In August 1894 the author Mary Ward received a letter from Harry Lowerison, a Fabian socialist and teacher at a working-class school in Hackney.Footnote 1 Lowerison had recently read Ward's 1888 novel Robert Elsmere, and he wrote to tell her of his reaction to it:
I had my fire-baptism much earlier than Elsmere. Beginning with eternal damnation as a boy, I thought myself, helped by multifarious reading, out of orthodoxy to my present position. Nay, at one time the feeling of the world-pain made me deny the existence of a God. . . . I have stood before my boys morning after morning with the story of the stainless Galilean, and have been gentler + more loving with them all the day for it.Footnote 2
Lowerison's account of his religious trajectory looks like the kind of reaction some scholars say we should expect from Victorian readers of Ward's best-selling novel, whose title character, an Anglican priest, comes to doubt the New Testament account of Jesus's divinity. According to William S. Peterson, Robert Elsmere “brilliantly captures the pain of spiritual loss so characteristic of the century” and is “a cri de coeur which large numbers of readers recognized as an expression of their own spiritual doubts and longings.”Footnote 3 For Mark Free, Robert Elsmere's success is evidence of the “ubiquity” of what he calls “the fairly common Victorian crisis of faith occasioned by the failing belief in the historical veracity of the Bible.”Footnote 4 And Clyde de L. Ryals approvingly cites a commentator from 1892 who attributed the novel's popularity to widespread skepticism.Footnote 5 Lowerison seems to have undergone such a crisis, and it leaves him, as Elsmere's does, with a theistic faith and a belief that Jesus, though not divine, is a perfect human and moral exemplar.
But the conclusion of Lowerison's letter swerves from this explanation of Robert Elsmere's appeal. “We are desperately poor,” Lowerison tells Ward of his school. “I want books to put in the boys’ hands + I want money to take them out on occasional rambles. . . . If I read you aright through your book you will give where you can.”Footnote 6 Lowerison's request for money complicates what had seemed like a straightforward identification with Robert's spiritual trajectory; that identification now also serves as a rhetorical move to gain Ward's financial assistance for his students.
Lowerison's letter thus asks us to reconsider the idea that readers were drawn to Robert Elsmere because they were undergoing crises of spiritual loss; however sincere Lowerison's identification may have been, his correspondence with Ward suggests that there was more to the reception of Robert Elsmere than identification with its title character's “loss of faith.”Footnote 7 Readings that attribute the novel's popularity to such identification draw on the secularization thesis, the view that religion declined in the nineteenth century with the onset of modernity. But this thesis, once widely held, has been challenged in recent years;Footnote 8 this too invites us to look for new accounts of the popularity of a novel that had, in its author's estimate, sold over a million copies by 1909.Footnote 9 Here, I turn to Charles Taylor's discussion of Robert Elsmere in A Secular Age. Taylor sees Ward's novel as following Thomas Carlyle and Matthew Arnold in their shared concern with the “cross-pressures” of the nineteenth century: pulled between the appeal of unbelief and the flatness of a world emptied of all divinity or spirit, they sought to create new spiritual positions.Footnote 10 Taylor suggests that Robert Elsmere's appeal lay in its affective account of this predicament: “it portrays so vividly the inner conflict, the intense suffering, which accompanied this deconversion and reconstruction” (385). While Taylor here frames the response to the novel in terms of identification—readers, he implies, shared the experience of emotional turbulence the book depicts—I want to instead pursue a different understanding of its appeal, one that I see as in line with Taylor's broader argument in A Secular Age. Taylor considers the end of the nineteenth century to be a moment when the possibilities for belief expanded in a “nova effect” (299). This effect is linked to what he calls “secularity 3”: the awareness, on the part of any given individual, that their religious belief, or lack thereof, is only one possibility among others (3). This, I think, helps us understand the appeal of Robert Elsmere : readers were drawn to the novel because they were alert to and concerned about the expanding nova of religious beliefs.Footnote 11 The novel gave readers a chance to explore a position other than their own, not only through its account of Robert's experience, but also through its dramatization of a range of beliefs held by its large cast of characters: the devout Anglicanism of Robert's wife, Catherine; the scornful atheism of Squire Wendover, whose scholarship plays a key role in Robert's conversion; and the religious indifference of Catherine's sister Rose, a talented violinist.
The appeal of such exploration manifests itself in the public debate that ensued about Robert Elsmere. The secularization-thesis reading of Robert Elsmere sees the novel in terms of private experience; it aligns with Michael Warner's account of sermons, whose aim, Warner argues, is to produce “inner revelation.”Footnote 12 Like the individual listening to a sermon, the reader of a theological novel supposedly hears a voice speaking to her individually. Public speech, in contrast, entails both the individual's response and their awareness that their reaction is not the whole story: “our partial nonidentity with the object of address in public speech seems to be part of what it means to regard something as public speech.”Footnote 13 For many readers of Robert Elsmere, the experience of these novels resembled the experience of public speech in this sense: they produced the feeling that there were other responses in circulation, and that as such the novels were objects to be discussed and debated.Footnote 14
The reception of Robert Elsmere was an instance of what I will call “public reading”: a mode in which the act of reading is informed by an awareness that others are also reading and discussing the book in front of you, that you are reading to join in that discussion, or indeed are joining it in the very act of reading.Footnote 15 In reconstructing the public reading of these novels, this essay joins a wave of recent interest in ways of reading that are not the same as the “critical reading” practiced by scholars today but that are not therefore to be dismissed as “uncritical reading”—as unsophisticated and unreflective.Footnote 16 Such work includes Merve Emre's research on “paraliterary reading” in the postwar United States; Erin Smith's account of religious reading; and Hugh McIntosh's cool reading, the ambivalent response to fiction that he sees as endemic to the late nineteenth-century United States.Footnote 17 These studies, in turn, continue older work like Jonathan Rose's on working-class readers in Britain and Janice Radway's on romance reading and middlebrow reading.Footnote 18 Like the modes of reading uncovered by these scholars, the reading of Robert Elsmere was not “naïve, immature, unexamined”;Footnote 19 the belief that readers identified with Robert is, I think, the product of an assumption that Victorians read uncritically. Readers of Robert Elsmere knew what others were saying about Ward's novel, they knew how it had been received in the press, they were concerned with how other people were responding, and in their own responses they positioned themselves in relation to this wider reception. In this way, the reading of Robert Elsmere was a kind of analogue to Taylor's secularity 3: as Taylor argues that the secular is distinguished by awareness of other people's religious views, so the reading of Robert Elsmere was characterized by awareness that other people were reading Robert Elsmere.
