In our current age of global media flows, we can often take for granted a familiarity with musical and artistic traditions from cultures around the world. We can watch West African drumming at a family party in Ghana via YouTube, access MP3s from a Russian ska band on SoundCloud, or choose a Jamaican dance hall music channel on Spotify. This article goes back to the postwar United States to examine the role of the then-new medium of television in broadcasting and, more importantly, teaching US audiences about music and dance traditions from different parts of the world. Most significantly, the program Omnibus (various, 1952–61), a televised variety show hailed as “a milestone of television's Golden Age,”Footnote 1 brought music and dance from places like Japan, India, and Yugoslavia into the homes of millions of US viewers. Omnibus was an important part of a popularization of world music and dance as part of a greater arts and cultural literacy campaign in the 1950s, aimed at educating and entertaining the average American. Scholarship on the appearance of non-Western musical traditions in the West has not investigated the significance of early television in introducing these cultural forms and disseminating them beyond the exclusive spaces of theaters and museums. This article seeks to add to our understanding of the emergence of “world” music awareness in the United States, adding important detail to a historical timeline of widespread encounter and pushing back the date on the emergence of East-West fusion from the 1960s to the 1950s. Perhaps even more significantly, I argue that Omnibus also contributed to specific postwar cultural diplomacy efforts by seeking to expand Americans’ cultural knowledge and artistic appreciation beyond the nation's borders, promulgating cultural capital that was distinctly internationalist.
Although attention has been paid to US internationalist efforts abroad in the postwar era, from European food trains to US jazz musicians’ role as cultural ambassadors, the role of international culture in US domestic life—especially in television—has been relatively neglected. In addition, much of the history of music and cultural diplomacy has focused on governmental institutions or state policies, with little attention paid to the efforts of US philanthropic organizations both at home and abroad. As the US government sought to “promote world peace” through multifaceted international and domestic economic and propaganda interventions, private organizations such as the Ford Foundation also spent massive sums in the US and abroad in the name of establishing world peace and promoting human welfare. Seeing the potential to influence the emerging medium of television, as well as the potential of television to help fulfill its ideological goals, the Foundation produced Omnibus as an entertaining educational commercial program. Through its selection and presentation of non-US arts and culture, especially music, Omnibus worked to normalize a cosmopolitan and internationalist American identity that was tied to the emergence of the United States as a global power. This article adds to our understanding of the “cultural Cold War” by focusing not on Western cultural imperialism and the economic significance of US cultural exports but on the cultural flows—and the politics of those flows—coming into the country.
I begin by situating Omnibus within the context of twentieth-century US social uplift movements, connecting larger trends in cultural literacy to the educational goals of the Ford Foundation in the 1950s, particularly its interest in the emerging medium of television. Then, using primary documents from the Ford Foundation, I connect its educational goals with its internationalist aims, examining how the international music broadcast on Omnibus featured music by countries particularly significant for US foreign policy objectives in the 1950s. Following this, I describe the broadcasts themselves, detailing the background on how and why certain musicians (and not others) were featured on Omnibus and shedding light on the internal politics of the show and its creators, particularly the challenges surrounding promoting internationalism and diversity as fears of the spread of communism made this non-isolationist political work even more challenging. I argue that Omnibus’s airing of international classical and folk music represents a significant effort on the behalf of the Ford Foundation to socialize Americans into an internationalist worldview.
Omnibus as “Intelligent Entertainment” for Middlebrows
Television historians describe Omnibus as “the most successful cultural magazine series in the history of US commercial television.”Footnote 2 It first aired in November 1952 as a precedent-setting ninety-minute live show, broadcast on Sunday afternoons on CBS (and later moving to ABC and NBC over the following nine years).Footnote 3 Arts and cultural programming originated on the radio and later appeared on each of the television networks with things such as the broadcasting of NBC's Opera Theater and Cameo Theater, ABC's televised opening nights at the Metropolitan Opera, and CBS's televised Broadway plays.Footnote 4 Creator Robert Saudek envisioned that “Omnibus would deal with subjects not ordinarily seen and heard on TV,” without being constrained by needing to fill a large block of time with a single feature. It would air “the best actors, musicians, dancers; the most articulate scientists, architects, and comedians.”Footnote 5 Historians of public broadcasting have noted Omnibus’s role in the development of educational programming and its influence on later initiatives like PBS.Footnote 6 Omnibus’s guest list is impressive: diver Jacques Cousteau led several underwater excursions, poet W. H. Auden introduced and explained a new play by fellow poet T. S. Eliot, dancer Gene Kelly and prizefighter Sugar Ray Leonard explained the dance inherent in contemporary sports via an impressive tap routine, chart-topping pop music duo Les Paul and Mary Ford demonstrated multitrack recording, jazz clarinetist Benny Goodman jammed with drummer Gene Krupa, and conductor and composer Leonard Bernstein explained how Beethoven composed his Fifth Symphony. Omnibus was notable for taking things apart and analyzing how they worked, hoping not just to interest audiences in the moment but to inspire sustained engagement in arts and culture after the show ended.Footnote 7 Omnibus sought to cultivate the understanding and appreciation of arts and culture, legitimating the new broadcasting entity of commercial television by setting an example for how it could be an effective medium for cultural edification.
