Originally published in 2004 under the title Sendero en tinieblas, Alberto Ulloa Bornemann's testimonio about his role in Mexico's guerrilla movements, his disappearance and his imprisonment subtly documents the ongoing attempts of the generation of 1968 to come to terms with state violence in the 1970s. More evidently, Ulloa wrestles with his current political, cultural and social views as they inform his perceptions of events that took place over 30 years ago.
Ulloa represents the upper-middle-class militant who decided to go to the people. A product of a private Catholic education at the Universidad Iberoamericana, Ulloa became a militant in the Liga Comunista Espartaco that aligned intellectually with workers' and peasants' struggles. Like many of his contemporaries, he felt alienated from the Mexican political process and society as a whole. Although there existed cross-activism of members of La Liga and the 1968 Mexican student movement, intellectuals criticised the student uprising as too bourgeois and narrowly focused. Ulloa represents this faction, despite his middle-class Mexican youth. In his recollection, he portrays himself as a self-centred, pedantic, immature young man in search of his own revolution. That revolutionary narcissism drives him to undertake desperate adventures to heighten his prowess.
Ulloa's search led to a trip to Cuba, where he hoped to defend the revolution and bring his family to the island. Upon arriving on the island, he criticised his own country, demonstrating his lack of political savvy in light of the fact that his was one of the few countries that supported the island nation against the colossus to the north. Of course, Cubans did not welcome him with open arms, rifles, job offers or revolutionary vanguard training. Instead, he attempted to find his own way, though he was ‘chaperoned’ like an unwitting quinceañera. During his stay, Ernesto ‘Che’ Guevara died in Bolivia. When Fidel Castro addressed Guevara's murder, Ulloa grew outraged by Castro's perceived ambivalence and the virtual marketing of revolutionary ethos that continues to encircle the image of Che. Even in his contemporary analysis, written by a man who threw in the revolutionary towel and devoted his life to the profession of government communications, Ulloa never makes the connection to his own quest. Instead of finding his revolutionary calling on the island, he was sent packing by his hosts, much to his dismay. In his recollection this experience left a subtle crack in his emerging ideology.
Despite the Cuba fiasco, he returned to Mexico to devote himself to a national, though less glamorous, organisation, Lucio Cabañas Barrientos' Partido de los pobres. Ulloa's militancy manifested itself more in his strategy: serving as a chauffeur for Cabañas, making arrangements, and offering safe haven in his own home, placing his wife and daughter at risk. Ulloa's description of his trips with Cabañas to build coalitions between different armed groups portray his uneasiness with kidnapping, bank robbery, fellow revolutionaries and violence. Moreover, his admitted boredom and criticism characterised his inability to shake his middle-class milieu. Recognising this, in 1974, at the time of his arrest, Ulloa committed himself to leaving the life and devoting himself to his family. Once arrested, Ulloa's revolutionary zeal further unravelled when he was confronted with the horrors of Campo Militar 1, Lecumberri and Santa Martha. Under torture he revealed the names of prominent activists in the movement who were also arrested, and yet his connection to them perhaps saved his life.
Ulloa's greatest strength lies in his interpretation of the prison, an experience that disembodied him. He writes: ‘I again suffered the realization that our lives were a fragile toy in the hands of anonymous powers, capricious and unpredictable’ (p. 171). Those powers were dispersed among high-level government officials, prison administrators, prisoners and his fellow revolutionaries. Ulloa's shifting values endured multiple challenges in the prison setting. His work, combined with the numerous prison diaries of Mexicans, whether 1968 activists or not, offers insight into institutional punishment, state violence, corruption, prison-organised crime and human survival that has not yet been systematically studied. Like Luis Gonzalez del Alba, José Revueltas, Eduardo Valle or Demetrio Vallejo, Ulloa portrays the complexities of political factions and ideologies that clash behind prison walls, just as he encountered with Cabañas.
Ulloa's testimony is obviously a re-creation of events based on memory. The reader gains an incredible insight into Ulloa's experiences in the late 1960s and early 1970s, but also a good reading of those who were co-opted into the system after the Dirty War. Despite his rejection of his family in the late 1960s, they paved the way for the return of the prodigal son, who is in a fortunate enough position to recall his past in print. Thus his work invites interesting discussion, whether in a classroom setting or among scholars.
My main criticism of the edition is its limited annotation. The Schmidts include a welcome glossary of names and terms that provide basic information about prominent leaders of the Left and in the Mexican government, and the Introduction positions the work superbly. Ulloa mentions many prominent people, however, and the work would have been strengthened with more complete annotations, whether through expository footnotes or a more in-depth introduction or epilogue by Ulloa. Such biographies would have further substantiated Ulloa's arguments, whether positive or negative, about Mexico's reincorporation of the guerrilla movement and what happened to those countless revolutionaries.