To support my argument about Robert Elsmere's reception, I consider Ward's novel alongside Joseph Henry Shorthouse's John Inglesant (1881).Footnote 20 Shorthouse's novel turns on the moral and physical adventures of its protagonist, a sixteenth-century Cavalier and agent of the Jesuits who is drawn to the Catholic Church but also influenced by Nicholas Ferrar's community at Little Gidding and by Molinist Quietism; Inglesant eventually finds peace in the Anglican communion. Shorthouse's novel was, if not as sensationally successful as Ward's, well received and popular, and it was frequently linked to Robert Elsmere.Footnote 21 Yet the differences between the two further problematize the secularization thesis: if readers identified with Robert Elsmere because of his loss of faith and religious crisis, how do we understand the success of a novel, published a few years earlier, whose protagonist gains new belief and who experiences religious uncertainty but never undergoes a crisis per se?
To address the questions raised by the popularity of these novels, this essay looks to evidence from “common readers” or “ordinary readers,” as distinct from readers who published their responses in the form of reviews and articles.Footnote 22 Thus it encounters the methodological challenges that scholars of reading have long faced. Robert Darnton famously argues that reading is the most difficult stage to study in the communications circuit; its difficulty stems from the archive itself, where traces of actual reading are often scanty or partial.Footnote 23 This is certainly the case with records of readers’ encounters with John Inglesant and Robert Elsmere. In particular, while a significant number of letters to Ward and Shorthouse survive, neither author seems to have retained the voluminous fan mail that both indicate they received. In October 1881 Shorthouse told his publisher, Alexander Macmillan, that he had received “several letters fr. strangers” and in February 1882 commented complacently, “I continue to receive the most gratifying expressions about the book. Every body seems to be reading it everywhere.”Footnote 24 Ward referenced a “bundle of letters” on March 25, 1888—well before the novel had reached the height of its popularity—and in November she commented, “The excitement of America about R. E. is much in excess of anything that has been seen in England and they write a proportionate number of letters.”Footnote 25 But this correspondence survives only in part; the authors, or their heirs, kept letters from personal friends, well-known people, and family members, as well as correspondence relating to publication and other business matters, but for the most part they did not preserve letters from unknown readers.
But there is still, I think, enough material to make it possible to draw conclusions about how and why these two novels found a wide audience. We can look to the letters from readers that Ward and Shorthouse did retain; we can look to the letters they themselves wrote in response to readers, or the letters they wrote describing their correspondence with readers; we can look to periodical sources, such as descriptions of reading and conversation about the novels as well as interviews with readers and letters to editors; we can look to accounts of the novels’ reading in autobiographies. Such sources are not without problems: as William St Clair argues, “Once a mental experience has been put into a text, even as simple a text as a note in a diary, it requires historical and critical interpretation.”Footnote 26 Still, what matters are the statements that readers made: these (and not what they secretly thought but never said) are what could act in the world.Footnote 27
1. The Readers of Theological Novels
Robert Elsmere and John Inglesant were read by a wide variety of readers, people who differed from one another in terms of social position and religious belief. Metropolitan elites, including politicians and clergy as well as artists and intellectuals, were one group. A piece printed in the Nottingham Evening Post and the Grantham Journal asserted that Robert Elsmere's audience comprised “bishops, archbishops, canons, and humbler dignitaries of the church” as well as the current prime minister, Conservative Robert Gascoyne-Cecil, former prime minister William Gladstone, and “many of the political colleagues of both these chieftains” (“Metropolitan Notes”; “Metropolitan Gossip”).Footnote 28 The novel was also read by prominent North Americans and Europeans, including Mark Twain, Oliver Wendell Holmes, American agnostic Robert Ingersoll, English philosopher Bernard Bosanquet, historian Goldwin Smith, and intellectuals in France, Austria-Hungary, and Germany.
