Similar to Gene Garthwaite's Khans and Shahs (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983) and Stephanie Cronin's Tribal Politics in Iran (New York: Routledge, 2007), this book by Arash Khazeni is devoted to the Bakhtiyari tribe in Iran, though its title inexplicably fails to make this clear. The book differs from its predecessors owing to the period under consideration—the turn of the 20th century—and to the viewpoint adopted—from the “periphery” rather than the “center.”
The first chapter describes the situation before this period. At the start of the 19th century, nomads made up half of Iran's population. A central government was emerging that was interested in modernization as well as in gaining control over the tribes and their territories in order to discover and exploit their resources. The Bakhtiyari had a reputation for rebellion and marauding, however, and the state's control over them was lax and indirect: at times, it consisted of little more than granting official titles such as sardār or vālī to tribal chiefs in exchange for services such as supplying soldiers and mounts. Some chiefs rose in rank by winning renown through military operations alongside the shah, while those who were more recalcitrant were targeted by punitive expeditions or even deported. The Qajars established a system of delegating regional powers, otherwise known as the “kings of tribes” (mulūk-i tavāyif). However, this practice did not stop tribesmen, certain tribal chiefs (such as Asad Khan Bakhtiyarvand), or even some horsemen of the Bakhtiyari regiment (nazim-i bakhtiyari) from committing acts of violence against shopkeepers, attacking caravans, or stealing livestock. The period from 1830 to 1850 was marked by a power struggle between the chiefs of the Chahar Lang and Haft Lang sections of the tribe as well as different sections within the Haft Lang. Unable to settle matters, the central government shared out offices, thus proving its inability to bypass tribal structures.
The second chapter focuses on Isfahan and the surrounding area during the second half of the 19th century. This period was marked by both the unification of the Bakhtiyari under the iron rule of Husayn Quli Khan (c. 1820–82, ilkhān in 1867) and the tribe becoming subject to Masʿud Mirza Zill al-Sultan's governorship in Isfahan (1874–1907). Zill al-Sultan considered the Bakhtiyari to be a group of savages, little more than animals (p. 64), and treated them as such. Offended by the ilkhān's growing power, Zill al-Sultan had him assassinated and replaced him with two of his brothers, Imam Quli Khan and Riza Quli Khan, who assumed the roles of ilkhān and ilbayg, respectively, thus prodding the brothers into rivalry in order to better control the tribe.
The third chapter is devoted to a decisive rivalry in the history of southwestern Iran involving three parties: the Bakhtiyari, the British, and the Persian government. In 1888, Nasir al-Din Shah opened the Karun River to navigation and international trade, in particular to the Lynch Brothers’ company. In 1898, this company signed an agreement with Bakhtiyari chiefs for building a highway from Karun to Isfahan, the so-called Bakhtiyari or Lynch Road. The Bakhtiyari and neighboring tribes (in particular the Kuhgilu) constantly marauded the road once it was opened. In fact, all of the parties involved viewed the road strategically in different ways: for the Bakhtiyari, it was an improved route for nomadic movements; for the khans, it was a way to obtain more wealth and reinforce their power and autonomy from the Qajar sovereigns; for the British, it was an instrument of political propaganda and a “project of ‘civilizing’ pastoral nomadic tribes, bringing them closer to the market and gradually settling them down” (p. 111).
Of greater consequence for the Bakhtiyari was the discovery of oil by Jacques de Morgan and its exploitation in 1905 by the British company, D'Arcy Oil Syndicate. This is the subject of the fourth chapter. Oil spewed from the ground for the first time on 26 May 1908 in Maydan-e Naftun, the Bakhtiyari winter pasture grounds. A means for settling and civilizing the tribes, oil would significantly reshape Bakhtiyari society and its environment. As petroleum was tapped, installations were set up, and the demand for labor grew. All this led to the rapid urbanization of Masjid-i Suleyman. Furthermore, the Bakhtiyari received payments from the British in exchange for their protection of the oil wells and the use of their pastures.
