Sources
The principal sources of information on which this chronicle is based are British Broadcasting Corporation, Monitoring Global News line − Asia-Pacific Political and British Broadcasting Corporation, Monitoring Global News line − Asia-Pacific Economic. These sources, now only available electronically, do not have reference numbers and are only identifiable by date of publication of material. The inclusion of each of these dates would unnecessarily clutter the text and such dates have therefore been omitted, except, at many points, for the original sources from which the BBC reports themselves are taken.
Abbreviations
- XHNA
Xinhua (New China) News Agency
- CNA
Central News Agency (Taipei)
- RTHK
Radio-Television Hong Kong
- ZTS
Zhongguo tongxun she (China Reporting Agency), Hong Kong
- ZXS
Zhongguo xinwen she (China News Agency), Beijing
- RMRB
Renmin ribao (People's Daily)
- SCMP
South China Morning Post
- KCNA
Korean Central News Agency
1.Internal developments
aThe Fifth Plenum of the 17th CPC Central Committee
bThe 17th and 18th sessions of the National People's Congress Standing Committee
cParty and Political Affairs
dSocial Affairs
eEconomic Affairs
fShanghai EXPO and Asian Games
gHuman Rights
hXinjiang and Tibet
iHong Kong and Macau Special Administrative Regions
2.Foreign Relations
aMultilateral Conferences
bDiplomatic Tours
cCountries, Territories and Regions
dTrade Matters
eDefence Diplomacy
1. Internal Developments
a The Fifth Plenum of the 17th CPC Central Committee
The lead up to the Fifth Plenum of the 17th Central Committee of the Communist Party of China was marked by some speculation (in the foreign media in particular) that there might be some movement on political reform (see for example SCMP, 14 Oct.). Much of this was based on interpretations of Wen Jiabao's speech in Shenzhen in September, and subsequent remarks to CNN on the question of political reform. China's official news agency, Xinhua, reported on 16 October that China would be launching a new round of reform to realize good governance, and it was expected that the Plenum would reveal a new round of comprehensive reform, including economic and political reform. Yu Keping, described as a prominent theorist, was quoted as saying that “only with constant reforms and innovations can China build a good government for good governance” (XHNA, 16 Oct.). But the main policy business of the Plenum had long been billed as discussion of the 12th Five-Year Programme. Shortly before the Plenum opened, the leadership held a “forum of non-CCP personalities” in Zhongnanhai to introduce the Party's proposals for the 12th Five-Year Programme. President Hu Jintao delivered a speech on the subject (XHNA, 19 Oct.). The theme of political reform was picked up in official press commentary after the Plenum but it tended to be rather conservative in tenor noting that the kind of political system a country chooses “depends on the will of the overwhelming majority of the country's people and its particular national condition, as well as its historical and cultural background” (XHNA, 27 Oct. quoting an article in People's Daily by Zheng Qingyuan).
The Fifth Plenum was held in Beijing from 15 to 18 October. It was attended by 202 full and 163 alternate members of the Committee, together with a number of non-voting delegates (full text of the Plenum Communiqué in XHNA, 18 Oct.). Hu Jintao presided over the Plenum and delivered an “important” speech. The Plenum heard and discussed a work report from Hu Jintao, and adopted the “CCP Central Committee's Proposal for formulating the 12th Five-Year Programme for China's Economic Development” (full text XHNA, 27 Oct.), which was introduced by Premier Wen Jiabao (full text of his speech in XHNA, 28 Oct.).
Politically, the main business of the Plenum was the appointment of Xi Jinping as a Vice Chairman of the Military Commission. A biographical sketch of him released after the announcement (XHNA, 18 Oct.) highlighted a number of military-related appointments he had held during his career, some of which had been unknown. The appointment is a further step in consolidating his position as the most likely successor to Hu Jintao at the Party Congress in 2012. The Plenum also promoted Yan Rongzhu to full membership of the Central Committee to fill a vacancy caused by the expulsion of Kang Rixin, the former Head of the China National Nuclear Corporation. Most of the Plenum's time was taken up with discussion of the 12th Five-Year Programme. The Plenum proposed the following as the major targets for economic and social development in the next five years: to maintain stable and relatively fast economic growth; to achieve major development in economic restructuring; to universally raise people's incomes at a relatively fast pace; to remarkably enhance social construction; to continuously deepen reform and opening-up; to achieve substantial progress in transforming the economic development pattern; to remarkably strengthen the country's comprehensive national power, international competitiveness and capability in shielding against risks; to make notable progress in meeting people's living and cultural demands; and to further consolidate the foundation for the making of a better-off society in an all-round way. On questions of political reform the Plenum was cautious and pragmatic.
The plenum emphasized that reform is a powerful driving force for accelerating the transformation of the economic development mode, and reform in every realm must be pushed forward in an all-round way with greater resolve and courage. Great impetus should be given to economic system reform, while vigorous yet steady efforts should be made to promote political restructuring. Work should be done to accelerate reform in cultural and social systems to make sure the superstructure adapts to development and changes in economy and to provide a strong guarantee for scientific development. The fundamental economic system should be stuck to and improved; administrative system reform should be promoted; reforms of fiscal and taxation systems should be accelerated; financial system reform should be deepened; reform in resource products pricing and market should be advanced; and reform in social programme system should be quickened. A mutually-beneficial strategy of opening-up should be pursued and more efforts should be made to further open up to the outside world, optimize the foreign trade structure, improve the quality of foreign investment utilization and accelerate the pace in implementing the “going global” strategy. It is necessary to actively participate in global economic governance and regional co-operation, to push forward development, deepen reform and promote innovation by opening up, and to vigorously create new advantages for participating in global economic co-operation and competition” (XHNA, 18 Oct.).
b The 17th and 18th Sessions of the National People's Congress Standing Committee (NPCSC)
The 17th Session of the NPCSC was held in Beijing from 25 to 28 October. It discussed draft legislation on vehicle and vessel taxation, and formally adopted the Social Insurance Law, the Law on the Application of Law to Civil Relationships Involving Foreign Interests, the revised Organic Law of Villagers' Committees and amendments to the Law on Deputies to the NPC and Local People's Congresses at various levels (XHNA, 25, 28 Oct.). Chairman Wu Bangguo addressed the closing session and enjoined the members to study hard the documents of the recently concluded Party Plenum; to unify their thinking and action on work relating to the 12th Five-Year Programme; and to carry out well their work as legislators in the last quarter of the year. The session voted to appoint Xi Jinping as Vice Chairman of the Central Military Commission (XHNA, 28 Oct.).
The 18th Session of the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress was held in Beijing from 20 to 25 December. The session considered amendments to the Criminal Law (in particular in relation to organized crime, food safety and drink driving), revisions to the Law on Water and Soil Conservation, and a law on safeguarding China's intangible cultural heritage (defined as the traditional cultural expressions and practices of China's ethnic groups that have been passed down through generations and that have become part of the group's cultural heritage, including material objects and sites of these expressions). The session decided to convene the annual session of the 11th National People's Congress on 5 March 2011. It heard reports from the State Council on boosting economic and social development in ethnic minority areas, deepening reform of the health care system and stepping up the development of the service sector. It discussed a report on the enforcement of the Energy Conservation Law. The session formally appointed Miao Wei (aged 55) as Minister of Industry and Information Technology, in place of Li Yizhong (aged 65). Miao had previously worked as General Manager of the Dongfeng Motor Corporation in Wuhan and had been appointed Vice Minister in 2008. A number of appointments were also made to the various specialist committees of the National People's Congress. It adopted revisions to the Law on Water and Soil conservancy. Chairman Wu Bangguo gave a speech to the closing session summing up the work of the session (XHNA, 13, 14, 20 and 25 Dec.).
The Standing Committee of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference met in Beijing from 20 to 22 October for its 11th session. Premier Wen Jiabao addressed the meeting on 20 October on the subject of the 12th Five-Year Programme and asked them to offer suggestions on the programme to the State Council as it did the drafting work on turning the proposals into a working document (XHNA, 20 Oct.). The meeting also decided to commemorate the 100th anniversary of the 1911 Revolution in 2011 (XHNA, 22 Oct.). Members of the Standing Committee had a special study session on the afternoon of 22 October on the subject of relations with Taiwan. Jia Qinglin delivered a speech, and Chen Yunlin, former Head of the Taiwan Affairs Office, delivered a report. Jia said that cross-Strait relations had shown a good momentum of peaceful development and that the Cross-Strait Economic Co-operation Framework Agreement had been of strategic significance in the normalization and institutionalization of cross-Strait economic relations. He said that the CCPCC and its members should take an active part in developing cross-Strait relations (XHNA, 22 Oct.). The Presidium of the CPPCC decided on 24 December to hold the next annual session of the CPPCC on 3 March, to be preceded by the 12th session of its Standing Committee on 26 to 28 February to make preparations for the annual session (XHNA, 24 Dec.).
c Party and Political Affairs
Two new provincial Party Secretary appointments were announced on 6 December. Luo Zhijun (aged 60), currently Governor of Jiangsu, was appointed concurrently Party Secretary of the province, replacing Liang Baohua (aged 65), and Li Hongzhong (aged 54), Governor of Hubei, was appointed concurrently Party Secretary of Hubei, replacing Luo Qingquan (aged 65) (XHNA, 6 Dec.). Both Li and Luo had reached the standard retirement age and both were subsequently appointed to positions in the specialist committees of the National People's Congress.
Huang Yao, former Chairman of the Guizhou provincial Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference, was sentenced to death, suspended for two years, on corruption charges in Beijing on 9 December. He was reported to have obtained bribes worth 9.54 million yuan between 1993 and 2009 to help others in business affairs, land planning and job promotions (XHNA, 9 Dec.).
The Politburo met on 28 December to hear the annual report of the Central Commission for Discipline Inspection and to consider anti-corruption work for 2011. The meeting noted that new and evident results had been achieved in improving the Party's work style and upholding integrity. But the struggle against corruption remained grim and the tasks were arduous. In the coming year the Party should strengthen the work of combating corruption and upholding integrity, with the focus placed on improving and perfecting the system for the punishment and prevention of corruption. The meeting called for further efforts to address problems concerning construction projects, and vehicles bought and used at public expense (XHNA, 28 Dec.). The following day China released its first White Paper on dealing with corruption entitled “China's Efforts to Combat Corruption and Build a Clean Government” (text in XHNA, 29 Dec.). Its main sections were:
I. Unswervingly Pushing forward the Undertaking of Combating Corruption and Building a Clean Government
II. Leadership System and Working Mechanism for Combating Corruption and Building a Clean Government
III. Legal Framework for Combating Corruption and Building a Clean Government
IV. Power Restraint and Supervisory System
V. Prevention of Corruption through System Reform and Institutional Innovation
VI. Handling Cases of Corruption in Accordance with Law and Discipline
VII. Education in Clean Government and Construction of the Culture of Integrity
VIII. International Exchanges and Co-operation in Combating Corruption Conclusion
It was reported that the authorities had investigated 119,000 corruption cases in the first 11 months of the year, slightly up on last year. 108,000 cases had been resolved resulting in 113,000 individuals being punished and 4,332 of them handed over to the judicial authorities for breaking the law (XHNA, 29 Dec.).
d Social Affairs
The Sixth National Population Census was held between 1 and 10 November, with more than 6 million census takers visiting over 400 million households across the country. To ensure greater accuracy a subsequent survey was conducted between 11 and 30 November on the scale of 1/10000 of the population. Key data was scheduled to be released in April 2011. At the last census the populations was 1.29533 billion. Most people surveyed were asked to fill out an 18-item questionnaire. Ten per cent were asked to fill out a more detailed 45-item questionnaire. Questions to be answered ranged from residency to employment (XHNA, 31 Oct.).
The official news agency, Xinhua, reported on 8 November that two women from Shaanxi had filed cases with the Supreme Court in Beijing seeking apologies from their local government which had publicly humiliated them after they had lodged complaints with the authorities in Beijing. The women had gone to Beijing to complain of unfair or improper behaviour by local officials. They had been escorted back to their home town and faced a public prosecution in the town square for making petitions in an illegal manner and disrupting social order, humiliated, and then detained for ten days (XHNA, 8 Nov.). On 23 November, it was reported that Zhou Yongkang, a member of the Politburo Standing Committee, had said that the way to reduce the number of petitions was through scientific and democratic policymaking. He said that government policies should not risk stability and governments should not approve projects that were opposed by the overwhelming majority. He said that officials should read petition letters, meet petitioners, and treat them as family members (XHNA, 23 Nov.).
The Politburo held its 23rd collective study session in early November on the subject of “correctly handling contradictions among the people in the new period.” General Secretary Hu Jintao presided over the session and gave a speech which emphasized the need to reduce such contradictions at source, improve the people's livelihood, and protect the people's rights and interests according to the law. He noted that the rapid urbanization and historic changes in China had led to increased “social contradictions” and “unexpected mass incidents” now and then. A number of scholars addressed the meeting. Fang Ning, of the Institute of Politics at CASS, said that the problems arose from imbalanced development which caused disparities in income, social security, social welfare and employment. It was necessary to recognize that economic development did not necessarily bring about social harmony and stability. Some of the largest incidents had occurred in areas where the economy was strong. It was important to balance the interests of all parties in dealing with these problems. Better rules and regulations were required; many incidents had taken place at grassroots levels and it was therefore important to “innovate social management as well as further reform and improve the system of self-government for grassroots masses. Implementing self-government for grassroots masses is both a process for the masses to express their appeals, demonstrate their will, and participate in public affairs, as well as a process of co-ordinating and smoothing out all interest relationships.” Professor Gao Peiyong of the Institute of Finance Trade and Economics argued that the basic problem was to handle properly the question of income distribution, especially the disadvantages experienced by migrant labourers. The income gap needed to be narrowed (RMRB website, 21 Oct.).
Xinhua reported that police near Dujiangyan in Sichuan had dispersed nearly 1,000 protestors who had gathered after a wage dispute had left one migrant worker dead and another injured. The two had been among eight construction workers who had demanded unpaid wages and had been attacked and beaten by company staff. Police promised that those responsible would be punished according to law and that the wages would be paid (XHNA, 12 Oct.). The Hong Kong Information Centre for Human Rights and Democracy claimed that several thousand protestors had been involved and that there had been up to 100 casualties. The dispute had begun with the failure of a company involved in post-earthquake reconstruction to pay its workers. The company claimed that it had not received payment from the government. When workers came to demand their wages they were set upon by company thugs (Hong Kong Information Centre for Human Rights and Democracy, 13 Oct.). Xinhua reported on 13 October that the suspects involved had all been arrested and that the local authorities had settled all unpaid wages (XHNA, 13 Oct.).
