This book poses something of a problem for historians of science and, most especially, historically minded critics of literature and science. It is both seemingly uninterested in history, largely disavowing a historical frame of reference to account for how poets have engaged with Darwinism over the last one hundred and fifty years, and yet at the same time offers some very fine and illuminating close readings of the work of those poets. Darwin's Bards begins by defiantly jettisoning almost all of the revisionist historiography produced by the Darwin industry over the last two decades or so, confidently insisting not only that ‘there was a “Darwinian Revolution”, an epiphany in the history of ideas, marking a single radical break with the intellectual traditions of the past’, but also that ‘Darwinism has remained largely consistent ever since Darwin first published On the Origin of Species in 1859’ (p. 5). This is not simply another instance of the far from unusual situation of a literary critic remaining blithely ignorant of the work done by modern historians of science (the locus classicus of which is John Carey's Faber Book of Science (2nd edn, 2005)), for Holmes is acutely aware that his two central claims are ones that are ‘routinely dismissed by cultural historians and historians of science’; and he goes on to defend his position regarding Darwinism's apparent overarching consistency by arguing that Peter Bowler's thesis of a ‘non-Darwinian Revolution’ in evolutionary biology is ‘somewhat exaggerated’ and even an ‘overstatement’ and that many late nineteenth-century evolutionists adhered to an explanation of species change that is virtually identical with contemporary incarnations of Darwinism (pp. 8, 37). That said, it needs to be acknowledged that Holmes's attempt to defend these sweeping and self-consciously dissenting assertions (‘the prevailing history of science notwithstanding’ is a familiar refrain in the book (p. 11)) is actually pretty cursory, with Bowler the only recent historian of science to be invoked in the argument and highly relevant works by Adrian Desmond, Jon Hodge, Jim Endersby and Jim Secord, amongst several others, not even making it into the otherwise lengthy bibliography. Nor is the assurance that the revolutionary nature and long-standing consistency of Darwinism become manifest when ‘looking not for the fine distinctions so much as the broad tendencies’ (p. 9) likely to prove persuasive to those whose professional instincts recoil at such generalized big-picture histories.
Curiously, alongside this proactively broad and undiscriminating historiography, Darwin's Bards affords subtle, precise, sharp-eyed readings of verse by such well-known Victorian poets as Tennyson, Browning, Meredith, Swinburne and Hardy, as well as more recent poems by the likes of Ted Hughes, Philip Appleman and Thom Gunn. Each of these poets, Holmes argues, grapples with the fundamental, largely unchanging challenges posed by Darwinian evolution, with the book's chapters each focusing on topics including theology, death and immortality, humanity's cosmic insignificance and relationship with other animals, and sex and reproduction. While such themes are almost conspicuously commonplace in Darwin scholarship, and the poets considered are for the most part eminently canonical (there is virtually no consideration of popular poetic forms, for instance), the detailed analysis of verse that deals with these issues often yields fresh insights that will be of interest to more historically minded critics. A case in point is Constance Naden's ‘Natural selection’ (1887), a comic account of a failed courtship between a naive geologist and the false Chloe. Beneath the poem's exuberant delight in its rhymes and anapaestic rhythm, there is, Holmes argues persuasively, ‘a deft exposé of key flaws in the method and the logic of much Darwinian writing about sex’, and especially the tendency, evident even in The Descent of Man (1871), to ‘move all too readily from anecdotal evidence to familiar stereotypes when describing sexual behaviour’ (pp. 192–193). He offers a no less perceptive account of how ‘Tennyson's understanding of evolution is … largely untouched by Darwin’ and instead sees ‘all lineages of animals follow parallel evolutionary tracks upwards towards increasingly human forms’ (pp. 70–71), although this actually points to a curious paradox in the book's relation to recent developments in the history of science. Despite the rather intemperate antagonism towards revisionist historiography articulated in the book's introduction, the rest of Darwin's Bards often recognizes the need for a more nuanced and subtle approach similar to that established by modern historians of science. Indeed, there is a lengthy chapter concerned with ‘Poetry and the “non-Darwinian Revolution”’, which acknowledges that ‘much of the poetry, as well as the science, of the 1870s and 1880s tallies with Bowler's account’ (p. 37). Along with Bert Bender's Evolution and ‘the Sex Problem’: American Narratives during the Eclipse of Darwinism (2004), Holmes's chapter is perhaps the most sustained examination of how late nineteenth-century literary writers drew on and developed non-Darwinian understandings of evolutionary change.
Ultimately, however, Darwin's Bards will have no truck with the kind of methodological relativism that has become a default position amongst historians of science, and instead it berates the non-Darwinian evolutionary verse produced by Swinburne and Mathilde Blind for being, as their authors apparently must have recognized, ‘grounded in lies’, and this ‘bad faith’, for Holmes, renders them ‘worse as poems than they otherwise would be’ (p. 54). This persistent opposition to the ‘received history of Darwinism’, by which Holmes means that which has been established in the last two decades, is frustrating, for the book is at its best when combining its admirably lucid close readings of poetry with precisely the kind of fine historical distinctions that are explicitly – and needlessly, I think – disavowed in the introduction.
