In this critical discussion of fusion music and its development during the late 1960s and the 1970s, Fellezs situates the music's evolution in an American context and provides a welcome addition to the academic literature on fusion, which is very limited (largely to journal articles and one book-length history, Stuart Nicholson's Jazz: The Modern Resurgence (1998)). Fellezs has produced a scholarly yet readable book (I will recommend it to my popular-music undergraduates), which is engagingly written and would be of interest to jazz and fusion fans and musicians as well as academics.
In terms of American studies, concentrating on the American side of the story facilitates the formation of Fellezs's argument about fusion being a product of “intercultural exchange” between jazz, funk and rock. This is a reasonable approach, as all of these genres (notwithstanding the “British invasion” of rock in the 1960s) are rooted in American culture. Where popular musicologists may accuse Fellezs of an omission is in a discussion of artists outside the US who could be considered proto-fusion pioneers, such as those in the UK. For example, Jon Hiseman, Ian Carr and his band Nucleus, and, arguably, Cream, all experimentally combined jazz and rock during the same period as American innovators, but are mentioned only in passing, if at all. However, British artists have been discussed at greater length by Nicholson and, in particular, Wicke (John Shepherd and Peter Wicke, Music and Cultural Theory (1999)) (though this book is not referenced in Birds of Fire), so Fellezs's focus on American fusion is justified, given the themes of his book.
The main underlying theme is one of bringing together music genres “encoded by race and gender” (227) in an American context. Fellezs illustrates this by exploring four case studies: two black musicians and two white. The two African American artists are drummer Tony Williams and pianist Herbie Hancock, the others being English-born guitarist John McLaughlin and, an unexpected choice perhaps (given that fusion is mostly male-dominated instrumental music), Canadian singer-songwriter Joni Mitchell. Being familiar with Mitchell's work of the late 1970s, when she collaborated with various jazz musicians (including Herbie Hancock), her inclusion is not surprising to this reviewer. Fellezs convincingly defends his choices because of the different ways in which each of them dealt with the expectations of their musical, racial and cultural backgrounds while experimenting with the fusion of diverse genres.
Within his other themes, Fellezs draws on a number of theoretical ideas, particularly Isobel Armstrong's concept of the “broken middle” (an unsettled, in-between space) that is inhabited by fusion – an idea to which Fellezs frequently returns. His thesis is that the music of his chosen artists “oscillated between ‘jazz,’ ‘rock,’ ‘funk,’ and ‘classical’ music, epitomizing none but incapable of breaking away completely into its own space” (8), and, therefore, that fusion failed to evolve completely into a distinct genre. Fellezs devotes a chapter to the discussion of genre (which is an ongoing subject of debate in popular-music studies), and the term “fusion” is certainly a contentious one, but it is probable that the majority of fans of the music would regard it as a genre (or at least a subgenre of jazz). However, Fellezs argues his case well (although some references to genre writing, such as that of Franco Fabbri, are noticeably absent), calling fusion an “idiom” rather than a genre.
Fellezs relies entirely on archival secondary sources for his research. In a methodology statement in the introduction he justifies this approach (rather than interviewing his case studies directly) on the grounds that, first, Tony Williams was no longer alive, and second, he wanted to avoid the problem of misremembered events. Whether to interview your subjects about their work of forty years ago is a difficult decision to make in this type of historical research, but one can understand Fellezs's view that contemporary material may reflect more accurately the cultural, political and social undercurrents of the time. There is evidently no shortage of these sources, which Fellezs weaves skilfully into his narrative. All the same, it would be interesting to read the remaining artists' current views on their own and others' work during that period, if only for comparison.
Despite this reservation, this is a well-researched and sophisticated text. The issues I have discussed are subjects for debate and further discussion rather than flaws, and Fellezs should be commended for making a significant contribution to the scholarly literature on this neglected form – or idiom – of popular music.