Bishop Fang Xingyao was elected Chairman of the Chinese Catholic Association and Bishop Ma Yinglin was elected head of the Bishops' Conference of the Catholic Church in China at a National Congress of Catholic Representatives. The new leaders were pointedly received at the highest level by Jia Qinglin, Chairman of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference who told them that “under no circumstances should the Chinese Catholic Church waver in adhering to the principle of independently running the church, and the Party and government will, as always, support and help the Chinese Catholic Church develop healthily” (XHNA, 9 Dec.). The Hong Kong South China Morning Post reported that Bishop Ma had been ordained by Beijing without Vatican approval. This was interpreted as a sign of worsening relations between China and the Vatican following the ordination of another Bishop (Joseph Guo Jincai, Bishop of Chengde) without Vatican approval in September (SCMP website, 10 Dec.). The Vatican reacted strongly to the Chinese announcement criticizing the Congress and China's policies on religious freedom. The Chinese Bureau of Religious Affairs denounced this criticism as “imprudent and ungrounded.” It stated that “China's system of congress of Catholic representatives does not involve issues of the Catholic doctrine and does not violate basic Catholic beliefs. There is no question of getting recognition by any foreign organization or state.” It went on to assert that
[e]veryone knows what the political stance of the Vatican is. Using religious belief to spread political philosophy is very dangerous and will do serious damage to the healthy development of the Chinese Catholic Church in China. … In recent years, China has shown the greatest sincerity in holding candid and constructive dialogue with the Vatican and seeking ways and means to achieve better ties in a bid to improve China–Vatican relations. However, there are always people within the Vatican who stepped out at critical moments to intervene by making endless unreasonable demands and obstructing the process of the improvement of ties. Their disruption of the recent Congress of Catholic Representatives in China was the latest case in point. While making contact and holding negotiations with China, the Vatican is also interfering in the internal affairs of the Chinese Catholic Church by open and secret means in an attempt to regain control of the Catholic Church in China. The Vatican is fully responsible for this regrettable state of affairs in China–Vatican relations (XHNA, 22 Dec.).
Qian Xiaoqian, Vice Director of the Information Office of the State Council, said that China's internet market would always be open to foreign enterprises. China would continue to improve its policies, regulations and laws and follow relevant WTO rules to provide a “stable, transparent and predictable” investment environment for foreign enterprises. So long as foreign enterprises complied with the law and respected Chinese traditions they would have bright prospects in China (XHNA, 8 Nov.). The Ministry of Public Security announced on 10 November that China would issue new rules on sentencing for cyber-attack crimes by the end of the year. China had become a major target for online crimes and 80 per cent of Chinese computers had suffered botnet attacks, most of which had originated abroad; similarly, more than 80 per cent of attacks on government computers had come from abroad (XHNA, 10 Nov.).
A gas leak and explosion killed 37 miners in Henan province on 16 October. The State Administration of Work Safety announced on 19 October that it was setting up a work team to investigate the disaster. A similar leak had occurred at the same mine in 2008 (XHNA, 19 Oct.). Hong Kong press reports noted that Chinese internet users had been angry at the poor performance of the Chinese government compared to the efforts made by the Chileans to rescue their miners (SCMP website, 19 Oct.). The Chinese government announced that it would be further consolidating the coal industry in the forthcoming Five-Year Programme period. It wanted to create 20 large coal mining groups with an annual capacity of 10–40 million tonnes by 2015. It also wanted to see more companies with an annual output of 50 million tonnes, the output of which should account for over half the national output. Outdated smaller mines should be eliminated, and the plan was to close 1,539 such mines in 2010 (XHNA, 21 Oct.).
e Economic affairs
The National Bureau of Statistics announced on 21 October that economic growth had continued to decelerate in the third quarter. GDP grew by 9.6 per cent (compared to 11.9 per cent in the first quarter and 10.3 per cent in the second). A spokesman for the Bureau said: “The economic performance is generally sound. … In the face of complicated and fast-changing domestic and international situations and challenges, China implemented the stimulus package and sped up economic restructuring. The economic turnaround has been further consolidated and is moving in the anticipated direction.” He said the government would keep its macro-economic policy “consistent and stable,” and make it more “targeted and flexible.” He said that the increase in interest rates announced on 19 October would help absorb liquidity and promote economic restructuring. Rising international commodity prices and the loose monetary policies of a number of countries were posing challenges for China in controlling inflation, and domestically runaway property prices and the rise in food prices because of natural disasters were also a problem. China had already taken measures to restrict house prices and control mortgage lending (XHNA, 21 Oct.).
The Ministry of Human Resources and Social Security announced on 22 October that the urban unemployment rate was 4.1 per cent at the end of September. A total of 9.31 million jobs had been created by the end of the third quarter, beating the annual target of 9 million for 2010. The employment situation in China was described as “stable” (XHNA, 22 Oct.).
The National Bureau of Statistics announced on 11 November that food prices, which account for one-third of weight in calculating the CPI in China, climbed 10.1 per cent in October, pushing the CPI to reach a 25-month high of 4.4 per cent in October (XHNA, 11 Nov.). On 17 November, the State Council announced new price control guidelines to help reassure consumers facing inflation. It ordered the government to continue to reduce prices of power, gas and rail transport for chemical fertilizer producers, ensure coal supplies for power generation companies and increase production of oil, especially diesel oil, to guarantee a sufficient supply. The authorities should adjust prices promptly and moderately, keep natural gas prices stable and impose temporary price controls on important daily necessities and production materials when necessary (XHNA, 17 Nov.). On 29 November the State Council announced further measures to increase penalties for price manipulation, collusion, malicious hoarding and the spreading of false information (XHNA, 29 Nov.).
The Politburo met to discuss the economy on 3 December. It decided that monetary policy would be shifted from “relatively loose” to prudent in the coming year. The economic development pattern should be the main focus of next year's work, and macro-regulation should be “more targeted, flexible and effective,” but China would continue its proactive fiscal policy. The meeting noted that the momentum of economic and social growth had been consolidated, providing a sound basis for stable and fast growth in 2011 (XHNA, 3 Dec.). The following week, the annual Central Economic Work Conference was held from 10 to 12 December. In a statement issued on 12 December it said that next year's macro-regulation should basically be proactive, stable, prudent and flexible. The focus would be on better handling the relationship between stable and relatively fast economic development, economic restructuring and inflation expectations. Economic development would become more co-ordinated, sustainable and reliant on the domestic economy. Growth slowed to 9.6 per cent in the third quarter and inflation continued to rise, reaching a level of 5.1 per cent in November. Agricultural development would be a priority. It noted that world growth was likely to resume in 2011, though uncertainties would remain. For China these included: the grain harvest and farmers' income; increased pressure to adjust the economic structure; resource and environment bottlenecks; the challenging task of improving people's livelihood and guaranteeing social stability (XHNA, 12 Dec.).
The annual central rural work conference was held from 21 to 22 December to discuss agricultural policy for the coming year. The agenda included frequent price fluctuations for farm produce, and setting the foundations for steady increases in grain output and rural incomes. The conference noted that
[n]ext year, agricultural and rural development will be facing many new difficulties and problems; grain production and farmers' income have to continue rising on the high baseline of yield and income increases over seven consecutive years; agricultural product supply and market prices have to remain stable amid highly uncertain variables caused by the interplay of multiple influencing factors; and agricultural and rural development have to extend the positive momentum in the context of greater demands from the overall state of economic and social development. The number of difficulties, the weight of the pressures, and the size of the challenges facing us have never been seen all these years (XHNA, 22 Dec.).
The People's Bank of China announced on 19 October that it was raising the one-year lending and deposit rate by 0.25 per cent with the deposit rate rising to 2.50 per cent and the lending rate to 5.56 per cent. This was the first such rise in three years and was interpreted as a response to growing concerns over inflation. The rise in the Consumer Price Index was 3.5 per cent in August, the highest for 22 months (XHNA, 20 Oct.). The People's Bank of China announced on 13 October that there had been a large increase in new lending and in foreign exchange reserves in September, leading to fears of rising inflationary pressures. New yuan-denominated lending rose by 9.2 per cent to 595.5 billion yuan. On 12 September the Central Bank temporarily raised the reserve requirement ratio for China's major banks by 50 basis points to 17.5 per cent. Foreign exchange reserves were up 16.5 per cent year on year in September and totalled US$2.648 trillion (XHNA, 13 Oct.). On 19 November, it raised the reserve requirement ratio to 18 per cent, the sixth such rise in the year, in order to enhance liquidity management and moderately regulate the money supply. This was against a background of a rise in inflation in October to 4.4 per cent (XHNA, 19 Nov.). A further rise in the reserve requirement ration to 18.5 per cent was announced on 10 December (XHNA, 10 Dec.). The People's Bank of China announced on 2 November that it would continue its moderately loose monetary policy but make it better targeted and more flexible in the coming months. It intended gradually to normalize its monetary policy, and to implement market oriented reform of interests and keep the yuan basically stable (XHNA, 2 Nov.).
f Shanghai EXPO and Asian Games
Wu Bangguo, Chairman of the NPCSC, spoke at the opening ceremony for China Pavilion Day at the World Expo on 1 October. He noted that over 60 million visitors, Chinese and foreign, had come to the Expo, including over 100 foreign heads of state. He said that
the China pavilion, “the Crown of the Orient” stands tall in the Shanghai World Expo Park, dazzling and mighty. Using “Chinese Wisdom in Urban Development” as its main theme, it showcases in a lively way the practice the Chinese people engage in creating a wonderful life and it also allows people to understand the concept of harmony that Chinese culture passes down from generation to generation and to imagine the wonderful future of China's development (XHNA, 1 Oct.).
Premier Wen Jiabao attended the closing ceremony for the World Expo in Shanghai on 31 October and declared the Expo closed. The Expo had attracted 246 participating countries and 73 million visitors. In a speech to the Expo 2010 Forum Premier Wen said that: “The Expo has put on display the splendid achievements of contemporary civilizations, pooled human wisdom in exploring the path of urban development, set many Expo-related records, and added a glorious chapter to the Expo history. Expo 2010 Shanghai has been a successful event, a splendid event, and an unforgettable event.” He added that: “The success of the Expo has strengthened China's confidence and resolve to pursue reform and opening-up. China will unswervingly follow the path of peaceful developments and of opening and inclusiveness of all civilizations, learn from the outstanding achievements of other countries, deepen mutually beneficial co-operation with other countries, and make greater contribution to the progress of human civilization.” Speeches were also given by the UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon and by the Secretary General of the Bureau of International Expositions, Vincente Gonzales Loscertales. Foreign dignitaries included Nepali President Ram Baran Yadav, Sri Lankan President Mahinda Rajapakse, Prime Minister Hubert Ingraham of the Bahamas, Finnish Prime Minister Mari Kiviniemi, Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban, Lesotho Prime Minister Pakalitha Mosisili, and East Timor Prime Minister Xanana Gusmao (XHNA, 31 Oct.).
The Politburo held its 24th collective study session on 3 December on the subject of the Expo. General Secretary Hu Jintao said that: “The Shanghai World Expo has left behind for us rich and abundant material achievements and valuable spiritual health. We must seriously sum up the experience and carry forward the spirit of the Shanghai World Expo in close connection with the implementation of the Fifth Plenum of the 17th CPC Central Committee and strive to translate the achievements of the Shanghai World Expo into new advantages for pushing forward scientific development and promoting social harmony” (XHNA, 4 Dec.).
The Asian Games were the last major set piece event of the year for China, and every precaution was taken to ensure that they ran smoothly. President Hu lit the torch for the Asian Games torch relay at the Temple of Heaven on 12 October. The Games were held in Guangzhou from 12 to 27 November. Premier Wen Jiabao attended the opening ceremony and declared the games open (XHNA, 12 Nov.). The Games closed on 27 November and a People's Daily commentary described them as having “opened a brilliant new chapter of progress in Asian sports and the development of the city of Guangzhou. The 16th Asian Games have brought new driving force to strengthen the unity among people from all countries and regions in Asia and have erected a new monument that displays China's national image characterized by civilization, opening up, harmony and progress” (People's Daily website, 28 Nov.).
g Human Rights
The imprisoned Chinese dissident Liu Xiaobo was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize on 8 October. He is serving an 11-year prison sentence in China for allegedly “inciting subversion of state power.” He was a key author of “Charter 08” which had called for democratic reform in China, and had been detained in December 2008 and sentenced on 25 December 2009. The award was made in the face of considerable pressure from the Chinese government to dissuade the Committee from making it. Following the announcement of the award, the Chinese government and press denounced the decision in vitriolic terms, describing the decision as a desecration of the prize (XHNA, 8 Oct.), and started a campaign to persuade governments to boycott the ceremony. It also took a number of retaliatory measures against Norway, including cancelling an important fisheries meeting (SCMP website, 12 Oct.). The official government spokesman, Ma Zhaoxu, said that the Committee had shown no respect for the judicial system in China, and that politicians were using it as a way to attack China. He defended China's human rights record, and said that China's remarkable achievements had been widely recognized by the international community (XHNA, 12 Oct.). A number of governments issued statements following the award calling on the Chinese government to release Liu, and supporting the decision of the committee in supporting those who are campaigning peacefully for the protection and promotion of human rights. The Chinese official spokesman said that foreign governments and political figures that had supported the prize going to Liu had no right to interfere in China's internal affairs, and wondered whether they had done so because they resented China's development and hated its political system (XHNA, 14 Oct.). The Chinese continued to publish numerous articles condemning the decision, and local activists were put under tight surveillance to stop them attending the ceremony (SCMP website, 30 Oct.). Agence France Presse reported that Vice Foreign Minister Fu Ying had said that Liu's fate was not a topic for discussion between President Hu and President Sarkozy during Hu's visit to France (AFP 4 November). China also attempted to persuade countries not to attend the ceremony or send representatives. On 5 November, Vice Foreign Minister Cui Tiankai had warned that countries which supported Liu would face consequences (AFP, 9 Nov.). The Foreign Ministry spokeswoman acknowledged on 2 December that relations with Norway had been affected. She said: “I think it is difficult to maintain China–Norway relations as well as they were in the past, because the Nobel Committee conferred the Nobel Peace Prize on a convicted Chinese criminal, and the Norwegian government publicly expressed its support for such a decision” (XHNA, 2 Dec.). The award ceremony was held on 10 December with an empty seat for Liu, and the Chinese spokeswoman commented that “this political farce will not shake the determination and confidence of the Chinese people to take the path of socialism with Chinese characteristics in the slightest. The attempts of some individuals will not succeed” (XHNA, 10 Dec.). A number of countries did respond to China's attempts to organize a boycott, but others ignored the pressure. According to Xinhua of the 65 countries represented in Oslo, 19 had “flatly refused” to attend the ceremonies.
The third Beijing Forum on Human Rights opened in Beijing on 12 October. Wang Chen, Director of the State Council Information Office, addressed the opening ceremony and told them that China had promised to enhance international co-operation in human rights and to make due contributions to world human rights causes. He spoke of the achievements China had made over the past 30 years during which, he said, the Chinese government had regarded respect for and the safeguarding of human rights as an important principle of governance. China had stuck to its own path of political development, pushing forward political restructuring while adhering to the rule of law and effectively safeguarding citizens' rights. The theme of the forum was “Human Rights and Development: Rethinking Concepts, Models and Approaches” (XHNA, 19 Oct.).
There was considerable publicity and discussion of an incident in which the son of a deputy chief of a local public security bureau branch was involved in a fatal hit and run accident on the campus of Hebei University on 16 October. According to the official, rather toned down, report of the incident, he was said to have shouted “Sue me if you dare. My father is Li Gang” to bystanders who tried to stop him escaping. The incident provoked enormous discussion on the internet and the authorities moved quickly to arrest the culprit, Li Qiming, on 24 October (XHNA, 25 October). Once the authorities had taken action concerted attempts were made to ensure that the incident was not further discussed in the Chinese media.