Social uplift movements have sought to make art accessible to all, spreading political democracy and cultivating informed citizenship through art.Footnote 8 For example, music appreciation in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century was presented primarily as a “science” or serious endeavor, in the belief that the legitimate appreciation of music came only through an understanding of music based in reason, logic, and intellect. The music appreciation movement stressed the moral value of “high” art music and the role of musical intelligence in promoting a better, more advanced society. Omnibus’s emphasis on quality programming and its host Alistair Cooke, a British correspondent for the BBC in the United States, all point to the dominating influence of the public service model, exemplified by the BBC, where media had a “cultural, moral, and educative force for the improvement of knowledge, taste, and manners.”Footnote 9
Omnibus actively sought to cultivate a “middlebrow” appreciation of arts and culture. The term emerged in the decades after World War I as something to be embraced: a way for the middle classes to partake in the enjoyments of commercial mass culture while also retaining a degree of refinement.Footnote 10 Writing in 1933, Pulitzer Prize–winning poet Margaret Widdemer clarified the term, saying that “middlebrow” cheerfully denoted “men and women, fairly civilized, fairly literate, who support the critics and lecturers and publishers by purchasing their wares.” Although highbrows were a “tiny group of intellectuals” and the lowbrow was the “tabloid addict class,” the middlebrow was the American majority of readers and consumers of culture.Footnote 11
Although the term “middlebrow” might sound condescending today, it was often used to signal that something would be accessible and fun, and perhaps more importantly, that one could partake of middlebrow culture and still be normal. Indeed, to be in the middle—the middle class, the middlebrow—was the hegemonic social ideal of the 1950s, and the ideal, normal American identity was constructed both through and around television. Not only did television dramas and sitcoms portray variations on “normal” family life on-screen, but print advertisements for television sets also portrayed the ideal American family engaged in the average leisure pastime of viewing television together.Footnote 12 Anna Creadick describes a dominant cultural discourse of “normality” in the postwar years, asserting that many Americans from across the class spectrum sought to appear middle class during this time when the “values” and “virtues” of the middle were even more defining than actual income.Footnote 13
Although many social uplift endeavors reinforced cultural hierarchies that dismissed popular or mass culture as debased and debasing and high art as overly elite and intellectual,Footnote 14 Omnibus gingerly navigated the fine lines between entertainment and edification, going beyond previous efforts that promoted only European classical art music as worthy of encounter for aspirational American audiences. Yet, it wasn't just Omnibus’s audiences who were aspirational in these postwar years; the television show was the brainchild of the Ford Foundation, one of the three largest postwar philanthropic organizations in the United States and a key player in postwar world culture-building.Footnote 15
The Ford Motor Company established its (initially small) foundation in 1936 as a way for the then-private auto company to manage its tax liability while still maintaining voting control of the company. The Ford Foundation substantially increased its giving in 1950, and in 1951 it established the Fund for the Advancement of Education, allocating it $7.2 million, part of which would provide “support for educational radio and television opportunities.”Footnote 16 US broadcasters were in the process of establishing a television system that many feared would, like radio before it, succumb to rampant commercialism and mediocre entertainment; skeptics of television believed it fostered passivity and social disconnection and would help contribute an end of social involvement and meaningful culture. In 1952, the Foundation proposed forming an independent commission to “study the problem” of the emerging US television system, with the hope they could step in where Congress would not, to help “[secure] the maximum social benefits” from the medium. Implied in the documents on this proposed commission (which never ultimately formed) was that the commercial television industry would not set the right “pattern” for US television on its own, so intervention and role-modeling was needed.Footnote 17 Robert M. Hutchins, associate director of the Foundation, steadfastly believed that non-commercial television projects were the only effective way to educate US audiences.Footnote 18 To that end, the Foundation funded the nonprofit Educational Television and Radio Center (later the National Educational Television Center), initially just distributing educational content produced by affiliate stations and later producing its own material, which many viewers, unfortunately, found “dull” and “overly academic.”Footnote 19 The National Educational Television Center became the Public Broadcasting Service (PBS) in 1970 and continued to receive substantial financial support from the Ford Foundation through the 2000s. However, the Foundation's challenge in 1952 was to develop a model of educational television that excited and engaged audiences even while educating them.
Unlike Hutchins, James Webb Young, the Foundation's consultant on mass communication, believed commercial television would have a bigger impact on improving the moral and intellectual current in the nation, with quality programming simultaneously raising standards across the medium and attracting large audiences, thus potentially rescuing commercial television from the “forces of vulgarization.”Footnote 20 Young recruited Saudek, then a successful vice president at ABC, to oversee the Foundation's Television-Radio Workshop (TvRW), a separate entity from the community television–oriented Educational Television and Radio Center. Rather than promoting Omnibus as “educational television,” a label he feared would kill its audience appeal, Saudek argued that audiences wanted to be “entertained intelligently.”Footnote 21 Indeed, Saudek himself proudly explained the show to readers of the New York Times as “entertainment for the largest possible ‘middlebrow’ audience,” and later writers also remembered Omnibus as reaching out to what they specifically termed as “middlebrow” tastes.Footnote 22 Discussing its eclectic “middlebrow” programming, Anna McCarthy writes that the show's “deliberate effort to appear different from other television programs, emphasizing cultural material that fell outside the broadcast mainstream, made Omnibus easy to mock” but that this variety fulfilled Saudek's aim to provide “something for everyone” and that “for every misfire there were plenty of moments that fulfilled the program's promise of a different kind of television.”Footnote 23
The Foundation provided the initial money for Omnibus as a means of accomplishing one of its core goals for improving the world through education, but some at the Foundation considered Omnibus a litmus test for commercial educational programming—an experiment as to whether commercial sponsors would support a more educational show.Footnote 24 To that end they wanted Omnibus to recoup its Foundation funding via advertising revenue, so when the Foundation ended its relationship with Omnibus in 1957 still in the red, some claimed this as the failure of the whole project.Footnote 25 Saudek understood the Foundation's financial backing of the show differently, saying it acted as a “guaranty” that gave Omnibus “fighting significance,” one that, importantly, freed the show from needing to bow to network and advertiser control, thus enabling more adventurous and creative programming.Footnote 26 The estimated total cost to the Foundation to fund Omnibus from 1952 to 1957, once advertiser revenue was accounted for, was just over $3 million.Footnote 27 Putting this amount into perspective, Ford Foundation program grants in 1955 alone totaled $64 million.Footnote 28 Some at the Foundation may have struggled with finding the right metric by which to measure Saudek's success with Omnibus, but the substantial positive response from critics and audiences indicates the show was exceptional for its time.
Awards, ongoing praise from critics, and substantial viewership numbers established the impact of Omnibus in 1950s US television. In 1954, Omnibus won a Peabody award for its contributions to “popular knowledge of the arts and sciences, with its accurately documented backgrounds and dramatic presentations of significant historical events.” In 1955, Peabody recognized it again for its series on John Adams, calling it a “feat of programming genius.”Footnote 29 Omnibus also did well at the Emmy Awards, winning eight of its thirteen nominations in a range of categories.Footnote 30 Critics were mostly favorable to the show, though some did scold it on rare occasions when it got too “pretentious” or “arty” or, alternatively, failed to live up to its innovative potential.Footnote 31 Yet by many standards, Omnibus got this delicate balance exactly right, especially as indicated by its popularity. In its first season, Omnibus’s Nielsen ratings were reported to be as high as thirty-one, meaning over thirty percent of all televisions in the markets where it aired were tuning into Omnibus, a highly respectable number even in the early network era.Footnote 32 Counterprogrammed against two children's shows on Sunday afternoons, it consistently held its own. Perhaps more meaningfully, it regularly outperformed the other arts shows aimed at adults, such as the more highbrow Hallmark Hall of Fame, by ten points or more each week.Footnote 33 In terms of how this translated into viewers, first season average weekly viewership was 10,750,000, and by 1956 Dwight Macdonald estimated viewership at seventeen million.Footnote 34 One survey claimed that viewers remembered what they watched on Omnibus more than what they saw on other shows, with 98 percent recalling details after eight weeks, compared to only 39 percent recalling details from other commercial shows including the high-ratings hit I Love Lucy.Footnote 35 Additionally, Omnibus has lived long in cultural memory of television's so-called golden era.Footnote 36 For example, Donna Cassyd, daughter of Syd Cassyd, the founder in 1946 of the Academy of Television Arts & Sciences, specifically recalls Omnibus as an example of how broadcasters could fulfill her father's goals for television as an educational tool.Footnote 37
The Ford Foundation had been keen in 1951 and 1952 to harness what it called the “genie in the bottle” of television to help fulfill its philanthropic mission of education.Footnote 38 Critics of the time may have quibbled about whether it was either too highbrow or not highbrow enough, but when one considers that an appearance on Omnibus could reach ten thousand times that of the capacity at New York City's Town Hall (where many musical guests on Omnibus played around the time of their appearance on the show), the social influence of this program should not be underestimated.
