A source of mystery and intrigue for explorers and scholars alike, Congo – or rather, the invention of Congo – is indeed a tangled story of ‘ambitions and disenchantments’ as Jean-Luc Vellut's latest monograph indicates.Footnote 8 This book's title also alludes to Congo's thorny history of encounters, one that calls into question the very notion of ‘progress’, a multivalent aspiration that continues to justify and guide contemporary development projects across this vast country.
Divided into five parts, Vellut assembles a narrative through a collection of some of his previously published essays. They address a spectrum of themes, and focus on oscillating local and foreign interests in what we now call Congo. The author engages with a global historical approach throughout the book, which effectively imbues each thematic field with a larger matrix of connections. Readers gain a sense of international solidarities that transcend political borders, such as early Pan-Africanism, in which W. E. B. Du Bois played a key role. Similarly, readers learn of Congolese resistance, particularly messianic religious movements, which were shaped by, and later embedded in, the Black Consciousness Movement in America. The author is also careful to show the ways in which the European presence in the Congo was not uniform by offering descriptions of the diverse interests of foreign groups there, including missionaries, colonial officials, and merchants. Without forfeiting any nuance, Vellut continuously refocuses his kaleidoscope, shifting back and forth between actors to reveal the fissures, frustrations, and exploitation in and between different groups of people across the continents.
Part One begins with the consolidation of the Congo Free State and the ways in which commerce served as the main engine of progress, as Europe drove the demand for rubber and palm oil, copal, and other natural resources. Bone-chilling human exploitation, discussions of liberal humanitarianism, and international antislavery sentiments provide context for the debates that took place with regards to colonial empire building. Vellut highlights how emergent ideas of international property and capital had profound sociocultural and environmental consequences.
The book's second part ushers in the age of formal colonialism, when the territory coalesced into Belgian Congo. These chapters demonstrate the many ways in which the colonial state was dependent upon its politique indigène, or its indigenous political systems, to maintain order. Vellut examines some of the racist policies motivated by hierarchical obsessions – Europeans’ paltry social status at home was one reason for safeguarding their prestige abroad. Readers also get a sense of the underlying racism that colored gender relations in the colony – Congolese women were despised, but also desired. ‘The Portuguese as an Ethnic Minority in the Congo’ is a fascinating chapter that chronicles the different waves of foreigners arriving to Belgian Congo, and the dynamic between competing big and small enterprises.
Part Three explores some of the grim consequences of colonial interventions, especially in the rural hinterlands where health epidemics and famines decimated local populations. Here it is interesting to note that the introduction of manioc, today considered a staple in ‘traditional’ cuisine, was an imported solution to famine, which brought with it its own set of consequences – while manioc satiates appetite, it offers little nutritional value. Rebellions and acts of resistance are broached through the perspectives of peasants, workers, and soldiers; they further reveal how perceived communist encroachments generated a political climate of panic. Here, Vellut gestures towards global historical connections in his descriptions of dockworkers who were considered conduits of subversive outside ideologies.
Perhaps one of the most compelling chapters is ‘Death Penalty in Congo: A Propos the Execution of Bwana François 1922’. It uses a micro-historical approach to analyze the legal proceedings and public execution of a young African man convicted of murdering his employer upon discovering that he had slept with his wife. Vellut describes the machinations of the inchoate colonial court system and the interventions of the metropole, illuminating the debates that circulated between Brussels and the Congo regarding crimes of passion as they related to the African population. An important moment in popular history, Bwana François's execution appeared in popular paintings and came to be celebrated as an act of Congolese resistance. Another important source of collective memory, Kimbanguisme, a popular religious movement with roots in Protestantism that preaches a doctrine of non-violence, contributed to the creation of vibrant artistic channels of expression such as hymnals, theater, and painting. The prophetic leader of the movement, Simon Kimbangu, makes several appearances throughout the book to show the entangled relationship between international missionary groups and perceived threats from emergent styles of worship.
Part Four attends to material culture, describing how curiosities circulated among both Africans and Europeans, resulting in a cross-fertilization of aesthetics. Vellut demonstrates that the emergence of popular folk art also served as a source of history from below. This section features chapters about Catholicism and the rise of syncretic religion. Here the author provides an in depth analysis of some of the local histories surrounding Kimbangu, spiritual leader and symbol of Congolese nationalism.
The book's final part, ‘Curtain Call on the Colonial Era’, is devoted to describing geopolitical perspectives during the twilight years of colonialism. These chapters address the effects of world wars, economic depressions, and the activities carried out by various missionary societies. Lumumba's speech in which he makes an impassioned bid for African unity is mentioned in passing, foreshadowing the country's future disenchantments.
Jean-Luc Vellut's rich body of work is well known to most francophone historians of Africa. But his writings would undoubtedly reach a broader audience of scholars across the disciplines if more English translations of his research were made available. In addition to being a valuable reference, this book, written in an accessible style, will be of interest to people who are searching for stories of encounter, conquest, domination, resistance, collaboration, and global connection.
