This rich and masterful study explores the complicated and often contradictory history of US intervention in Nicaragua, from the era of Manifest Destiny through the period of dollar diplomacy and military occupation. While others have trodden this ground, Gobat sheds new light on much-studied topics, from William Walker's filibustering in the mid-1850s to Augusto Sandino's rebellion against US occupation (1927–33), by stepping outside of the more dogmatic historiographic traditions that tend to oversimplify the lived experiences of empire and modernity. Gobat argues that Nicaraguan elites saw in US cultural values, such as liberal democracy, and forms, such as railroads and baseball, great possibilities for crafting an independent, cosmopolitan nation. These same values and forms, however, often produced unsettling changes that when joined to experiences of the darker side of US intervention led many of Nicaragua's most profoundly Americanised elites to turn away in scorn. Gobat's nuanced arguments on the uneven embrace and rejection of ‘Americanisation’ are not simply compelling, but also highlight the need to attend to the shifting landscapes of political, economic, social and cultural history. The simpleton's claim that ‘they hate freedom’ may suffice as a sound-bite explanation for anti-Americanism, but Gobat's study should serve as a model for understanding the deeply ambivalent relationships that develop between the United States and those countries over which it exerts its imperial might.
The book is organised in four major chronological sections. The first part examines the potential inter-oceanic canal across Nicaragua as the site of paradoxical developments between Nicaragua and the United States from the Gold Rush era through the emergence of dollar diplomacy. Despite the disastrous encounter with William Walker's filibuster campaign in 1856, Nicaraguan elites envisioned the canal and the United States as opportunities and models for cosmopolitan economic and cultural change. Their pro-American sentiments, however, were temporarily soured by the USA's choice of the Panama route in 1902 and the deteriorating relationship with, and subsequent intervention against, José Santos Zelaya in 1910. The second part explores the aftermath of intervention and how US support for conservative oligarchs in the name of stability engendered a paradoxically liberal anti-Americanism. Despite this, US financial intervention transformed the political and economic landscape. The third part analyses the local impact of dollar diplomacy between 1912 and the civil war of 1926–7, notably the unintentional levelling of rural economic opportunity and class relations that attended US control over Nicaragua's financial markets and instruments. Coupled with cultural threats to the gendered and social order, these changes led one-time pro-American conservatives to become some of the most ardent critics of the vision of US-style modernity. The fourth part tackles the US military intervention in response to the civil war of 1926–7 and ‘the democratizing impulses of U.S. imperial rule’ (p. 231). US occupation led to resistance from both the newly anti-American conservatives and the revolutionary forces of Augusto Sandino. Sandino's successful struggle against US forces attracted the conservatives, but with the withdrawal of the US military in 1933, the cleavages between their ‘reaction and utopian forms of anti-Americanism’ (p. 266) proved unbridgeable.
At turns cultural, political and economic, Gobat's analysis relies on an astounding and diverse array of sources. Dozens of newspapers, novels and memoirs are complemented by archival materials from Nicaragua and the United States, including personal and private papers, correspondence, court cases and land and mortgage registries. Gobat's seamless incorporation of local archival materials in Granada, in particular, allows him to home in on the local context without losing track of the wider national and international implications of empire. The book is enhanced by five beautifully rendered maps and dozens of photographs drawn from Nicaraguan and US archives. The images subtly but effectively augment Gobat's argument on the cultural and economic influence of US modernity in Nicaragua.
The book's engaging narrative and incisive argument recommend it to readers ranging from advanced undergraduates to specialists. Gobat ends with a brief and timely epilogue that places Nicaragua within the long century of US empire and elucidates the ‘more deeply rooted’ sources of blowback to US intervention (p. 278). It is in these linkages, between the local and the international and between the cultural and the political, that Gobat is most effective. At the same time, it is this localised approach that opens his analysis to a key question and critique. Given the deeply regionalised and divided history of Nicaragua, how fully can we extrapolate the experience of Granada's elites to other regions and the national level? Hopefully Gobat's extraordinary study will push others to take up this call.