But evidence suggests that theological novels also found an audience among less elite readers. The New-York Tribune asserted in December 1888 that Robert Elsmere was “read eagerly by all classes of people.”Footnote 29 A reporter for the Chicago Tribune claimed to have watched at a bookstore while “a lady bought a copy and carried it to her carriage, and a working girl squeezed out the few necessary nickels and hid the purchase under her shawl.”Footnote 30 Ward's correspondents offered similar observations. American historian W. R. Thayer told her: “No book since Uncle Tom's Cabin has had so sudden and wide a diffusion among all classes of readers; and I believe that no other book of equal seriousness ever had so quick a hearing. I have seen it in the hands of nursery-maids, and of shop-girls behind the counter; of frivolous young women, who read every novel that is talked about; of business men, professors, students, and even schoolboys.”Footnote 31 In the spring of 1889 the St. Louis Post-Dispatch set out to discover the “literary opinions and favorite authors” of residents in dozens of small towns along the Missouri–Illinois border. Their findings, published in an article that spread across three full newspaper pages, recorded the reading preferences of hundreds of rural readers, many of whom mentioned Robert Elsmere.Footnote 32
Ward's own letters register the novel's success with “different circles” and “all classes” of readers. In March 1888 she exclaimed to her husband, “What a curious variety of people it seems to be reaching!”Footnote 33 The same month she sent a packet of letters to Goldwin Smith, remarking, “I think they show that the book is affecting different sorts of people. Most of them come from persons to whom it was not sent, but who have written spontaneously.”Footnote 34 In September 1888, when Robert Elsmere had reached a thirteenth edition, Ward mused: “It is strange to me how everyone seems to have read R. E., of all sorts + kinds”; two months later, she exclaimed, “How it has penetrated!”Footnote 35 On a visit to Toynbee Hall, the settlement house where recent Oxbridge graduates lived among the poor of the East End, Ward found the novel “read to pieces” and discovered that a workmen's club had partly modeled itself on the New Brotherhood, the religious fellowship Elsmere founds.Footnote 36 In July 1888 she forwarded to her father “a very curious letter about R. E. written by a genuine working man—though evidently one who has raised himself.”Footnote 37 In Manchester in November 1889, she visited the working-class town of Oldham, where the free library held seventeen copies of Robert Elsmere, and where “the librarian said he could never get a sight of them himself—they were always out!”Footnote 38 The novel's Manchester audience also included those who could afford a lending library: in March 1888 Ward's sister-in-law told her “that Manchester is beginning to besiege their Mudie branch for it.”Footnote 39
There is less evidence about the social span of John Inglesant's readers, yet it too seems to have had a wide audience. As we have seen, Shorthouse told Macmillan that, on the basis of his correspondence, “Every body seems to be reading it everywhere.” In December 1881 he wrote to William Angus Knight, a professor of moral philosophy at St. Andrews, “One of the most pleasing things about the book is, I think, the way it seems to have appealed to such different conditions of mind. The persons of whom you speak, Mr. Gladstone, Professor Huxley, and Mr. Fred. Pollack on the one hand, and on the other, boys, of no hitherto suspected taste for literature, who have read the book with an eagerness which has surprised their friends.”Footnote 40
As this comment suggests, the novels’ readers were also religiously diverse. John Inglesant interested the agnostic Thomas Henry Huxley, the Anglican biblical scholar Brooke Foss Westcott, and the ultramontane Catholic Henry Edward Manning,Footnote 41 whose beliefs differed from one another and from Shorthouse's fictional celebration of High Church Anglicanism. Ward, too, received a letter of admiration from Huxley and recorded exchanges about the novel with Catholics as well as with readers who held more liberal religious positions: she reported that Grant Duff, the politician and writer, agreed with the novel's criticism of Christianity but objected to its reformed version, and that Unitarians were more receptive.Footnote 42 The spiritualist Frederick Myers was “enthusiastic, but begg[ed] me in future work, to take psychical research into consideration.”Footnote 43 The novel's apparent affinities with Unitarianism deterred some readers: the Quaker minister and social activist Elizabeth Comstock reported knowing of a couple who stopped halfway through, despite their “great interest,” because they objected to its “strong Unitarianism.” But she also knew a Congregationalist woman who “sat up all night reading it.” Comstock read it herself.Footnote 44 And the novel was also appreciated by members of the Anglican Church. Politician Alfred Lyttelton allowed Ward to dedicate it to the memory of his wife, Laura, permission that Ward had not expected to receive, “for all the Lytteltons belong to the Church side.”Footnote 45 Ward also exchanged letters about it with two Anglican bishops, Reginald Stephan Copleston and Mandell Creighton, and records other conversations with Anglican readers.Footnote 46 Robert Elsmere and John Inglesant were read and discussed by readers across what Taylor describes as the expanding nova of belief positions at the end of the nineteenth century.
2. Public Readings of Robert Elsmere and John Inglesant
Among this diverse array of readers, some did find in the novels an appealing representation of their private religious experience. The artist Edward Burne-Jones, who had originally intended to become a clergyman, wrote to Ward apropos of Robert Elsmere, “of course it interests me—isn't it all about the old life I remember and felt so rebellious about?” He added, “I am back again five and thirty years and feeling softened and subdued with memories you have wakened up so piercingly.”Footnote 47 In 1890 Shorthouse replied to a letter from the mother of a young man who found “John Inglesant vacillating with similar conflicting doubts to his own”; Shorthouse replied that he had intended such identification to be part of the reading experience, writing, “What reason is there why John Inglesant, or I, or any other man should be free from these doubts any more than your son is free from them?”Footnote 48 Some readers portrayed Robert Elsmere as the cause of their change in belief. In her memoir Testament of Youth, Vera Brittain listed Ward's novel, which she read during her adolescence, as one of the books that had “determined the direction in which I was moving.” Calling it a “deistic tract,” she remembered that it “converted me from an unquestioning if somewhat indifferent church-goer into an anxiously interrogative agnostic.”Footnote 49 Julian Huxley, Ward's nephew, similarly recalled that the novel “made a deep impression on me, and helped to convert me to what I must call a religious humanism, but without belief in any personal God.”Footnote 50