China announced that the Supreme Court had overturned 10 per cent of death sentences on review since 2007, claiming that the process played an obvious role in reducing the number of executions. An official of the Court said that “[w]e must make sure the use of the death sentence is accurate and free of mistakes to respect and protect the convicts and their rights.” It admitted that there were still problems including the use of torture as well as poor standards among some rural judges. Another official said that “the Supreme People's Court should go beyond only examining evidence, and establish rules to better define serious crimes where the death penalty is applicable to ensure its appropriate use” (XHNA, 26 Nov.).
A report in December highlighted abuses of the mentally ill. In Sichuan it was reported that the owner of a shelter for the mentally ill had been selling his charges to a factory in Xinjiang province, where they were forced to work without pay. The report stated that a rescue team had been sent to free the workers, and the factory had been shut down. The owner of the factory had fled but was later apprehended. Reports from Xinjiang announced that a number of local officials had been punished for failing to take action against the factory (XHNA, 14 Dec.).
China and Australia held their 13th dialogue on human rights in Beijing on 20 December. The leaders of the delegations were Vice Foreign Minister Cui Tiankai and Heather Smith, Deputy Secretary of the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (XHNA, 20 Dec.).
h Xinjiang and Tibet
The Hong Kong Information Centre for Human Rights and Democracy reported that the highly respected “Great Mullah” Mahmut had died on 15 December. The authorities had reportedly been concerned at the size of the 5,000-strong crowd that gathered for his funeral in Urumqi (Hong Kong Information Centre for Human Rights and Democracy 20 Dec.). The new Party Secretary of Xinjiang, Zhang Chunxian, told a meeting in Xinjiang in December that “we should be aware that the stability of Xinjiang remains fragile. There are still many factors from home and abroad that may affect stability, and the task of maintaining stability remains tough” (XHNA, 24 Dec.).
The State Administration for Religious Affairs issued new regulations on the administration of Tibetan Buddhist temples on 9 October to come into effect on 1 November. They stipulated that overseas individuals and organizations should not interfere in temple affairs or as a cover to disrupt social order. An accompanying circular said that the internal management of temples had fallen into chaos in recent years, that some temples had over-expanded, and that a number of temple staff had fallen under the influence of overseas separatists and were engaged in activities that could sabotage ethnic solidarity (XHNA, 9 Oct.).
The South China Morning Post reported that several thousand Tibetan students had protested in Rekhong County, Qinghai, against a new education policy which stipulated that all classes should be taught in Chinese except for Tibetan language and English (SCMP website, 21 Oct.). The demonstrations were reported to have spread to other Tibetan areas of Qinghai, and there had been sympathy protests by some Tibetan students at the Nationalities University in Beijing (SCMP website, 23 Oct.). Xinhua confirmed on 22 October that there had been some dissatisfaction among local Tibetans concerning the provincial bilingual education reform plan. The Director of the provincial education department was quoted as saying that the plan was intended to strengthen both the use of Putonghua and of native languages, and was not aiming to use one language to weaken the other. He said that spending on education in the minorities' mother tongues would be increased (XHNA, 22 Oct.).
The Dalai Lama visited Japan in November to attend the World Summit of Nobel Peace Laureates in Hiroshima. During his visit he issued a statement urging China to free Liu Xiaobo and other prisoners of conscience (Kyodo News Service 15 Nov.). On 14 December the Dalai Lama was reported to have said that he would shortly take permanent retirement as temporal leader of the Tibetans and delegate his responsibilities to elected representatives at the next parliament. He said that he would continue to serve the Tibetan cause even if he was reduced to just sitting in a wheelchair: “Ninety-nine per cent of the people in Tibet and elsewhere trust me. I have the moral responsibility to serve them. … It is the responsibility of every Tibetan to carry forward our struggle” (The Telegraph website, Kolkata India, 14 Dec.).
i Hong Kong and Macau Special Administrative Regions
Donald Tsang, the Chief Executive, delivered his annual policy address on 13 October entitled “Sharing Prosperity for a Caring Society” (text in Hong Kong government website, 13 October). He said that now that the financial crisis was over, it was important to focus on the structural problems of social development, such as housing, relative poverty and ageing. He said that housing was the current greatest concern for Hong Kong people and he announced that the government would be increasing the land supply to help ease demand. In the press conference following the address, he was asked about Article 23 legislation and responded:
I have said that although it is very much a constitutional duty of this administration, this has never been one of my undertakings in my manifesto for election in 2007, nor was it included in my first Policy Address of this term in 2007. What's more, I've been watching public sentiment very carefully throughout these years. I have not detected there is a major change in their concern about the problems that may arise during the enactment process. In other words, in the remaining time of my term I would much better devote my energies to resolving livelihood issues, social issues and the rest of the constitutional matters, which are quite a lot, which need to be tackled (Hong Kong Government website, 13 October).
Donald Tsang visited Beijing from 20 to 23 December to brief state leaders on economic, social and political developments in Hong Kong in the past year. He and Chui Sai On, the Chief Executive of the Macau SAR, were received by President Hu Jintao on 22 December. Hu said that the situation in Hong Kong had improved in 2010, and the development of the political system had taken a step forward in line with the Basic Law. He said that the central government applauded the efforts made by the SAR. Vice President Xi Jinping was present at the meeting (XHNA, 22 Dec.). The following day they met Premier Wen Jiabao who told them that the central government would work to promote co-operation and exchange between the mainland, Hong Kong and Macau, and would support the Hong Kong government in ruling in accordance with the Basic Law. He advised the Hong Kong government to strictly follow the changes in the international economy and carefully handle the impact of the global financial crisis, so as to maintain a stable financial business environment while taking part in international competition. It should also work to improve people's livelihood and settle economic and social development problems (XHNA, 23 Dec.).
Wang Guangya, Director of the Hong Kong and Macau Affairs Office, was reported to have warned against interference from Hong Kong after three Hong Kong National People's Congress deputies had written to the Supreme People's Court requesting the release of Zhao Lianhai. He said that “others should not interfere … under ‘one country, two systems,’ well water should not intrude into river water” (SCMP website, 30 Dec.).
Premier Wen Jiabao paid his first visit to Macau on 13 and 14 November during which he attended the Third Ministerial Conference of the Forum for Economic and Trade Co-operation between China and Portuguese-Speaking Countries. He met the Chief Executive of Macau, Chui Sai On, on 13 November. He said that the situation in Macau was exciting with stable economic and social development. The central government would continue to implement “one country, two systems” with Macau enjoying a high degree of autonomy while benefitting from full support. He said regional co-operation between Guangdong, Hong Kong and Macau would be an important element of the next Five-Year Programme, and he expected Macau to grasp its opportunities and achieve diverse economic development (XHNA, 13 Nov.). The following day he said that the SAR should work to develop modern service industries, including tourism, exhibition, finance and cultural creativity, ensure the orderly development of the gaming industry, and strive to build up Macau as a world tourism and leisure centre. He also asked Macau to make full use of favourable policies provided by the central government, strengthen co-operation with the Mainland, especially with Guangdong Province, foster new competitive industries and economic growth points, and fortify its risk-resisting ability (XHNA, 14 Nov.).
Macau's Chief Executive, Chui Sai On, delivered his annual policy address on 16 November. A series of new measures were introduced in various sectors including the diversification of Macau's economy, social welfare, transparency of government, and regional co-operation. It was announced that casinos would not be allowed on newly reclaimed land which would be used for housing and industry (XHNA, 16 Nov.).
2 Foreign Relations
a Multilateral Conferences
ASEM/EU–CHINA
Premier Wen Jiabao attended the Asia–Europe Meeting (ASEM) Summit in Brussels on 4 October. He presented the opening meeting with a five-point plan for advancing co-operation between Europe and Asia from a strategic and long term perspective (full text of his speech in XHNA, 5 Oct.). He said that they should: a) jointly push forward global economic growth, intensify macroeconomic policy co-ordination, cautiously manage the timing and pace of an exit strategy from economic stimulus, and keep the exchange rates of major reserve currencies relatively stable; b) jointly push forward reform of the international economic and financial system, improve decision making in international financial institutions and give a greater say to developing countries; c) address global challenges together, in particular that of climate change on the principle of “common but differentiated responsibilities”; d) work to facilitate exchanges of mutual learning among civilizations; and e) uphold peace and stability in Asia and Europe. He also made some concrete proposals:
First, establish an Asia–Europe Centre for the Research and Utilization of Water Resources, to promote the sustainable development of Asian and European countries by jointly increasing their capability to manage water resources through science and technology co-operation. Second, hold the Second Asia–Europe Meeting of Transportation Ministers to deepen Asia–Europe transportation co-operation and facilitate personnel and cargo exchanges. Third, hold a high-level Asia–Europe symposium on sustainable management of forests to deal with climate change and promote pragmatic Asia–Europe co-operation in forestry. Fourth, hold an Asia–Europe symposium of vocational and technical education to strengthen exchanges and co-operation between Asia and Europe in improving the quality of labourers (XHNA, 5 Oct).
In the sidelines he met President Sarkozy of France and told him that China expected France to take new steps towards pushing the European Union for more positive policies on China (XHNA, 4 Oct.). He also had side meetings with the Japanese Prime Minister, the President of South Korea, the European Troika, the President of the European Central Bank, the EU Commissioner for Economic and Monetary Affairs and the German Chancellor (XHNA, 6 Oct.). He urged the EU to treat the RMB exchange rate issue in an objective and fair way that would benefit the EU. He said China would further reform the yuan exchange rate mechanism to increase the country's flexibility and would increase its imports from the EU (XHNA, 6 Oct.).
Premier Wen addressed the EU-China Summit on 6 October and called on the EU to recognize China's market economy status and to lift the arms embargo. He suggested that the summit should enhance its role in providing strategic guidance and clear the way for the further advancement of China–EU ties. He hoped that the Europeans would “take an objective and fair stance on China's currency exchange rate.” He said that China had confidence in the EU and believed that a strong and stable EU was good for the world as well as China. He hoped that the EU would respect China's major concerns and core interests and formulate more positive and visionary policies towards China (XHNA, 6 Oct.). Following the meeting the two sides issued a joint communiqué.
Premier Wen then attended the China–EU Business Summit and addressed the meeting (text in XHNA, 6 Oct.). He said that the trade issue should not be politicized. China pursued balanced and sustainable trade, and any substantial revaluation of the yuan, as the US was demanding, would hurt the world economy because of the damage it would do to China, which had contributed about half of global growth last year. He urged European businessmen not to pressure China on the issue and said that there would gradually be more flexibility in the exchange rate. He said that foreign businesses operating in China would enjoy the same national treatment as Chinese enterprises on issues of intellectual property, independent innovation and government procurement (XHNA, 7 Oct.). He also attended the China–EU Cultural Forum.
ASEAN/EAS
Premier Wen led a substantial delegation to the ASEAN-related meetings in Hanoi from 28 to 30 October. These were the 13th Summit between China and ASEAN, the 13th Summit between China and ASEAN + 3 and the fifth East Asia Summit. In advance of the meeting Assistant Foreign Minister Hu Zhengyue said that “China attaches importance to and actively takes part in East Asian co-operation. In the series of meetings, China will review with other countries the co-operation that has been carried out and discuss how to further promote the integration process of East Asian co-operation.” The China–ASEAN Free Trade Area launched on 1 January 2010 and bilateral trade increased by 44 per cent in the first nine months of the year to reach US$211.3 billion (XHNA, 21 Oct.).
Premier Wen had a number of side meetings during his stay in Hanoi. He met the Vietnamese Prime Minister Nguyen Tan Dung, the Cambodian Prime Minister, Hun Sen, and the Lao Prime Minister, Bouasone Bouphavanah on 28 October for separate meetings to discuss bilateral and other issues. With the Vietnamese Prime Minister, Wen said that the South China Sea should be handled in a proper fashion, as it was of vital importance in the sound and stable development of their bilateral relations (XHNA, 28 Oct.). He met the Singapore Prime Minister, Lee Hsien Loong, on 29 October. He also had meetings with the Prime Ministers of India and of Australia (XHNA, 30 Oct.). There was brief informal meeting with the Japanese Prime Minister, somewhat overshadowed by continuing difficulties in the relationship over the East China Sea.
Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi had a meeting with his Japanese counterpart Seiji Maehara on 29 October, their first meeting since the East China Sea incident (XHNA, 29 Oct.). Japanese press reports contained quite detailed accounts of their wide-ranging discussions suggesting that relations were on the mend. However, the Chinese reacted strongly to what had been reported.
Premier Wen addressed the 13th China–ASEAN leaders meeting on 29 October (text in XHNA, 29 Oct.). He noted how mutual trust had increased and co-operation had deepened. The two sides had helped safeguard regional peace and stability. He said that China treasured its traditional friendship with ASEAN countries and suggested six ways of further improving relations: a) promote trade relations and strive to reach a target of US$500 billion in bilateral trade by 2015, for which China was willing to establish one economic and trade co-operation area in each ASEAN country over the next five years; b) use Chinese loans and the “China–ASEAN Investment Co-operation Fund” to improve links and communications; c) push for openness and the merging of financial and capital markets in an orderly manner; d) improve agricultural co-operation, for which China was willing to help with training and the provision of experts; e) increase investment in sustainable development, and jointly deal with climate change, natural disasters and other challenges; f) improve understanding and increase cultural, educational and youth exchanges, and designate 2011 as China-ASEAN Year of Friendly Exchange. The meeting adopted and issued a joint declaration on implementing the Second Five-Year Action Plan for China–ASEAN strategic partnership for peace and prosperity, and a Joint Statement between Chinese and ASEAN Leaders on Sustainable Development (XHNA, 29 Oct.).
Premier Wen put forward a four-point proposal at the ASEAN + 3 meeting which he described as the main vehicle for East Asian co-operation. He said that stronger ASEAN + 3 co-operation was essential to the revitalization of East Asia. His proposals were: a) to accelerate the establishment of an East Asia Free-Trade Area. China had already put forward a roadmap for ASEAN + 3 trade facilitation over the next five years, and would be consulting other parties on specific measures to advance trade and investment liberalization. He announced a contribution of a further US$1 million to the ASEAN + 3 Co-operation Fund; b) to deepen financial co-operation, and make the Chiang Mai Initiative more effective. They should continue to build the Asian Bond Market and look at ways to encourage cross-border bond transaction and settlement in the region; c) to promote co-operation in other fields including food security, agriculture, infrastructure construction, as well as education. China would help build the Emergency Rice Reserve and donate US$1 million to it on top of the 300,000 tons of rice already pledged. China would like to support a Master Plan on ASEAN connectivity of transport links. China supported the establishment of an ASEAN + 3 education ministers' meeting; d) to improve co-ordination on major international issues such as climate change (XHNA, 29 October).
Yang Jiechi had a meeting with US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton on 30 October. One of the main items of discussion was the Diaoyu/Senkaku question, as the meeting followed an earlier confirmation by the US Secretary of State that the question did fall within the purview of the US Japan security alliance. Yang reiterated China's position, and urged the US to act cautiously on the issue and not to make irresponsible remarks. He noted more widely that, with joint efforts, relations between China and the US had managed to keep a stable momentum (XHNA, 30 October). China later strongly rejected as “wishful thinking” the idea that had apparently been floated at the meeting that the US might host three-way talks on security issues between China, Japan and the US (XHNA, 1 Nov.).
Premier Wen told the East Asia Summit participants that China was ready to work together with other parties to deepen East Asian co-operation on the basis of upholding the established principles and purposes of the East Asia Summit. He said that the leading role of ASEAN should be respected and that existing mechanisms also had a role to play. Wen said the summit had stuck to the orientation of the strategic forum “led by leaders” and launched fruitful dialogue and co-operation in five key fields, namely finance, energy, education, bird flu control and disaster rescue. He welcomed the participation of Russia and the US and hoped they would play a constructive role (XHNA, 30 Oct.).