On one level, Omnibus can be understood as an example of early television that successfully balanced entertainment and edification in a way that appealed to a broad audience who, in the years after World War II, saw education as a way to climb the social ladder. But, as William Hughes argues in his examination of Omnibus’s staging of James Agee's historical drama Mr. Lincoln, the Ford Foundation's “publicly avowed goal to improve the quality of television programming coexisted with another, less public, agenda: to use the new medium [of television] to immunize the public against totalitarianism at home and abroad.”Footnote 39 Through Omnibus, the Ford Foundation sought to make learning about arts, culture, and politics fun for the whole family, employing the emerging medium of television and capitalizing on an aspirational postwar culture to achieve its goals for improving US civil society. Japanese theater and Indian classical music were certainly novel entertainment for 1950s US television audiences, as well as part of general trend in cultural uplift akin to the Book of the Month Club, but, as I shall argue, these musical episodes functioned as important pieces within the Ford Foundation's larger internationalist aims in the postwar era.
Omnibus, Postwar Internationalism, and “Soft” Cultural Policy
Omnibus may have been fulfilling the highest aspirations that some had for television to provide viewers educational and uplifting entertainment. But it also had very particular ideas on what the average American in the 1950s needed to learn. Not only ought they to learn more about classical music, US history, and literature, but following the United States’ rise to power as the “leader of the free world,” many civic leaders (including those heading the Ford Foundation) believed Americans needed to know more about nations and cultures around the globe. By predicating American social uplift on access to global culture and the world beyond the home, Omnibus was simultaneously strengthening the ideological functions of the home within the nation and, by extension, the nation's place within the world. Throughout the 1940s, this articulation of television-home-nation had strengthened. For instance, in a 1942 introductory book on television, pioneering radio inventor Lee de Forest dreamed big in terms of television's possibilities, including access to the world beyond US national borders. Television, he claimed, allowed the “total means of participation in the sights and sounds of the entire world,” while simultaneously enabling families to spend evening social time together, thus “strengthening … the home ties. …Why should not this altered attitude toward our home life eventually work to the betterment of our national life?”Footnote 40 Access to television expanded exponentially during the postwar (and Cold War) reconsolidation of American identity and national values. As the GI Bill helped (straight, white) former servicemen buy into the suburban dream of single-family homes with all the mod cons, including a television set, the lifting of a television station allocation freeze in 1952 increased the availability of television signals so that by 1955 around 65 percent of US homes were tuning in to television.Footnote 41 As the 1959 Khrushchev/Nixon “Kitchen Debates” came to illustrate, all this middle-class domestic bounty had a politics: the United States’ openness to economic progress reflected both domestic prosperity and, significantly, international authority.
Affirming Omnibus’s success at being a television program for normal middlebrow folks, host Alistair Cooke announced proudly at the close of its third season in 1955 that the show's main audience was suburban and rural families. Said Cooke, “More people watch Omnibus on the prairies and in the suburbs than in the big cities. We are very proud of that statistic and proud too that the pump priming of the classics that Omnibus did three years ago has now made it a regular thing to see ballet and Shakespeare and classical tragedy on any network.”Footnote 42 Rather than just attracting urban and urbane audiences who were already attending the theater and the symphony, Omnibus reached audiences for whom seeing live theater and music in anything other than local amateur productions would likely have been a rarity. Thus, although a family in Hutchinson, Kansas, could drive to nearby Wichita to see a symphony orchestra performance, they certainly would never have seen live Japanese theater or Indian classical music in central Kansas in 1955. But with its new station KTVH broadcasting Omnibus starting in 1953, Hutchinson now had access not only to symphonies and plays but also to music from around the world.Footnote 43 According to one survey of three hundred Omnibus viewers in Charlotte, North Carolina, only 81 percent had attended high school and just 33 percent had attended college.Footnote 44 Works by American and European authors, artists, and composers made up the majority of arts and culture programming on Omnibus, putting the show securely into a larger Eurocentric history of US social uplift efforts—indeed, early Ford Foundation brainstorms even included a proposal for a “Great Books” component to the show.Footnote 45 But the presence of several Omnibus features on non-Western classical and folk musics can be understood as part of the strengthening of political and social internationalism within postwar American national ideology.
Americans had previously encountered non-Western musics within the context of nineteenth-century European colonialist internationalism and US nation-building, but these musical encounters at world's fairs and other exhibitions were usually presented as exotic entertainment or, worse, proof of the savagery of non-Western peoples. Visitors to Chicago's 1893 Columbian Exposition might have heard music from Java, North Africa, the Middle East, China, and the South Pacific, and it was here that Benjamin Ives Gilman of the Boston Museum of Fine Arts made the some of the first recordings of non-European musics on wax cylinders.Footnote 46 Although the Exposition did have an official plan for musical uplift for fairgoers, it focused exclusively on Western musics via symphony orchestras, bands, and organ concerts. Non-Western musics happened outside the official exposition grounds, segregated to areas such as the Midway where lowbrow entertainment, spectacle, and commercial interests were the defining goals. Vendors used cultural displays at these “ethnic” villages to hawk new products, as was the case with the Java Village, sponsored by Dutch plantation owners eager to market coffee, tea, and cocoa. Other villages contributed to the Exposition's goals of celebrating human progress and educating about “good” culture by presenting negative examples of primitivist disorder and barbarism, against which the official classical art music of the Exposition could be understood as orderly and civilized.Footnote 47
Twentieth-century changes to existing power structures through wars, European economic crises, and collapsing colonial empires contributed to a complex postwar political landscape where the United States wrestled with the formation of a national ideology in an altered international context. John Fousek describes this meeting of American values with global power (and responsibility) as the dominant ideology of “American nationalist globalism” where “national self-interest and global altruism were identical.”Footnote 48 Maintaining what Fousek calls a “pax Americana” required winning hearts and minds, both out in the world but also at home; protecting freedom and democracy abroad equaled combating American cultural and political isolationism at home. Frances Stonor Saunders argues that US postwar global “altruism” was actually an extremely diverse and far-reaching set of propaganda efforts—a “Cultural Cold War”—fought primarily by the Central Intelligence Agency with support to music, theater, and literary arts, sometimes using American philanthropic foundations like the Ford Foundation as “quiet channels.”Footnote 49 Inderjeet Parmar concurs, arguing that the “Big 3” of US philanthropic foundations—the Ford, Rockefeller, and Carnegie Foundations—were “directly engaged in extending and consolidating US hegemony around the globe.” Specifically, “they sought to unite American society to build and catalyze anti-isolationist and globalist opinion” in areas relevant to foreign policy.Footnote 50 Not only did this work involve creating and funding specific initiatives, but for these efforts to be successful, these foundations also had to work to change how the world thought of the United States and how Americans understood themselves in relation to the rest of the world.
