Marchandes á la mode—fashion merchants—and their British counterparts are important to our understanding of the eighteenth century. They are significant not only as workers but also because they represent one area of work where women could be virtual professionals and entrepreneurs. They are also key figures as representatives of “fashion,” which was central to understanding the worlds of the eighteenth century. Clare Crowston, in Fabricating Women (2001), and others have drawn out these aspects over the last twenty or so years. She returns to them in this book, taking the discussion into the realms of credit. The study of credit is also relatively new—especially to historians of women and gender—and demonstrates how women functioned in the money markets, an area normally perceived as male. Elaborating on women's credit activities is critical in understanding their role and participation in the economy, appreciating them as businesswomen, and generating a more holistic view of their economic activity. This book goes further than the discussion of these two phenomena, however. Crowston's interest is in examining “how contemporaries conceived and practiced credit across an array of activities, experiences, and reputations” (p. 3). She argues that the character and pervasive aspects of credit—economies of regard—are essential to comprehending eighteenth-century France.
Historians of eighteenth-century Europe (including Britain) have long known that credit was more than a monetary transaction, and this was commonly understood in contemporary Britain as well, as Daniel Defoe illustrates: “There is a particular nicety in the credit of a tradesman. . . . [A] man is slandered in his character, or reputation, and it is injurious; . . . but if this happens to a tradesman, he is immediately blasted and undone” (Daniel Defoe, The Complete English Tradesman, p. 132). However, this simple dyad is just that—too simple. Crowston contends that to fully understand the history of business, a deeper appreciation of credit, beyond even “reputation,” is essential. She argues that the French “attached not one but multiple closely interrelated senses to the word credit” (p. 1). It permeated language, culture, personal, and professional relationships. Life relied on trust.
Credit, Fashion, Sex operates on two levels: as a detailed examination of what Crowston terms “the credit system” and as a more specific study of the overlaps between fashion and credit, epitomized by the marchandes. Although gender does not appear in the title, and despite the apparent gender neutrality of understandings of credit, it becomes clear that gender is intrinsic to understanding the multiple meanings inherent in the economies of regard.
Crowston begins by reconstructing the credit culture that permeated ancien régime France—through a detailed and finely nuanced examination of texts available through technology allowing word searches and frequency analysis—to elucidate a myriad of uses and understandings of credit. She explores patronage networks, in court and outside, power dynamics, and influence, but also family, legal usages, and even how in translation the term credit was used to make the foreign “familiar” (i.e., translating the English “interest” to crédit). Through her analysis, people's awareness of and self-conscious use of nonmaterial credit become palpable. The criticism of abuses of credit and power also points up how such misuse was perceived as undermining a tacitly agreed cultural dynamic. Crowston demonstrates a significant evolution over time in critical thinking about abuses and credit, especially for France, and the impact these had on royal power. While her main aim is not necessarily to expose the issues that culminated in the French Revolution, there is no doubt that this discussion and analysis goes a long way toward shedding new light on the French ancien régime in its final years.
In the second part of the book, she uses marchandes de mode as a case study, in effect, to “tie the knot” between credit as power and influence and credit as economic feature, scrutinizing its role in the so-called consumer revolution of the eighteenth century (p. 8). These chapters are essential to her intention “to demonstrate the articulation of the sociopolitical credit of le monde with the merchant's economic world of credit” (p. 10). Certainly the chapters on marchand(e)s (4, 5, and 6) play to Crowston's strengths and her deep knowledge of the sewing trades; in this sense, Credit, Fashion, Sex is a successor to Fabricating Women. Here however, the emphasis is less on the trades and the inner workings of skill and technical abilities than on business practices. Credit did not always mean debts would be paid, either. Business people had to live with credit—and understood that transactions with people of credit could moreover add to their own credit. Her discussion highlights the persistent lack of liquidity that made credit so important in financial affairs. This was not a cash economy and thus repayment would not always be timely.
Not only were fashion and luxury at the heart of consumption practices, but dress and appearance were also important representations of power. Thus Crowston claims that fashion, like credit, became an all-encompassing dynamic, spanning multiple spheres, so that both fashion and credit became “information economies constitutive of—rather than merely reflective of—social hierarchies” (p. 99). They also captured key critical discourses, such as the discrediting of Marie Antoinette and, ultimately, the regime as a whole. Notably, as Crowston argues, fashion shifted from being relatively gender neutral to being associated with women, thus laying the ground for misogynist criticism. Specifically, she explores shop and trade credit with a thorough analysis of credit worthiness, comparing single and married women, couples and male marchands, showing the distinctions between their credit to be very narrow indeed. This is important, detailed research that demonstrates how the credit system and network worked rather than falling back on existing assumptions.
The two parts of the book are clearly linked by the common thread of credit. Yet they sit a little uneasily together, despite their obvious connections. At times dense and detailed, well written, and with signposts to keep readers from losing their way, this book nevertheless is not a light read. It tends to focus on Paris, and especially the royal court, and thus is on one level an introductory foray into an examination of credit and its implications. It raises questions that scholars ought to probe, including methodological issues that ask what kinds of history we want to write. It suggests comparison with other cultural regions of Europe where experiences—in, say, Germany or Denmark, or England and Scotland—may have been quite different. Crowston intended to study France and acknowledges that “a broad spatial perspective is necessary” (p. 323). This book and its approach have created a bit of a stir in historical circles, evidenced by the discussion in H-France forum (vol. 9 [Summer 2014]). The book is a reminder of how many questions remain to ask and answer. It also shows what a fine scholar can do when given the time and physical space (i.e., a book's length) to explore analytical issues in depth. This is a tour de force in many respects.
In the final analysis—returning to where this review started—women's access to credit made it possible for female entrepreneurs to operate their businesses and, similarly, enabled married women to make purchasing choices without recourse to their husbands. That the fashion industry was based on female entrepreneurs and customers was, as Crowston says, a key element in the expansion of credit in the French economy.
