Roma prima del mito (‘Rome before the Myth’) is a monumental work in two volumes illustrating old and new discoveries in the territory of Rome from c. 6000 to 3000 b.c., i.e. from the Neolithic to the beginning of the Bronze Age. I believe the title alludes to Andrea Carandini's equally important syntheses of the archaeological evidence of Rome from the Bronze Age to the end of the Iron Age, when historiographical and archaeological sources situate the famous figure of Romulus (A. Carandini, La nascita di Roma (1997) and Roma il primo giorno (2007)). Romulus also provided the end point for Anna Maria Bietti Sestieri's latest synthesis L'Italia nell'età del Bronzo e del Ferro: dalle Palafitte a Romolo 2200–700 a.C. (2010). While Carandini's work is still hotly debated, its importance for the archaeology of early Rome cannot be denied. This new overview by Giovanni Carboni and his colleague and friend Anna Paola Anzidei, both prematurely passed away, and their team of more than fifty contributors will prove equally important and fundamental for the history of the earliest occupation of the area.
The book presents the fruits of many years of research and excavations conducted in the territory of Rome by the Prehistory section of the Soprintendenza of Rome, since the launch of the first projects in the 1980s: ‘Progetto di ricognizione sistematica del territorio di Roma’ (‘Systematic survey of the territory of Rome’), ‘Ricerca di una comunità del Lazio Protostorico’ (‘Research of a community of Protohistoric Latium’) and ‘Roma e il Lazio dall'età della pietra alla formazione della Città’ (‘Rome and Latium from the Stone Age to the formation of the city’). As Carandini does for the formation of the city of Rome and Bietti Sestieri does for the Bronze and Iron Ages, Anzidei and Carboni present the state of the art on research for previous phases. But the book is also much more than a simple synthesis. It presents an interdisciplinary approach that shows how much can be achieved when different disciplines collaborate.
Part One of the first volume is devoted to the landscape. G. Giordani et al. (ch.1.1) present the latest research on the recent (Upper Pleistocene and Holocene) volcanic activity of the Alban Hills, which shaped the landscape of the so-called Campagna Romana. E. Cerilli et al. (ch. 1.2) illustrate the exceptional human, animal and vegetable imprints in the so-called lahar, a mud layer now dated to the end of the Pleistocene. A. Celant and D. Magri (ch. 1.3), delineate the vegetation history of the area in these early phases of occupation.
The longer Part Two provides a history of scholarship from c. 1850 to 1980 (ch. 2.1) and then of excavations and occasional discoveries over the four decades to 2009 (chs 2.2–6). The territory is analysed by sector, proceeding anti-clockwise from north-west to north-east. This section with its wealth of detail, maps and illustrations represents the backbone of the work and provides the foundations for the essays that follow. Part Three, at the beginning of the second volume, is devoted to cultural aspects and the various facies from the Neolithic to the beginning of the Bronze Age. C. Delpino and C. La Marca (chs 3.1–3) cover the different aspects of the Neolithic, from the diffusion of agriculture and impressed and linear ceramics (Ancient Neolithic), to tricromic and Serra d'Alto ceramics (Middle Neolithic) to the style of Ripoli III Fossacesia/Chassey-Lagozza (Recent/Final Neolithic). These analyses emphasise exchanges of cultural aspects, people and also raw materials from north to south and from east to west. Chs 2.4–9 cover a period from the Eneolithic to the Bronze age (i.e. from the fourth to second millennia b.c.). One novelty is that it has been possible to identify the origin of the Ortucchio facies in this region. It has also been possible to identify some communities linked to the southern facies of Gaudo (3330–2860 b.c.) and La Terza (2900–2300 b.c.), which appear quite suddenly and probably not always peacefully. But the most interesting element is the presence of many Rinaldone necropoleis, which make it possible to define a new ‘Roma-Colli Albani ed aree limitrofe’ group, which lasted about 1700 years. Finally, while the Rinaldone and Gaudo facies have been known mainly from funerary contexts, this book presents some important settlement evidence.