The Ford Foundation substantially increased the scale of its giving in 1950 in accordance with the expanded national and global aims recommended in a 1949 Foundation Report, created by a committee chaired by H. Rowan Gaither. He and Paul Hoffman, the Foundation's president, were already involved in internationalist initiatives, Gaither as president of the newly formed RAND Corporation and Hoffman as head of the agency administering the Marshall Plan. Chief among the Foundation's stated goals were influencing policy and improving education and research,Footnote 51 with the broader intention of bringing about global peace through the spread of democracy.Footnote 52 Achieving these goals involved international and domestic action, “lessening … ignorance and misunderstanding among peoples of the world” and “increasing public understanding of world affairs and more effective participation by the citizens of the United States.”Footnote 53 In a 1951 memo from Dyke Brown (a Ford Foundation employee who would become the Foundation's vice president in 1953) to Rowan Gaither, Brown explicitly laid out how the Foundation could assist in “the conduct of political (psychological) warfare and other activities designed to combat Communist threats to peace, freedom, and the West” by working to strengthen the United Nations. This would include gaining knowledge about countries of “strategic” importance while helping them “become responsible members of the world community.” Of particular importance to this work was “the advancement of international understanding in ways designed to increase, among opinion leaders here and in strategic areas abroad, knowledge of, and respect for, other peoples and their cultures (their values, ideologies, national aspirations, and interests).” This was not just an intellectual appreciation of international affairs, clarified Brown, but also the building of “mutual understanding” via the “exchanging of people between countries” which would engender “the obligations that form the basis of a responsible world order.”Footnote 54 Putting people into meaningful contact with each other, they hoped, would create a form of global social bonding that could help the United States better achieve its goals for political and economic stability.
Specifically, the Foundation's international programs sought to “win allies and influence neutrals.”Footnote 55 To that end, both Japan and India are named specifically in Brown's memo as countries that were crucial for the United States to win as allies against the USSR via integrating them into a global political and economic community. Although still communist, Yugoslavia had broken ties with the USSR in 1948, and within Ford Foundation documents, Yugoslavia is ranked third in order of priority and importance in the Foundation memo, ahead of Japan, and identified specifically as having “important potentialities to the West in this crack in the Soviet structure.”Footnote 56 Brown emphasizes that the Foundation should go beyond education about international affairs to promote the global exchange of arts and culture as a “means, not an end” to international understanding.Footnote 57 Although the Foundation did support person-to-person cultural work through exchange programs, its Fund for the Advancement of Education, mentioned earlier as created specifically to utilize mass media, similarly sought to produce “mature, wise, and responsible citizens” by cultivating an awareness of international issues and culture.Footnote 58
The direct connection of Foundation's TvRW to these international goals of the Foundation can be found in the “Area 1 Notebook” of official reports to the Foundation trustees from 1949 to 1951. Here, documents outline the Foundation's goals for a “bold program for the lessening of international tensions and the attainment of world peace” through “building a world community” with the same countries named in the Dyke Brown memo listed in the same order of priority.Footnote 59 The notebook contains an extensive and detailed budget of all the programs in 1951 that were fulfilling the Foundation's internationalist goals, such as money for institutions abroad (such as the Free University of Berlin and The Hague Academy of International Law), and exchange programs for men and women from other countries to come to the US to study law, social welfare, and community action. Within the budget for the Fund for the Advancement of Education projects “bearing directly on Area 1,” the TvRW is listed as producing a series “which will deal with international understanding,” and it is given a budget of $1.2 million, four times the amount given to the next highest item in the Fund.Footnote 60 Omnibus, as the flagship project of the TvRW, may have appeared on the surface to be arts and culture programming similar to what other television networks were offering, but Foundation documents reveal it was conceived as a medium for the Foundation's specific political projects.
The internationalist aims of the Ford Foundation, combined with its connections to larger government foreign policy and intelligence work, help contextualize the selection and presentation of arts and culture on the Foundation's most important media venture, Omnibus. The show creators’ choice to feature musical culture from nations specifically identified in the Foundation Report as crucial to the postwar geopolitical scene strongly suggests that Omnibus, as a tool of the Foundation, acted strategically in its choices of which musics and nations to feature. For instance, although Soviet musicians and dancers did start performing in the United States in the late 1950s, and although Omnibus did have connections to the producers who brought them, Soviet artists are conspicuously absent from Omnibus’s programming.Footnote 61 Omnibus’s airing of international musicians was more than just cultural tourism for citizens of the new world power, and it was very different from the racist exoticization of non-European cultures that had been the norm in US popular culture prior to the Cold War era. Instead, Omnibus encouraged middlebrow Americans to approach non-Western culture with an internationalist global worldview, expanding their cultural perspectives and thus, ideally, strengthening their political commitments to postwar US expansionism. Specifically, a careful examination of the particular cultures and performers represented on the program reveals meaningful connections to a range of particular US political agendas in East Asia, Eastern Europe, India, and Latin America.
Winning Allies: Japanese Musical Theater and Yugoslavian Folk Music
Omnibus’s first important inclusion of a non-Western music came in its second season, on February 14, 1954, when it featured the Azuma Kabuki Dancers from Tokyo. In typical Omnibus fashion, this eighteen-minute music and dance segment occupied only a portion of the ninety-minute broadcast. These “famous Kabuki dancers,” said host Alistair Cooke, were in New York for their first performance outside of Japan “to introduce to the Western World this very elaborate and ancient and cherished art.” Because their opening performance at New York's New Century Theater wouldn't happen for four more days, Omnibus provided its viewers with what purported to be the first-ever public performance of Kabuki by Japanese dancers in the United States. Cooke situated the segment in the context of American internationalism and diplomatic relations, first explaining that the impetus to bring Kabuki to the United States came from soldiers who had “written home” about this fantastic art, then explaining that Prince Takamatsu and the Japanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs finally consented to New York theater impresario Sol Hurok's pleas to coordinate a US tour for Azuma Kabuki dancers, implying that this tour nearly didn't happen at all because of reluctance from the Japanese government.
Although Saudek may have had a personal soft spot for ballet and dance, the pairing of international music with dance on Omnibus provides insight into the larger challenge of translating the aural medium of music to the visual medium of early television.Footnote 62 After all, the image quality of most televisions in this era often made it difficult to see physical nuances of a musician's performance, and even telecasts of symphony orchestra performances usually focused on the expressive actions of the conductor rather than the musicians.Footnote 63 Cooke explained the rigorous training and devotion required of the performers, as well as the ceremony behind the construction of the stage, before introducing Miso Komoto, the Japanese-American narrator for this segment. Komoto began by introducing what she described as an “orchestra,” consisting of shamisen, flute, and percussion, and explained that because music played a key role in “creating the atmosphere of the Kabuki dance” audiences must first hear the instruments alone to become “accustomed to” their different tone quality. The musical demonstration began with a slow unison melody from flute and shamisen but then transitioned to a faster and more rhythmic section dominated by drumming, with the flute and shamisen now playing a livelier heterophonic melody. Two solo dances followed: a slow dance by Ms. Azuma to a melodic koto and flute accompaniment and the allegedly death-defying “Lion Dance,” where the male performer must master the art of twirling his floor-length wig in precise rhythm to a musical accompaniment dominated by rhythmic drumming. The centerpiece of Azuma's 1954 Omnibus performance was a dramatization of the origins of Kabuki, performed by five female dancers and one male in the role of a samurai, accompanied by the full contingent of instruments playing off-stage and mostly off-camera.Footnote 64 The Azuma dancers returned to Omnibus two years later in January of 1956 to open another US tour, again performing dramatic group and solo dances, but this time the musicians were rarely in the shot until, in the final moment of the episode, the camera pulled back to show the entire company, including the musicians on the side of the stage.
