Global Markets Transformed takes us on a journey through the changing dimensions of the world market in the seven decades after 1870. During these years, the global economy underwent a remarkable transformation, as revolutionary innovations in transportation, communication, and industrial and agricultural production brought about an unprecedented acceleration in international flows of commodities, industrial goods, labor, and capital. Although these transformations extended across the globe, they had differing impacts among countries, and not everyone gained from the globalization of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.
By focusing on key commodity chains, the authors, Steven C. Topik and Allen Wells, contrast the developments in western Europe and North America, which were fundamental to the period's profound transformations, with the radically different developments in the rest of the world. Their analysis highlights difference—as opposed to homogeneity—as the indelible mark of this period. Not only were striking contrasts evident between far-flung regions of the world, but also between countries in the same region and even within the same country, in particular between those living urban and rural lives and between the rich and the poor. The authors argue that “the heterogeneity of the world economy meant that simultaneously with the ‘Great Acceleration’ that brought people together through intensified international economic relations (…) there also grew a ‘Great Divergence’ that distributed the benefits of economic and technological advance unequally” (pp. 259–60).
The book consists of three chapters, each a mosaic of self-contained sections that combine to impart the main message. As the sections are sometimes only tangentially related and the train of thought often non-linear, the argument can at times be difficult to follow, risking the reader losing the overall thesis. On the other hand, the fascinating details supplied in each section unquestionably enrich the reader's journey.
The first chapter presents an overview of the world economy in the period between 1870 and 1945. The chapter is divided into ten detached sections; while each touches on a different topic, four main ideas emerge. First, the “Second Industrial Revolution” (p. 2) that took place during this period was characterized by numerous transformations, among them the rise of new materials and products; the advent of mass-production, packaging, branding, and advertising; the appearance of large department stores; the growth of vertically integrated corporations; and a gradual change in global leadership from the United Kingdom to the United States and Germany. With these changes came an increase in social tensions, which occasionally ended in political upheavals and social revolutions. The second main idea is that these economic, technological, and political transformations brought about divergent effects across the world. “While eminent old empires such as the Ottoman, Chinese, Austro-Hungarian, Spanish, and Portuguese declined and fragmented, Western Europe, North America, Russia, Japan, and some parts of Latin America fared relatively well” (p. 11). There were also, however, sharp contrasts even within individual countries, particularly between urban city centers and the countryside. Third, protectionism was the preferred policy during this period. Although Britain, given its privileged position in world markets, was a strong advocate of low tariff duties and limited government, most countries did not share Britain's disposition toward free trade, instead imposing tariffs on international trade. This period's global integration was for the most part a result of the technological innovations mentioned above and very little a result of trade policy. The fourth idea is that the natural environment was both a resource and a victim of economic growth, the expansions in productivity and trade during this period placing an increasing pressure on land, forests, and wildlife worldwide.
The authors use the second chapter to discuss “the sinews of trade” (p. 45). Among these are currency standards; developments in the transportation sector such as the steamship, the Suez and Panama canals, the railroad, the automobile, and the airplane; and developments in international communications such as the telegraph, underwater cables, the radio, and the telephone. Each of these is discussed in its own independent section. Throughout the course of the chapter, we learn about the crucial technological advances that emerged over these seven decades; how political, institutional, colonial, and military considerations affected countries’ decisions to use these new technologies; the impact of these developments on trade and labor migrations across the world; the role of government in financing and regulating these new sectors; and transformations in industries (specifically, iron, steel, petroleum, copper, and rubber) that both resulted from and facilitated the expansion of these technologies.
After this two-chapter overview of the economic, institutional, and technological contexts in which world commodity markets operated and evolved during the period, in Chapter 3 we reach the heart of the book. Here, the authors trace the evolution of a few specific commodity chains, “selected because they were some of the most valuable globally traded products of the time” (p. 9): grains such as wheat and rice, the hard fibers needed to package them, and stimulants such as sugar, coffee, tea, and chocolate. Recognizing the global scope of each commodity market, the authors do not concentrate exclusively on western Europe and North America, but they also place great emphasis on other areas of the globe—Latin America, Asia, Oceania, and Africa. Their primary focus is on the evolution of relationships and exchanges in each commodity chain and how they interact with the technological and institutional innovations of the period. The result is a chapter composed of detailed descriptions of each commodity market: the different actors along the chain; producing and consuming countries; global market leaders; the role of colonial dominance; countries’ choices in terms of protectionism, immigration, and labor conditions; differences between urban and rural living within the same country; the impact that a growing urban, industrial working class had on the surge in demand for these commodities; and the social, political, and dietary impacts on people's everyday lives.
Although Global Markets Transformed is not a complete story of the first era of globalization, its analysis of key commodity chains under a magnifying glass is a valuable addition to the literature. Perhaps its most valuable feature is the integration of various aspects of key commodity markets into a single, accessible volume, thereby making this scholarship available to academics, policymakers, and the general reader alike. Furthermore, by focusing on commodity chains and providing extensive coverage of regions beyond western Europe and North America—often lacking in the literature—the book provides a new perspective on this period's globalization, one in which “outcomes [are] not uniform, foreordained, consistent, or constant” (p. 266). Because two-thirds of the book (Chapters 1 and 2) serve essentially as introduction, and only the last chapter delivers the core message, the book feels somewhat unbalanced. Nonetheless, Global Markets Transformed is a welcome contribution to the narrative of the process of globalization in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.
