The toga was everywhere in Roman antiquity, but is nowhere near prominent enough in modern scholarship. Such is the impetus behind Ursula Rothe's new book, the first monograph in English on the toga for almost one hundred years. R. sets out to tackle the notion that the toga was a mostly symbolic garment. Instead, R. argues that it was widely worn and was a canvas for negotiating and enacting Roman identity — or rather, Roman identities, since (in line with other recent scholarship on Romanness) R. shows the many, intersecting ways of being Roman. These togate Roman identities are not confined to the elite of Rome and Italy; in especially rewarding sections of the book, R. dissects the strategies and concerns of toga-wearers (and sometimes deliberate non-toga-wearers) below the elite and in the provinces. R. brings together a wide variety of both visual and textual evidence, ranging from the regal period to the seventh century a.d. The brisk pace of the volume means that there is more probing of individual pieces of evidence that could be done, but overall R. succeeds well in her aim of making readers think again about the place of the toga in Roman society.
R. has a consistently, and refreshingly, light-touch approach to theory; her arguments rest on recent work on identity and dress, but she does not smother her reader in these theoretical folds. This approach generally serves her well, although there could be more precision on how identity and ethnicity are meant to fit together (occasionally the two seem to be elided), and some might quibble with R.'s welcome avoidance of the minefield of earlier theories of culture and identity in the provinces only to settle on the model of ‘globalization’ with little question in ch. 6.
R.'s story of the toga is told across seven chapters. Her introductory chapter outlines what was at stake in wearing the toga: she shows convincingly that at Rome, unlike in Greece, it was your clothes, not your body, that talked. Ch. 2 offers a brief history of the toga. R. is cogent in showing that the garment's importance did not begin and end with Augustus; the Augustan period emerges as one in which there was a resolution but not in the end a revolution in toga-wearing. In chs 3 to 5, R. explores the relationship between the toga and different aspects of Roman identity: gender, social status, politics. R. does not use the toga to tell a wholly new story of Romanness, but she shows clearly and compellingly how the toga worked within our current understandings of Roman values. There are especially successful sections on how distinctions in the wearing of the toga mirrored status distinctions within society. This includes a good discussion of decisions not to wear the toga by the tunicatus populus, which well illustrates R.'s wider argument that dress choices were not all oriented around the elite. R. is also sharp on the wearing of the toga as ‘a burden as well as a privilege’ (92). Apt modern comparisons — notably the usage of the sari to illustrate the difficult and active processes of learning to wear the toga — bring toga-wearing to life. This idea of the toga as a lived and living garment is a central, and in the end persuasive, part of R.'s work, although it is ultimately not quite clear how far R. thinks surviving visual evidence really enables us to reconstruct everyday realities of dress; she often raises, but never quite resolves, the problem of how to interpret the evidence of funerary monuments in particular.
Where chs 2 to 5 focus on Rome and Italy, ch. 6 moves into the provinces. R. acknowledges that this structural distinction is potentially regressive, and some more dialogue between chs 2–5 and 6 might have been productive in underlining the dialogue between Rome and the provinces for which R. argues. That said, ch. 6 itself is a highlight of the book. Here, R. offers rich and satisfying analysis of a series of detailed case studies from across the Roman Empire, with especially sensitive discussion of epigraphic evidence from the north-western provinces. She uses these case studies powerfully to demonstrate that the meaning of the toga cannot be taken for granted; it meant very different things in different provinces. As R. indicates, there is scope for further work on evidence from other geographical areas (notably North Africa) which would presumably only add to this sense of variety. Ch. 7, which also functions as a ‘conclusion of sorts’ (147), tells the history of the toga into Late Antiquity; this way of ending might have been more satisfying if there had been some more explicit reflection on how ‘what happened next’ sheds light on what came before. There follows a tantalisingly brief epilogue on the continuing (mis)appropriation of the toga into the modern day. The book is completed by a useful glossary of dress terms, notes and a short index. The standard of production is high, with clear presentation, very good quality images (including a brilliantly helpful guide to toga draping drawn by R., 27) and few errors.
This is a valuable intervention that removes the toga from the art-historical catwalk and persuasively revives it as street fashion. There is enough to engage specialists, but the accessible writing is likely to make it appeal more widely. In showing what (not) to wear and why it mattered, R. offers insights not only into the toga itself, but through the toga into important themes of Roman history including identity, status and empire.
