Kit Morrell's book constitutes the publication of her PhD thesis, and deals with the efforts on the part of Roman politicians to reform the governance of the Roman provinces during the years 70–50 b.c. In particular, it analyses the initiatives of Pompey the Great and Cato the Younger to curb bribery and improve both governing practices in the provinces and the welfare of the provincials. The book tackles several important issues, and undoubtedly raises a series of questions that will encourage further discussion on late republican politics.
The introduction presents a short survey of earlier attempts to reform provincial governance, setting the scene and contextualising the following discussion. M.’s approach does not subscribe to the vision of the crisis of the late Republic as a ‘crisis without alternative’, and accordingly presents a meticulous discussion of a considerable number of sources. Ch. 1 investigates the year of Pompey's first consulate (70 b.c.); most of the discussion deals with Verres’ trial, the restoration of the tribunes’ powers and the judicial reform carried out through the Lex Aurelia. M. argues for the presence of Pompey behind Verres’ trial, and maintains that Cicero's views (expressed through his Verrine speeches) echoed Pompey's plans for reform, which were then carried on through the tribunes of 67 b.c. Ch. 2 deals with Pompey's campaigns against the pirates and Mithridates; here, M. emphasises Pompey's innovative solution of the re-settlement of pirates, the lasting impact of his organisation of the eastern provinces, as well as his display of clemency, restraint and honesty in the direction of the military campaign, in his dealings with client or allied kingdoms and in the management of the provinces. M. argues that Pompey was influenced by, if not properly a follower of, Stoic philosophy, particularly Posidonian ideas, which seem to have informed his actions. This is a point that deserves attention, although reconstruction of the personal philosophical preferences of a figure like Pompey can often only be conjectural; one can also add that the reconstruction of Posidonius’ philosophical thought is affected by the paucity and problematic condition of the fragments of his works. Furthermore, Pompey clearly took great care in diffusing his own account of the campaigns through the works of Theophanes of Mytilene and, probably, Posidonius, which we do not possess, but were subsequently used as sources by later historians. We thus know very little of how Pompey wanted his feats during the eastern campaigns to be represented. Finally, M.’s analysis of inscriptions praising Pompey dedicated by the cities in Asia does not take into adequate consideration the degree of standardisation of epithets used to celebrate benefactors in general.
Ch. 3 presents a stronger argument for Cato's Stoicism as informing his political decisions, along with an analysis of his mission to Cyprus; this is followed, in ch. 4, by a thorough discussion of the Lex Iulia de pecuniis repetundis, passed by Caesar during his consulate in 59 b.c. M. argues that, rather than a reconceptualisation of the lex repetundarum, Caesar's law was only the latter stage of a process, and probably the result of a collaboration in which Pompey and Cato took part, with less input from Caesar than previously thought. M. states that ‘a new extortion law was a somewhat surprising move for Caesar in 59’ (141); however, one can argue that this is not as surprising when taking into account Caesar's actions throughout his political career. These include later measures to extend the Roman citizenship to the peoples of Transpadana, his projects of reorganisation of the entire body of laws during his dictatorship and, in particular, the promotion of judiciary actions by provincials against dishonest governors at the very beginning of his career. Furthermore, his office as pontifex maximus from 63 b.c. had strengthened his image as guarantor of justice (see his defence of the Catilinarian conspirators in the same year).
Ch. 5 further elaborates on the issues still present in the extortion law of 59 b.c., and deals with Pompey's extension of it to equestrian officials in 55 b.c., as well as the trial of Rabirius Postumus. Crassus’ disastrous campaign against the Parthians and the measures undertaken by Rome after Carrhae are the topics of ch. 6; ch. 7 investigates the legislation on provincial governance promoted by Pompey in 52 b.c. The last chapter argues that Cato's policy of upright and ethical governance was followed by the governors appointed under Pompey's law, and analyses, in particular, the cases of Cicero in the province of Cilicia, Bibulus in Syria and Thermus in Asia, which seem to have attracted the attention of contemporaries.
This volume has great merit in highlighting the thrusts for reform promoted by several political protagonists in the last years of the Republic, and their active attempts to tackle the roots of issues impacting provincial governance, as well as promoting a positive and fruitful re-evaluation of Pompey's actions as a politician and as a reformer. The research is supported by an ample bibliography, and the arguments rest on the analysis of a remarkable number of sources, which, however, are sometimes pushed to their very limit. The evaluation of the protagonists’ actions at times focuses too much on their effects in the provinces, when it might have benefited from a closer consideration of the dynamics of and the repercussions on Rome's internal politics. Nevertheless, this work is a valuable addition to the scholarship on the late Republic, and will certainly become key reading for all those who conduct research on the period.