Alistair Cooke claimed the Azuma dancers were the first “kabuki” to perform in the United States, but a variety of debates over the definition and appearance of true kabuki raise questions around whether Azuma's was truly firstFootnote 65 or even whether what appeared on Omnibus was really authentic “kabuki” at all.Footnote 66 After World War II, a veritable explosion of English language publications on kabuki reveals a burgeoning Western interest in Japanese theatrical traditions.Footnote 67 Writing in 1956, Earle Ernst explained that since the end of the Second World War, Americans were drawn to kabuki with a kind of romantic “nostalgia” for the history of the “defeated nation.”Footnote 68 Cooke's story that American interest in kabuki was primarily a result of US servicemen having encountered kabuki performances may not have been exactly accurate, but certainly it was useful for helping a broad television audience feel more comfortable about what they were seeing, as it was something already vetted by trusted husbands and fathers. According to kabuki aficionados such as Faubion Bowers and author James Michener, both the Japanese and US governments sought to market kabuki to US citizens as a means of generating political sympathy between the countries.Footnote 69 Contrary to Cooke's story of Japanese reluctance, the Japanese government specifically promoted the Azuma Company for cultural export, despite their performances being more fittingly characterized as nihon buyō, an amateur dance genre derived from kabuki.Footnote 70 Kevin Wetmore explains persuasively that promoting “a female-led nihon buyō company … as kabuki” was a way to make Japan “safe for America” by “Orientaliz[ing]” and feminizing kabuki and, by extension, the Japanese nation: “The writers and artists wisely marketed a ‘kabuki’ to McCarthy-era America that viewed female dancers, Oriental women, and a feminized Japanese culture as more saleable than the exotic but potentially homoerotic onnagata.”Footnote 71 1954 was a crucial time in transforming the American public's image of Japan from enemy to ally, coming between the ending of the US occupation in 1952 and the 1956 grant of United Nations membership status to Japan, and through its broadcast of the Azuma Company, Omnibus participated in the cultural policy work laid out explicitly by Foundation heads including Dyke Brown.
Just as Omnibus used music and dance to guide US sympathies favorably towards Japan as a Cold War ally, the show also featured music and dance from another country that the United States wanted to enlist in the struggle against communism: Yugoslavia. In 1948, Josip Tito, leader of the communist republic of Yugoslavia, broke ties with Joseph Stalin and the USSR. Still invested in communism, Tito sought different economic and foreign policy strategies that were oriented towards Europe and Western states.Footnote 72 Following the “Tito-Stalin Split,” President Harry S. Truman issued the “Yugoslav Emergency Relief Assistance Act of 1950,” providing $37 million in aid to Yugoslavia via the Economic Cooperation Administration, the same organization administering the Marshall Plan.Footnote 73 In 1953, Yugoslavia and NATO states Greece and Turkey signed the Tripartite Treaty of Friendship and Cooperation, and in 1954 they upgraded these policies of cultural and economic cooperation to the formal military alliance of the Balkan Pact. Furthermore, from 1953 to 1956, Yugoslavia's foreign minister adopted a “policy of Europe-centered neutralism.”Footnote 74 But even the 1951 Tito-Stalin Split was enough for the Ford Foundation to see Yugoslavia as a significant opportunity for Cold War cultural interventions.
On January 22, 1956, while it was still uncertain if Yugoslavia would continue to orient itself towards Europe, Omnibus featured the Ensemble Tanec, known at the time as the more generic National Folk Ballet of Yugoslavia.Footnote 75 Established in 1949, the group quickly achieved fame in Europe and was brought to the United States for a fifteen-week tour that began (like the Azuma Company) with their debut US performance on the Omnibus television soundstage. Standing in front of a map of the Balkan region, Cooke introduced Tanec's first dance by explaining that the group would be presenting a multiethnic mix of traditions that go back thousands of years, stressing that Yugoslavians have been subject to centuries of war, invasion, and annexation. When Tanec returned later in the episode, Cooke again stressed Yugoslavia's history of being “overrun,” “conquered,” and “occupied,” again calling attention to the country's multiculturalism but also stressing the hardships of Yugoslavians for Omnibus viewers. Cooke also worked hard to normalize the people behind the dances, presenting them as modern people whose dances are now just “spectacle” and “ancient ritual.” Audiences were meant to appreciate the excitement and beauty of the dances while understanding them to be manifestations of difference that are now firmly in Yugoslavia's past. The music, called “remarkable” and “fiercely beautiful” in New York Times reviews,Footnote 76 is central to dance and consists primarily of heterophonic melody played by differing combinations of bagpipe, accordion, clarinet, flute/whistle, violin, and the shawm-like zurla, with a large drum, guitar, and upright bass driving the rhythm. Indeed, the music proved so popular that following Tanec's US tour they recorded an LP, released later in 1956 by Smithsonian Folkways. For both the Azuma Company and Ensemble Tanec, Omnibus played a significant role in familiarizing US audiences with the music from a nation significant to US foreign relations.
