Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T07:09:22.418Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Turbulent secondary flows in channels with no-slip and shear-free boundaries

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 April 2021

Nikolay Nikitin*
Affiliation:
Institute of Mechanics, Lomonosov Moscow State University, 1 Michurinsky prospect, 119899 Moscow, Russia
*
†Email address for correspondence: nvnikitin@mail.ru

Abstract

A simple principle is formulated, which makes it possible to explain and, in some cases, to predict the shape of secondary flows of Prandtl's second kind that arise in turbulent flows in straight pipes of non-circular cross-section. The motion along the no-slip wall is directed in the direction of reduction of pressure. Therefore, the direction of the secondary motion along the perimeter of the pipe cross-section can be determined by the location of the mean wall pressure local extrema. Velocity fluctuations along a curved wall cause the mean wall pressure change, the greater the change, the greater the curvature of the wall. Thus, the location of local wall pressure extrema is consistent with the wall curvature. In a number of cases, an approximate picture of secondary flows can be predicted a priori using only symmetry considerations and a wall curvature analysis. The conditions for the formation of a secondary flow change on a free surface where, in addition to pressure, Reynolds stresses act on the fluid particles, and the result of their interaction is unknown in advance. A turbulent flow in a rectangular channel is considered, in which one of the walls (upper) is shear-free. Application of the formulated principle dictates the presence of secondary flows in the upper corners, with a downward motion along the solid sidewalls. This contradicts the popular point of view about the shape of secondary flows in open channels, according to which the motion along the sidewalls is directed upward towards the corner and then towards the centre of the channel along the free surface. The paper presents the direct numerical simulation (DNS) results showing that along with the large-scale secondary flow, which generally agrees with the traditional picture, there is a smaller-scale single-vortex secondary flow with the opposite direction of rotation in the vicinity of each upper corner. The presence of a no-slip wall is an important element of the described mechanism of secondary flow formation. In this regard, the question logically arises about the possibility of the occurrence of secondary flows in the corners between two free boundaries. A series of DNS of turbulent flows in a square duct with two solid and two free adjacent walls have been carried out. It was found that the Reynolds stress forces in the vicinity of the corner between free boundaries are potential, are neutralized by the pressure gradient, and therefore do not create a secondary flow.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Coordinate systems $(y, z)$ and $(y_*, z_*)$ in the corner region of the cross section: (a) in the developing boundary layer (Eichelbrenner & Preston 1971); (b) in square duct (Dai & Xu 2019).

Figure 1

Figure 2.Dominating directions of velocity fluctuations and values of products $v'w'$ in the near-wall region of three types of boundaries: (a) convex, (b) flat and (c) concave. The designations $P^+$, $P^-$ and $P_0$ reflect the positive, negative and neutral effect of the second term on the right-hand side of (2.1) on the mean pressure on the wall.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Fluctuation trajectory $AB$ and polar coordinate system $Or\theta$ with pole $O$ at the centre of curvature of the curve $AB$ at the point $M$ ($R$ is the radius of curvature). The points $M_1, M_2$ lie on the curves $AB$ and $r=R$, respectively, at an arclength $s$ from the point $M$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.(a) Directions of tangents to the fluctuation trajectories in a square duct at $Re_\tau =150$. The bottom left quarter of the cross-section is shown. The length of the vectors is proportional to the degree of anisotropy of normal stresses $(\overline {v_\tau '^2}-\overline {v_n'^2})/(\overline {v_\tau '^2}+\overline {v_n'^2})$. (b) Mean pressure field and streamlines of the secondary flow.

Figure 4

Figure 5.The form of the secondary flow streamlines in the vicinity of the points of the local minimum $P^-$ and the local maximum $P^+$ of the mean wall pressure.

Figure 5

Figure 6.(a) Mean pressure distribution and (b) streamlines of secondary flow in a pipe with a cross-section in the form of a circular sector with an apex angle of $90\,^\circ$.