Leaders of China, Japan and South Korea also met together on 29 October. Premier Wen noted that co-operation between the three countries had been developing soundly and was an important part of East Asian co-operation. He proposed that they push for completion of the study plan for a China–Japan–ROK Free-Trade Area by 2012 and that they reach a tripartite investment agreement soon. He suggested that they increase co-operation in S&T innovation in key sectors such as energy conservation, environment protection, new energy resources and renewable energy (XHNA, 29 Oct.).
APEC
President Hu attended the APEC Summit held in Yokohama on 12 and 13 November, where he delivered a keynote speech (full text in XHNA, 13 Nov.). Hu said that China was firmly committed to the path of peaceful development, and strove for common development of all nations while pursuing its own development. China would continue to pursue open economy and common and sustainable development as well as balanced growth of domestic and external demand. It would continue to bring in talent and investment from overseas, and build an open and transparent legal environment. China would work with the rest of the international community to counter climate challenges under the principles of common but differentiated responsibilities (XHNA, 13 Nov.).
In the summit margins, he met the Japanese Prime Minister, the Hong Kong Chief Executive, Donald Tsang, and Lien Chan, the Taiwanese representative (XHNA, 13 Nov.). With Lien Chan, honorary Chairman of the Kuomintang, Hu noted that relations across the Taiwan Strait had maintained a sound momentum, and the Economic Co-operation Framework Agreement had been an important achievement. Both sides needed to value these achievements and push forward a stable and continued development of relations. He said that China would strive to tackle the relatively easy problems first and proceed with economic co-operation before taking on the thornier issues of political exchanges. The new turn in the relationship was because both sides had built trust and developed a positive interaction in opposing Taiwan independence and upholding the 1992 Consensus (XHNA, 13 Nov.).
G20
The Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman said on 21 October that China hoped that the forthcoming G20 Summit would promote global economic growth in a robust, sustainable and balanced manner (XHNA, 21 Oct.). President Hu Jintao arrived in Seoul on 11 November for the G20 meeting. He had separate bilateral meetings with President Obama of the United States, President Dmitri Medvedev of the Russian Federation, and President Lee Myung Bak of South Korea on 11 November. At the Summit itself, Hu put forward a four point proposal for realizing strong, sustainable and balanced growth (text of his speech in XHNA, 12 Nov.). They were:
First, the world community should improve the framework for strong, sustainable and balanced growth and promote co-operative development.
Second, the world community should champion open trade and promote co-ordinated development.
Third, the world community should reform the financial system and promote stable development.
Fourth, the world community should narrow the development gap and promote balanced development (XHNA, 12 Nov.).
The summit closed with the issue of a joint communiqué. According to Xinhua, it showed obvious compromises on contentious issues. The summit had been held at a time of tension among G20 countries over issues including trade imbalances and currency policies, and matters had been made worse by the US quantitative easing which had “caused uproar” among some G20 members, including China (XHNA, 12 Nov.).
Climate Change
China hosted talks under the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCC) in Tianjin from 2 to 9 October in a final round of preparation for the UN Climate Change Conference in Cancun (XHNA, 4 Oct.). State Councillor Dai Bingguo addressed the opening session and pledged that China would continue to play an active and constructive part in climate talks. He said that the negotiations should stick to the basic framework of the UNFCCC and Kyoto Protocol and the mandate of the Bali Roadmap and follow the principle of “common but differentiated responsibilities.” He added that developed countries should set targets to take the lead in reducing greenhouse gas emissions and arrangements should be made to provide adequate financial and technological support to developing countries. He noted that China's energy demand would see further reasonable growth, and that therefore China would face significant constraints in controlling emissions. It would nevertheless stick to the targets it had announced in 2009 (XHNA, 4 Oct.). China's Chief Negotiator, Su Wei, complained that developed countries were being “laggards in terms of countering the challenge of climate change. That's a major reason why no breakthrough has been achieved in climate negotiations.” He said they should take on their due responsibilities, having been responsible for over 80 per cent of emissions over the past 200 years (XHNA, 5 Oct.). The session closed on 9 October and the Chinese press quoted Christiana Figueres, the Executive Secretary of the UNFCCC, as saying that it had produced some concrete results and that the text of the draft decision negotiated at Tianjin would be submitted to the Cancun conference in November. The Chinese chief negotiator was also quoted as saying that the outcome had exceeded their original expectations (XHNA, 9 Oct.).
Premier Wen Jiabao addressed a meeting of the National Leading Group on Climate Change on 19 November. The meeting heard that
China, as a responsible big country, advocates jointly responding to the challenge of climate change through realistic, effective international co-operation. Our country will adhere to the basic framework of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change and its Kyoto Protocol and to the principle of “common but differentiated responsibilities,” and advocates strictly following the mandate of the Bali Roadmap and drawing guidance from the political consensus reached under the Copenhagen Accord to further strengthen the full, effective, and sustained implementation of the Convention and the Protocol. Our country will proceed from its national conditions and realities to take on international obligations commensurate with its development phase, due responsibility, and actual capability and play a constructive role as it always does, to push the Cancun meeting to achieve positive results along with various other parties.
The meeting also reported that
[w]e are currently drawing up an outline of the 12th Five-Year Programme for National Economic and Social Development and will list reductions in energy consumption and carbon dioxide emissions per unit of GDP as binding targets. Our country will continue adhering to the basic state policy of economizing on resources and protecting the environment; establishing a concept of green, low-carbon development; accelerating the change of the economic development pattern; and intensifying the work of addressing climate change. We will actively explore a low-carbon development path with Chinese characteristics and effectively control greenhouse gas emissions to make positive contributions to advancing sustainable development in the world (XHNA, 19 Nov.).
In pre-reporting of the Cancun meeting, the chief Chinese negotiator, Su Wei, said that China hoped for balanced progress, especially on the four core issues of mitigation, adaptation, financial support and technology transfer. He said that China would play an active constructive role at the conference (XHNA, 29 Nov.). China told the conference that it had reduced its pollutant emissions from 2006 levels by 10 per cent, and reduced energy consumption per 10,000 yuan of GDP by 20 per cent (XHNA, 1 Dec.). In an interview with Xinhua on 4 Dec, Su Wei said that China would not compromise on issues of principle such as the continuation of the Kyoto Protocol, although he said China could compromise on other issues. He attacked those countries (Japan) that appeared opposed to the Kyoto Protocol. He said that there had been some progress in the first week on adaptation, finance, technology and mitigation for developing countries, but it was hard to say if final results could be achieved (XHNA, 4 Dec.). Xinhua commentary on 6 December stressed that China remained hopeful of achieving substantial results and had shown the “image of a responsible country” (XHNA, 6 Dec.). China supported the two draft documents presented to the conference although it felt that they still had some shortcomings. The leader of the Chinese delegation, Xie Zhenhua, said that
[a]s a member of the Group 77 and China, China has participated in the negotiations comprehensively, actively and flexibly. The drafts have shown all parties' opinions evenly. We are satisfied with the drafts though they have shortcomings… We have not finished our negotiations and are still faced with difficult tasks in the future. The Chinese government will continue to stick to green, low-carbon and sustainable development with a high sense of responsibility to the Chinese people and the world.
The Chinese delegation said that the conference had sent positive signals to the international community, and had managed to reach a deal to fight global warming (overcoming last minute objections from Bolivia). The delegation expected all parties to display strong political will and conclude the negotiation on the second commitment period of the Kyoto Protocol at the next conference, to be held in Durban, South Africa. In particular, that conference should establish effective mechanisms for finance, technology transfer and adaptation to support developing countries' efforts in addressing climate change, successfully conclude the negotiation in accordance with the mandate of the Bali Roadmap and take a big step forward in international co-operation in combating climate change (XHNA, 11 Dec.)
b Diplomatic Tours
President Hu Jintao
President Hu Jintao paid a state visit to France and Portugal from 4 to 7 November. He arrived in France on 4 November and had talks with President Sarkozy. Hu noted the strategic and global nature of the relationship and promised to deepen the comprehensive strategic partnership that they had. Bilateral trade was expected to reach US$40 billion this year (after falling back from a high point of US$38 billion in 2008) and the two countries had carried out extensive exchanges and co-operation in education, science and technology, and culture, and kept close communication and co-ordination on major international issues. President Sarkozy said France was glad to see China's achievements in reform and opening up, which was an unprecedented process in world history. President Hu put forward a four-point proposal for improving ties, including developing mutual respect for each other's core interests and major concerns. He called for a doubling of trade by 2015, further co-operation in nuclear energy and aviation, and tapping potential in energy efficiency and environmental protection, new energy resources, new materials, electric cars, information and telecommunications, high-end product manufacturing and finance. Both Presidents spoke of co-operating further in the G20. After the meeting they issued a joint statement (text in XHNA, 5 Nov.) and attended the signing ceremony for a number of co-operation documents covering a wide range of areas, including nuclear energy, aviation, finance, energy efficiency, environmental protection, climate change and culture. China is expected to buy a large number of aircraft including A320s, A330s and A350s. A multibillion-dollar agreement was also signed with Areva on the long-term supply of uranium (XHNA, 4 Nov.). Hu also met the Senate leader, Gerard Larcher, and the speaker of the National Assembly, Bernar Accoyer. After his meetings in Paris he visited Nice and had further talks with President Sarkozy there. He left France on 6 November. The Chinese press said that his visit had opened a new chapter in the comprehensive strategic partnership with France. The total value of trade agreements signed could reach €20 billion (XHNA, 7 Nov.).
President Hu arrived in Portugal on 6 November and had talks with President Anibal Cavaco Silva in which they agreed to deepen the comprehensive strategic partnership between them. President Hu said that they had no conflict of fundamental interests and their peoples cherished friendly feelings towards each other. President Silva said that the successful settlement of the Macau issue had created a favourable environment for Macau's development. Hu called for greater political trust to be built up, and suggested that trade should be doubled by 2015. President Silva said that the comprehensive strategic partnership established in 2005 had been a milestone in relations. Trust was deepening and trade developing smoothly. President Hu later had meetings with Jaime Gama, President of the Portuguese Assembly, and with the Prime Minister Jose Socrates. China and Portugal signed bilateral co-operation agreements on trade and economy, telecommunications, electric power and culture, and issued a joint statement (XHNA, 7 Nov.).
Premier Wen Jiabao
Premier Wen Jiabao paid an official visit to Greece, Belgium Italy and Turkey from 2 to 9 October. He visited Greece from 2 to 4 October and had talks with the Prime Minister George Papandreou, President Karolos Papoulias and the Speaker Philippos Petsalnikos. Combined trade stood at US$40 billion in 2009. In a speech to the Greek Parliament on 3 October he said that China was ready to intensify its co-operation with Greece and help the country tide over its financial difficulties. He noted that China had signed over 20 co-operation agreements and contracts with Greece in 2010, and suggested that they seek to double their bilateral trade over the next five years. He said that the two sides would co-operate to manage the Piraeus Container Terminal and increase its capacity to 3.7 million TEUs by 2015. He told that Parliament that China supported a strong Euro and would not reduce its Euro bond holdings. In his talks with Prime Minister Papandreou, he said that China had bought and was now holding Greek Treasury bonds and would take a positive attitude to further purchase. China would also set up a special fund for shipping co-operation of US$5 billion, and would help upgrade the port of Piraeus. After the meeting they issued a joint statement on deepening their comprehensive strategic partnership (full text in XHNA, 3 Oct.) and attended the signing ceremony for 13 bilateral deals in areas including maritime transportation, loan, telecommunication, export and cultural exchanges (XHNA, 2 Oct.).
Premier Wen and his party arrived in Brussels on 4 October to pay an official visit to Belgium and to attend the ASEM Summit and the China–EU Summit. He met the Belgian King and had talks with the Prime Minister. Wen said that China was looking to develop its relations with Belgium in the fields of high-end manufacturing, biological technology, new material and agricultural products processing (XHNA, 6 Oct.). Agence France Presse reported on 7 October that a Belgian consortium, comprising a subsidiary of the French company GDF Suez, had signed a framework agreement with China on the commercial manufacture of nuclear fuel in China (AFP 7 Oct.).
Wen arrived in Rome on 6 October and had talks with Prime Minister Berlusconi the following day, and a meeting with President Giorgio Napolitano. The two sides agreed to expand co-operation in technological and industrial creativity, and to prioritize the development of renewable energies, electric automobiles, low-energy buildings, environmental protection technology education and capacity building, especially in China's western provinces. They also agreed to deepen their co-operation on environmental protection and to promote co-operation among smaller firms. They formally launched the Chinese Culture Year in Italy. They also witnessed the signing of agreements on economy, science and technology, culture and justice (XHNA, 7 Oct.).
Premier Wen and his party arrived in Turkey on 7 October. He had talks the following day with the Prime Minister, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, and witnessed the signature of eight agreements on bilateral trade and economic co-operation, co-operation in third-country infrastructure and technical consultation, cultural exchanges, co-operation in information and telecommunication technology, maritime co-operation, railway co-operation and co-operation in other fields. In a press conference following their talks, the two Prime Ministers announced that they had established a strategic co-operative relationship. Premier Wen said that they both faced threats from the “three evil forces” of terrorism, separatism and extremism, and shared common interests in safeguarding territorial integrity and sovereignty (XHNA, 8 Oct.). Trade between the two countries was over US$10 billion in 2009, with Turkey importing US$8.3 billion and exporting US$1.7 billion, and had risen from US$1 billion in 2000 to 12.6 billion in 2008. During the visit the two sides agreed to try to increase bilateral trade to US$50 billion by 2015 and US$100 billion by 2020. Premier Wen also visited Istanbul where he had talks with the Turkish President, Abdullah Gul (XHNA, 8 Oct.).
Premier Wen Jiabao paid official visits to Russia and Tajikistan from 22 to 25 November, and attended the 15th Chinese–Russian Prime Ministers' meeting and the ninth Prime Ministers' meeting of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO). On arrival in St Petersburg, he said that developing a long-term healthy and steady strategic partnership of co-ordination was in the interests of both countries. He met the Russian Prime Minister, Vladimir Putin, and told him that he wished to inject new vigour into the comprehensive deepening of the Sino-Russian strategic partnership of co-ordination. During his visit Wen and the Russian leaders reviewed their comprehensive bilateral co-operation over the past year and determined the priorities in the next phase of their practical co-operation. Wen noted that the two sides had deepened their political mutual trust and strategic mutual trust, made obvious progress in co-operation in trade, energy, finance and cultural fields, and strengthened strategic co-ordination. The two Prime Ministers witnessed the signing of a number of agreements in such sectors as trade, high-tech, energy, agriculture, finance. Bilateral trade was US$45.1 billion in the first ten months of the year, an increase of 45 per cent from the previous year (XHNA, 23 Nov.). He met President Medvedev on 24 November (XHNA, 24 Nov.).
Premier Wen arrived in Tajikistan on 24 November. Premier Wen met the Tajik President Emomali Rahmon on 25 November. Wen described Tajikistan as one China's important co-operation partners in Central Asia. They agreed to step up mutual political trust and promote substantial bilateral economic co-operation to a higher level. They noted that the two countries have also carried out close co-operation in the areas of economics and trade, telecommunications, mining, transportation, electricity, agriculture, infrastructure, education and culture, boosting the two countries' economic and social development. Premier Wen also had talks with the Tajik Prime Minister. At the end of the visit the two sides issued a joint communiqué. Bilateral trade in the first ten months of the year was worth US$1.08 billion, an increase of 2.5 per cent (XHNA, 25 Nov.).