Yet readers also responded by finding in the novels spiritual comfort and affirmation of their religious positions. Sarah Shorthouse wrote of her husband, “he often had the consolation of knowing that his words had met the needs of many wayfarers who, like himself, were seeking to ‘tread the King's highway of the Holy Cross,’”Footnote 51 and this claim is borne out in correspondence. In March 1881 Shorthouse wrote to his cousin Isabel Southall, “The concluding passage of your letter is naturally most gratifying and assuring to me; some time—at an entirely suitable opportunity—it would be very interesting to know from you the precise way in which the book has appeared to you capable of conveying ‘spiritual blessing.’”Footnote 52 The following December, Shorthouse expressed his gratitude to Knight “for your kindness in telling me so much of the way John Inglesant has been received among your friends. It is, as you well say, delightful to learn that anything that you have written has become such a help as you describe.”Footnote 53 A similar exchange recurs two decades later in a letter to “an Invalid Gentleman”: “I have received a kind message from you through your friend,” Shorthouse wrote; “It must always, of course, be a satisfaction to a man to know that he has written a book which has given so much pleasure and help.” Sarah Shorthouse explains in a footnote that the reader in question “wished the author to be told of the very great comfort and help that John Inglesant had been to him in his severe illness.”Footnote 54 The American author Sarah Orne Jewett had a similar response to Ward's fiction, telling her fellow author in 1892 “what a delight and what a new treasure of helpfulness and inspiration your great books always are to me as they are to so many.”Footnote 55
Both types of response—those that registered religious loss, and those that found spiritual comfort in the books—accord with the view that Robert Elsmere was popular because it portrayed recognizable religious experience, because it produced in readers the type of “inner revelation” that Warner attributes to sermons. For all these readers, the novels played a role in their personal experiences of navigating the “cross-pressures” of the nineteenth century. But there were also many readers who engaged with Ward's novel, and with Shorthouse's, yet did not identify with their protagonists or approach the books primarily in relation to their own intimate religious experience. For such readers, the novels were closer to public speech in producing the awareness that the books were not only speaking to them; their experience of Robert Elsmere and John Inglesant was one of public reading. Such reading is represented in contemporary accounts of the books’ reception. In mid-April 1888, two months after Robert Elsmere was published, the “Metropolitan Notes” section in the Nottingham Evening Post and the Grantham Journal reported, apropos of London, “One hardly joins a group of gossipers without hearing the work spoken of.”Footnote 56 The following month, the Christian Union, a family periodical published in New York, claimed that the novel's “theme is the after-dinner talk of English society; it is the literary event of the season.”Footnote 57 Its popularity soon spread to the United States. Writing to her husband in October 1888, Ward quoted an American publisher who had told her, “Robert Elsmere is in the mouth of nearly the whole reading public.”Footnote 58 The previous month, a “Special Correspondent” to the Hartford Courant, who signed herself F. O. H., had told readers that this was true in New York City, complaining that she was “tired of having my neighbor, no matter where I dined, begin his conversation with, ‘What do you think of “Robert Elsmere”?’”Footnote 59
These discussions were so common that they became objects of satire. In February 1889 the Pall Mall Gazette reprinted a comic exchange from the Atlanta Journal titled “The Old Question”: Reginald Young inquires whether “Miss Mabel” would “consider me impertinent should I ask you the old question?”—not “will you marry me?” but “have you read ‘Robert Elsmere’?”Footnote 60 By May 1889 the North-Eastern Daily Gazette was claiming that most people were avoiding magazine articles about the novel and trying to avoid conversation: “In company one waits in agony for the inevitable question, ‘How do you like “Robert Elsmere”?’ When it comes there comes also to the lips the beseeching exclamation of afflicted Job—‘Have pity on me, O my friends!’”Footnote 61
Similarly comic and satirical commentary circulated about John Inglesant. In June 1882 an exasperated Saturday Review called for the formation of an “Anti-John Inglesant Society.” The weekly complained that whereas usually the discussion of a popular novel faded within a couple of months,
there is no escaping from John Inglesant. At every dinner, in every society, a moment comes when some one says, “Have you read John Inglesant ?” Even in church there is no refuge for the hunted one. Preachers ask fiercely in their sermons, “Have you read John Inglesant?” . . . By this time we know from the expression of a lady's face when she is going to ask this question, and we reply, without waiting for the inquiry, “No, we have not read John Inglesant.”Footnote 62
In 1883 a number of British provincial newspapers circulated a quip about Shorthouse's novel: “‘Have you read “John Inglesant”?’ was not so very long ago a leading question at dinner parties. Had it been differently framed and had asked whether the book had been read through, the answer might not have been so often in the affirmative.”Footnote 63
Jürgen Habermas argues that the end of the nineteenth century saw a shift from a “culture debating” to a “culture consuming” public; the “rational-critical debate” of the former gave way to the leisure reading of the latter, whose hallmark was the absence of all serious discussion. The ease with which responses to Robert Elsmere and John Inglesant were satirized might make their reception seem more like consumption than debate. The correspondent for the Hartford Courant reported that dinner-table conversations focused on the novel's characters: “I have heard many comments on the character of Catherine,” she observed, adding that women favored her and Robert himself, whereas “the sterner sex give all their smiles to the beautiful, willful Rose”; she described “the vehement and eloquent manner of an eminent and eloquent D. D.” on this point.Footnote 64 These readers did not discuss the varying religious positions represented by Robert, Catherine, and Rose. Instead, they gossiped about personality—“character”—and, in Rose's case, sexual appeal. Such treatment is satirized in the British comic magazine Pick-Me-Up: a piece from 1893 describes the efforts of a hostess who, in an endeavor to make the conversations at her dinner parties less frivolous, settles on Robert Elsmere from “a list of interesting subjects capable of intelligent treatment”; her guests comment that they “know Elsmere” well and will be seeing him shortly, or that they plan to have a dress made of Elsmere, or that they are eager to eat some.Footnote 65 The hostess's attempt to foster discussion is foiled by dinner guests who experience culture only in terms of consumption or self-display.