Figure 6

Figure 7.(a) Mean pressure distribution and (b) streamlines of secondary flow in a pipe with a cross-section in the form of a circular sector with an apex angle of $270\,^\circ$.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Schematic picture of secondary flows (a) in an elliptical pipe (Nikitin & Yakhot 2005; Voronova & Nikitin 2006, 2007); (b) in a rectangular pipe with rounded corners (Vidal et al.2017); (c) in a pipe with a semicircular wall (Vidal et al.2017, 2018). Dashed lines correspond to clockwise rotation, solid lines to anticlockwise rotation. Additionally, the direction of rotation in the secondary flows is indicated by arrows. Areas with a local increase in pressure on the wall are denoted by $P^+$ and areas with a reduced pressure by $P^-$.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Flow in an annular eccentric tube (Nikitin et al.2009). The upper half of the cross-section is shown. (a) Streamlines of the secondary flow; (b) mean pressure distributions along the perimeter of the inner (dashed line) and outer (solid line) cylinders. The coordinate $s=0$ corresponds to the wide part of the gap, $s=1$, to the narrow one. Green dots on the cylinder walls point to the positions of the local pressure extrema $P^+$ and $P^-$.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Scheme of secondary flows in an open channel (Nezu & Nakagawa 1993).

Figure 10

Table 1.Simulation parameters.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Secondary flow streamlines with no averaging about the line of symmetry $y=W/2$.

Figure 12

Figure 12.(a) Mean pressure field and streamlines of secondary flow; (b) isolines of mean longitudinal velocity.

Figure 13

Figure 13.(a) Intensity of transverse velocity fluctuations $\sqrt {\overline {v'^2}+\overline {w'^2}}$ (five contours with increments of 0.2); (b) isolines of the secondary flow velocity $\sqrt {V^2+W^2}$ (five contours with increments of 1 % of $U_b$).

Figure 14

Figure 14.Secondary flow velocity and terms of (1.6) along the free surface, $z=1$. Lines: 1, $V/2$; 2, $-{\partial } P/{\partial } y$; 3, Reynolds stresses force (right-hand side terms of (1.6)); 4, force of inertia (convective terms) $-V{\partial } V/{\partial } y-W{\partial } V/{\partial } z$; 5, viscous force $\nu ({\partial }^2 V/{\partial } y^2 + {\partial }^2 V/{\partial } z^2)$.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Distribution of the mean longitudinal vorticity $\varOmega _x$ over the channel cross-section. Negative values are shown with dashed lines.

Figure 16

Table 2.Simulation parameters.

Figure 17

Figure 16.Mean pressure fields and secondary flow streamlines in a channel with two shear-free boundaries: (a) $Re = 2000$, (b) $Re = 4000$, (c) $Re = 8000$, (d) $Re = 16\,000$. The boundaries $y = 0$ and $z = 0$ are solid, and the boundaries $y = 1$ and $z = 1$ are free.

Figure 18

Figure 17.Fields of the $(\textit {a})$ Reynolds stress force $\boldsymbol {f}$, $(\textit {b})$ minus gradient of the fluctuation pressure $Q$, $(\textit {c})$ their sum in the vicinity of the intersection of two solid walls $y = 0$ and $z = 0$. Here $Re = 16\,000$. The size of the vectors in panel (c) has been increased by 10 times compared with panels (a) and (b).

Figure 19

Figure 18.Fields of the (a) Reynolds stress force $\boldsymbol {f}$, (b) minus gradient of the fluctuation pressure $Q$, (c) their sum in the vicinity of the intersection of solid wall $y = 0$ and free boundary $z = 1$. Here $Re = 16\,000$. The size of the vectors in panel (c) has been increased by 10 times compared with panels (a) and (b).

Figure 20

Figure 19.Fields of the (a) Reynolds stress force $\boldsymbol {f}$, (b) minus gradient of the fluctuation pressure $Q$, (c) their sum in the vicinity of the intersection of two free boundaries $y = 1$ and $z = 1$. Here $Re = 16\,000$. The size of the vectors in panel (c) has been increased by 10 times compared with panels (a) and (b). The size of vectors on all panels is doubled compared with figures 17 and 18.