Premier Wen also attended the ninth Prime Ministers' meeting of the SCO Summit. In the margins he met Prime Minister Masimov of Kazakhstan. Premier Wen said that the two sides should continue to secure and expand their co-operation in energy; ensure the safe, stable and highly efficient operation of China–Kazakhstan crude oil pipelines; lose no time in implementing a number of representational co-operation projects in the sector of non-resources; boost pragmatic co-operation in the spheres of high technology, infrastructure and agriculture; and jointly promote the construction of an international border co-operation centre (XHNA, 24 Nov.). He put forward a six-point proposal for enhancing practical co-operation in the SCO. He said that safeguarding regional security, stability and harmony was of vital importance, and that the SCO should set up, step by step, a permanent and effective mechanism to safeguard regional security and stability, and to take joint actions and comprehensive measures to deal persistent, heavier and more effective blows to the “three evil forces” of extremism, separatism and terrorism as well as drug trafficking and transnational organized crimes (XHNA, 25 Nov.).
Premier Wen paid a state visit to India and Pakistan from 15 to 19 December. In advance of the visit to India, the Chinese ambassador to India said that China's relations with India were “very fragile” and needed special care and guidance, and added that it was important to avoid a war of words (Press Trust of India, 13 Dec.). A Xinhua scene setter noted that China had high expectations of the visit. The Assistant Foreign Minister, Hu Zhengyue, said that “China–India relations are significant. The leaders of both nations agree the world has sufficient space for the two emerging economies to grow.” According to Chinese statistics bilateral trade rose from US$18.7 billion in 2005 to US$51.8 billion in 2008, and was expected to hit US$60 billion in 2010. Trade contracts worth US$16 billion were signed during the visit (XHNA, 13 and 17 Dec.). Premier Wen arrived in New Delhi on 15 November, and played up the strength of the relationship. In an address to a bilateral business forum he said that
the rapid economic development in China and India has become an important engine of the global economic growth. The two countries are co-operative partners instead of rival competitors. There is sufficient space in the world for China and India to develop and for China and India to co-operate. Trade and economic co-operation between the two countries are mutually beneficial win–win trade and economic co-operation and they have a bright future” (XHNA, 15 Dec.).
He met the Prime Minister Manmohan Singh on 16 December. Prior to the meeting he told reporters that he hoped that his visit would strengthen bilateral co-operation and lift bilateral ties to a new height. In the meeting, they had “in-depth, frank and sincere talks on bilateral relations and important international issues and reached extensive consensuses.” They reaffirmed their commitment to promote bilateral relations. Prime Minister Singh said that the Tibet Autonomous Region is a part of the Chinese territory, and that the Indian government does not allow anyone to carry out anti-Chinese activities on its land. Premier Wen expressed his appreciation for India's stand and hoped that the Indian side would adhere to the correct position on this issue (XHNA, 16 Dec.). According to Indian sources, Premier Wen said that Indian and Chinese official should have in-depth talks on the visa issue (the Chinese practice of stapling visas into passports of people from Jammu and Kashmir). After the meeting they witnessed the signing of six agreements on green technology, the exchange of hydrological data on common rivers, media exchanges and cultural exchanges (Press Trust of India, 16 Dec.).
The Joint Communiqué issued after the Prime Ministers' meeting announced that the two sides had agreed to regularize their exchanges of high-level visits reflecting their strategic and co-operative partnership for peace and prosperity. A telephone hotline was agreed and annual visits between foreign ministers. They agreed to establish a strategic economic dialogue mechanism and a China–India CEO's forum. They announced the target of increasing bilateral trade to US$100 billion by 2015, and called for co-operation in education, banking, infrastructure construction, environmental protection and information technology. They agreed to resolve outstanding differences on the border at an early date, and a working mechanism for consultation was set up. Indian press comment noted that there had been little progress on the key Indian concerns of the visa issue and terrorism from Pakistan, neither of which was mentioned in the communiqué. China did express guarded support for India's aspirations for a seat on the UN Security Council (XHNA and Press Trust of India, 16 Dec.). Premier Wen met the Indian Vice President and Speaker of the Rajya Sabha, Ansari, on 16 December. He met Sonia Gandhi, President of the Indian National Congress, and agreed to have more exchanges at party level. He met President Patil on 16 December and said that China was willing to work with India, proceed from a strategic and long-term perspective, make joint efforts to inherit the past and look forward to the future, promote exchanges and co-operation between the two countries in the fields of politics, economy, science, technology, and culture towards more fruitful results, and achieve common prosperity (XHNA, 16 Dec.).
Premier Wen arrived in Pakistan on 17 December, and said that “the purpose of my visit this time is to solidify friendship, deepen co-operation, support Pakistan's efforts of post-disaster reconstruction, and ring in, together with Pakistan, the 60th anniversary of China–Pakistan diplomatic relations in 2011.” A Xinhua scene setter spoke of the “all weather” friendship between China and Pakistan (XHNA, 17 Dec.). Wen had talks with the Prime Minister, Syed Yusuf Raza Gillani, and they agreed to strengthen further the bilateral strategic co-operative partnership and their “evergreen” ties. They had friendly, candid and in-depth exchanges of views on bilateral relations, the regional situation and major international issues, and reached an extensive consensus. Wen said that China highly appreciated Pakistan's long-term strong support on issues related to China's core interests and major concerns. It would, as always, support Pakistan's efforts to safeguard national sovereignty and social stability and achieve economic independence and sustainable development. After the talks, they witnessed the signature of 13 agreements on co-operation in economy, energy, banking, security and technology, and China undertook to give a grant of US$229 million to help with reconstruction after the floods, and a soft loan of US$400 million (details in Associated Press of Pakistan report, 17 Dec.). Premier Wen met senior Pakistani military leaders on 18 December and called for enhanced military exchanges and co-operation. He also met President Asif Ali Zardari, and addressed the China Pakistan Business Council where he announced that the two sides had signed trade deals worth US$10 billion (XHNA, 18 Dec.). On 19 December, he addressed the Pakistani parliament on the topic of “Shaping the Future Together Through Thick and Thin,” and said that “to cement and advance the all-weather strategic partnership of co-operation between China and Pakistan is our common strategic choice” (XHNA, 19 Dec.). A Joint communiqué was issued at the end of Wen's visit (full text in XHNA, 19 Dec.).
Vice President Xi Jinping
Vice President Xi Jinping visited Singapore, South Africa, Angola and Botswana from 14 to 24 November. During his stay in Singapore from 14 to 16 November, Xi had talks with Singapore President Sellapan Ramanathan, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong, Senior Minister Goh Chok Tong, Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew and other leaders (XHNA, 14 Nov.). He then went to South Africa from 17 to 19 November where he met President Zuma, and the Speaker of the South African National Assembly, Max Sisulu on 17 November. He later co-hosted the 4th Plenum of the China South Africa Bi-National Commission. Xi said that two countries should increase their co-operation in sectors such as science and technology, education, culture and tourism, under their comprehensive strategic partnership. The two sides signed a number of agreements covering co-operation in public welfare, energy, trade statistics analysis and banking supervision (XHNA, 17 Nov.). Xi visited Botswana from 20 to 22 November and had meetings with President Ian Khama and Vice President Mompati Meraghe. Trade between the two countries had peaked at US$360 million in 2008, and in the first eight months of 2010 was US$179 million (XHNA, 19 Nov.). During his visit three agreements were signed on economic and technical co-operation, infrastructure and energy development, and finance (XHNA, 20 Nov.). He visited Angola on 19 and 20 November, and following meetings with President Jose Eduardo do Santos and Vice President Fernando da Piedade, it was announced in a joint communiqué (text in XHNA, 20 Nov.) that China and Angola had established a strategic partnership. On his way home, he stopped over in Mallorca and met the Spanish Foreign Minister Trinidad Jimenez. She told him that Spain was ready to further promote co-operation with China and continue to work for better EU–China ties and the EU's early lifting of the arms embargo against China (XHNA, 23 Nov.)
Other senior leaders
Jia Qinglin, Chairman of the National Committee of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference paid official goodwill visits to Syria, Poland, Oman and Kazakhstan from 29 October to 11 November (XHNA, 29 Oct.).
Wu Bangguo, Chairman of the NPCSC, visited Cambodia, Indonesia and Thailand from 3 to 13 November (XHNA, 31 Oct.).
c Countries and Regions
Africa (Cote d'Ivoire, Namibia, Sudan, Uganda, Zambia)
China published a White Paper on its relations with Africa on 23 December (full text in XHNA, 23 Dec.). The foreword noted that
[d]uring their years of development, China and Africa give full play to the complementary advantages in each other's resources and economic structures, abiding by the principles of equality, effectiveness, mutual benefit and reciprocity, and mutual development, and keep enhancing economic and trade co-operation to achieve mutual benefit and progress. Practice proves that China–Africa economic and trade co-operation serves the common interests of the two sides, helps Africa to reach the UN Millennium Development Goals, and boosts common prosperity and progress for China and Africa … Especially since the Forum on China–Africa Co-operation (FOCAC) was established in 2000, economic and trade co-operation has been further enhanced and revitalized; trade, investment, infrastructure and capacity building have been pushed forward in an all-round way; and co-operation in finance and tourism has been gradually expanded, thereby forming a multi-tiered and wide-ranging co-operation pattern on a new historical starting point. China–Africa economic and trade co-operation is a major component of South–South co-operation, infuses new life into the latter, and elevates the political and economic status of developing countries in the world, playing a significant role in promoting the establishment of a fair and rational new international political and economic order.
The White Paper noted that bilateral trade between China and Africa had reached US$114.81 billion in the first 11 months of 2010, an increase of 43.5 per cent. It said that co-operation in resource development is a significant part of China–Africa investment co-operation as African countries possess rich resources. Chinese enterprises were said to adopt open, transparent and multiform ways of co-operation to jointly exploit and utilize resources with African countries and international enterprises against monopoly and exclusiveness. It said that China had helped African countries to build public facilities, increase agricultural production, improve medical care and public health service, reduce debts, and had provided disaster relief and humanitarian aid. New areas of co-operation such as banking, tourism, civil aviation and environmental protection had developed in recent years. The structure of the White Paper was:
Foreword
I. Promoting Balanced Development of Trade
II. Expanding Mutual Investment Fields
III. Attaching Importance to Infrastructure Construction
IV. Strengthening Building of Development Capacity
V. Helping to Improve People's Livelihood
VI. Broadening the Scope of China–Africa Co-operation
VII. Giving Full Play to the Guidance Role of FOCAC
Conclusion
Appendix I: The Eight-Point Plan China Pledged at the FOCAC Summit
Appendix II: The New Eight-Point Plan China Proposed at the Fourth FOCAC Ministerial Summit
The spokeswoman for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs said on 6 December that China hoped that the political parties in the Cote d'Ivoire could settle their election disputes through legal procedures and political dialogue. China would support efforts by the African Union and other African countries to mediate. She called on all sides to “remain calm and restrained.” She refused to be drawn on which side of the dispute China supported saying that China always upheld the policy of non-interference in other countries' internal affairs (XHNA, 6 Dec.). On 9 December, China said that it respected the decision made by the Economic community of West African States to recognize Alassane Quattara as President-Elect of Cote d'Ivoire (XHNA, 9 Dec.).
The Namibian Minister of Foreign Affairs, Utoni Nujoma, visited China from 7 to 14 December. He met Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi on 9 December. He also met Vice Premier Li Keqiang, who said that China regarded Namibia as one of its most trustworthy friends and partners (XHNA, 9 Dec.).
The Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman said on 19 October that China hoped that the referendums planned for January 2011 in Sudan would be held in a transparent and fair manner and reflect the will of the Sudanese people: “Whatever the result of the referendums, it is of paramount importance to safeguard the peace and stability of Sudan” (XHNA, 19 Oct.). The Sudanese Foreign Minister, Ahmed Ali Marti, visited China from 8 to 10 December. He met Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi on 8 December. Yang said that China fully supported Sudan's peace process and that “the involved parties should resolve disputes through dialogue and consultation and work together to promote a smooth referendum in southern Sudan” (a referendum on self-determination for Southern Sudan was due to be held on 9 January 2011). He said that the referendum should be conducted in a fair, free and transparent way to reflect the true aspirations and choice of the Sudanese people (XHNA, 8 December). China's representative at the UN said on 16 December that
[w]e hope the north and south Sudan will keep up the momentum, speed up the preparation for the referenda and ensure that the referenda are conducted in a peaceful, free, transparent and just manner in accordance with the CPA. … We call on the international community to create a favourable condition for the referenda and refrain from prejudging the outcome…no party should take unilateral action. No matter what outcome of the referenda might be, peace and stability in Sudan and the region must be ensured. … China hopes that the north and south will cherish the peace that was hard to come by, and continue their equal dialogue and consultation in order to reach an early agreement on the border demarcation, Abyei and wealth sharing and other outstanding issues.
He added that China supported a peaceful and comprehensive settlement of the Darfur issue: “Achieving substantial result at an early date of the Darfur peace process and reaching a comprehensive political agreement represents a basic guarantee for the long-term peace and stability in Darfur” (XHNA, 16 Dec.).
The Ugandan Foreign Minister, Sam Kutesa, visited China from 10 to 15 October. He met Vice Premier Li Keqiang on 11 October and Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi on 12 October. Yang said that China wanted to push the bilateral relationship to a new high. Foreign Minister Kutesa was reported to have thanked China for its support for Uganda's economic and social development and said that Uganda wanted to develop co-operation in fields such as infrastructure, energy, tourism and agriculture (XHNA, 12 Oct.).
On 18 October Zambian police arrested two Chinese managers who had wounded a number of Zambian miners in a dispute over working conditions at a Chinese-run coal mine in Zambia on 15 October. Eleven local employees and three Chinese had been injured. The Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman said that the Chinese Embassy had taken timely measures to handle the incident, and had directed the companies to handle disputes properly and visit the families of the injured. He stated that the matter had been largely resolved (XHNA, 19 Oct.). On 21 October, the spokesman said that he hoped that the problems could be solved properly and that the Chinese government had always required Chinese overseas companies strictly comply with the laws and regulations of the host countries and live in harmony with local people (XHNA, 21 Oct.). Vice President George Kunda of Zambia visited China in October to attend the World Expo. He had meeting with Vice President Xi Jinping and State Councillor Dai Bingguo on 22 and 21 October (XHNA, 22 Oct.).
Americas (Bahamas, Canada, Chile, Costa Rica)
The Prime Minister of Bahamas, Michael Ingraham, and the President of the Senate and Speaker of the House of Assembly visited China in October. Prime Minister Ingraham had meetings with Wu Bangguo, Chairman of the NPCSC, on 26 October, and with Vice Premier Li Keqiang on 27 October (XHNA, 27 Oct.). Premier Wen Jiabao met the Prime Minister in Shanghai on 31 October and said that China would like to help the Bahamas improve its ability for self-development and deepen co-operation in infrastructure, finance, tourism, agriculture and new energy (XHNA, 31 Oct.).