The Bakhtiyari are known for the part they played in the Constitutional Revolution (1906–11). Their participation was not without problems, however, as the fifth chapter shows. Following a civil war (1908–09) during which the Bakhtiyari wavered between the constitutional and loyalist causes, the tribe ultimately took the side of the constitutionalists due to the influence of ʿAli Quli Khan Sardar Asad (c. 1857–1917). The latter, who was in Paris at the time of the events, returned in March 1909 and mustered the tribe to march on Isfahan, after which he rallied 800 Bakhtiyari horsemen to march on Tehran in June. In mid-July, Bakhtiyari and Azeri constitutionalists entered the capital. The city's newspapers presented the savages and thieves of yore as heroes and patriots! Muhammad ʿAli Shah abdicated in favor of his son Ahmad, and Sardar Asad became first the interior minister and then the minister of war. This was the only time of relative unity among the Bakhtiyari khans. Their growing power became a cause for concern, however, and a reason for opposition from, for example, the League of the South (Ittihad-i Junub), a group formed in February 1910 by several chiefs from other tribes (Qashqai, Arabs from Khuzistan, Lurs). Having become “mercenaries of the Revolution” (p. 180), Bakhtiyari soldiers returned to their old ways: in March and April 1910, thousands of them were raiding the Isfahan–Kerman road and ransoming travelers and caravans. In late April, untimely initiatives by young khans, who were filling in the tribal positions left vacant by the senior khans now serving in Tehran, exacerbated tensions between the ilkhānī (descendants of Husayn Quli Khan) and hājjī-ilkhānī (descendants of Imam Quli Khan) branches of the family of Bakhtiyari khans. To the question “To what degree did the Constitutional Revolution reach the Bakhtiyari tribe?” (p. 190), Khazeni provides a balanced answer. On the one hand, he points to the emergence of a new vocabulary and new attitudes as well as to the growing political influence of the bibi (daughters of khans), but, on the other hand, he relates reports that most of the Bakhtiyari at the time knew only how to “obey and follow the commands of the Sardar” (p. 191).
In conclusion, Khazeni states that the Qajar's “confederate and decentralized state structure was the hallmark of the early modern state in Iran” (p. 193). The delegation of power to the periphery enabled this state to maintain an empire with only limited use of force. On the periphery, this delegation allowed the tribes to preserve their autonomy from the center. The British adopted a similar position vis-à-vis the tribes. Khazeni claims to have “avoided the association of the modern state with the notion of ‘progress’” (p. 194) in an effort to understand what it meant to the tribes to be integrated into the state. Although perceived and presented by the British as a way to “civilize” the Bakhtiyari, the building of the Lynch Road and the development of the petroleum industry damaged the environment and despoiled the nomads. The Constitutional Revolution did bring Bakhtiyari chiefs into national politics but left “ordinary Lurs” on the periphery while dismantling the tribe's political structure.
This book contains about forty photographs (unnumbered and not listed in a table), three maps, notes, a glossary of approximately fifty words, a bibliography with about 350 references to archives or printed documents, and an (incomplete) index with about 300 items. However, the back matter is weak in several respects. Not all the words in the glossary are clearly defined. For instance, it is misleading to define il as a “tribal confederacy” (p. 257); the same is true of defining ilrah as “tribal migration route,” which would be better rendered in English as “nomadization” (the periodic movements of nomads). The map of “Bakhtiyari tribal migration [sic] routes” (p. 9) is lacking. There are inaccuracies in the bibliography: works by the same author are not cited in chronological order, and several book titles are spelled incorrectly. Throughout the book, transcriptions from Persian are made using the “Library of Congress system without diacritical marks” (p. xi), which often makes it difficult to recognize the original words in Persian.
In terms of historiography, since the book has been organized by periods and/or themes, a recapitulative chronology of events should have been included. Khazeni lends too much credit to Sardar Asad's Taʾrikh-i Bakhtiyari (1911) and to the writings of local scholars, which are not free of inaccuracies in regard to the origin of tribal subdivisions (p. 21), the localization of the tribe's summer and winter quarters (pp. 55–56), and the status of the land (p. 105). These flaws could have been avoided in part or in full had the author paid closer attention to anthropological studies. It comes as a surprise to notice that Khazeni, while claiming to have adopted a viewpoint from the periphery, has overlooked the processes underway inside the tribe, in particular the contradictory game played out between lineage-based forms of solidarity, social stratification, and rivalries within chiefdoms, in particular between the basta (a word not mentioned) ilkhāni and hājjī-ilkhānī. Finally, it should not be taken for granted that the “Third World” center/periphery paradigm, so dear to Samir Amin, is best suited for shedding light on the topic studied in this book.
Despite these imperfections, Tribes and Empire contributes to our knowledge of the conditions, persons, and parties involved in several major episodes that marked a turning point in Iranian history. When placed alongside the studies by Gene Garthwaite and Stephanie Cronin, this book makes the history of the Bakhtiyari the best known among the tribes of modern Iran.
