinx uses later to describe the Duchess, thus situating Darren and Elliot's parents’ generation in a long-forgotten past, even in spite of its temporal proximity. But, like the dent in Darren's skull and the chronic pain in Elliot's knee, traces from this “prehistoric” age—how they kissed, how they loved—crop up in the present day. Elliot inherits his father's protective sensibilities, asserting to Lola that, “if things got so bad I was afraid people might hurt you … Hurt you and Darren and … I couldn't stand that … You know, I made a promise to Darren. I'd kill you both before I let anyone hurt you. […] I'd shoot you while you slept or something. It's like a … like a comfort to think of it” (70).Footnote 58 Motivating this hypothetical act of violence—of murder—is unadulterated care, a loving impulse that resorts, desperate and unwilling, to death as a safeguard against a world that offers only suffering. And perhaps Lola grasps this sensibility more than she lets on. When she and Elliot describe to Naz a now obsolete butterfly, “A gold with white fleck. […] It was the second to appear. […] They made you feel immortal” (64), and Naz asks her to define the word “immortal,” her response in the seventh draft, “Like you'll live forever,”Footnote 59 was changed, in performance, to “Like there's no tomorrow” (64), swapping out the possibility of a limitless future in favor of a suspended present, a temporal standstill to ward off the violence and trauma that surely lie ahead.
Elliot's admission follows the appearance of a new butterfly—“It's mauve and midnight blue but … well, people're calling it black. Just like they called the first one white. A neat little symmetry, don't you think? Almost like someone's planned it” (69)—that violently kills by psychosomatically bringing to fruition its users’ suicidal fantasies: “you don't have to do a thing. The butterfly does it all for you. […] [V]eins open without blades. Necks break without rope. Brains splatter without a single bullet being fired” (69). If inundating London with memory-eroding butterflies was stage one of the play's enigmatic invasion, this lethal black butterfly is surely the second. And when Elliot informs a horrified Lola that users are “getting together to do it now. Suicide parties,” the indication of genocide is clear: “Twenty were found in a club a few days ago. The place was like an abattoir” (69). These are the brutal conditions that induce Elliot's escapist impulse, and he confesses that he can relate to the black butterfly's suicidal users. For Elliot, death becomes an active choice that not only absents the self from the misery of contemporary life but also offers a measure of agency in the face of social and political powerlessness: “The power's still in our hands, Lol. Don't you see? We can decide … not to carry on. We can decide to … disappear” (70).
It is a desperate notion, surely, and it achieves its clearest expression in this scene, but vaguer iterations appear throughout the play. Indeed, Elliot's articulation of the lengths to which he would go for love retrospectively suggests a richer dimension to the brothers’ macabre call-and-response game in the play's opening scene, a playful, yet poignant, ritual that Darren prompts by asking his brother how much he loves him:
Elliot: I love you so much I could chase you and chase you.
Darren gets up and faces Elliot.
Darren: I love you so much I could grab you and grab you.
Elliot: I love you so much I could grab you harder and harder.
Darren: I love you so much I could make you scream and scream.
Elliot: I love you so much I could kick you and punch you.
Darren: I love you so much I could punch you and kick you.
Elliot: I love you so much I could make you bleed and bleed.
Darren: I love you so much I could kill you and kill you.
Elliot: I love you so much I could burst into flames.
Darren: I love you so much I could burst into flames.
Elliot and Darren embrace. (20–1)
Once again, Ridley juxtaposes the expression of love with images of increasingly violent cruelty, the two sensibilities chafing against each other in an unsettling symbiosis. In the original production, Elliot and Darren's professions of love were accompanied by movement—Ben Whishaw and Robert Boulter gestured urgently over their hearts before tenderly holding each other's faces, repeated with variations for each line—a kind of private sign language which suggested that their mutual love sought expression beyond a scorched language that failed to adequately communicate. And the revelation of the boys’ past, their attempted murder at the hands of their father in order to prevent their future suffering, suggests that the rehearsed threats of violence they recite express not an impulse to harm one another but a desire for salvation. Importantly, the Duchess alludes to the boys’ exchange in her first attempt to perform a song,Footnote 60 suggesting its origin in their childhood (albeit, we hope, in a less violent form), and she fuses the reference with another fragment of The Sound of Music: “I love you so much […] I love you so much I could […] I love you so much I could climb every mountain” (83).