The Foreign Minister of Canada, Lawrence Cannon, visited China from 19 to 23 October. He met Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi on 22 October. Yang spoke of the strategic partnership between the two countries and said that China wanted to promote the long-term, healthy, and stable development of relations. Cannon noted that Canada wanted to develop co-operation in the fields of economy, trade, energy resources, environmental protection, tourism, health care, and humanities. Foreign Minister Cannon also met Vice Premier Li Keqiang. (XHNA, 22 Oct.).
The President of Chile, Sebastian Pinera, paid a state visit to China from 15 to 17 November. He had talks with President Hu Jintao on 16 November. The two leaders then witnessed the signature of three agreements on economic co-operation. President Hu spoke of their comprehensive co-operative partnership established in 2004 and suggested expanding co-operation in areas like agriculture, science and technology, mineral development, light industry, household appliances and machinery. President Pinera also met Wen Jiabao and Wu Bangguo on 17 November. Chile is China's second largest trade partner in Latin America and trade in 2009 was US$17.72 billion (XHNA, 16 and 17 Nov.).
The Costa Rican Foreign Minister, Rene Castro, visited China from 24 to 31 October, and had talks with Yang Jiechi on 25 October. Yang said that China attached great importance to bilateral relations and that they had much improved under the new government (XHNA, 25 Oct.).
Australasia (Antarctica, Australia, Fiji, East Timor)
State Councillor Liu Yandong visited Antarctica in December. Speaking on King George Island where she was visiting the Chinese Great Wall Station, she said that China attached great importance to polar research and would continue co-operating with other parties to conduct peaceful polar explorations. As a consultative member of the Antarctic Treaty, China was committed as always to performing scientific research within the framework of the treaty and broadening international co-operation in order to effectively preserve the Antarctic ecological environment, guarantee the peaceful theme of polar research and protect the common benefit of mankind (XHNA, 27 Dec.).
The Australian Foreign Minister, Kevin Rudd, visited China in November. He had talks with the Chief of the PLA General Staff Department, Chen Bingde, on 4 November. The Australian Deputy Prime Minister and Treasury Minister, Wayne Swan, was also visiting China in November and met Vice Premier Li Keqiang on 4 November. Swan said Australia hoped to enhance co-operation in trade, energy and resources, tourism and culture (XHNA, 4 Nov.).
Premier Wen Jiabao met the President of East Timor, Xanana Gusmao, on 31 October in Shanghai. He said that China cherished its friendship with East Timor and suggested they expand co-operation in agriculture, oil and gas exploration, mining and investment (XHNA, 31 Oct.).
The President of Fiji, Epeli Nailatikau, visited Shanghai for the World Expo and had a meeting with Wu Bangguo on 2 October (XHNA, 2 Oct.). The Minister for Foreign Affairs, Civil Aviation and International Co-operation, Ratu Inoke Kubuabola, visited China from 11 to 14 October. He was received by Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi. Yang said that China attached importance to its co-operation with Fiji. Kubuabola said that Fiji would strengthen ties with China in the areas of economics, trade, tourism, culture and education (XHNA, 13 Oct.). He met Vice President Xi Jinping the following day (XHNA, 14 Oct.). The Fijian Prime Minister, Vorege Bainimarama, visited Zhejiang province in November to discuss trade and investment opportunities (Fijilive website, Suva, 15 Nov.).
Central Asia (Kazakhstan)
The Foreign Minister, Yang Jiechi, visited Kazakhstan from 27 to 29 December. He met the Kazakh Foreign Minister, Kanat Saudabayev, on 28 December and they exchanged views on key issues of bilateral relations, international and regional security, as well as stressing the strategic nature of their co-operation (Kazinform News Agency, in Russian, 28 Dec.). He met President Nazarbayev on 28 December. Yang said that the Chinese government highly valued its relations with Kazakhstan and regarded it as one of its diplomatic priorities. He noted that China was willing to foster the relations with Kazakhstan to be a model of good neighbourliness and equal co-operation, and a guarantee for both countries' development (XHNA, 28 Dec.). He also had talks with Prime Minister Karim Masimov and they agreed to deepen their co-operation in energy, infrastructure and non-resource areas (transport infrastructure, trade and finance) (XHNA, 28 Dec.).
Europe (EU, Cyprus, Denmark, Italy, Turkey, Russia, United Kingdom)
China and the EU held their third High-Level Economic and Trade Dialogue in Beijing on 21 December. Vice Premier Wang Qishan led for China, and the EU side was led by the European Commission Vice-President in Charge of Competition Policy, Joaquin Almunia, Trade Commissioner Karel De Gucht as well as Commissioner for Economic and Monetary Affairs Olli Rehn. The meeting covered macro-economic challenges facing the international economy, competition questions as well as trade, investment, innovation and customs co-operation. Wang Qishan said that China supported the measures being taken by the EU and the IMF to create financial stability, and noted that China had taken concrete action to help some EU members combat the sovereign debt crisis. Wang called on the EU to make substantial headway in relaxing the restrictions on its export of high-tech products to China, and urged it to accord China Market Economy status as soon as possible. Trade with the EU in the first 11 months of the year was US$433.9 billion, up 33 per cent (XHNA, 21 Dec.).
The Foreign Minister of Cyprus, Markos Kyprianou, visited China from 17 to 19 October. He met Vice Premier Li Keqiang on 20 October. Li said that China and Cyprus were friends and good partners seeking joint development. He also had talks with Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi (XHNA, 20 Oct.).
Yang Jiechi met the Danish Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister, Lene Espersen, in Shanghai on 31 October. Ms Espersen welcomed the two countries' co-operation in education, research and development and renewable energy and environmental protection (XHNA, 31 Oct.).
The Turkish Foreign Minister, Ahmet Davutoglu visited China from 28 October to 2 November. He began the visit in Kashgar, and then travelled on to Urumqi, Xi'an, Shanghai and Beijing. He met Vice President Xi Jinping on 1 November, and the two sides committed themselves to joint efforts to crack down on terrorism and separatism. Xi thanked Turkey for its efforts in combating “East Turkestan” terrorist forces (XHNA, 1 Nov.). He met Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi on 2 November. Yang said China hoped to enrich their strategic co-operation and take it forward in politics, economy, security, culture and people-to-people exchanges (XHNA, 2 Nov.).
The British Prime Minister, David Cameron, visited China from 9 to 11 November, accompanied by a high-level delegation of four senior ministers and 50 top businessmen, for discussions on a wide range of topics including trade, finance, energy and education. The visit was preceded by the Third UK–China Economic and Financial Dialogue led by the Chancellor of the Exchequer and Vice Premier Wang Qishan in Beijing on 9 November (XHNA, 9 Nov.). Prime Minister Cameron had talks with Premier Wen Jiabao on 9 November. Wen noted that China and Britain were comprehensive strategic partners. They should strengthen political trust and promote the fundamental interests of both countries. China welcomed British enterprises expanding their co-operation with China, particularly in high-end manufacturing, aviation, aerospace, innovation industries, the financial industry, the service industry, energy saving, environmental protection and other fields. Wen said that China encouraged Chinese enterprises to increase investment in Britain. He hoped that the two countries would continue to conduct rich and colourful activities in education, culture, healthcare, exchanges between teenagers, the Olympic Games and other areas, and enhance mutual understanding and friendship between the Chinese and British people. David Cameron replied that Britain valued its comprehensive strategic partnership with China, had persistently pursued the one-China policy and was ready to strengthen exchanges and enhance mutual trust on the basis of mutual respect and through important bilateral dialogue mechanisms. Britain wanted a trade and economic partnership that promoted common growth and welcomed Chinese investment in the UK. The two leaders also discussed important regional and international issues. After the talks, they witnessed the signing of documents on bilateral co-operation (XHNA, 9 Nov.). Prime Minister Cameron met President Hu on 10 November. Hu told him that co-operation was stronger than competition between the two countries. He said that he hoped that the two countries could make good use of the developmental opportunities that beckoned. Prime Minister Cameron said that they should expand co-operation in energy, environment and pharmaceutics. He agreed with Hu to fight against protectionism and push forward the Doha round of talks. During the visit several commercial deals were signed with contracts worth US$2.7 billion. Trade reached US$357.5 billion in the first nine months of the year, a rise of 29.4 per cent. During the visit, the two sides also held high-level dialogues on finance, education and energy. Prime Minister Cameron attended a China-UK Business Summit along with Vice Premier Li Keqiang (XHNA, 10 Nov.).
Japan
Relations with Japan remained difficult with the fall out from the Diaoyutai/Senkaku Islands dispute. Premier Wen Jiabao had a meeting with the Japanese Prime Minister, Naoto Kan, in the margins of the ASEM in Brussels on 4 October, with the Diaoyutai/Senkaku issue being a major item of discussion. Premier Wen reiterated the Chinese position that the islands had been Chinese territory since ancient times. They agreed to increase people-to-people exchanges and to hold a high-level meeting at an appropriate time (XHNA, 5 Oct.; Kyodo News Agency, 4 Oct.).
It was announced that the Japanese had cancelled a proposed ship visit to Qingdao by two ships of the Maritime Self-Defence Force after the Japanese were told that it should be postponed because of the ill feeling generated by the Diaoyutai/Senkaku incident (Kyodo News Service, 14 Oct.). On 16 October demonstrations took place in a number of Chinese cities, including Xi'an, Chengdu, Hangzhou and Zhengzhou, to defend China's position on the Diaoyutai Islands and to protest against Japan's actions (XHNA, 16 Oct.). There were also protests outside the Chinese Embassy in Tokyo. The Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman expressed “deep concern” at these and urged Japan to fulfil its obligations under the Vienna convention and to properly protect the Embassy. He said that the demonstrations in China were “understandable” but that patriotism should be expressed rationally and in compliance with the law (XHNA, 16 Oct.). Further sporadic demonstrations continued throughout October, with protests in Sichuan, Shaanxi and Gansu on 24 October (Kyodo News Service 24 Oct.), and in Chongqing on 26 October (XHNA, 26 Oct.).
On 19 October China expressed itself “deeply shocked” at remarks made by the Japanese Foreign Minister, Seiji Maehara, when he described the Chinese reaction to the “ship collision” incident as “hysterical.” The Foreign Ministry spokesman said that the remarks ran counter to attempts to improve relations and that the Chinese hoped the Japanese would show sincerity in improving the two countries' relations with practical moves, so as to create necessary conditions and environment to realize meetings between the two countries' leaders at the forthcoming ASEAN meetings. Assistant Foreign Minister Hu Zhengyue said on 21 October that that it required appropriate conditions and an atmosphere for Chinese and Japanese leaders to meet. “We hope that the Japanese and Chinese sides will move towards each other and show their sincerity in improving the two countries' relations with actual deeds, instead of saying something contradictory to this or doing something that runs counter to this.” He claimed that China had acted with restraint over the ship incident, but that the Japanese had deliberately escalated it, which forced China to take “some appropriate and necessary responses.” He also complained about remarks made by the Japanese Prime Minister on 15 October when he had said that there was no hurry for a high-level meeting and that the ball was in China's court (ZXS, 21 Oct.).
The Japanese and Chinese Foreign Ministers met in the margins of ASEAN + 3 meetings in Hanoi on 29 October. Japanese press reports of the meeting (Kyodo News Service, 29 Oct.) suggested that they had agreed to improve ties and possibly to prepare the ground for a meeting between the Prime Ministers. The Japanese Foreign Minister said he had reiterated Japan's firm position on the disputed islands and that the Chinese had responded with theirs. The meeting had taken place in an “extremely congenial atmosphere.” However, shortly afterwards the Chinese expressed anger over the meeting, claiming that the Japanese had made untrue statements about it, distorted China's position, and were trying to stir up resentment against China over the islands issue, and had ruined the atmosphere for talks between the leaders. China was further upset by the US Secretary of State saying, following her meeting with the Japanese Foreign Minister, that the Diaoyutai Islands fell within the scope of the US Japan Security Treaty (XHNA, 29 Oct.).
Tensions remained even after President Hu did eventually have a meeting with the Japanese Prime Minister in the margins of the APEC Summit in Yokohama on 13 November. Hu said that both sides should proceed from a strategic perspective and a long-term angle, strictly observe the principles laid down by the four political documents between China and Japan, hold firm to the correct development direction of China–Japan relations, make efforts to push forward China–Japan strategic reciprocal relations along a healthy and stable track. Prime Minister Kan was reported by the Chinese to have fully agreed with Hu Jintao on his opinions regarding the development of China–Japan relations. He hoped that both sides would strengthen exchanges and co-operation in various fields and push for further improvement and development of the two countries' relations (XHNA, 13 Nov.). After the Summit the two Foreign Ministers met and agreed to “implement the important consensus reached by the Chinese and Japanese leaders, firmly grasp the right direction for the development of Sino-Japanese relations, and preserve the overall situation of bilateral relations. Both sides maintained they would adopt positive measures to enhance people's feelings, promote practical co-operation, and push forward the improvement and development of Sino-Japanese relations” (XHNA, 13 Nov.). By 16 December relations were showing signs of improvement and the Chinese Foreign Ministry Spokeswoman said that the many meetings and contacts leaders had made at multilateral occasions had allowed them to reach important consensuses. She said China was willing to work with Japan to promote the mutual strategic relationship to new heights. Both sides should act in accordance with the principles of the four political documents (China–Japan Joint Statement on Comprehensively Advancing Strategic and Reciprocal Relations, the Sino-Japanese Joint Statement, the China–Japan Treaty of Peace and Friendship and the Sino-Japanese Joint Declaration) (XHNA, 16 Dec.).
Koreas
There was a busy round of bilateral exchanges between China and North Korea. A senior North Korean delegation led by Choe Thae Bok, a member of the Politburo, visited China at the beginning of October to inform the Chinese leadership of the outcome of the meeting of the Korean Worker's Party held at the end of September. Liu Yunshan, Head of the Propaganda Department, congratulated the Koreans on the outcome of the conference and said that China stood ready to work with the new leadership to develop bilateral ties, realise more benefits for the two peoples and more contributions to lasting regional peace and common prosperity (XHNA, 1 Oct.). The delegation met President Hu Jintao on 2 October. President Hu said that the Congress had been a major event in the political life of North Korea and promised that the CCP would: “actively promote and expand exchanges and co-operation in various fields, strengthen communication and co-ordination in regional and international affairs, and make common efforts in helping maintain regional peace and stability and promoting joint development.” He made no public direct mention of the elevation of Kim Jong Un. A Xinhua commentary of 30 September noted that
[i]n the list of the new leaders' names, nobody's name is more eye-catching than Kim Jong Un, the newly-elected vice chairman of the KWP Central Committee Military Commission and member of the KWP Central Committee. This name, Kim Jong Un, appeared for the first time in Kim Jong Il's order to promote him to be senior general, an order issued one day before the KWP conference opened. Although there are numerous conjectures about Kim Jong Un's identity, such as he is Kim Jong Il's son, DPRK has yet to openly acknowledge any of the conjectures. The elections this time have eliminated the uncertainties surrounding this matter and they have strengthened the leading body while the country is ushering in a new historical period that will carry forward its legacy (XHNA, 30 Sept.).
A Chinese delegation led by Zhou Yongkang, the Politburo Standing Committee member in charge of security issues, visited North Korea from 9 to 11 October to attend the celebrations of the 65th anniversary of the founding of the Korean Workers Party. Zhou met Kim Yong Nam, President of the Supreme People's Assembly on 9 October, and was with Kim Jong Il and Kim Jong Un for the grand military parade and other festivities in Pyongyang on 10 October (XHNA, 10 Oct.). He had a formal meeting with Kim Jong Il on 11 October. Kim said that he was very satisfied with the healthy state of relations with China, and that he and President Hu had reached important consensus on the crucial issues between them as well as on other issues of mutual concern. Zhou said that the close relationship between the two leaders showed that China and North Korea were intimate comrades and true friends (XHNA, 11 Oct.).
