This volume features a collection of eight papers derived from a symposium devoted to rock art research presented at the XIX Annual South Asian Archaeology Conference 2007 in Ravenna, Italy. Papers cover recent developments in the Indian sub-continent and Central Asia spanning from India and Ladakh in the south to Afghanistan, Tajikistan and Kazakhstan in the north. The forms of rock art discussed range from percussion marks and engravings into natural stone to surfaces painted with images and symbols.
The first paper is by Giriraj Kumar who discusses recent developments in rock art research in India with regards to very old markings made by early humans known as cupules, hemispherical impressions in the rock made by percussion with another stone. They occur in the Bhimbekta caves of Madhya Pradesh province, central India which have numerous rock art images dating from different time periods. Over twenty years ago the Bhimbekta cupules were dated by scientific techniques indicating they were produced during the Middle Palaeolithic (Acheulian period), circa 300,000 years ago. Moreover, additional micro-erosional analysis suggests they could have even belonged to the Lower Palaeolithic, over 700,000 years ago. Additionally, Kumar presents data about the archaeo-strtaigraphic contexts of cupules discovered at a Daraki-Chattan cave in the Chambal basin of Madhya Pradesh province, which were also associated with the Lower Palaeolithic. The difficulties of obtaining precise dates for the earliest rock art, as researchers strive to attain greater accuracy with more confidence, are also discussed. Thus, this paper concludes with recent data that refine the age determinations of the cupules from Bhimbekta and Daraki-Chattan with more precision.
The next paper by Luca Maria Olivieri discusses rock art sites with painted images from the Lower Swat, Pakistan. Olivieri reports on ongoing archaeological surveys over many years in the Swat Valley which have so far identified 49 painted shelters. These shelters feature images painted in pigments derived from red ochre, orange ochre as well as rare examples of yellow and white ochre. The age of the paintings ranges from the Bronze Age to historic periods with orange ochre appearing in more recent times. Those images believed to be from the Bronze Age, however, are not clearly defined by the author. Iron Age images found in the shelter of Dandi-Sar 1 depict human figures and circle motifs labelled as so-called ‘solar symbols’, but there is no explanation that qualifies their arguable connections to the sun. After the first century bce Buddhist monasteries appeared in the region and at some shelters (Kafir-Kot 1 & 2, Ram-dunai 1, Dandi-sar 2, Gweluno-ghar) there are depictions of stupas similar to early Buddhist architectural monuments in the Swat Valley. Interestingly, in this context, images painted in orange ochre are believed to date to the eighth–twelfth centuries ce as they contain Brahmanic religious symbols. A scene from Takh-gat shelter, for example, features schematic figures that are interpreted as depicting Shiva accompanied by fighters. All in all, as more information is collected from the Swat Valley hopefully it will provide greater understandings about rock art in the future.
Laurianne Bruneau and Martin Vernier examine stylistic connections of particular motifs in Ladakh with the so-called Scytho-Siberian ‘animal style’, which follows upon previous rock art research conducted in the Karakorum. The Scytho-Siberians of Ladakh are known as the Saka, but the existence of the Saka archaeological culture in Ladakh is still quite a mystery. Their survey of a 100 rock art sites in Ladakh has found eleven containing Saka motifs relating to the ‘animal style’. The greatest concentration of Saka motifs is found at Domkhar in the Sham region and mainly depict prowling feline predators with curling tails, stags and also some images of ibexes and yaks. Similar motifs have been found in the Upper Indus Valley of Pakistan and the authors hope to explore these connections further in the future. The paper does not, however, reassess assumptions behind the ‘animal style’. In particular, there are problems with traditional typology as it fosters the expectation that Saka and Scytho-Siberian arts consist entirely of zoomorphic depictions, when in fact anthropomorphs also occur.
