Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T06:57:17.771Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Impact of osmotic pressure on the stability of Taylor vortices

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 January 2022

Rouae Ben Dhia
Affiliation:
Aix-Marseille Univ, CNRS, Centrale Marseille, M2P2, Marseille, France
Nils Tilton
Affiliation:
Mechanical Engineering, Colorado School of Mines, Golden, CO 80401, USA
Denis Martinand*
Affiliation:
Aix-Marseille Univ, CNRS, Centrale Marseille, M2P2, Marseille, France
*
†Email address for correspondence: denis.martinand@univ-amu.fr

Abstract

We use linear stability analysis and direct numerical simulations to investigate the coupling between centrifugal instabilities, solute transport and osmotic pressure in a Taylor–Couette configuration that models rotating dynamic filtration devices. The geometry consists of a Taylor–Couette cell with a superimposed radial throughflow of solvent across two semi-permeable cylinders. Both cylinders totally reject the solute, inducing the build-up of a concentration boundary layer. The solute retroacts on the velocity field via the osmotic pressure associated with the concentration differences across the semi-permeable cylinders. Our results show that the presence of osmotic pressure strongly alters the dynamics of the centrifugal instabilities and substantially reduces the critical conditions above which Taylor vortices are observed. It is also found that this enhancement of the hydrodynamic instabilities eventually plateaus as the osmotic pressure is further increased. We propose a mechanism to explain how osmosis and instabilities cooperate and develop an analytical criterion to bound the parameter range for which osmosis fosters the hydrodynamic instabilities.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Sketch demonstrating concentration polarization in a plate-and-frame RO system.

Figure 1

Figure 2.(a) Sketch of the base-state flow and concentration field in a Taylor–Couette cell with two semi-permeable cylinders and a superimposed radial inflow. (b) Sketch of the counter-rotating Taylor vortices (the blue online toroidal streamtubes), the outward and inward jets which (the black arrows) advect the concentration boundary layer to form zones of alternate accumulation and depletion of solute, shown in the planform above.

Figure 2

Figure 3.(a) Radial velocity of the base state $U_b(r)$ for radius ratio $\eta =0.85$ and radial inflow ${Re}=-0.1$. (b) Concentration field of the base state $C_b(r)$ for radius ratio $\eta =0.85$ a radial inflow with Péclet number ${Pe}={Re}\,{Sc}=-20$ (light grey, green online) and ${Pe}={Re}\,{Sc}=-100$ (dark grey, blue online). The vertical dashed (blue online) line materializes the polarization layer thickness $\delta$ as computed from (2.15) for ${Pe}=-100$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.(a) Maximum of the concentration field $C_{b,{max}}$ (in log scale) as a function of the radius ratio $\eta$ and Péclet number ${Pe}={Re}\,{Sc}$ (in log scale). (b) Boundary layer thickness $\delta$ (in log scale) as a function of the radius ratio $\eta$ and Péclet number ${Pe}={Re}\,{Sc}$ (in log scale). Note the uncommon ${Pe}$-axis merging negative and positive values of this parameter to account for radial in- and outflows, and the resulting discontinuities of the surfaces. Note also the reversed $\eta$-axes in both figures.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Reduced operating pressure $\sigma \Delta P/{Re}$ as a function of $\chi \,{Sc}$ and ${Pe}={Re}\,{Sc}$, for (a) $\eta =0.85$ and (b) $\eta =0.25$. All quantities are in log scale and note the uncommon ${Pe}$-axis merging positive and negative values of this parameter to account for out- and inflows and the resulting discontinuities of the surfaces.

Figure 5

Figure 6.(a) Radial velocity field $U^{{num}}$ and (b) concentration field $C^{{num}}$ as functions of $r$ and $z$, obtained by DNS for $\eta =0.85$, ${Re}=-0.1$, $\sigma =10^{-10}$, ${Sc}=1000$ and $\chi = 10^{-3}$, at ${Ta}=90$. The black superimposed curves highlight the fluctuations of radial velocity and concentration at the membrane. The dark grey (blue online) frames on both surfaces are a reminder of the base state $U_b$ and $C_b$ and the dark grey (blue online) dashed curve superimposed on the concentration field bounds the polarization layer, the thickness of which $\delta$ is given by (2.15). Note that for the sake of clarity, the $r$-axis has been reversed between both surfaces.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Velocity fields of the vortices $\boldsymbol {V}_{p,{merid{.}}}=(U_{p},W_{p})$ and concentration perturbation $C_{p}$ in a meridional plane $(r,z)$, for $\eta =0.85$, ${Re}=-0.1$, ${Sc}=1000$, $\sigma =10^{-10}$ and $\chi =10^{-3}$, obtained numerically at ${Ta}=80$ (a) and analytically at critical conditions ${Ta}^{{crit}}=78.4$ (b). Corresponding radial profiles of the radial (c), azimuthal (d) and axial (e) components of the velocity and concentration ( f) perturbations, obtained by linear stability analysis (light grey, green online, solid curves) and DNS (dark grey, blue online, dashed curves).

Figure 7

Figure 8.Analytically obtained critical Taylor number ${Ta}^{{crit}}$ (a) and axial wavenumber $k^{{crit}}$ (b), in the presence of radial inflow with ${Re}=-0.1$, for $\eta =0.85$, ${Sc}=10^3$ and $\chi =10^{-3}$, as functions of the velocity–pressure coupling coefficient $\sigma$, in log scale. The dashed horizontal lines correspond to the case where $\sigma =0$ in boundary conditions (3.2b). Analytically obtained radial profiles of the radial component of the velocity (c) and concentration (d) for ${Re}=-0.1$, $\eta =0.85$, ${Sc}=10^3$ $\chi =10^{-3}$ and $\sigma =0$ (dashed, blue online, curve), $\sigma =10^{-3}$ (light grey, green online, solid curve) and $\sigma =10^{-2}$ (dark grey, red online, solid curve).

