Analysis of when and how Romans spoke, and who was listening, is now the orthodox approach to the problem of describing their political system. Rostra and contiones have dominated discussion of the last thirty years, and rightly so. Rosillo-López offers an alternative mode of analysis by insisting on the importance of public opinion, in a general sense, as a source for the creation and distribution of political ideas within a complex polity. Habermas with a twist: a politically effective public opinion can be detected long before the printing press. For R.-L., public opinion was multi-faceted, chaotic, prone to misinterpretation, but, above all, considered relevant by members of the political class. The book is therefore a statement on method as well as a contribution to the ongoing debate on the extent to which non-elite members of Roman society affected its politics.
The book begins with a brief introduction and then an attempt to situate the work within various theoretical discussions of Roman politics, the sociology of public opinion and the nature of information systems. R.-L. favours analysis that highlights a symbiotic relationship between plebs and elite (she uses ‘plebs’ throughout as a catch-all for ‘non-elite’, not to be confused with ‘plebeian’), and argues that studies of public opinion allow for the interactive nature of this symbiosis to be analysed. The problem of defining ‘public opinion’ is then treated, before the chapter closes with a discussion of censorship and free speech, which are analysed in terms of their impact on the autonomy, and thus legitimacy, of that which purports to be public opinion.
Ch. 2 provides a physical description of Rome's built environment, with the aim of showing that information was able to traverse boundaries of class and gender quite efficiently. R.-L. argues for a high degree of socialisation, not only among elite families, but between ordinary members of society and their illustrious compatriots. Various sources are combined to show a bustling, noisy city in which everyday commentary on politics, whether astute, comic or ignorant, moved freely. While her analysis of Rome's built environment is not new, its overall effect is nonetheless interesting and a genuine contribution to scholarship.
Chs. 3, 4 and 5 focus on different aspects of form. Ch. 3 deals with rumour and gossip, which are differentiated. Rumour is widely spread and is most effective when official sources of information are either non-existent or cannot be trusted; gossip is restricted and functions as a form of social control by reinforcing group think. For R.-L., these forms of public opinion were the bedrock upon which formal discourse often emerged. Various incidents are analysed to show that rumour run riot could dominate the rostra and become an official narrative through the mouth of the magistrate. R.-L. thus turns politics on its head. Ch. 4 deals with the question of genre in anticipation of an analysis of written forms of public opinion in ch. 5. A catholic interpretation of ‘political literature’ — graffiti, written speeches, inscriptions, poetry, in short, anything written down that alludes to the political — is offered and R.-L. seems to favour the view that literacy exists on a spectrum, and that, in any event, many people absorbed literature through informal oral performances. ‘Political literature’, being an expansive category, allows for a wider circulation and absorption than that produced by focusing solely on, for instance, political speeches. Ch. 5 covers the various sub-genres of her meta-category, with a focus on various types of verse, pamphlets, open letters, memoirs, histories, graffiti and placards, with each serving a similar function, i.e. informing, and reflecting, public opinion. The chapter also includes an interesting study of the commentarius rerum urbanarum, which is interpreted as a formal, but not official, source of news and distinguished from the similarly obscure acta diurna. As with her analysis of rumour and gossip, R.-L. argues for a complex matrix of interactions between elite and non-elite, such that public opinion is rarely the creation of one or the other.
Chs 6 and 7 seek to uncover the varieties of public opinion and their impact on the rhetorical strategies of the elite. R.-L. agrees with Peter Brunt's view that political groupings in Roman politics were spontaneous, transitory and oriented by issues rather than sociological phenomena (The Fall of the Roman Republic (1988)). Our sources, notably Cicero, oversimplified divisions in society to support their various agenda: words like populus, plebs, multitudo and vulgus are ontologically useless. The theory of the ‘spiral of silence’, by which a variety of opinions is hidden beneath the appearance of a unified opinion, is then deployed to propose a more diverse range of public opinions. In doing so, R.-L. seeks to move us away from a focus on leaders of public opinion; common networks, such as barber shops, and people who frequented public spaces, such as subrostrani, are offered in their place. Orators and advocates had to confront this reality head on, with mixed results. The failure of Caesar's assassins to assess the popular view of Caesar correctly was, to a large degree, dependent on the fatal success of their own rhetoric within elite circles, while Cicero was able successfully to form a view of Verres which crowded out all other opinions.
Ch. 8 offers a set of conclusions. While there are multiple themes running through the work, perhaps the most interesting is the demonstration that an alternative methodology to the standard preference for studying formal institutional frameworks has offered results suggesting a high level of participation in politics across all social classes and genders. R.-L. has therefore offered an original contribution to the question of defining the Roman political experience, and how that experience is best analysed. It deserves to be widely read and properly considered. Scholars working in the field will have to test her methodology and deal with her conclusions, but it would also be a useful addition to university courses and is accessible to the informed layperson, particularly given that a much cheaper paperback version was published in 2020.