This exchange was tellingly reworked for the play's premiere. In his seventh draft of the play, Ridley forwent the word “could,” writing each sentence in the present indicative—“I love you so much I chase you and chase you. […] I love you so much I grab you and grab you”Footnote 61 —before shifting to the conditional for the last three lines. Thus, the violence the boys describe—chasing, grabbing, kicking, and punching one another, making each other scream and bleed—seems linked to acts that are occurring contemporaneously, a declarative articulation that itemizes rather than conjectures. But the sudden introduction (in the eighth draft, which would serve as the prompt script for the premiere performance) of “could”—“I love you so much I could kill you and kill you”Footnote 62 —evinces a potentiality the boys acknowledge but surely hope they never have to realize. In the play's final moments, as “[t]he sound of distant bombing starts” (131), Elliot points a gun at his brother's head—Whishaw brandished the weapon slowly, sadly, in the original production and gently beckoned Boulter with his hand, a resigned invitation to come forward for the mercy killing—and Darren desperately reinitiates the sinuous hand movements of their call-and-response sequence, leveraging (even more clearly now) not its threat of fatal harm but, rather, its repeated invocations of love, in order to deny the potential of the conditional “could”:
Elliot aims gun at Darren's head.
Darren: (pushing gun away) Say it, Ell! I love you so much—
The fire gets louder and brighter.
The sound of bombing gets louder.
Elliot aims gun at Darren's head.
Darren: (pushing gun away) Say it, Ell! (132)
The sequence repeats—Elliot points the gun and Darren swipes it away, urging him to respond, as the bombs draw nearer—an excruciating stretching out of time against an impossibly loud soundscape, until an abrupt blackout ends the play and leaves the boys’ fate ambiguous. But that the final moments cede to Darren's unflinching determination—“Ell! We'll be okay! We'll find a way. Like we've always done. Me and you. […] Put the gun away, Ell. It's not the way” (131)—suggests that the brothers’ love for one another will hold out against the devastation closing in around them. The possibility that either brother “could kill you and kill you” is countered by the hope that neither will. And, rather than “burst into flames,” Darren entreats Elliot to continue surviving, even as the flat burns down with them inside. Darren's pleas thus come to represent an antidote to his father's (and, indeed, Elliot's) recourse to death as a form of salvation, a renewed invocation of familial love that manifests in the struggle to keep on living.
The play's ending thus fulfills Ridley's promise to “lead you through this tunnel and take you back to a place of light. […] [T]here has to be this sense of redemption at the end,”Footnote 63 but it certainly doesn't disparage Elliot's or his father's point of view, rendered with a sensitivity that beckons us to empathize and seek to understand. The desperate sensibility they express, like the play, Tiffany asserted, is “the product of a diseased world, not a diseased mind.”Footnote 64 And Tiffany's defense of Mercury Fur came at a time when the play needed defending. While a number of critics championed the work—Gardner found in it “a jagged lyricism and a savage beauty[,] […] a genuine faith in the possibility of redemption”;Footnote 65 John Peter identified it as “a play for our time, when a sense of terror is both nameless and precise”;Footnote 66 and Miranda Sawyer suggested that it “speaks about contemporary life, holds it up to the audience and makes us question our complicity”Footnote 67 —other critics condemned it, their reviews ranging from dismissive to disgusted. Perhaps the most infamous review in this camp was penned by Charles Spencer of the Daily Telegraph, who self-consciously acknowledged his echoes of Jack Tinker when he described Mercury Fur as “the most violent and upsetting new play since Sarah Kane's Blasted opened at the Royal Court 10 years ago” and accused Ridley of being “turned on by his own sick fantasies. […] Mercury Fur is a poisonous piece, and […] all involved are demeaned by the play they bring to life with such hideous conviction.”Footnote 68
The Ethics of Seeing