Parts Four and Five are dedicated respectively to lithic (Holocene) and metallurgic (Eneolithic) production. Particularly interesting are analyses of use-wear which reveal the real use of stone tools, sometime contradicting typological analysis (ch. 4.6, by I. Caricola et al.), and the analysis of fabrication techniques for ornaments from both funerary and settlement contexts (ch. 4.8, by M. Colasanti). Particularly remarkable is the study by M. Cultraro (ch. 5.2) of some axes of the ‘Roma Colli Albani’ group, which reveal connections with the east and are found with pottery which probably originated in the Aegean–Balkan area. Other essays are devoted to chemical and isotopic analyses of lead (C. Aurisicchio and L. Medeghini, ch. 5.3) and use-wear on metal artifacts and stone tools used in metal production (respectively C. Iaia and A. Dolfini, ch. 5.4, and I. Caricola, ch. 5.5).
In Part Six, C. La Marca and G. Carboni (ch. 6.1) reconstruct hut structures from pre-history to the present on the basis of comparison with nineteenth- and twentieth-century huts in the Campagna Romana and Pianura Pontina. M. N. Cerri (ch. 6.2) draws on ethnographic comparison and experimental archaeology to recognise a musical instrument in a so-called ‘walnut shell vase’ (‘vaso a guscio di noce’). Finally A. M. Anastasia et al. (ch. 6.3) discuss textile production in Neo- and Eneolithic communities.
Part Seven contains technical (V. Forte, P. Pulitani, chs. 7.2–3) and archaeometric (C. Aurisicchio, V. Forte, L. Medeghini, chs. 7.1, 5–6) analyses of pottery. Particularly interesting is the chemical analysis of metal objects by Aurisicchio and Medeghini, demonstrating the use of raw materials from far afield. Part Eight presents palaeobotanical analyses by A. Celant and collaborators. Residue analyses of Rinaldone and Gaudo jugs (ch. 8.3) reveals that fermented beverages were already in use by this time, probably for cultic or funerary purposes.
Part Nine is devoted to physical anthropology and Part Ten to zooarchaeology. Chs 9.1–2 focus on demography, mortality, pathology and trauma based on evidence from both settlement and funerary contexts. The bio-molecular analysis of F. De Angelis and O. Rickard (ch. 9.3) indicates that Eneolithic communities were quite sedentary, with few individuals from distant regions. Chs 10.1–4 and 6 analyse specific sites and also provide a general interpretation of subsistence in Eneolithic communities in Latium, while S. M. Stellacci (ch. 10.5) presents a technical and morphological analysis of animal bone instruments and their function.
The volumes are well presented and illustrated with many maps, drawings of pottery and tools, reconstructions, graphs, etc., which allow the reader to appreciate better the ideas and hypotheses in the accompanying text. It covers almost all aspects of human activity, although infancy, infant feeding and motherhood — often neglected — seem to be absent, or insufficiently emphasised. Interesting in this regard is the female pottery statuette in the shape of a violin of Cycladic (Drios) type from the settlement of Cassetta Mistici (Rome), which is relevant both for gender studies and the connection with the Cyclades (fig. 3.6.51).
As Carboni rightly emphasises, the material culture presented in these volumes confirms that the environs of Rome were a very special area at a crossroads between north and south and east and west of the Mediterranean. In this respect, it is worth repeating the importance of the axes with Levantine elements analysed by Cultraro (ch. 5.2) and the analyses that seem to confirm the eastern provenance of the deceased of the tomb at Casetta Mistici.
It is probably no coincidence that several fundamental changes in settlement organisation happened earlier and more dramatically in this area than in other parts of the peninsula. These include the first stable settlements in the Ancient Neolithic, the hypogea (Rinaldone-group Roma-Colli Albani), the capillary diffusion of stable settlements, the origin of the Ortucchio facies, the presence of Gaudo people and the local relevance of the beaker group (Final Eneolithic), as well as the aforementioned contacts with the Aegean, Anatolia and the Levant.
It is clear that the volumes are very much a collaborative work, by all those involved in or collaborating with the Prehistory and Protohistory sections of the Soprintendenza led by Anzidei and Carboni, based at the Museo delle Origini at La Sapienza University in Rome, and other Superintendents who have collaborated in the exploration and defence of this heritage. This reminds us that archaeology is and remains a combined effort. This book allows that heritage to be appreciated and re-used by specialists, students and the wider public.