The next paper by B.R. Mani discusses the rock art of Ladakh and Baltistan. Early Tibetan Buddhist rock inscriptions and depictions of stupas in Ladakh (circa eighth to ninth centuries ce) had been initially noted by the famous explorer Aurel Stein. Mani then provides us with a summary of a survey area stretching 25 km from Sanjak to Batalik in the Baltistan region where many discoveries of rock art were made. Based on the data of this region three phases for Ladakh rock art are proposed: Early, Kushan and Tibetan-Buddhist periods. Examples of the Early Phase are found at Tilichange (2 km north-west of Sanjak) which feature several scenes involving images of ibexes, cattle, deer, humans, archers and horse-riders. So-called ‘solar symbols’ are also identified among the Tilichang images, but there is no further discussion about the basis of this interpretation. The existence of a phase of rock art associated with the Kushan period (second century bce to third century ce) is argued for, but no examples were supplied from Baltistan. Tibetan period images are provided, however, as there is a large boulder at Alchi carved with representations of two Buddhist stupas and Tibetan inscriptions.
The last in the series of articles on Ladakh is by Phuntsog Dorjay who examines early Buddhist sculptures carved into the natural rock around the landscape. He importantly provides descriptions and photographs of several sites. It is argued that the sculptural iconography is clearly derived from India and stylistically it can be compared to the bronze workshops of Kashmir, circa seventh to twelfth centuries ce.
Marco Ferrandi discusses the state of rock art research in the Hindukush region of Afghanistan. Once again it is pointed out that Aurel Stein noted some examples of rock art in this region. Research has not seen such extensive surveys in the Hindukush as there have been in the neighbouring Karakorum region and only minor documentations have been made. Significantly, Ferrandi points out the history of archaeological research in Afghanistan has devoted its resources to the examination of great civilisations, while studying rock art has not been seen as a viable topic of research. In order to rectify this situation he provides us with several photographs and a useful distribution map of known rock art sites in Afghanistan. The majority of the sites cluster in the north-eastern region which is situated in the Hindukush range. Interestingly, it is noted that there have been no discoveries of Buddhist rock carvings, especially when compared to the Karakorum region. This situation is unusual as Afghanistan contains many important early Buddhist sites and future research will hopefully find the reasons for this absence.
Marta Passerelli presents rock art research conducted along the Yaghnob River Valley in northern Tajikistan. The local dialect spoken in this region is Yaghnobi, a contemporary language that is descended from Sogdian, an ancient north-eastern branch of the Iranian language family. Two groups of petroglyphs were discovered in a gorge found along the Yaghnob River as well as two isolated rock carvings of goats. One group is a small scene of schematic depictions of hunters and an ibex. The second group is a large panel composed of about 45 schematic depictions of figures including ibexes, dogs, humans and at least six tamga symbols. One tamga, in particular, is similar to one found at Shatial, Upper Indus Valley, Pakistan, which is known to occur in Sogdian coins, circa fifth to seventh centuries ce.
The final paper in the volume is by the Kazakhstani rock art researcher Irina Shvets. Unlike the previous papers, which provided new documentation of rock art sites, Shvets instead reviews pertinent issues in Kazakhstan rock art research relating to their preservation and dating. She points out there are several incidents of deliberate damage conducted at rock art sites. A recent example includes the vandalism of the famous Buddhist rock carvings at the site of Tamgaly-Tash on the Ili River: the four Buddhas were painted over in some parts and shot at with a gun.
Shvets's article, however, is mainly devoted to the thorny issue of dating rock art as methods still heavily rely upon stylistic comparisons for the images because datable archaeological contexts are rare. These dating issues are relevant to all the previous papers presented in this volume. Several of them utilise relative dating frameworks that are underpinned by implicit assumptions which require further re-examinations. As Shvets points out, we need to be cautious with chronologies based on methods of relative dating, especially by stylistic comparison. This should not constrain us, however, from continuing to collect data and to explore fresh interpretative frameworks in rock art research. Crucially, South Asian and Central Asian rock art studies have now achieved the stage of introspection where questions need to be asked about how we study the images along with a critical awareness of the epistemologies involved in the processes of recording, dating and interpretation.
Overall, this volume importantly presents new data about rock art images from the Indian sub-continent and Central Asia. It also provides an excellent introduction to the relatively little known rock art sites of Ladakh and Afghanistan. Moreover, this collection of articles leaves the reader wanting to learn more about the rock images in this part of the world and hopefully more discoveries and innovations will continue to be published in an accessible manner in the years to come.