Of course, Spencer was not an outlier in his apparent moral disgust. Faber, Ridley's long-time publisher, refused to print Mercury Fur, “object[ing] to the play,” Ridley claimed, “because of its cruelty to children. […] I had gone too far.”Footnote 69 That the play's dramatization of violence (against a child, specifically) might disqualify it from publication adumbrates the limits, for Faber at least, of acceptable dramatic representation, even at the level of text. But the sensibility informing this decision not to publish Mercury Fur—ostensibly a sensitivity to the danger of unfettered representation and visual consumption, the benumbing that accompanies repeated exposure to disturbing images—is, of course, to be found in the play itself, having in large part motivated Ridley to write it in the first place. The irony of Faber thus censoring Ridley's purposeful artistic deployment of violence is especially pointed in light of the global news media's reliance on violent and horrific images to tell (and sell) real-life stories, a discrepancy the playwright identified as particularly germane: “I'm being told by my editor that I've gone too far because of this play and there's the Beslan siege on television. So I'm watching children getting blown up by terrorists, while being told by my publisher that I have written an unacceptable play about cruelty to children!”Footnote 70 The consequent falling out—for Ridley has since been published by Bloomsbury—perhaps reveals the extent to which Faber failed to recognize Mercury Fur’s clear engagement with contemporary world events. Indeed, different reviewers found the play to be in conversation with contemporary events unfolding in numerous diffuse geographical locations (Chechnya, Rwanda, Iraq) and historical moments (the Holocaust, the Gulf War, 9/11). The sprawling geography and historicity of the play's associations, then, not only reflect Mercury Fur’s engagement with real-life trauma and violence but also signal the play's dramatization of the space–time compression that is part and parcel of the global neoliberal turn.
Harvey reminds us that, as a result of flexible accumulation, “accurate and up-to-date information is now a very highly-valued commodity.”Footnote 71 Indeed, information is capital in Mercury Fur, at no point more so than when Spinx reveals that the Party Guest is paying for the event not with money but with vital information on how to avoid the impending bombing of London: “He's paying with contacts. Where to go. Where to be safe. What to say” (116). And Spinx's announcement that their white-collar client will soon be leaving for “[a]nother country. His whole company's getting out” (115) echoes Harvey's assessment that “[a]ccess to, and control over, information … have become essential to the centralized co-ordination of far-flung corporate interests.”Footnote 72 The class dimension resurfaces in this moment, as the Party Guest defends his opportunistic flight from the city by declaring, “I ain't part of this shit,” before Elliot rebuts, “But you don't mind having your fun in the shit before you fuck off!” (116). Access to information is thus revealed as a marker of privilege, and information, itself, a powerful currency, leveraged by the corporate class for political interests—but with real life-and-death consequences for the down-and-outs represented by Elliot, Darren, and the rest of the characters in Mercury Fur. But, if information in the play is, indeed, a premium commodity to be bought and sold, Darren importantly cancels the transaction. When Elliot implies that Naz will have to be killed after helping with the party (thus paying for privileged information with his life), Darren ultimately rescues him and kills the Party Guest instead, resisting capitalist logic with recourse to friendship, loyalty, and compassion.
Mobility, too—that the Party Guest, by virtue of his economic status, is afforded the opportunity to flee from London (even if his plans are ultimately thwarted)—signifies in terms of class, speaking to Harvey's claim that, in a world increasingly overtaken by neoliberal thought, “[s]uperior command over space becomes an even more important weapon in class struggle.”Footnote 73 Denied access to this geographical mobility, the play's characters become sitting ducks in the impending onslaught, outlined by the Party Guest with the dispassionate detachment of only someone who won't be around to see it: “There'll be three days of non-stop bombing. Fire bombs. Napalm. Technology we ain't even heard of. Everywhere's a valid target. Civilian. Military. The whole fucking thing. After three days the soldiers will move in” (116). The preliminary steps of the play's ominous invasion—the staged sandstorm, the hallucinogenic butterflies, the calculated erosion of cultural memory and history, the recently introduced black butterfly that slays its users—culminate, then, in out-and-out genocide, the utter devastation of a city and its people, particularly its disenfranchised, who are rendered incapable of fleeing and powerless to fight back.
