Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-18T06:25:14.618Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Edward MacDowell's Original Program for the Sonata Eroica

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 February 2015

Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Manuscript sources for Edward MacDowell's Sonata Eroica (1895) divulge a radically different, notably more sinister program than the commentary that the composer imparted to Lawrence Gilman, his first biographer. Gilman's widely promulgated account, merely comprising four character sketches based on Tennyson's Arthurian epic, Idylls of the King, maintains that the score's movements respectively depict the coming of Arthur, Doré's engraving of a knight surrounded by elves, MacDowell's idea of Guinevere, and the passing of Arthur.

Inscriptions in a continuity draft preserved at the Library of Congress, however, reveal that the first movement was initially conceived as an independent ballade (an intrinsically programmatic genre) and was originally inspired by Tennyson's portrayal of Vivien seducing Merlin. Another inscription discloses that MacDowell envisioned the third movement as Lancelot's adulterous serenade to Guinevere. Additional manuscript variants and close correlations between the score's vibrant musical topics and Tennyson's literary contexts demonstrate that the entire sonata, including the elfin scherzo and war-like finale, embodies a tale of seduction and its dire consequences.

Although the Eroica's vivid, newly discovered program remains compatible with MacDowell's professed aesthetics, he suppressed the inscriptions. Speculative reasons for his doing so include formal considerations, critical opinions on programmaticism, and his attitudes toward sex.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © The Society for American Music 2015 
Figure 0

Figure 1.Edward MacDowell, Sonata Eroica, First Movement, mm. 1–32Continuity Draft with Ballade as Original Title and Epigraph from Merlin and VivienEdward and Marian MacDowell Collection, Papers of Edward MacDowell, Music: Holographs, Manuscripts of Edward MacDowell, Box 4, Folder 20, Music Division, Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.

Figure 1

Example 1a.MacDowell, Sonata Eroica, First Movement, mm. 19–54 (here numbered 1–36 to facilitate comparison with Figure 1 and Example 1b). Principal Theme, Transcribed from the Continuity Draft.

Figure 2

Example 1b.MacDowell, Sonata Eroica, First Movement, mm. 19–54 (here numbered 1–36 to facilitate comparison with Example 1a). Principal Theme, Breitkopf & Härtel, Plate 21004 (1895).

Figure 3

Table 1.Correlations of Form, Topics, and Poetry in the Sonata Eroica's First Movement

Figure 4

Example 2.MacDowell, Sonata Eroica, First Movement, mm. 55–66. Subordinate Theme, Breitkopf & Härtel, Plate 21004 (1895).

Figure 5

Example 3.MacDowell, Sonata Eroica, First Movement, mm. 91–94. Subordinate Theme's Recurrence in the Development Section, Breitkopf & Härtel, Plate 21004 (1895).

Figure 6

Example 4.MacDowell, Sonata Eroica, First Movement, mm. 175–78. Subordinate Theme's Recurrence in the Recapitulation, Breitkopf & Härtel, Plate 21004 (1895).

Figure 7

Example 5.MacDowell, Sonata Eroica, First Movement, mm. 193–99. The Coda's Windblown Scales, Breitkopf & Härtel, Plate 21004 (1895).

Figure 8

Example 6.MacDowell, Sonata Eroica, Second Movement, mm. 1–20. Elfin Figuration in the Scherzo, Breitkopf & Härtel, Plate 21004 (1895).

Figure 9

Example 7a.MacDowell, Sonata Eroica, Second Movement, mm. 76–111 (here numbered 1–36 to facilitate comparison with Example 7b). Original Version of the Trio, Transcribed from the Continuity Draft.

Figure 10

Example 7b.MacDowell, Sonata Eroica, Second Movement, mm. 77–112 (here numbered 1–36 to facilitate comparison with Example 7a). Published Version of the Trio, Breitkopf & Härtel, Plate 21004 (1895).

Figure 11

Table 2.Correlations of Form, Topics, and Poetry in the Sonata Eroica's Fourth Movement

Figure 12

Example 8.MacDowell, Sonata Eroica, Fourth Movement, mm. 1–10. Principal Theme, The Embodiment of a Sturmmarsch, Breitkopf & Härtel, Plate 21004 (1895).

Figure 13

Appendix.Contents of the Sketches and Continuity Draft for the Sonata Eroica, Edward and Marian MacDowell Collection, Music Division, Library of Congress (US-Wc), Papers of Edward MacDowell: Music, Holograph Manuscripts of Edward MacDowell