But there were also readers for whom the novels were an occasion for serious debate. In this, they may have taken a cue from the reception of the books in the periodical press, where they were widely reviewed and discussed. Perhaps the most significant of these articles, one that shaped much of the subsequent response, was by former prime minister William Gladstone, one of the nineteenth century's most public figures, whose review of Robert Elsmere appeared in Nineteenth Century in May 1888. Far from identifying with Elsmere (or any other character), the politician criticized both the fictional clergyman's change in belief and the new creed he develops. In Gladstone's view, Elsmere's loss of faith is motivated by a set of arguments that had been refuted by Christian apologists, and Ward's failure to reference those apologists shows inadequate expertise in theological matters. Gladstone also argues that the new belief system Elsmere develops drains Christianity of its essence: a nondivine Christ, Gladstone asserts, cannot provide spiritual sustenance, especially to those wrestling with sin. These theological critiques are framed by a literary one. Gladstone begins his review by discussing the problems involved when a novel tries to make a theological argument: “A treatise must nowhere beg the question it seeks to decide, but must carry its reader onwards by reasoning patiently from step to step. But the writer of the romance, under the convenient necessity which his form imposes, skips in thought, over undefined distances, from stage to stage, as a bee from flower to flower.”Footnote 66 Theological treatises are thorough in their arguments; they do not pass over objections and counterarguments. Novel writers, however, are flighty, even shallow: drawn to showy flowers, they miss the terrain in between.Footnote 67
Still, for all his criticisms, Gladstone's review constituted a remarkable acknowledgment of Robert Elsmere's importance; though it disagrees with Elsmere's religious position, it effectively presents that position as valid by devoting attention to it in England's premier intellectual journal. His response—at once a public expression of his private piety and a public affirmation that such piety was no longer the only option—circulated beyond the elite pages of Nineteenth Century in countless redactions, summaries, snippets, and pamphlets and in the pages of other writers, who repeated or developed his ideas.Footnote 68 More broadly, his review did much to set the tone for what followed, presenting Robert Elsmere as an argumentative book whose claims needed to be unraveled and challenged by the reader.
Gladstone thus helped establish Robert Elsmere as an occasion for public reading, and others pursued such reading from a wide range of positions. Some responded from a standpoint closer to unbelief. Agnostic Robert Ingersoll considered the novel problematically “conservative,” as “an effort to save something—a few shreds and patches and ravelings—from the wreck” of Christianity.Footnote 69 In voicing this critique, Ingersoll made the novel part of the public discourse on religion in which he was engaged: since the 1870s he had lectured and written widely on the subject and had popularized biblical criticism in the United States, and in 1888 he had an exchange with Gladstone in the pages of the North American Review.Footnote 70 W. D. Childs told Ward that he regretted how seriously the novel treated religion, which he thought would “revive interest in theology and retard the progress of rationalism.”Footnote 71 Grant Duff wrote that he shared her views, but “he deprecates the attempt to make anything new + would rather poetize and allegorize the old.”Footnote 72 But the novel received more critiques from those who held traditional Christian views, reminding us, as Frances Knight and Mark Knight have done, of the continued significance of Christianity at the fin de siècle.Footnote 73 Frances Anne Conybeare (supposedly one of the models for Catherine) wrote to Ward arguing that the “‘mere life and death of the carpenter's son of Nazareth could never have proved the vast historical influence for good which you allow it to be,’ had that life ended in ‘nothing but a Syrian grave.’”Footnote 74 Mandell Creighton, the bishop of London, wrote Ward a lengthy critique of the novel; though Creighton's letter is not preserved, Ward's detailed response allows us to infer something of its contents. Creighton seems to have told Ward that her main character had never been a Christian, or “he could not have been influenced as he was.” Ward defended Elsmere against Creighton's claim that he is “‘very ill-trained’ and his impressions ‘accidental.’”Footnote 75 Timothy Larsen makes the compelling suggestion that Robert Elsmere's popularity might be due to readers who believed yet feared the threat to faith represented by new religious positions.Footnote 76 Though fear is not the primary affect of Conybeare's response or Creighton's inferred critique, in their eagerness to articulate and defend their own positions we might detect a trace of anxiety.
Another episcopal correspondent, Reginald Copleston, the bishop of Colombo, presents an even fuller experience of Taylor's secularity 3 as he criticizes the novel's religious views. He wrote to Ward,
I have this confidence—+ you would agree to it—that this loving God in whom we trust will not fail to guide you to the Truth. At this moment, you + I do not agree in what direction that Truth is, we agree this: that the living Truth himself is guiding you—by what paths who can say?—towards himself.Footnote 77
Copleston recognizes the validity of a religious position very different from his own, and he attempts to make sense of that difference by imagining a reconciliation in divine time. His response is similar to Lyttelton's: when the latter gave Ward permission to dedicate Robert Elsmere to his wife's memory, he told her that he thought “the ultimate effect of the book is religious.”Footnote 78
Anglican readers who did not, themselves, experience the cross-pressures the novel describes in the same way as its protagonist thus engaged with Robert Elsmere ; these readers also did not identify with the Anglican Catherine. Instead, like Gladstone, they reflected on the religious position they saw the novel taking. We see a similar dynamic among Roman Catholic readers of John Inglesant, though Shorthouse's novel presents a far more negative account of Catholicism than Robert Elsmere gives of Anglicanism. The novel's anti-Catholicism centers in its portrayal of Father St Clare, the Jesuit priest who is the novel's villain. In January 1882 Shorthouse wrote to Macmillan, “I am of course interested to hear of Cardinal Manning reading the book. It is curious that he should prefer the 1st vol. Most R Catholics object exceedingly to the character of the Jesuit in it, which they say is an impossibility.”Footnote 79 The problems presented by the fictional priest animated other readers as well. Writing to Edwin Abbott in November 1880, Shorthouse remarked: “Whether such a Jesuit is true to nature or not is another question. I have had a very interesting correspondence with a Benedictine monk upon this point. He condemns Father St. Clare as a monster of atheism and villainy, impossible in the Society of Jesus.”Footnote 80
The figure of St Clare was taken up by the historian and Catholic John Dalberg-Acton, who corresponded about John Inglesant with Mary Gladstone, William Gladstone's daughter and an enthusiast for the novel.Footnote 81 Acton did not consider St Clare impossible but thought that he had been unrealistically portrayed. Shorthouse reacted defensively to Acton's letter, shown to him by a mutual friend: “He seems to misunderstand the character of the book and to have read it, as he says, hastily.”Footnote 82 Considering that the letter in question runs fifteen pages long, it is hard not to see Shorthouse's remark as authorial pique. Acton not only tabulates a series of factual errors but criticizes Inglesant's vacillations in belief as arbitrary, a problem he thinks Shorthouse could have avoided by making use of many seventeenth-century philosophers and theologians whose ideas he fails to include. Mary Gladstone told Acton that she thought he should publish his response; though he demurred, her reaction captures the public quality of his assessment.