A delegation of senior Chinese military officers, led by Guo Boxiong, Vice Chairman of the Military commission, visited North Korea for the 60th anniversary of the entry of the Chinese People's Volunteers into the Korean War on 25 October (XHNA, 23 Oct.). They were received by Kim Jong Il who hosted a special banquet for them. Kim Jong Un was also present (XHNA, 25 Oct.). In China President Hu and Vice President Xi Jinping met veterans of the Chinese People's Volunteers. Xi said that the Chinese action had been “a great and just war for safeguarding peace and resisting aggression” (text of his speech in XHNA, 25 Oct.).
The Premier of North Korea, Choe Yong Rim paid an unofficial working visit to northern China and met Vice Premier Zhang Dejiang in Changchun on 3 November (KCNA 3 Nov.).
Relations with South Korea were also busy, although there were difficulties over the North Korean issue and South Korea's military relationship with the US. Premier Wen Jiabao met the South Korean President Lee Myung-bak in the margins of the ASEM meeting in Brussels on 5 October and they agreed to boost co-operation and communication to accomplish the common goal of denuclearizing North Korea and bringing lasting peace to Northeast Asia. Premier Wen said that China looked for an early resumption of the six-party talks to ease tensions and resolve the nuclear issue. He said that the forthcoming G20 Summit in Seoul would be of great significance and promised that China would support South Korea in seeking positive outcomes from the meeting (XHNA, 5 Oct.). The Chinese and South Korean Foreign Ministers met in the margins of the Hanoi meetings on 28 October (XHNA, 28 Oct.). The Chinese Foreign Minister, Yang Jiechi, had planned to visit South Korea from 26 to 27 October but the visit was called off as tensions rose on the peninsula. South Korea opened a consulate in Wuhan, covering the provinces of Hubei, Hunan, Henan and Jiangxi, on 25 October (XHNA, 25 Oct.).
China continued to press for resumption of the six-party talks, through a number of contacts during the period. North Korea's chief negotiator on the nuclear issue, Kim Kye Gwan, who had recently been promoted to Vice Foreign Minister, visited Beijing from 12 October at the invitation of China's special representative for Korean affairs, Wu Dawei. He had talks with Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi, and was reported to have had candid and thorough discussions (XHNA, 14 Oct.).
The North Korea nuclear issue took a further twist when the North Koreans revealed to a visiting American scientist that it was operating 2,000 centrifuges capable of producing highly enriched uranium. Tensions were further raised when North Korean artillery shelled the island of Yeongpyeong. The Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs expressed concern over the shelling, although in a restrained way. The spokesman said: “We are concerned about the issue and the real situation needs to be confirmed.” He went on to restate China's position that all relevant parties should create conditions for resuming the six-party talks and that they restart at the earliest possible date (XHNA, 23 Nov.). This followed a meeting the previous day between China's representative for the Korean peninsula, Wu Dawei, and Wi Sung-lac, South Korea's special representative for Korean Peninsula Peace and Security. It was also announced that Stephen Bosworth, the US special representative for North Korean policy, would be visiting China on 23 and 24 November following visits to South Korea and Japan. Speaking in Russia, Premier Wen Jiabao said that all parties should exercise maximum restraint and the international community should make more efforts to ease tensions. Restarting the six party talks was an essential way to achieve stability and denuclearization on the peninsula (XHNA, 24 Nov.). The Chinese Foreign Minister, Yang Jiechi, had planned to visit to South Korea from 26 to 27 but the visit was called off as tensions rose, although the Chinese Foreign Ministry cited scheduling problems (XHNA, 25 Nov.). Meanwhile the Foreign Ministry again called for calm and restraint, and urged the two Koreas to engage in dialogue and refrain from similar actions. It repeated the urgency of restarting the six-party talks. It also noted its concern at the proposed military exercise by the US and South Korea on 28 November. On the question of uranium enrichment, the MFA spokesman said
[t]he relevant countries should earnestly and accurately implement various Security Council resolutions on the Korean nuclear issue. The Chinese side has been fulfilling its international obligations in a responsible manner, and it has devoted itself to promoting the materialization of the denuclearization of the peninsula and maintaining peace and stability on the peninsula and in Northeast Asia in line with the spirit of the relevant Security Council resolutions.
He also noted its concern at the proposed military exercise by the US and South Korea on 28 November (XHNA, 25 Nov.). He repeated these concerns on 26 November saying that China was opposed to any party taking military actions in China's exclusive economic zone without permission (XHNA, 26 Nov.). Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi met the South Korean Ambassador on 26 November, and also had a telephone conversation with US Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton, and reiterated China's position (XHNA, 26 Nov.). State Councillor Dai Bingguo, accompanied by China's chief nuclear negotiator, Wu Dawei, visited South and North Korea from 27 November. He had talks with the South Korean Foreign Minister, Kim Sung-hwan, and with President Lee Myung-bak who asked China to act “fairly and responsibly” to contribute to bringing peace to the peninsula (Yonhap News Agency, 28 Nov.). On 28 November, Wu Dawei announced that China was proposing emergency consultations among heads of the delegations to the six-party talks: “The Chinese side, after careful studies, proposes to have emergency consultations among the heads of delegation to the six-party talks in early December in Beijing to exchange views on major issues of concern to the parties at present” (XHNA, 28 Nov.). On 6 December President Hu Jintao spoke on the telephone to President Obama about the Korean situation. Hu said that
[t]he Chinese side expresses deep regret and is deeply worried about the current situation on the recent exchange of fire between the two Koreas that caused personnel casualties and the loss of property. The Korean Peninsula is a region with a very fragile security situation. Particularly the current situation, if handled improperly, could very likely lead to the continuous escalation of the tense situation and even the loss of control, which is not in line with the common interests of various relevant parties, and which is also a situation that we really do not want to see. Under the current situation, the pressing need is to deal with the situation in a calm and rational manner, and resolutely prevent the further deterioration of the situation.
He added that “the denuclearization of the peninsula, the peaceful resolution of the nuclear issue of the Korean Peninsula through dialogue and talks, and the maintenance of the peace and stability on the Korean Peninsula and in Northeast Asia are the Chinese side's consistent position, which are also the starting point and ultimate goal of the Chinese side's handling the Korean Peninsula nuclear issue and other relevant issues” (XHNA, 6 Dec.). On the North Korean side, the Chairman of the North Korea Supreme People's Assembly, Choe Tae Bok, visited China from 30 November to 4 December. State Councillor Dai Bingguo, accompanied by Wu Dawei, visited North Korea on 8 and 9 December and was received by Kim Jong Il on 9 December (XHNA, 9 Dec.). State Councillor Dai Bingguo met the US Deputy Secretary of State, James Steinberg, on 16 December for talks on the peninsula (XHNA, 16 Dec.). The UN Security Council held an emergency meeting on North Korea on 19 December, but it failed to agree a statement. According to the South Korean press this was because China was refusing to denounce the North Korean shelling on Yeonpyeong Island (Yonhap, 19 Dec.). The Chinese said that they had made intensive diplomatic efforts and hoped everyone involved would work with China for the same goal. The Chinese representative at the UN said that China was deeply worried at the situation (XHNA, 20 Dec.).
Middle East (Iraq, UAE)
China's permanent representative to the UN said that China supported the new UN resolutions on lifting major sanctions against Iraq. “China welcomes the adoption by the Security Council of resolutions which lift the sanctions imposed according to Chapter 7 of the Charter regarding the mass destructive weapons, missiles and civilian nuclear activities, which conclude the oil-for-food programme and provide for appropriate arrangements relating to the development fund for Iraq.” He commended the Iraqi government for stabilizing the overall situation, and said that: “We understand and support Iraq's aspiration for complete reintegration into the international community” (XHNA, 15 Dec.).
The UAE Minister of Foreign Affairs, Shaykh Abdullah Bin Zayed Al Nahyan, visited China in October and met Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi on 21 October. Yang said that China attached great importance to its all-round friendly and co-operative relations with the UAE and wanted to expand co-operation in fields such as trade, energy, rail and international flights. Shaykh Abdullah expressed the hope of upgrading their relations to the level of strategic partnership. He met Vice President Xi Jinping on 23 October (XHNA, 21 and 23 Oct.).
South Asia (India, Nepal, Pakistan)
Zhou Yongkang, a member of the Politburo Standing Committee and Secretary of the Commission for Political and Legal Affairs, visited India in late October/early November. He had a meeting with the Indian Prime Minister, Manmohan Singh, on 1 November and said that China wished to increase political trust with India and expand co-operation for mutual benefit and deepen their strategic co-operative partnership. He also met Sonia Gandhi, President of the Congress Party, and Secretary General Rahul Gandhi, the Minister for External Affairs, and other political leaders. He made a five-point proposal on the further development of China–India relations, including promoting political mutual trust, expanding co-operation in economics and trade, boosting friendly exchanges, strengthening international co-operation, and promoting friendly consultation. Trade is expected to reach US$60 billion in 2010 (XHNA, 3 Nov.). China and India held a meeting in Beijing on border issues from 29 to 30 November, led by State Councillor Dai Bingguo and National Security Adviser Shivshankar Menon. They agreed to continue to “seek a fair and reasonable solution acceptable to both sides,” but no substantive progress was reported. They also discussed the wider bilateral relationship. Vice President Xi Jinping received Menon after the talks and said that the two countries were co-operative partners, not competitors (XHNA, 30 Nov.).
The President of Nepal, Dr Ram Baran Yadav, visited China from 21 October to 2 November to attend the closing of the Shanghai World Expo. He first travelled via Tibet. Premier Wen Jiabao met him in Shanghai on 31 October. He described China and Nepal as good neighbours, good friends and good partners, and said that their relationship was a model of friendly and equal co-operation. China would consolidate its traditional friendship with Nepal and enrich its comprehensive partnership (XHNA, 31 Oct.).
President Asif Ali Zardari visited China from 11 November. His first stop was in Guangzhou for the opening of the Asian Games. He met Premier Wen Jiabao in Guangzhou on 12 November. Wen expressed deep sympathy for the floods and said China would give its full support to post-disaster reconstruction. Zardari hoped the two countries could cement co-operation in areas like agriculture, irrigation and infrastructure and enhance co-ordination in international and regional affairs to safeguard interests of both countries (XHNA, 12 Nov.).
South East Asia (Burma, Cambodia)
The Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman said on 9 November that China welcomed the smooth general election that had just taken place in Burma. It was a vital part of the seven-step roadmap to the transition to an elected government (XHNA, 9 Nov.). A more detailed press commentary said that the change came out of the military's own choice and conforms to people's aspiration and the international trend and fundamental condition that speeds up the country's national economic and social development. It concluded that “Myanmar still must meet many challenges. But there is one point that can be assured, that is Myanmar society is heading for pluralism and democratization with the inevitable emergence of complicated phenomena of joint existence of various political forces dominated by the main political force” (XHNA, 9 Nov.).
Hun Sen, Prime Minister of Cambodia, visited China from 13 to 17 December. He had meetings with President Hu Jintao and with Wu Bangguo, Chairman of the NPCSC. He had talks with Premier Wen Jiabao, at which they agreed to establish a comprehensive strategic partnership of co-operation. Wen said the government would encourage Chinese companies to increase investment in Cambodia and help in its construction of special economic zones. China would look to expand co-operation with Cambodia in areas including agriculture, infrastructure construction, finance and human resources, and continue to provide assistance. They agreed to increase trade to US$2.5 billion by 2015. In the first half of the year bilateral trade was worth US$627 million (XHNA, 13 Dec.).
Taiwan
In important elections on 27 November, the ruling Kuomintang held on to three mayoral positions in Taipei city, Xinbei City and Taichung city while experiencing an overall fall in its vote to the opposition DPP with 44.54 per cent compared to 49.87 per cent). The DPP won easily in the southern towns of Kaohsiung and Tainan. The elections were widely seen as a test of the current government as they covered roughly 60 per cent of the total population (CNA, 27 Nov.). China commented that it had paid “close attention” to the results and would continue working with Taiwan to expand and deepen cross-Strait relations (XHNA, 28 Nov.). President Ma claimed that the results showed that the KMT's reforms had borne fruit. He said that cross-Strait relations had not been an election issue and that the government would not change its policy in this regard or alter its progress (CNA, 29 Nov.).
A further round of the cross-Strait talks was held in Taipei from 20 to 22 December, and a medical and health co-operation agreement was signed. Chen Yunlin, President of the Association for Relations across the Taiwan Strait (ARATS), had talks with Chiang Pin-kung, head of the Straits Exchange Foundation (SEF). Before the talks, Chiang was reported to have said that the exchanges had reached a tenuous and difficult stage. There were still differences on investment protection (Taipei Times website, 18 Dec.). The Chinese party arrived on 20 December for talks on 21 December. They signed the medical and healthcare agreement on the afternoon of 21 December, which included provision for swift reporting by both sides on emergency situations. They were unable to complete work on the investment agreement (XHNA, 21 Dec.). Wang Cho-chiun, the Director General of the Taiwan Police Agency, visited China from 26 October to 1 November under the “Agreement on Cross-Strait Mutual Assistance in Cracking Down on Crime” which was signed in April 2009. This was the first senior police officer to visit the mainland and followed a visit by a Vice Minister of Public Security to Taiwan in September (XHNA, 27 Oct.). China approved the applications of two more Taiwanese banks to open branches on the mainland: the Cathay United Bank in Shanghai and the Hua Nan Bank in Shenzhen. The Taiwan Business Bank was also allowed to open a representative office in Shanghai. This followed permission for two Taiwanese banks to open in September (XHNA, 13 Oct.). The Bank of China opened its office in Taipei on 25 October (CNA 25 Oct.). Five further Taiwanese banks were granted permission to operate Chinese branches on 18 December (Taipei Times website, 18 Dec.).
A row blew up over the insistence by a Chinese delegation to the Tokyo International Film Festival that the Taiwanese delegation could only participate under the name “Taiwan, China” or “Chinese Taipei” rather than Taiwan, which it always used previously. Taiwanese politicians described the behaviour as “overbearing.” The Chinese tried to play it down. The Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs spokesman said that the Ministry was aware of the issue, but that as far as Taiwan's participation in international events was concerned, “both sides should make reasonable arrangements through bilateral co-ordination so long as they are made under the premise of not creating two Chinas or one China, one Taiwan” (CNA, 25 and 26 Oct.). China formally opposed attempts by Taiwan's supporters to bring it into the negotiation process of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change as an observer. A Chinese representative at Cancun claimed that some countries had “tried to mix negotiations with political issues such as the issue related to Taiwan … These speeches went against the purposes and principles of the UN Charter and relevant regulations of the UNFCCC, and constituted a violation of China's sovereignty and territorial integrity, and interference in its internal affairs” (XHNA, 9 Dec.).
Taiwan welcomed the announcement in the Hong Kong Chief Executive's policy address that Hong Kong would be discussing plans with Taiwan to open a “comprehensive” office in Taiwan (CNA, 13 October). Hong Kong decided that it would upgrade the tourism board's office in Taipei to a full representative office with an enhanced role in promoting tourism (XHNA, 17 Dec.).