If hope does, indeed, exist for the brothers at the end of the play, it relies on geographical displacement, a disorienting relocation to somewhere new in the reconfigured spatial landscape of the world (or perhaps even beyond).Footnote 74 Darren suggests as much when he likens himself and Elliot to “[s]pace explorers. Right, brov? […] And we're exploring this … new planet. To see if it's fit for human life. […] But it's not. Is it, Ell?” (129–30). It is the resigned acceptance of this reality—that the very planet on which they live is unfit for human life, inhospitable to their existence—that renews Darren's determined optimism. He assures his brother, “We've got to find another planet. […] A more friendly planet, eh, brov? That's what we're gonna find, Ell. You hear me?” (130). This recalls a moment in Ridley's introduction, when he describes visiting an “old bomb site. […] I stand on the tallest mound and survey the sand-glistening landscape. I'm on another planet,”Footnote 75 and, perhaps, it gestures, too, to the astronomical reference in the play's title. Mercury, a planet certainly unfit to sustain human life, thus becomes another symbol of hope (futile as it may be) in the face of imminent doom: if it represents an unlikely safe haven from the atrocities of Earth, it inevitably remains the first planet to be engulfed by the Sun when it evolves into a red giant, it, too, destined to “burst into flames.”
But that Darren emerges at the play's end as a personification of hope—a perhaps unlikely figure given his scrambled recollection of history and abraded family memories—reveals a crucial dimension of Ridley's project. If the play's unnamed invading power weaponizes amnesia in order to rend people first from their memories and then from one another, Darren's relentless appeal to brotherhood evinces a kind of resistance that leverages human connection in order to withstand the neoliberal state's most assaultive and divisive strategies of imperial domination. The deafening soundscape of the play's final moments—Darren's desperate pleas competing against a chorus of bombs—might, at first blush, appear unsettlingly ambiguous. But the aural resilience of Darren's voice, for the bombs never fully drown him out, speaks to Ridley's promise of redemption, his commitment to guide us through trauma in order to deliver us “back to a place of light.”Footnote 76 Certainly, the play's appeal to family and community—which draws, in performance, on an understanding of theatre as a collective experience shared by performers and spectators alike—articulates a somewhat conservative message in its reaffirmation of traditional values, both social and theatrical: that is, the solution to our neoliberal dystopia lies in a return to the “good old days” of social-democratic consensus politics. But perhaps Mercury Fur’s fractured temporality gestures to the future as much it expresses nostalgia for the past. In so forcefully underlining the economic disparity that has been the legacy of Thatcherite fiscal policy (and its later iterations under both Labour and Tory governments), Ridley combines his call to witness with an equally sober call to political awareness—romanticizing a return back, surely, but maybe with the hope that a newly politicized audience might seek out a way forward, too.
Mercury Fur gives unsettling theatrical form to a world besieged by unfettered neoliberal violence, and central to the work is the deployment of theatre itself as a means of fostering empathy—not only between the play's characters but also among the audience, whose acute proximity engenders empathic witnessing rather than passive spectatorship—which Ridley offers as a vital form of resistance to the unstable and disorienting reconfigured cultural landscape that is part and parcel of neoliberalism's reconstitution of class power. Ridley thus plots the empathic spectatorship he advocates along economic lines: the class privilege that empowers Party Guests uncritically to consume Party Pieces contrasts with the starkly different class position of the play's other characters, who seek to recover empathy and compassion in their ethical struggle against the divisive exigencies of global capitalism. If the spatiotemporal compressions of neoliberalism destabilize and uproot us, coerce us to conform to the flexibility of ubiquitous markets, and alienate us from the values of community and collectivity, Mercury Fur’s staging of trauma compels us to witness, ethically and empathically, the violence of class warfare in order that we might confront it, here and now.