Acton gave particular attention to the novel's conclusion, which he called unsatisfying for its lack of detail about Inglesant's final embrace of the Anglican Church: “there is no transition. The passage is made by the help of no subtler agency than a Newhaven smack. The thing is unexplained, inartistic, inorganic, but quite consistent with the drifting nature of Inglesant.”Footnote 83 Thus we see that for Acton, religious and literary critiques blended together: the problem with the end of John Inglesant is that it is “inartistic, inorganic” in its failure to portray the climax of the protagonist's journey; this lacuna also means that the novel omits the culmination of its argument for Anglicanism. Acton's criticism thus anticipates Gladstone's in the way it entwines literary and religious considerations.Footnote 84
Acton is not exceptional in attending to the literary qualities of these novels. Ward told her mother, in a letter dated March 15, 1888, that she had heard “that Mrs. Ritchie is very full of R. E., + says it has made her reconsider all her theories of novel-writing + its necessary limitations.”Footnote 85 For judge Charles Bowen,Footnote 86 this combination seemed less unexpected: “the sense of having rendered a really artistic thing, must become twice as sweet when in doing so you can feel, as you may, that you have been trying to paint what is good and loveable in itself.”Footnote 87 American abolitionist Sallie Holley responded to a proposal sometimes made by the novel's critics: “The reason ‘why the evangelical clergy don't meet the book on its own ground,’ that is, fight Robert Elsmere with another book, is because they cannot do it. No more could slaveholders meet Uncle Tom's Cabin by another book representing the truth and power of slavery.”Footnote 88 Oliver Wendell Holmes made a similar comparison: Ward records a letter from him calling Robert Elsmere “unquestionably the most popular + effective novel we have had since Uncle Tom's Cabin.”Footnote 89 But not everyone who commented on Robert Elsmere's literary aspects was so favorable. Benjamin Jowett wrote to Ward, “my feeling is that you have the ability + knowledge which would make a great authoress but in the realm of serious writing rather than of fiction.”Footnote 90 Creighton seems to have voiced a similar opinion about Ward's 1892 novel David Grieve ; Ward told him, “David Grieve's journal will probably be the last piece of controversial religion I shall ever put into a novel. You are quite right in thinking the form of it too academical. The expression is wrong in the more literary part.”Footnote 91
In their remarks on Robert Elsmere's literary qualities, these responses all pick up on issues that were central to the novel's public reception. Robert Elsmere animated a debate about the capacities and limits of fiction: as we have seen, Gladstone's review stressed that novels were dangerous venues for argument, because of the novelist's ability to make leaps of logic. Others, however, applauded Robert Elsmere's incorporation of theological and religious issues: the London Daily News, for example, declared that “‘Robert Elsmere’ has an interest for the student of literature in proving the wide range and adaptability of the novel. . . . It seems to promise a new departure, in which we shall take most of our problems in this captivating form.”Footnote 92 This discussion is picked up in the responses of Ritchie, Bowen, Holley, and Holmes. In comparing Robert Elsmere to Uncle Tom's Cabin, Holley and Holmes affirm fiction's ability to intervene in public matters and to present arguments on topics of public interest. Ritchie's reconsideration of her novel-writing theories echoes the Daily News's acclamation of Ward's novel as a “new departure” in the novel's ability to present “problems.” Bowen's praise might initially seem rather generic, but it was hardly a matter of universal agreement that Robert Elsmere was “really artistic.” On the other hand, Creighton and Jowett express the view that fiction is ill-suited to handling theological issues: “controversial religion,” “serious writing,” and “academical” form are separated, for them, from fiction and the literary.
As Miriam Burstein has shown, the question of fiction's ability to engage theological issues was at least as old as the century.Footnote 93 Yet this question became particularly charged at the fin de siècle in response to theological novels. At a moment when religious positions were multiplying, and the sense of possible beliefs expanding, the question of whether fiction could handle theology was a question of where religion would be located, how it could be discussed, and who could discuss it. Copleston picked up on the charge of this issue in his letter to Ward: after telling her about his difficulties with the publication of his study Buddhism Primitive and Present in Magadha and in Ceylon (1892), he added: “It is dangerous to joke in a letter, where there is no tone or look to correct matters in an instant if the joke is taken for earnest, else I should say: How delightful it must be to write books where there are no facts, no reference, no responsibility; where all comes freely + flowingly out of your own hand, + can't be found out!”Footnote 94 Copleston's nervous hedging (“dangerous to joke”) may register his awareness that such comments had indeed been made in earnest: this is the substance of Gladstone's critique, that novels need not have “facts” or “reference”; that they have no “responsibility,” that they can simply omit inconvenient ideas, and that they are, in consequence, not reliable as vehicles for theological arguments.
