As we move further into the so-called Decade of Centenaries in Ireland, there is an increased academic and public interest in the happenings and individuals that facilitated the transition of Ireland from an integral part of the British Empire to a partially independent country. In this intellectual context of reconsidered narratives, William Murphy's monograph is an exciting and necessary scholarly addition. Meticulously researched, broadly considered, and nuanced in interpretation, Murphy's book convincingly argues for the need to move beyond the public arena and instead to examine the period through the usually hidden “prism” of the prison (255).
Through eleven substantive chapters, broadly entwining a thematic and chronological structure, Murphy discusses the intricacies of political imprisonment, what it meant, and how it was performed in vivid detail. While many recent volumes exploring this period have narrowly considered “Revolutionary Ireland” in terms of explosive acts of violence and game-changing events, Murphy shows how more subtle activities within prisons have been unfairly excluded from our considerations. He argues that political imprisonment was central to not only explicitly questioning the right of the state to imprison, if not to govern, but also to create political consciousness and radicalize those held within prison walls and those situated in wider society. Deftly critiquing the now outdated notion that prisons simply make transgressors disappear, Murphy eloquently argues for reconsidering intended and actual roles of imprisonment in removing those who challenge the rights of the state. In doing so, Murphy avoids the temptation to narrowly define political imprisonment as relating solely to nationalist aspirations. For example, he begins the book by foregrounding the often unconsidered importance of the acts and aspirations of suffragettes (chapter 1), especially the template they provided for active disruption of prison life and the use of hunger strike for later political prisoners. Likewise, the inclusion of political imprisonment as a result of class and workers' conflicts such as the 1913 Dublin Lock Out reveals the disparate but entangled nature of political imprisonment in early twentieth-century Ireland.
The breadth of Murphy's vision is evident in the range of sources that he has consulted: all the Irish archives that one would expect, but also the National Archives of Scotland, the National Archives, Kew, and a number of private and university archives throughout the British Isles. Utilizing this wide range of sources, Murphy considers political imprisonment at its broadest level and is keen to reveal that it was not a united or homogeneous experience. By highlighting the impact of class, gender, geography, and individual personalities, he has skillfully intertwined various conceptions of political imprisonment with how they were received in wider society, and in doing so reveals how a figure such as Michael Collins was able to enter the internment camp of Frognoch obscure and emerge as a leader while others receded from public consciousness as a result of their experiences. Maintaining this level of particularity while ensuring that the most important figures, places, actions, and events are balanced in their inclusion is a difficult task, but Murphy undertakes it with confidence. Maintaining breadth of vision, he conceives “political imprisonment and the Irish” to extend beyond the confines of the island, emphasizing how the British prison system was increasingly relied upon to hold and isolate political prisoners as the Irish system began to creak in the aftermath of the Easter Rising (1916) and into the War of Independence (1919–21). Likewise, he does not fall into the trap that many later historians have in naturalizing unraveling political outcomes by focusing on only twenty-six rather than thirty-two counties. Throughout the monograph he includes, compares, and contrasts prison experiences, roles, uses, and interconnections throughout the island.
There are a small number of minor omissions that, if addressed, could have added yet more layers to this already refined offering. Further glimpses into the prison experiences of the politically active Irish in Great Britain (particularly those men and women who played significant roles in shipping arms, fund-raising, and providing paramilitary personnel) would have added another level of interconnection. Their stories would have been particularly welcome as they are frequently forgotten by historians, mirroring their complaints in memoirs and personal correspondence of being excluded by those whom they considered their compatriots and being more harshly punished when incarcerated in British jails. Furthermore, while the experience of women constitutes a full chapter and discussions of women are sprinkled liberally throughout the volume, there is a continued emphasis on the role of men that has ensured that some of the women's acts, including the audacious escape of four women from Mountjoy Jail in 1921 via rope ladder, are not included. The relative downplaying of women's experience is perhaps best explained by the decision to end the period of research in the aftermath of the War of Independence in 1921. Although in some ways it is a natural end point, and one that frequently rounds off the “Decade of Centenaries,” it is most unfortunate from a perspective of gendering this period of Irish history. Women's experience of political imprisonment suffers most from the continued discomfiture with exploring the civil war, as women's important roles in facilitating, and at times fighting alongside, the men received explicit attention in the civil war period, when they were interned en masse. This is an important aspect of political imprisonment that would also tie well into Murphy's opening chapter on the imprisonment of suffragettes. It is to be hoped that Murphy's next monograph will bring his insightful eye and expansive vision to the very different context of political imprisonment during, and in the aftermath of, the internecine bitterness of civil war.
