In July 2014 Mexico's president, Enrique Peña Nieto, signed into law new rules for the telecommunications and broadcasting industries. These are designed to curb the dominance of América Móvil, owned by Carlos Slim, the world's richest man, and of Televisa. They are also supposed to help correct the 2006 telecommunications legislation known informally as the Ley Televisa. This law clearly favoured corporate media, particularly Televisa and TV Azteca, and severely disadvantaged community radio and other forms of grassroots media. The law established that radio and television enterprises that hoped to gain access to new parts of the television and radio spectrum would be granted licences through a process of competitive public bidding. A few indigenous stations were able to accomplish this and were legalised, but most could not compete and remained ‘illegal’. The 2014 telecommunications reform may rein in corporate giants slightly, but it will also tighten up regulation and prosecution of the many community and indigenous stations that operate without a licence. They persist, however, as documented in this book.
Indigenous Media in Mexico analyses the development of indigenous radio, television and video, first in the context of state intervention to convert indigenous people into modern Mexicans – a policy known as indigenismo – and then as part of the struggles for indigenous rights and autonomy in the 1990s. The case studies in the book look in depth at indigenous media experiences in the states of Oaxaca and Chiapas. Like all contemporary political and cultural actors, Mexico's indigenous peoples are media-savvy. Working to combat ongoing racism linked to Mexican nationalism and a history of state programmes designed to replace indigeneity with modernity, the growth of hundreds of community- and indigenous-run video projects, radio stations and television stations in Mexico since the 1990s has altered the politics of representation in Mexico's public sphere. Wortham takes us through this process.
First, the invention of video indígena was initiated primarily as a documentary genre through the Transferencia de Medios Audiovisuales a Organizaciones y Comunidades Indígenas (Transfer of Audiovisual Media to Indigenous Communities and Organisations, TMA) programme, organised through the Instituto Nacional Indigenista (National Indigenous Institute, INI) under the directorship of a well-known intellectual, Arturo Warman. TMA had offices in Oaxaca and later expanded to include Centros de Video Indígena in Oaxaca City, Mexico City, Morelia and Hermosillo. Through the TMA programme and the video centres a cadre of media experts was trained, some indigenous and some not, who went on to found independent media projects.
In Oaxaca, Wortham follows the Zapotec radio station XEGLO in Guelatão as well as two video production units, the K-Xhon Video-Cine Zapotec collective and Ojo de Agua Comunicación SC. These are three very different kinds of indigenous media enterprises. Following the Zapatista rebellion in 1994, XEGLO, which was an INI-sponsored station, had its content monitored for support to the Zapatistas and was taken off air a number of times. Wortham reports that the INI installed cut-off boxes in all XEGLO's stations, allowing the signals to be cut remotely from INI offices in Mexico City. K-Xhon was the media production sub-group of the Assembly of Authorities of the Zapotecs and Chinantecs of the Sierra, which used media as a way to disseminate their views on indigenous autonomy. They were in close contact with the Ejército Zapatista de Liberación Nacional (National Zapatista Liberation Army, EZLN) in the 1990s. Ojo de Agua has emerged as the most important and longest-lasting media collective in Oaxaca, with indigenous and non-indigenous members. It has been fundamental in launching, nurturing and providing technical and other forms of support to dozens of indigenous media enterprises in and out of the state since 1998. During 2006 its cinematographers were able to record crucial footage which documented hundreds of human rights abuses resulting from high levels of repression against the social movement which ran much of the capital city for five months. Another chapter on Oaxaca documents the development and struggles of Radio and Video Tamix in Tamazulapam de Espíritu Santo, Mixe, both to create social change from the inside and to have the work of radio and video production recognised and embedded in the community. This means having video production count as one of the dozens of volunteer jobs known as cargos which characterise the ways that indigenous communities are governed in Oaxaca. The ultimate decline of Radio and Video Tamix indicates the significant challenge involved in creating self-sustaining projects which successfully develop community support and consensus over the long term.
The final section of Wortham's book goes to the heart of where the struggle for indigenous autonomy is linked with the struggle for communication as a fundamental aspect of cultural rights: to the EZLN and its media policies in Chiapas. Along with the right to self-determination regarding governance, justice, policing, education and health, the right to control media and communication is a fundamental part of the Zapatista programme for indigenous autonomy. The San Andrés Accords signed by the EZLN and the Mexican government in 1996 (though never fully legislated) laid out fundamental media rights for indigenous peoples. Founded by Alexandra Halkin, a Chicagoan, in 1995, the Chiapas Media Project has worked directly with Zapatista villagers to bring their everyday struggles and perspectives to light. Drawing on local epistemologies and knowledge systems, the films do not cater at all to outside expectations. For example, The Indigenous Family, released in 1999, carefully and slowly documents the work that men and women do, with no flashy scenes. As Wortham documents, Halkin quickly trained a wide-ranging cadre of Zapatista film-makers and also incorporated Chicago youths into the project, which later expanded to other parts of Mexico. Wortham shows how the videos are important tools for Zapatista audiences and are also designed to educate outside audiences about the challenges of life in the Zapatista rebellion and put a realistic face on a movement that was overly glamorised and sensationalised by international commercial media.
Worthman's careful and complex analysis of the emergence of indigenous media in Mexico is a crucial element for understanding the key role of the politics of culture and communication in today's movements for indigenous autonomy. The book will be of interest to general audiences as well as those in the areas of cultural anthropology, international media studies, indigenous studies and Latin American studies. While the Mexican state continues to support primarily transnational corporate media companies, the indigenous peoples of Mexico have been busy crafting an alternative public sphere. The stage is now set for another confrontation between indigenous communities trying to protect their territories from transnational energy and mining companies, which now have the right to temporarily occupy indigenous land if there is a public resource such as gas or oil in the subsoil. The development of strong and independent indigenous media such as those analysed by Wortham will be key to challenging this impending plunder.