Robert Elsmere and John Inglesant also received attention from readers who, though they thought novels were as capable as treatises of making arguments on theological topics, questioned the specific ways that Ward and Shorthouse had gone about this. Thus for Acton the unsatisfactory quality of Inglesant's religious narrative was both an intellectual problem and a literary one: the novel would be better, as a novel, if it were intellectually more robust. “A fine opportunity has been wasted,” Acton complains:
A clever, refined, high-spirited youth, who has won, in a religious philosophy, a standing ground apart from Churches, who yet learns to sympathise with them, and who sheds his prejudices and illusions as he grows in spiritual experience; that would be a noble study in the days of Grotius, Descartes, Lord Herbert, Hammond, Baxter, Roger Williams, Blondel, Raynaud, and Pascal. None of these appear on the platform.Footnote 95
Fiction and philosophy meld as Acton envisions an alternative John Inglesant, one in which the title character is the imaginary counterpart of real early modern thinkers, whose ideas are interwoven with the novel's own religious position. But in either case Acton imagines the novel as a “platform,” a scene of public debate.
Edmond Scherer, a French theologian to whom Ward sent Robert Elsmere when it was in manuscript, considered the issue of fiction's relationship to theological argument with particular nuance. His letter to her about the novel praised its “creative art,” its portrayal of character, and its style; he called it “as a novel, a very entertaining and very remarkable one,” but then complicated this assessment: “it is a work with a tendency, a teaching work. It destroys and builds up. I do not think it is equally successful in both tasks.” The lack of success lay, for Scherer, in the “building up” of the third volume: he thought that “the chief fault of the book” was in the way that the “plan for a new Civitas Dei,” worked out through Elsmere's “propagandism and philanthropic efforts,” takes over the end of the book, such that “the third volume almost dwindles into a religious biography, into a book meant for edification rather than amusement.”Footnote 96 Ward, forwarding this letter to Smith, remarked “That he would be out of sympathy with the optimism of the 3rd vol I knew.”Footnote 97 But this account of Scherer's response underplays the real essence of his critique, which is not of the novel's religious position but of the way it weaves that position into a work of fiction.
Yet Scherer does not say that the novel, as a genre, could not take up religious issues or make arguments. Rather, as Acton does with John Inglesant, he criticizes the particular way Robert Elsmere goes about this. His discussion of the novel's “critique of orthodox beliefs” praises that critique as “masterly,” anticipates that it will “leave a mark” in the religious world, and predicts that it “will diffuse notions which have never been presented, at least in a popular form, so ably and so unanswerably.”Footnote 98 Here he suggests that the book successfully combines the literary and the theological, putting into fiction an argument expert enough to impact the religious world, yet sufficiently novelistic to interest readers not otherwise engaged with theological debates. For Scherer, the problems in the third volume of Robert Elsmere are problems in Ward's artistic choices, rather than proof that the novel qua novel cannot handle religious debate.
Yet another position on Robert Elsmere's literary and religious elements is presented by a reader who found the novel's artistic excellence troubling given her divergence from its religious views:
She has been deeply interested. She thinks the relation of Robert + Catherine a masterpiece, dramatic + consistent throughout, + she was full of appreciation of it all. [‘]But of course’ she said, ‘you cannot expect us to rejoice in it, or to wish that it should spread largely among those who would have no defence against it. We feel the power of it too much, and Catherine beautiful as she is not the champion we should + might have chosen.’ All this she said as nicely as possible + it was very interesting to me—Footnote 99
Ward's interlocutor focuses on Robert and Catherine's marriage, which dramatizes the debate between orthodox faith and Robert's new beliefs; the emotional intensity with which the two negotiate their divergent views and abiding mutual love was noted and applauded by many readers, including Gladstone, who called it “the real battle” of the novel. This reader registers the power of this plot while also demurring from the particular way that Catherine serves as a “champion” of Christian belief; her response seems to split between artistic admiration and intellectual criticism. Also notable here is her use of the pronoun “we”: the reading experience was, for her, not private or individual but rather collective; she read as one member of a faith community.
This reader, and Scherer, share with other responses a concern with how other readers were reading or would read. Scherer thinks about how working-class readers and religious scholars will respond to the novel. The reader cited above worries about how it will be read by believers who have not provided themselves with a “defense” against the novel's criticisms of Christianity. A similar preoccupation with other readers emerges in comments that attribute Robert Elsmere's success to the way that it rendered private issues public. Jowett remarked apropos of the novel's impressive sales, “It has considerable merit, but its success is really due to its saying what everybody is thinking.”Footnote 100 Holley wrote, “Mrs. Ward reveals the thoughts of . . . many earnest, greatly consecrated souls and intensely devoted minds,—honest, clear-seeing intellects”; elsewhere, she muses, “I have no doubt that love of popularity keeps many people from avowing their honest convictions.”Footnote 101 The historian Goldwin Smith, writing to Ward from Toronto, thought that even though “religion shows every sign of vitality,” that appearance was an illusion: “the state of opinions on this Continent is, I fancy, pretty much that which Robert Ellesmere would bring us—Theism, with Christ as a model of character but without real belief in the miraculous part of Christianity.”Footnote 102 These comments evoke a moment of religious fluctuation, a sense that belief is now shifting for many and that fiction has captured that change, making it available to public discussion. They also exemplify public reading: these readers’ responses to Robert Elsmere foreground how other people respond to Robert Elsmere.
