In Two Troubled Souls, Aaron Spencer Fogleman presents a remarkable portrait of a marriage, an intimate look into the partnership of Jean-François Reynier and Maria Barbara Knoll, whose travels took them on a dramatic circuit around the Atlantic world. Fogleman's research in Europe and America enables him to chronicle their travels from France to Germany to Surinam to St. Thomas to Pennsylvania to South Carolina in fine detail. Both of them were religious seekers, dedicated pietists whose thirst for a religious community brought them together, threatened to tear them apart, and involved them in one unlikely adventure after the next until their life journey ended in the backwoods of the Carolina frontier.
Jean-François Reynier's odyssey began in the picturesque town of Vevey on the shores of Lake Geneva. He was born into a large Huguenot family who fled France after the revocation of the Edict of Nantes. As a young man he was drawn into the circle around Madame de Warens, a local noblewoman who wove together philosophy, physics, alchemy and pietism. He was also influenced by the French Camisards and German pietists, where he first learned about pietist groups in America, and he indentured himself in order to emigrate to Pennsylvania. After six miserable years in servitude, he wandered from the backcountry commune at Ephrata to New York City to Count Zinzendorf's Moravia community in Georgia. There he practiced medicine, befriended John Wesley, and joined missions to convert Africans and Native Americans to Christianity, but trouble followed him, and he decided to travel to Germany to lay his case before Count Zinzendorf personally. He arrived in the Moravian community outside Utrecht in 1739 and settled into a happy time in that close-knit fellowship. Within a year the Moravians had arranged his marriage to Maria Barbara Knoll and prepared to send the newlyweds to join a small Moravian mission to enslaved people and Native Americans in Surinam. Maria Barbara had joined the Moravian community in 1739, though what her life was like before that time is lost to history.
The Moravians had established missions in Africa, the Caribbean, North America, Scandinavia, and many parts of Europe, making them an integral part of the Atlantic world. The couple traveled to Surinam, but failed there. In 1742 Zinzendorf transferred them to the new Moravian community in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania. They stopped at the Danish West Indies, where they found a struggling slave mission and helped put it back on its feet, an unusual success story for the beleaguered pair. Maria Barbara enjoyed the rich communal life in Bethlehem, but Jean-François was soon at odds with the leadership and decided to leave, a decision that his wife resisted. The two separated and nearly divorced as Maria Barbara sought to remain with the Moravians and Jean-François bounced from one religious group to the next. He also published an autobiography that was critical of the Moravians. They returned to Ephrata, where Maria Barbara thrived but her husband was soon embroiled in conflict. They separated, and Maria Barbara openly engaged in sexual relations with a leader of the community. In 1765, Jean-François persuaded his wife to reunite with him and they agreed to relocate to Savannah.
Much had changed in Georgia since Jean-François's stay there – it was now a thriving royal colony, and with the ban on slaveholding lifted, the economy was growing rapidly. They purchased a house and an enslaved African girl, and Jean-François practiced medicine. Within a few years, Maria Barbara convinced her husband to move to Ebenezer, a Salzburg Lutheran community with a strong pietist bent that appealed to her. They lived comfortably on a two-hundred-acre farm there, and Maria Barbara found the supportive religious community she had long sought. Jean-François died in 1775 and Maria Barbara in 1777.
Their quest for a community of faith takes us inside some of the most radical religious groups in Europe and the colonial Americas, and as disparate as those groups appear, the Reyniers' experience demonstrates that they were in some ways linked by the troubled souls who flitted from one of them to the next. Fogleman brings all the skills of the microhistorian to bear here – a compelling narrative, deep and exhaustive research in fragmentary records, and the use of individual lives to explore much larger social and cultural trends. The work is well suited to classroom use, and my summary cannot do justice to the richness of the narrative. The Reyniers' religious odyssey illustrates several important themes in early America's religious history – its stunning diversity and complexity, the vital Atlantic connections that knit that religious world together, the importance of the eighteenth century in shaping America's religious trajectory, and the connection between religion and slavery.