Influencing Neutrals: Indian Music Comes to the United States (and Meets Jazz)
The dominant story about East-West fusion is that it began in the 1960s and 1970s with rock and jazz groups like the Beatles and Mahavishnu Orchestra.Footnote 77 But this kind of collaboration began at least ten years earlier, and Omnibus had a key role in facilitating it. At the close of their third season in April 1955, Omnibus was achieving great success, having recently won a Peabody Award and two Emmy Awards. A New York Times article, published on the morning of this season finale, discusses Saudek's continued commitment to “experimentation” and presenting the “different.”Footnote 78 For this season finale, Omnibus broadcast the young Indian classical musicians Ali Akbar Khan and Chatur Lal; this was indeed the very first time Indian classical music had been nationally televised in the United States.Footnote 79
As with many Omnibus guests, Khan and Lal were in New York to perform live concerts. Specifically, Khan and Lal were supported through a collaboration between several US foundations and the Indian government and guided by American virtuoso violinist Yehudi Menuhin, an enthusiastic ambassador for both Indian classical music and the practice of yoga. Menuhin, a former child prodigy and a popular classical soloist, was at a high point in his own career. He had been elected president of the Asian Music Circle of London, which aimed to organize concerts and lectures promoting Asian music in the West. During this time, philanthropist John D. Rockefeller III was in the process of creating the Asia Society of New York City.Footnote 80 After a concert tour of India in May 1954, Menuhin had a full schedule of US concerto performances that summer, and in January 1955 he even starred in his own twenty-seven-minute Omnibus segment, accompanied by the Little Orchestra Society of New York. Rockefeller invited Menuhin to host the Living Arts of India Festival at the Museum of Modern Art in April 1955, an event supported by the Asian Music Circle and the Ford Foundation. Menuhin, who met sitarist Ravi Shankar and his tabla accompanist, Chatur Lal, on a 1952 trip to India, invited his friends to perform. But when Shankar had to refuse the invitation because of complications in his personal life, Shankar's brother-in-law, sarod player Khan, went instead.Footnote 81
On April 10, 1955, Easter Sunday, Omnibus opened with a nod to the holiday via a short segment on decorated Russian Easter eggs, but Indian music and dance came second on the program. Menuhin acted as the narrator and guide for a twelve-minute segment that was dominated by the presentation of two dances, with time at the end for just a few minutes of Raga Manj Khamaj (which Menuhin explained as easier for Western audiences to follow because it closely resembled a C-major scale) performed by Khan and Lal.Footnote 82 A key aim of Saudek's was that the show could feature “performance as performance,” without any explanation, so that viewers could learn to appreciate the art on its own terms. Yet Omnibus also believed that a little of the right kind of “analysis” and background for art could help “a broader number of people … take an interest.”Footnote 83 This segment adhered to these goals almost as a recipe. Accompanied by mridangam, percussion, and a vocalist, dancer Shanta Rao first performed a “ritual” dance, “Alarippu,” which received very little explanation.Footnote 84 But now that audiences had been fully immersed in several minutes of Indian music and dance without much explanation, the presentation of “Padam Chaliyani” came with a little more guidance for how viewers could find it meaningful, via the technical treat of a prerecorded English-language voiceover by Rao that accompanied the live performance, summarizing the meaning of the sung text. These scenes focus on Rao's dancing, with the musicians occasionally visible on the edges of the frame. Finally, deepening the immersion process, the last part of the segment focused on music, unaccompanied by dance. Khan and Lal played a five-minute alap-jor-jhala sequence, preceded by Menuhin explaining for audiences the organizing systems of both the raga and the tala. Ever the educator, Menuhin sought to actively engage viewers at home: “I challenge you to maintain this rhythm against the increasing complexities of the cross-rhythms,” for even as the musicians “seem to try to unseat each other … they never abandon the original rhythm.” After Lal joins in on tabla at the jor, the camera pans out to include Menuhin crouched down by the players, clapping to help the audience follow the tal pattern. As the excitement builds in the jhala, Menuhin drops out and the audience's attention is drawn to the interplay between the two instrumentalists.
The two MoMA concerts occurred after the Omnibus broadcast, the first with a “modest-sized audience that was almost evenly divided between public spectators and invited guests.”Footnote 85 The second concert, advertised in the New York Times listings as open to MoMA members and the general public, was billed as a “Concert of Indian Music.”Footnote 86 Whereas the more telegenic dance may have dominated the Omnibus feature, no mention was made of any dancers in the advertisement or Menuhin's article, and according to reviews of this performance, the concert was exclusively musical. In the time between the Omnibus performance and the MoMA concert, Khan and Lal recorded the first LP of Indian classical music, Music of India: Morning and Evening Ragas. Just as he did for their Omnibus performance, Menuhin provided a spoken introduction to Indian music on the recording. Peter Lavezzoli argues for the historical importance these events, saying, “Khan's American visit in 1955 was the first time that any Indian classical musician was invited to perform, and more importantly to record, in the United States for the sole purpose of preserving the music as it is.”Footnote 87
Omnibus’s airing of Indian classical music laid the groundwork for East-West fusion by forging productive relationships but also by providing an inspirational seed. At the conclusion of Khan and Lal's rousing 1954 performance, Alistair Cooke had commented that it was like “one of our jam sessions,”Footnote 88 and New York Times music critic Howard Taubman urged readers to attend the second MoMA concert, comparing the “free, improvisatory quality” of Indian classical music to the “flexibility and freedom of the best jazz performances.”Footnote 89 Although Khan's popularity among US audiences would soon be eclipsed by that of his brother-in-law, Ravi Shankar, Khan's 1955 trip marked the beginning of a new direction for him: he soon returned to the United States, established a music school in the 1960s, and collaborated with jazz musicians including saxophonist John Handy in the 1970s.Footnote 90 Furthermore, having seen the success of Khan and Lal's 1955 US trip, Shankar decided in 1956 to embark with Lal on a tour of the United States and Europe.Footnote 91 Much was made of this tour, including a feature in Life in December 1956, showing photos of a party hosted by jazz historian Marshall Stearns where Shankar and Lal “jammed” with Dizzy Gillespie and Willy “The Lion” Smith.Footnote 92
Stearns's party may have been attended by a select group of musicians and jazz aficionados, but the earliest televised fusion of Indian classical music and American jazz would soon take place on Omnibus in front of millions. On December 2, 1956, Chatur Lal returned to the show (without Khan or Shankar) to play with jazz drummer “Papa” Jo Jones in a segment titled “Different Drummers.” Cooke provided the commentary, acknowledging the differences between jazz and Indian classical music but stressing their similarity as improvisatory traditions. In a rendition of Ellington's “Caravan,” Lal and Jones trade drum solos, with the band hidden in the shadows behind the players. Still following Omnibus’s formula of “music first, explanation second,” Cooke then explains the tabla's capability to play pitched sounds, as well as providing a brief introduction to Indian rhythmic system of the tala. The most musically exciting portion comes when both Lal and Jones improvise for several minutes over a sixteen-beat tala, watching each other the entire time, able not only to imitate each other's flourishes but to create moments of impressive synchrony. Cooke tells us that Lal and Jones have been rehearsing together all week and that he hopes this demonstration “has shown the incredible subtlety of Indian rhythms.”Footnote 93 Although the closing jazz number unfortunately featured the band more than the drummers, the overall effect of “Different Drummers” was to underscore the shared complexity and inherent compatibility of Indian music and American jazz. Here again, Omnibus not only sought to familiarize audiences with Indian music but also, by comparing it to American jazz, to normalize it for an average middlebrow viewer. To be an informed and erudite citizen, the show suggested, is to understand both American jazz and Indian drumming and to see them as musically compatible.
Viewed on its own, “Different Drummers” is musically interesting, allowing a glimpse into some of the creative cross-pollination that usually happened outside of the public eye, or at least not on television, but when seen in the larger political context of the 1950s, both episodes of Indian music in Omnibus have more than just musical significance. In the same year this musical and cultural exchange between Indian music and jazz was happening on Omnibus, the State Department began sending jazz musicians abroad—Dizzy Gillespie's band was the first group sent in 1956—in a program conceived by Marshall Stearns,Footnote 94 the host of the party where Shankar, Lal, and Gillespie jammed together for the pages of Life. This state-sponsored “cultural diplomacy” of sending jazz musicians overseas expanded on existing governmental efforts to export US culture, such as the Voice of America radio broadcasts (also connected to musicians performing on Omnibus).Footnote 95 But although those cultural exports have been well studied, the cultural flows from the other direction are equally important, and Omnibus’s broadcasts of international culture to a mainstream US television audience played a key role in cultural policy within the United States.Footnote 96
Whose Folk Music? Omnibus Looks Outward, not Inward
Omnibus’s producers and the Ford Foundation deliberately strove to broadcast diverse artistic, historical, and cultural material not found anywhere else on the dial, but they also actively sought to educate audiences about cultural diversity, particularly as it served the Foundation's broader aims for strengthening international relations. Given that international folk music in the United States in the 1940s and 1950s shared an industrial context and audience with the US folk revival, considering Omnibus’s attention to a range of other musical genres, and knowing that Omnibus-connected Sol Hurok managed some US folk musicians,Footnote 97 one might have expected to see more US folk artists appear on the show from time to time. Instead, no artists associated with the folk revival of the 1950s were ever featured as musical guests. Similarly, for all the jazz on Omnibus over the years, it never aired any blues musicians. Whether bypassed in the overwhelming ambition to bring in artists from beyond US borders, relegated to the category of harmless but charming nostalgia not worth putting on TV, or excluded for being too lowbrow for the middlebrow, the relative dearth of US folk and blues music on Omnibus raises important questions about the complexity of both domestic and international cultural politics of the postwar era.