United Nations
The UN Secretary General, Ban Ki-moon, visited China from 30 October to 3 November, primarily to attend the closing session of the Shanghai World Expo. He had talks with Yang Jiechi covering Millennium Development Goals, climate change and other international and regional affairs (XHNA, 30 Oct.). He met President Hu Jintao in Beijing on 1 November. President Hu told him that the UN needed to abide by the purposes and principles of the UN Charter, actively practice multilateralism, and push forward democratization of international relations. He also suggested that the UN speed up measures to implement the Millennium Development Goals and strengthen its roles in international affairs. He also had meetings with State Councillor Dai Bingguo and with Wu Bangguo (XHNA, 1 Nov.).
USA
China's relations with the US remained scratchy throughout the period with concerns over the yuan exchange rate, the military relationship, and North Korea featuring largely. Some efforts were made to get the military relationship back on track, although it remained overshadowed by continuing Chinese concerns over arms sales to Taiwan, and by questions over the US military presence and activities in East Asia. The Chinese Minister of Defence, Liang Guanglie, went to a meeting in Hanoi of ASEAN Defence Ministers during which he had a meeting with the US Defence Secretary, Robert Gates (XHNA, 6 October). The annual consultations under the Military Maritime Consultative Agreement were held in Hawaii in mid-October. The two sides exchanged opinions on the maritime security situation in a candid manner (XHNA, 17 Oct.). Ma Xiaotian, Deputy Chief of the PLA General Staff, led the Chinese delegation to the 11th round of defence consultations to exchange views on military ties, maritime military security and other international and regional security issues. The session was held on 10 December with US Under-Secretary for Defence, Michele Fournoy. It was agreed that Defence Secretary Gates would visit China January 2011. Ma said that China attached importance to military-to-military relations and had made sincere efforts for their steady and healthy development. He noted that while they shared wide-ranging common interests some obstacles remained such as US arms sales to Taiwan, Congress bills restricting military exchanges between the two countries, and the high frequency of military surveillance close to China's special economic zone (XHNA, 10 Dec.). The Ministry of Commerce welcomed on 15 October reports that the US intended to waive the embargo on sales of the C-130 to China for use in oil-spill response operations (XHNA, 15 Oct.).
In a sign of warming relations, the US Attorney General Eric Holder visited China in October and was accorded a meeting with Zhou Yongkang, the Politburo Standing Committee Member in charge of security issues. In a press conference at the end of his visit, Holder said that China and the US would be key partners in combating corruption, terrorism and other crimes. He said that the two sides would work together to produce tangible results (XHNA, 21 Oct.). Wang Yi, Director of the Taiwan Affairs Office, visited Washington in late October and met US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, Deputy Secretary of State James Steinberg, Assistant Secretary of State Kurt Campbell and National Security Council's Senior Director of Asian Affairs Jeff Bader for discussions on Taiwan (XHNA, 22 Oct.). A Xinhua article noted that US politicians had been making China a scapegoat in the mid-term election campaigns. A number of candidates had issued advertisements accusing their opponents of helping China at the expense of American workers. The article quoted a number of US sources deploring this trend and the distorted view it gave of the relationship between China and the US (XHNA, 29 Oct.).
Vice Premier Wang Qishan visited Washington for the 21st Joint Commission on Commerce and Trade on 15 December. The Chinese press reported that these had had a positive outcome and a number of bilateral agreements were signed covering a variety of areas such as investment promotion, agriculture, examination, inspection and quarantine, energy, water conservancy and trade statistics. They agreed to explore the possibility of establishing a bilateral framework on intellectual property rights. China agreed to resume imports of beef. According to Chinese statistics, from January to November this year, bilateral trade reached US$346.9 billion, surpassing that for the whole year of 2008 (XHNA, 126 Dec.).
State Councillor Dai Bingguo had an informal meeting with US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton in Hainan after the East Asia Summit. They exchanged views in a “candid and friendly manner” and agreed to enhance their dialogue and handle differences on sensitive issues properly (XHNA, 1 Nov.). US Deputy Secretary of State, James Steinberg, visited China from 15 to 17 December, primarily for discussions on Korea. He met State Councillor Dai Bingguo on 16 December, and had discussion with Vice Foreign Ministers Zhang Zhijun and Cui Tiankai and with Wu Dawei. A press statement described the talks as useful. Dai reiterated China's position that China has always held a highly responsible attitude and played a constructive role on the Peninsula issues. “China maintains that it is of great urgency that parties involved should jointly prevent the escalation of tension on the Korean Peninsula. The six-party talks are the only effective way to solve the Peninsula issues and realize lasting peace and stability in Northeast Asia” (XHNA, 16 and 17 Dec.).
d Trade Matters
China announced the discovery of a new substantial deposit of rare earths in Zhuxi County in Hubei province on 7 October. Earlier Premier Wen Jiabao had told European businessmen that China wanted to develop its rare earths deposits in a sustainable manner. China needed to satisfy both domestic and global demand, and be able to look to the future. He said that it was important that China exercised proper controls, but it would not close the market (XHNA, 7 Oct.). The spokesman for the Ministry of Commerce said on 15 October that China's measures for managing and controlling the export of rare earths were fully consistent with its WTO obligations and that China would never use the export of rare earths as a means of blockade. He repeated that the measures were taken to protect the environment and achieve sustainable development. He said that China hoped to achieve mutually beneficial co-operation with Japan over rare earths and manage these resources through international collaboration (XHNA, 15 Oct.). Later China dismissed as groundless reports that it was intending to reduce its exports of rare earths in 2011 by 30 per cent. It said China would set its 2011 quotas based on rare earth output, market demand and needs of sustainable development (XHNA, 20 Oct.). Zhongguo xinwen she put the Chinese argument at length in an article on 22 October. It noted that 97 per cent of rare earth production currently came from China, although it had only 36 per cent of the world's reserves. Production in 2009 was 120,000 tonnes but this had led to falling prices and widespread environmental degradation, while countries such as the US and Japan picked up the valuable resources on the cheap. It claimed that Japan had built up stockpiles that could last 20 years. As a result, China had been cutting back on exports since 2006. The quota for export in 2010 was 30,258 tonnes (down 40 per cent from the previous year), and in July China had announced a further cut of 72 per cent. Although some countries were threatening to take this to the WTO, it was entirely within China's sovereign rights to decide how much to export (ZTS, 22 Oct.). On 28 October Kyodo reported that China had resumed rare earth shipments after blocking them for Japan from 21 September and for the US and Europe since 18 October (Kyodo News Service, 28 Oct.). China announced that it would be reducing its rare earth export quotas slightly in 2011, but “not by a very large margin.” The quota system has been in place since 1998 and since 2006 China stopped granting new rare earth mining licenses in an attempt to control the environmental impact (XHNA, 2 Nov.). China stated that almost half of its rare earth exports in the first nine months of the year (16,000 tonnes) had gone to Japan, an increase of 167 per cent year on year. In 2010 China had cut its export quota by 39 per cent while also reducing its rare earth development and production capacities by 25 and 23 per cent. China had also added a duty of 15–25 per cent on rare earth exports (XHNA, 16 Nov.). The Japanese confirmed on 24 November that rare earth shipments had resumed (Kyodo News Service, 24 Nov.). On 14 December, China announced that it would raise its tariffs on some rare earths from 1 January 2011 (XHNA, 14 Dec.).
The Chinese Ambassador to the WTO, Sun Zhenyu, spoke at the biennial WTO review of US trade policy and practice. He was quoted as having called for the United States to fulfil its international obligations, comply with WTO rules and change its trade protectionist policies. He urged the US to take a more positive attitude to the Dohar round. He complained of numerous non-tariff barriers erected by the US, and the massive subsidies provided to domestic agriculture. He complained that the US was unilaterally setting and implementing intellectual property enforcement standards. He decried the US “two-faced” policy of mounting an all-out export drive while limiting certain exports in the name of national security (XHNA, 1 Oct.).
The Ministry of Commerce expressed its regret on 16 October over a US government decision to investigate China's renewable energy policies. The US Trade Representative started an investigation on 15 October in response to complaints from the United Steelworkers' Union that Chinese support for its renewable energy industries was giving them an unfair advantage (XHNA, 16 Oct.). The Ministry of Commerce expressed its concern over the US request to the WTO to investigate Chinese subsidies on wind power equipment (XHNA, 23 Dec.). On 22 October, the WTO dispute settlement body ruled that the US Department of Commerce had acted inconsistently with WTO rules in imposing anti-dumping and countervailing duties on four categories of Chinese imports. The case had been filed by China in 2008 (XHNA, 23 Oct.). China won another victory on 25 October when the WTO Disputes Settlement Body ruled that US restrictions on Chinese poultry imports were inconsistent with WTO rules (XHNA, 26 Oct.). On 3 December, the WTO ruled that the EU anti-dumping duties on Chinese screws and bolts imposed in 2009 were discriminatory and in violation of global commerce rules (XHNA, 3 Dec.). The WTO ruled on 14 December that the punitive US tariff on Chinese tyre imports, announced in September 2009, was consistent with global trade rules (XHNA, 14 Dec.).
China published rules on the registration and administration of representative offices for foreign companies on 25 November. They are due to come into force on 1 March 2011 and cover topics such as rules on the registration, establishment, information change, cancellation of registration and legal responsibilities of the representative offices of foreign companies. Representative offices are not allowed to conduct business in China, but they can perform market surveys, product or service display and promotion, and liaise on behalf of their parent companies (XHNA, 25 Nov.).
The yuan reached a new high point against the US dollar on 8 October of 6.6830, an increase of 2.12 per cent since the People's Bank of China announced that it would allow increased flexibility in the exchange rate on 19 June (XHNA, 8 Oct.). The Deputy Governor of the People's Bank of China, Yi Gang, told a seminar in Washington that China would continue to reform the way its exchange rate was formed, but that a sharp rise in the value of the currency would damage the Chinese economy (XHNA, 7 Oct.). The value of the yuan rose against the US dollar by about 1.74 per cent in September, the biggest monthly gain since the July 2005 revaluation (XHNA, 13 Oct.).
e Defence Diplomacy
The Chinese Minister of Defence, Liang Guanglie, visited Vietnam from 10 October to attend the ASEAN + 8 Defence Ministers' meeting and to visit Vietnam (XHNA, 10 Oct.). He had a meeting with Nong Duc Manh, General Secretary of the Communist Party of Vietnam on 10 October, and was told that the bilateral relationship had maintained its momentum in recent years with frequent high level exchanges and increasing co-operation and had reached the level of a comprehensive strategic partnership of co-operation. Liang said that China was ready to deepen its military ties with Vietnam. He also met the Vietnamese Minister of Defence earlier that day (XHNA, 10 Oct.). He met the Vietnamese Prime Minister, Nguyen Tan Dung, on 11 October. Liang told him that China would like to work together with Vietnam to further advance comprehensive strategic co-operative partnership (XHNA, 11 Oct.).
He met the Japanese Defence Minister, Toshimi Kitazawa, for their first conversation since the row over the detention of a Chinese fishing boat in the Senkaku/Diaoyutai Islands in September. According to Japanese sources, the Japanese Minister suggested the establishment of a liaison system to prevent conflicts at sea (Kyodo News Agency 11 October). The Chinese press reported that Liang Guanglie had said that Japan should properly handle sensitive issues in bilateral relations to help the relationship back onto a normal track at an early date (XHNA, 11 Oct.).
Liang met the US Secretary for Defence, Robert Gates, on 11 October in what was the first high-level meeting of defence leaders since the row over the US arms sales package to Taiwan in January. According to Chinese reports, Liang told Gates that it was important for the two countries to respect and care for each other's core interests and major concerns, continuously consolidate strategic mutual trust, decrease suspicion and misjudgement, and properly settle differences and sensitive issues in order to keep bilateral military ties developing in a continuous and stable way. He added that China had been positive and sincere in developing military ties with the US. China expected the two sides to make joint efforts to gradually settle problems in bilateral military ties and orient the ties towards healthy and stable development. Secretary Gates accepted an invitation to visit China early in 2011, and in press conference after the meeting the Chinese said that the annual consultations on maritime security would be held in Hawai‘i later in the week and that there would be a new round of the annual defence consultations in Washington, led on the Chinese side by Deputy Chief of the PLA General Staff, Ma Xiaotian (XHNA, 11 Oct.).
A Chinese commentary said that the ASEAN + 8 Defence Ministers’ meeting would be a brand new security dialogue platform to tackle the new security challenges in the Asia Pacific region. Non-traditional security challenges had become all the more pressing, so enhancing international co-operation was essential to tackle such challenges, in which, military forces have played and will continue to play an irreplaceable role (XHNA, 11 Oct.). Liang himself told the meeting that China's defence development did not aim to challenge or threaten anyone, but to ensure its security and promote international and regional peace and stability. It was agreed at the meeting that China and Vietnam would chair an Expert Working Group to strengthen regional capacity to deal with non-traditional security challenges, and it would focus on humanitarian assistance and disaster relief (XHNA, 12 Oct.) What the Chinese reporting did not cover was that a number of ASEAN Ministers took the opportunity to raise concerns at the meeting about the South China Sea and the need to resolve disputes peacefully. This had not been included on the agenda (SCMP website, 14 Oct.). China's own take on the meeting was summed up in a report of 13 October, which noted three key concepts for the meeting. The first was the newness of the meeting which China hoped would develop into a new platform for co-operation in defence and security areas. The second was pragmatism and the stress laid by the Chinese delegation on the need to base the new approach on pragmatic co-operation. The third was China and the United States and the way in which the two sides had interacted productively at the meeting (XHNA, 13 Oct.).
The Chinese announced that units of the Marine Corps of the PLA would conduct a joint drill with Thai counterparts from 26 October to 14 November in an exercise in Thailand called “Blue Assault 2010.” The drill would focus on anti-terrorism training (XHNA, 20 Oct.). PLA commando units and commando units of the Turkish armed forces trained together at the Turkish Commando School and Training Centre for a week from 8 November. The training included basic assault skills in hilly terrain and tactics (XHNA, 8 Nov.) The Romanian Minister of Defence, Gabriel Oprea, visited China from 10 to 15 November, and had meetings with the Defence Minister Liang Guanglie and with Guo Boxiong, Vice Chairman of the Military Commission (XHNA, Nov.). He also viewed a Romanian Chinese training exercise, “Friendship Action 2010,” which was held in Yunnan (Agerpres, 10 Nov.). China and Singapore conducted their second joint training exercise in counter-terrorism from 19 November. Eighty-six PLA personnel and about 60 from the Singapore Armed Forces took part in the nine-day exercise “Co-operation 2010” (XHNA, 19 Nov.).
The Chinese Hospital Ship, Peace Ark, sailed on a “Harmonious Mission 2010” to Djibouti, Kenya, Tanzania, the Seychelles and Bangladesh to provide medical services to local people from 31 August to 15 November (XHNA, 9 November). The Chinese guided missile frigate, Xiangfan, paid a friendly visit to Vietnam on 3 December after conducting a joint patrol with the Vietnamese navy. Joint patrols have taken place in the Beibu gulf since 2006 (XHNA, 3 Dec.). Three Chinese naval vessels visited Indonesia on 27 December on their way home from deployment in the Gulf of Aden and Somali waters. They were from the Sixth deployment to the region and had escorted 615 ships, saved one ship hijacked by Somali pirates and three chased by pirates (XHNA, 27 Dec.).