A similar sense of the novels’ publicness and their relation to religious change underpins the feeling of obligation that some readers felt with respect to these books. In March 1888 Ward reported, “We have had an afternoon party here today, mostly consisting of people who have read it or are struggling through it.”Footnote 103 Those “struggling” readers must have felt a duty or compulsion to persist with a long and difficult novel. Such feelings emerge in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch interviews with readers. Some of these readers experienced an obligation to mention Robert Elsmere, whether, like Carrie Given or Morris Kleeman, they “haven't read ‘Elsmere,’” or whether, like Maude Elocum, their list of preferred novels includes “of course ‘Robert Elsmere.’”Footnote 104 The sense of obligation attending the novel is registered even by those who disliked it. When asked her opinions about fiction by the Post-Dispatch, Helen Newton volunteered, “I don't like ‘Robert Elsmere,’” and Jennie Ferris made sure to mention that the novel was “her pet aversion.”Footnote 105
We see another expression of this sense of obligation in reports of the physical circumstances of reading. In October 1888 Ward wrote to Smith, “An American correspondent writing to me today says ‘you would have been amused could you have been present incog[nito] at our seaside Fairyland . . . this past summer—where Robert Elsmere was in every yacht + hammock + tennis court’ &c &c.”Footnote 106 These American vacationers brought the novel into their everyday activities. So did less privileged readers. In December 1888 the New-York Tribune published two vignettes to support their claim that Robert Elsmere was “read eagerly by all classes of people.” The first pictured “a young man, poorly but neatly dressed,” reading, “with avidity,” a paperback edition of the novel in the elevated train “after midnight”; the second described a train conductor reading, between stops, “a well-preserved copy of one of the cheap editions,” which he “handl[ed] as if it were a cherished treasure,” hiding it carefully under a seat cushion and “taking the utmost pains to see that the corners of the cover did not get wrinkled in the process of depositing it in its resting-place.”Footnote 107 Both sketches evoke a reader who is lower class but respectable—the young man's poor but neat clothing is echoed by the carefully handled cheap edition—and who reads the novel with commendable seriousness; the second vignette concludes that the conductor was “disobeying the rules of the company” but “ought to be let off lightly” if found out.Footnote 108 If these readers seem far from the inhabitants of the Fairyland evoked by Ward's correspondent, they are similar in the way that they fold their reading into things they would be doing anyway: the conductor reads while working, and the young man while perhaps commuting home after work. These ways of reading convey a sense of urgency, a sense that this was a book that needed to be read, a book whose reading could not be postponed or suspended to pursue other activities and commitments. Moreover, the situation of these readers—all of whom are reading in public places—registers the sense that the reading of the novel was a public act, an act that took place in public and that had the aim of enabling the reader to participate in public discussion. We see such discussion recollected by A. R. Ramsey, a columnist for the Ladies Home Journal, who in the fall of 1889 remembered that the previous summer Robert Elsmere had been the subject of the question “‘Have you read it?’ which serves as the starting point of all conversation on hotel piazza, or village lawn.”Footnote 109 According to her recollection, the novel served as a foundation of public life, a basis on which to establish relationships between strangers, an opportunity to enter into conversation in public spaces.
In August 1888 the American poet and essayist Louise Guiney wrote to a friend: “We hear no news. Ye weather is Sheolic in heat. Pears iz out, and apples iz in. The air is blue with Robert Elsmere, and with gossip over Miss Phelps, who has indulged in the private eccentricity of getting married to a missionary-man, of Apollo's age.”Footnote 110 Warner distinguishes gossip from public discourse: the former is precisely not a relation among strangers, because gossip is exchanged between people who know each other and also know the person gossiped about.Footnote 111 But although the structure of Guiney's sentence seems to equate Robert Elsmere with gossip, given what we have seen it seems more appropriate to understand this letter as shifting from public discussion to private speech. Even if Guiney is referencing discussions of the novel among people known to each other, it seems likely that those discussions were inflected by the awareness of a larger conversation about the novel, a conversation taking place among strangers. The appeal of Ward's novel, and Shorthouse's, lay not in their presentation of private experiences of religious crisis with which all their readers identified, but in the opportunity they afforded to read and to debate one's reading in public.
3. Conclusion
Among Ward's correspondents was Henry James, whose letter to her about Robert Elsmere dwelt at length on the subplot that concerns Rose, whose musical ambition and energy bring her into conflict with her sister Catherine. James questioned this element of the novel: “with Rose—here I am much in the dark—and I don't understand your full intention . . . why—if she is only going not to act herself out, not to affirm the full artistic, aesthetic (I don't know what to call it—untheological) view of life, I don't exactly see why you gave her so much importance.”Footnote 112 James, a key figure in the development of professional literary criticism in the twentieth century, responds to Ward's novel in terms of form: bypassing the debates that animated Victorian audiences, he thinks about Robert Elsmere in relation to an ideal of the novel as an organic whole, in which all parts work together toward the same end. “I can't helping wishing that you had made her serious, deeply so, in her own line, as Catherine, for instance, is serious in hers. Then, if she had been more strenuous and complete, the opposition would have been more real and complete,” James writes, expressing not only a wish that the novel had upheld a religion of art but also a wish that it had constructed a strong opposition.Footnote 113 Indeed, what seems important to James is the opposition as a formal structure. James is not alone, in the nineteenth century, in commenting on Rose's plot or even in remarking its odd prominence, but he is unusual in focusing on it in such purely aesthetic terms.
Yet James is also influenced by the public reading that, I have argued, was the primary mode of response to Robert Elsmere. Writing about Ward in the English Illustrated Magazine in 1892, shortly before the publication of Ward's novel David Grieve, James omitted his formal critique of Robert Elsmere to instead foreground the reception of the book, which, he wrote, “was not merely an extraordinarily successful novel; it was, as reflected in contemporary conversation, a momentous public event.”Footnote 114 His article engages, too, with the question of whether novels could deal with theology: James asserts that Ward “accomplished the feat, unique, so far as I remember, in the long and usually dreary annals of the novel with a purpose, of carrying out her purpose without spoiling her novel.”Footnote 115 Thus even the nineteenth century's foremost advocate for the English-language novel as a work of art was drawn to participate in the public reading that defined the reception of Robert Elsmere.