Just as the Ford Foundation expressed support for international culture as a means of maintaining peace, so too did folk musicians around the world express the desire to use music to create human connection and common ground across political borders. Starting in the 1940s, record companies like Folkways, Decca, and Victor released increasing numbers of folk songs by international musicians, mostly from Europe, the Americas, and the Near East.Footnote 98 By the late 1950s and early 1960s, international folk music was increasingly available to amateurs in sheet music form and songbooks. For instance, in addition to the many spirituals, Anglo ballads, and Yiddish folk songs it published, Sing Out!, the magazine of the US urban folk revival (first published in 1950) included songs identified as originating in France, Spain, Russia, Puerto Rico, and India.Footnote 99 Different, overlapping reasons explain the revival of “folk” music, usually broadly understood as music that falls outside the bounds of both classical art music and commercial music. For some, reviving these traditional musics provided a way to resist modernization and its attendant anxieties and to promote rural and racial/ethnic pride, but it also was seen as a music that could unite people through a shared past and national heritage.Footnote 100 International folk music, too, had the potential to fulfill its own internationalist goals for world peace; as the introduction to a 1958 book of Caribbean folk songs put it, “it is impossible to hate someone whose songs you love.”Footnote 101
Omnibus did feature folk song from outside of the United States twice, by musicians with substantial international musical careers who had released several recordings to the US market and had worked previously in radio. Brazilian guitarist and singer Olga Coelho, who first toured the United States in 1943 and appeared in an episode of the 1940s radio show University of the Air (an early NBC experiment in distance learning), was a featured solo performer in Omnibus’s first season in 1953.Footnote 102 Then, a year later (a week after Azuma's first appearance), Omnibus featured the “folk music of South Africa” via the husband-and-wife singing duo Marais and Miranda. Like Coelho, Josef Marais had long been popular in the United States; the white South African of Dutch descent began hosting the US radio show African Trek on NBC Blue in 1939, and in the 1940s Marais released records with his Bushveld Band.Footnote 103 In the early 1950s, Marais and his classically trained Dutch wife Miranda were selling out concerts at New York City's Town Hall, where they performed a variety of international folk songs with Western vocal aesthetics and harmonizations.Footnote 104 Like many of Omnibus’s musical acts, they appeared on the show in the same week they were performing in New York, on tour around the United States.Footnote 105 In the ten-minute feature, Marais and Miranda performed three songs, one describing life on the veldt for the Afrikaans sheep farmer and two songs they described as sung by “Africans,” one of which, though mostly in English, contained a word or two of Zulu.
Coelho and Marais and Miranda fit well into both Omnibus’s and the Ford Foundation's politico-cultural agendas. On the one hand, Omnibus’s choice to air these international musicians was fully in keeping with the show's middlebrow cosmopolitan aesthetics and its educational mission. On the other hand, we can also discern a coherent internationalist politics to booking these particular acts. For instance, in explaining the popularity of Coelho, scholar Antonio Pedro Tota describes how the United States and Brazil sought to build cultural goodwill during the 1940s for both political allies and commercial markets, exchanging musicians and other performers between the United States and Latin America as part of the work of the Office of the Coordinator of Inter-American Affairs (OCIAA). Prior to World War II, Brazil's strongest economic ties had been with Germany and Italy. Franklin Roosevelt's foreign policy toward Latin America, referred to as the Good Neighbor policy, was created to help the United States access needed raw materials (and Brazil to find new buyers) while also creating a bulwark in the southern hemisphere against the spread of Nazism.Footnote 106 Following the war, the Ford Foundation worried that so much attention on Western Europe might cause Latin America to “feel” like “forgotten people” and argued that their location, resources, and support for the United Nations made them a “tremendous political asset.”Footnote 107 Furthermore, James Webb Young, the architect of the Foundation's TvRW, had previously done communications work for Nelson Rockefeller during Rockefeller's time with the OCIAA.Footnote 108 Although Coelho appeared on Omnibus a year after Young left the Foundation, her inclusion on the program connected prewar and postwar international cultural policy work.
Whereas Coelho was a musician who benefited from the cultural climate created to support the Good Neighbor policy, Josef Marais was directly tied to US foreign relations: during World War II he worked for the US Office of War Information coordinating Voice of America broadcasts to the Netherlands and South Africa.Footnote 109 Writing about a 1946 Daily Worker feature on Marais and Miranda, Ronald Cohen explains the popularity of the duo with US folkies as “one aspect of the Left's search for peace and brotherhood.”Footnote 110 However, Marais himself disavowed the folk label, saying, “We're not folk singers, and if you can give us the right word [for what we do], ‘fine.’”Footnote 111 Given the folk revival's suspiciously youthful audiences, perhaps Marais hoped this remark would cultivate a different demographic, inviting listeners to classify the duo's music as more mature and elevated, especially given Miranda's more classical Western vocal sound. It is possible that Marais may have also had political reasons, as identifying his music as “folk” could have seemed dangerous given the McCarthyist political climate (with many folk singers including Pete Seeger, Josh White, Burl Ives, and Paul Robeson being blacklisted during these years, as I will return to below). But Time magazine explains Marais's repeated disavowal of the folk label differently: Marais and Miranda transformed “folk” song into “pop” music, saying they “were not the kind of folk singers who try to present the songs as they were originally sung,” instead they sought to simply “preserve the flavor” of these folk musics.Footnote 112
Omnibus featured US performers playing US folk songs just twice in its nine years, both times mainstream commercial musicians known better for singing popular song rather than folk song. First, in February 1956, the singing duo Frances Archer and Beverly Gile performed a set of US folk songs on Omnibus. Archer and Gile might have already been recognizable to one subset of Omnibus’s core audience: children. The duo began performing on television on the Mickey Mouse Show in 1955 and released several albums on Disneyland Records including the 1957 Folk Songs from the Far Corners.Footnote 113 Second, in Omnibus’s final season in 1961, it devoted an entire sixty-minute episode to a “medley” of “American Songs,” performed by Broadway singer-actors Myron McCormick, Edie Adams, and Robert Goulet. Although their repertoire may have been understood as “folk” music, the sounds of these musicians—rounded timbre, clear tone, and vibrato—conformed to aesthetic ideals of Western art and commercial music. Omnibus may have been committed to presenting the best of the best, but in the case of US folk music, to the extent that it featured this music at all, it was performed by Disney- and Broadway-sanctioned popsters who were not at all representative of the 1950s folk revival and its ideals of non-commercial “authenticity.” Given that practical access to folk revival musicians would likely have been easy, via proximity to the US urban folk scene centered around New York's Greenwich Village and Hurok's connections, the absence of any “authentic” folk musicians or members of the folk revival is curious.