Figure 8

Figure 9.Critical Taylor number as a function of the Schmidt number ${Sc}$ and coupling coefficient $\chi$, in log scale, for $\eta =0.85$ and ${Re}=-0.1$ (a) and ${Re}=0.1$ (b). The dark grey (blue online) solid curves correspond to the locus of the boundary condition criterion on the inner cylinder $\chi _1$ (5.7) and the light grey (green online) ones to the boundary condition criterion on the outer cylinder $\chi _2$ (5.11).

Figure 9

Figure 10.Critical Taylor number as a function of the Schmidt number ${Sc}$ and coupling coefficient $\chi$, in log scale, for $\eta =0.85$ and ${Re}=-1$ (a) and ${Re}=-0.01$ (b). The dark grey (blue online) solid curves correspond to the locus of the boundary condition criterion on the inner cylinder $\chi _1$ (5.7) and the light grey (green online) ones to the boundary condition criterion on the outer cylinder $\chi _2$ (5.11).

Figure 10

Figure 11.Critical Taylor number as a function of the Schmidt number ${Sc}$ and coupling coefficient $\chi$, in log scale, for ${Re}=-0.1$ and $\eta =0.95$ (a) and $\eta =0.55$ (b). The dark grey (blue online) solid curves correspond to the locus of the boundary condition criterion on the inner cylinder $\chi _1$ (5.7) and the light grey (green online) ones to the boundary condition criterion on the outer cylinder $\chi _2$ (5.11).

Figure 11

Figure 12.Wavelength at critical conditions $\lambda ^{{crit}}$, as a function of the Schmidt number ${Sc}$ and coupling coefficient $\chi$ in log scale, for $Re=-0.1$ and $\eta =0.95$ (a) and $\eta =0.55$ (b). Note the axes orientation differs from figure 11.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Velocity fields of the vortices $\boldsymbol {V}_{p,{merid{.}}}=(U_{p},W_{p})$ and concentration perturbation $C_{p}$ in a meridional plane $(r,z)$, for $\eta =0.85$, ${Re}=-0.1$, $\chi =10^{-3}$ and ${Sc}=500$ (a) and ${Sc}=2000$ (b), obtained analytically at critical conditions. The dark grey (blue online) dashed lines above the inner cylinder bound the polarization layer, the thickness of which is given by (2.15).

Figure 13

Figure 14.Velocity fields of the vortices ($U_{p},W_{p}$) and concentration perturbation $C_{p}$ in a meridional plane for $\eta =0.85$, ${Re}=-0.1$, ${Sc}=1000$ and $\chi =5\times 10^{-5}$ (a) and $\chi =10^{-1}$ (b), obtained analytically at critical conditions.

Figure 14

Figure 15.(a) Critical Taylor number $Ta^{{crit}}$ as a function of the coupling coefficient $\chi$ in log scale, for $\eta =0.85$, ${Re}=-0.1$ and ${Sc}=1000$. (b) Radial velocity perturbation $u_p$, (c) concentration perturbation $c_p$, the dashed black vertical line bounding the polarization layer, the thickness of which $\delta$ is given by (2.15), (d) advection of the bases-state concentration by the radial velocity perturbation (term ${\bigcirc{\kern-6pt 3}}$ of (5.2)) and (e) advection of the concentration perturbation by the base-state radial flow (term ${\bigcirc{\kern-6pt 1}}$ of (5.2)), as functions of $r$, obtained analytically at $\chi =0$ (solid black curves), $10^{-4}$ (dotted curves, magenta online), $10^{-3}$ (dashed curves, blue online), $10^{-2}$ (dashed-dotted curves, red online) and $10^{-1}$ (solid light grey curves, green online), the circles in (a) correspond to the four last cases, whilst the black horizontal dashed line corresponds to the osmosis-free $\chi =0$ case. The dashed vertical (blue online) line in (a) corresponds to the limit value $\chi _1$ inferred from (5.7).

Figure 15

Figure 16.(a) Critical Taylor number ${Ta}^{{crit}}$ as a function of the coupling coefficient $\chi$, in log scale, for $\eta =0.95$, ${Re}=-0.1$ and ${Sc}=1000$. (b) Radial velocity perturbation $u_p(r)$ and (c) concentration perturbation $c_p(r)$ , obtained analytically at $\chi =10^{-4}$ (solid curves, green online), $10^{-2}$ (dashed curves, blue online) and $5\times 10^{-1}$ (dashed-dotted curves, red online), the circles in (a) correspond to these three cases.

Figure 16

Figure 17.Limit values $\chi _1\,{Sc}$ and $\chi _2\,{Sc}$, bounding the $\chi \,{Sc}$ range where osmosis lessens the critical Taylor number, as functions of $\eta$ and ${Pe}$, shown for (a) radial inflows (${Pe}<0$) and (b) radial outflows (${Pe}>0$).

Figure 17

Figure 18.Asymptotic critical Taylor number ${Ta}^{{crit}}_{{min}}$ approximated by the critical Taylor number $\left.{Ta}^{{crit}}\right |_{|{Pe}|=200,\chi \,{Sc}=46}$ at Péclet number $|{Pe}|=200$ and coupling coefficient $\chi \,{Sc}=46$ (solid curves) and critical Taylor number for pure solvent ${Ta}^{{crit}}_{{pure}}$ (dashed curves), as functions of the radius ratio $\eta$, for radial outflows (a) and inflows (b). (c,d) Corresponding ratio $\epsilon =1-{Ta}^{{crit}}_{{min}}/{Ta}^{{crit}}_{{pure}}$.