Julia Clancy-Smith's Mediterraneans reconceives of the social history of the region spatially, temporally, and conceptually. Impeccably argued, deeply and widely researched, and replete with nuanced interpretations and deft relations of individual lives, the work frames migrants, creoles, criminals, vagabonds, and others down on their luck or at the margins, not as marginal, but instead as central to the evolution of imperial, colonial, and postcolonial state formations in the region during the 19th century. Although geographically anchored in Tunis and its environs, Mediterraneans will no doubt prove broadly influential for scholars of the Middle East, empire, migration, and social history.
The work focuses on several broad themes: migration and mobility, labor both licit and illicit, and gender and sociability. These subjects reveal themselves through widely divergent source sets, whose variance arises as much out of the very purview of the archive as out of the histories themselves. Clancy-Smith embraces this challenge; rather than ignoring in despair the gaps in the archival record, or merely cataloguing the stories that have no end or even, at times, beginning, the author correctly emphasizes that the opacity of the stories of migrants and the otherwise mobile lies at their core. As a result, Mediterraneans particularly excels at depicting in aggregate the precarity of daily lives, ably demonstrating how what might otherwise seem individual tragedies or anecdotes from one person's life are illustrative of larger patterns.
The three chapters on labor, all beginning with the title “Making a Living,” note the complex legal negotiations, social transactions, and politicized skills associated with survival in metropolitan Tunis. “Work,” she contends, “is never solely about wages or gaining one's daily bread but rather ensnares individuals and families in intricate networks, positioning them in the local order” (p. 101). Those intricate entrapments, whether with consular power or local spiritual or temporal authority, weave through her rich narratives of workers in these chapters, and more broadly through the other chapters. The elaborate negotiations over the legal identity of protegés and the unprotected provided opportunities for migrants and creoles; the “informal economy” was hardly that to those who relied upon it (p. 196).
Clancy-Smith deftly addresses gender as both an object of analysis and as a methodological insight. Women's perspectives remain, in Tunisia as in most North African states, archivally discontinuous, with the voices of elite European women predominating. Clancy-Smith, however, uncovers stories of women (both European and North African) often hidden from view, ranging from the fencers of stolen goods to the elite bathers of La Marsa. The richness of such stories, ephemerally collected in the archives but never collated, attests to the prodigious research and deep instinct for sources that pervade the book. The author also returns in various chapters to the precarity of migrant and creole masculinity: gendered pride frequently provided fuel for conflicts ranging from street scuffles to diplomatic rows.
No aspect of identity proved, however, more precarious in the 19th-century Mediterranean than nationality. Simply put, such labels lacked operative force for people living in mobile communities: creoles in Tunisia often maintained only nominal ties with their homelands, and many arrived—or were dumped—in North Africa specifically to erase their place of origins. The example of the complex relationship between Maltese migrants, the British state, and London's consular representatives in Tunis demonstrates that Mediterranean migrants frequently experienced national monikers, however politically logical, as socially arbitrary. For Sicilians, Spaniards, Provençaux, and Sardinians, the social connections forged through labor, neighborhood, and religious community often took precedence.
Mediterraneans also offers two crucial and vitally needed methodological correctives for the study of empire, its foundations, and its aftermath in the broader Middle East. First, Clancy-Smith reiterates the centrality of what she calls “ethnographic” understandings of social worlds. By this she aims “not merely to salvage these life stories” (p. 6), but to delineate the experiences of their worlds. These worlds, as she so convincingly illustrates, operated at the level of the sensory, the affective, the mobile, and the personal. The warp and weft of social history unveils itself far better in these analyses of pastry makers’ battles and the political import of intercultural social callings than in the minute cataloguing of institutional categorizations. Hence, Mediterraneans returns to, or rather revivifies, a different tradition within social history and within the historical social sciences more broadly. Underlining the experiential and affective, this mode of argument respects the multiplicity of nondominant narratives precisely by refusing to abandon the larger conceptual frame. On the margins but not marginal, these migrant stories call into question our larger narratives about empire, statecraft, and the region as a whole.
This methodological insight in turn derives from a second one. Clancy-Smith refuses to succumb to “the temptation to fall back upon comfortable binaries or taxonomies of religion, civilization, empire” (pp. 10–11). The origin-stories North African states have told too often rely as much on such hoary clichés as did the colonial projects against which they rebelled. Nineteenth-century Tunis looms in this work as devoid of neat binaries, openly defiant of taxonomic imprisonment, and in constant motion across the boundaries (both literal and figurative) of a still-nascent colonial world.
Ultimately, this history of people in-between, across, and beyond boundaries dramatically revises our understanding of the formation of the polities during and after empire. “The legal armature of the modern nation-state was assembled by virtue of transnational, piecemeal processes, some of which occurred on the outermost margins of imperial formations” (p. 244). Clancy-Smith reminds historians to look for the birth of the law in its transgression. More broadly, however, this work points out that the true test of institutions lies in their universality, their application to those on the margins, and the interstices they leave for manipulation, resistance, and destruction. As movements both popular and authoritarian engage in the re-formation of the state in Tunisia, Egypt, and (with perhaps less likelihood of success) elsewhere in the region, Mediterraneans should serve as a sobering reminder to pay attention to the ways such re-formations mobilize social power. The Copts of the 21st century, no less than the Maltese of the 19th, challenge the “comfortable binaries” Clancy-Smith avoids.