Several explanations may exist for why Omnibus shied away from featuring artists in the US folk scene that were the musical equivalents of the classical, jazz, popular, and even the Indian classical musicians they featured on the show. Perhaps the show's producers feared that that more “authentic” and unpolished US folk music wouldn't be commercially viable or that it was more lowbrow than middlebrow. Although they appear to have been interested in children and adults, Omnibus doesn't appear to have sought a teen/youth market, apparently content to let Ed Sullivan, Milton Berle, and Steve Allen host popular rock ’n’ roll musicians. On the rare times when American songs and US “folk” music occurred on the show, it happened either as atmospheric accompaniment or decontextualized from its origins, thus becoming nostalgic and/or patriotic commercial pop music. For instance, some viewers might have recognized the voice of Susan Reed, former teen folk star known for performing on Anglo ballads while accompanying herself on the zither and folk harp. Reed provided accompanying music for a staged adaptation of Susan Glaspell's short story “A Jury of Her Peers” and for the soundtracks of two animated short films broadcast on the show.Footnote 114 She also participated in a nostalgic throwback to homespun entertainment in a segment featuring the family of painter Thomas Hart Benton.Footnote 115
It is possible that Omnibus and the Ford Foundation sought distance from the leftist ideological connotations of the US folk movement. As her fame dwindled in the 1950s, Susan Reed felt she had been “graylisted” out of the music business, her perceptions indicating how the negative association of folk music with Leftist politics potentially tainted the careers of many musicians.Footnote 116 And Pete Seeger and the Weavers, who had earlier appeared on NBC, were blacklisted from television beginning in 1951 after being featured in the anti-communist newsletter Counterattack.Footnote 117 However, Omnibus did not bow to the blacklist, not even from the first episode.Footnote 118 Show regulars Burgess Meredith and Leonard Bernstein were both named as subversives in another publication of Counterattack, the 1950 booklet Red Channels: The Report of Communist Influence in Radio and Television.Footnote 119 Saudek deliberately and enthusiastically hired Meredith “right in the middle of that trouble,” starting as an actor for several short plays on Omnibus’s first season, then tapping him to host Omnibus’s 1953–54 youth-oriented spin-off program, Excursions.Footnote 120 Barry Seldes argues that Omnibus’s hiring of Bernstein in 1954 acted to effectively remove and rehabilitate the conductor from the blacklist.Footnote 121 Saudek recounted that Omnibus received a few letters of complaint and that Henry Ford II pointedly (and perhaps not very humorously) teased him about “still employing Communists on that show of yours,” but the Foundation's Board, although generally nervous about accusations of communism, continued to back the show.Footnote 122 Therefore, anti-communist politics cannot sufficiently explain the absence of US folk music from the show. Instead, the relative absence on Omnibus of folk music traditions from within the United States illuminates the dynamic push-pull of foreign and domestic politics in the immediate postwar era, as well as the cultural politics of this time.
For those aspiring to the normal and middlebrow in the 1950s, the direction of attention tended to be outward-looking and future-oriented. There was a long tradition of Americanist striving whereby one's ethnic and rural past were things to be overcome and abandoned on the journey to full belonging in the assimilationist ideal,Footnote 123 an ideal that included “self-improvement.” This imperative to work on the self as a route toward upward mobility fueled cultural appreciation movements in music and the visual arts that had historically been oriented outwards towards Europe, with what Lawrence Levine has called a “colonial mentality in matters of culture and intellect.”Footnote 124 What Omnibus’s programming reveals is a shift in that outwards orientation during the postwar era—from provincialism to internationalism, from former colony to global leader—that further empowered discourses of American omnipotence and exceptionalism.
Conclusion: American Power
The discourse of American exceptionalism was particularly widespread and powerful in the years when Omnibus aired, invigorated by postwar economic prosperity, military might, and a good deal of self-congratulatory thinking. During the Cold War, Americans exported and sold the idea of America—the principles of freedom, democracy, and liberalism—to other countries.Footnote 125 Eisenhower's establishment in 1954 of the President's Special International Program for Participation in International Affairs, better known as the Cultural Presentations Program, sought to teach other countries about the superiority of American democracy as a cultural and political system by using music and art.Footnote 126 There's no doubt these musicians and artists gave their best to this effort, but the internationalist focus of this cultural policy often functioned, as scholars have pointed out, to obscure many of the social inequalities and legalized discrimination occurring back home in the land of the free and the brave. For instance, the US State Department's aforementioned “jazz diplomacy” of the mid-1950s employed musicians of color to represent these ideals of freedom, while back home in the United States these same musicians were subject to segregation, exclusion, casual violence, and death threats.Footnote 127 The 1950s were also a time when The Power of Positive Thinking, advocating a pro-capitalist Christianity and also aimed at aspirational middlebrows, appealed strongly to parts of the US populationFootnote 128—perhaps even the act of saying that American society was fair, tolerant, and peaceful would help make it so. Godfrey Hodgson examines how high school and college textbooks not only instructed students to rank their country above others but positioned the United States’ success as a fulfillment of its special status, as more equal and free and, therefore, uniquely more democratic and moral than other societies.Footnote 129 Omnibus can be understood as an important player in the shifting perception of the United States as a global leader; the shows' airing of international musics contributed to the building of an attractive cosmopolitan mindset amongst the American middle class that would help make US foreign policy objectives seem common sense, even generous.
Omnibus went off the air in 1961, in a world different than the early 1950s one in which it began. Japan and the United States became official military allies in January 1960 when they entered into the Treaty of Mutual Cooperation and Security, and in 1961 President Tito of Yugoslavia and President Nehru of India founded the official Non-Aligned Movement, along with the leaders of Egypt, Ghana, and Indonesia. 1961 would see the failed Bay of Pigs invasion in Cuba, the building of the Berlin Wall, and US military escalation in Southeast Asia. Not only was the international scene differently complicated but, back home in the United States, the Civil Rights movement fought to show the country and the world that the peace and prosperity that seemed to characterize the 1950s was not something experienced by all Americans equally. Omnibus’s model of teaching citizenship in the mode of cultural and musical appreciation no longer matched the changed landscape of American activism and political engagement.
Omnibus reveals a particular moment in postwar US culture, when a successful middlebrow variety show on commercial television, created by corporate philanthropy, could be a way to change the world by educating viewers who, it was fervently hoped, would become better citizens in a free democracy. In this article, I have sought to demonstrate how Omnibus’s broadcast of international music and dance was more than just diverse entertainment on an already eclectic show. Omnibus adds to our understanding of Cold War music exchange by illustrating the role played by private foundations and businessmen, rather than by governmental programs and diplomats, in bringing international musicians from Japan, Yugoslavia, and India. It also reveals how the Foundation's goals for using television to educate the US population joined with its larger political goals of internationalism in support of specific US foreign policy objectives. In doing so, this case study illuminates the complicated web of cultural politics in the 1950s, when music played a significant role not only in the emerging medium of television but in the subtle details of global power dynamics.
