The study of international networks has picked up considerable pace in the last decade. An increasing number of studies have relied on the notion that international relations are about networks. Not only are relations between any two states or between states and nonstate actors a function of the internal characteristics of units or their history; they also depend on the relations between any of these two units and their respective environments. Interdependence exists on many levels—some quite visible, others more latent. A better understanding of these many layers of interdependence, their origins and their impacts would greatly enhance our understanding of global politics.
This is the key message of Networked Politics, and it is an important one. Miles Kahler's introductory chapter offers two conceptions of international networks. The “networks as structures” perspective is the common conception advanced by network science: a set of units (nodes) and a rule that defines whether and to what extent any two units are linked to each other. Structures are emergent from the relationships among nodes. The “networks as actors” conception views networks as “a specific institutional form that stands in contrast to the hierarchical organization of states and to the temporally limited exchange relations of markets” (p. 5). Kahler notes that these two conceptions “illuminate the relationship between structure and agency in international relations” (p. 7). These two—seemingly different—conceptions of networks define the structure of the book.
What follows is a set of essays on the networked mechanisms of different aspects of international politics. Each chapter focuses on a different type of network and on different questions regarding the networks under study. However, they all address important aspects of the functioning of international relations in a globalized and interdependent world.
Emilie M. Hafner-Burton and Alexander H. Montgomery focus on Preferential Trade Agreement (PTA) networks. They argue that a network conception of power and inequality offers a radically different view of the position of actors within a network than the more conventional perspectives. Their description of the changes in power positions of individual states, as well as the changing structure of PTA networks over time, provides insights in particular about the ability of a structural approach based on network-analytic concepts to highlight hidden trends in international politics over time.
Network-analytic approaches are particularly relevant when there is interdependence in the formation and maintenance of relationships. Zachary Elkins's chapter on constitutional networks highlights the impact of international networks on constitutional adoption and reform in states. Elkins offers a fourfold typology of the ways in which networks might affect constitutional reform or adaptation. He highlights several mechanisms by which states or institutions might develop or change constitutions as a function of network processes. This chapter offers no empirical evidence of how these mechanisms work. Rather, it suggests some ideas concerning how they can be studied.
Helen Yanacopulus focuses on the question of network design. She examines how two collective-action coalitions—the Jubilee 2000 and Make Poverty History—developed institutional structures with a broad appeal. She also examines the impact of evolving structures on the influence of these groups. She ascribes the ability of these coalitions to influence outcomes to the scaled-up network-of-networks structure.
Michael Kenney's analysis of transnational criminal networks is particularly illuminating. It focuses on the dilemma of network design in a criminal context: having to trade off a structure maximizing the leadership's ability to communicate and control the network against the need to minimize the probability of penetration and breakup by legal authorities. The case study of the Columbian drug cartel illustrates the problem of adapting network structure to changing circumstances due to government activity.
This leads directly into Kahler's study of Al Qaeda. Popular conception has Al Qaeda operating as a highly hierarchical and centralized terrorist network. The reality is that the network is characterized by its formation of a link among territorially and organizationally diverse but ideologically similar groups, with the leadership serving as an ideological, training, and brokerage agent. Here, too, the adaptability of Al Qaeda to changing circumstances is a feature of these kinds of clandestine networks.
David A. Lake and Wendy H. Wong examine the structure of Amnesty International (AI). Using the preferential attachment model of network formation, they suggest that the evolution of AI as a network illuminates the fact that norms are emergent properties of networks.
Janice Gross Stein studies the Accountability of Humanitarian Organization networks—networks combining donor organizations and humanitarian nongovernmental organizations (NGOs). She argues that had these elements acted without forming a network, they could not possibly have accomplished a number of important objectives, including developing mutually acceptable concepts of effectiveness and accountability, and reducing the hierarchical relationship between donors and activists.
Peter Cowhey and Milton Mueller examine the self-organizing governance structure of the Internet. This network emphasizes the potential or actual conflict between principals and agents. The former wish to exercise control; the latter wish to exercise freedom of communication and access to information. The authors argue that the reduced costs of global information networks provided incentives for governments to delegate governance and coordination responsibilities to NGOs, rather than to international organizations over which they could exercise control.
Mette Eilstrup-Sangiovanni examines transnational governmental networks (TGNs) of international security. Using a typology that distinguishes between institutionalized, hierarchical intergovernmental-organization (IGO) networks and decentralized TGNs, she argues that even in the highly controlled international security realm, many aspects of TGN structure and functions offer advantages to government to coordinate and accomplish outcomes that may not have been possible if the interaction occurred via IGO networks.
Kathryn Sikkink summarizes the volume by highlighting the common themes and characteristics of the networks discussed in the various chapters. Her focus is on the alleged difference between networks as decentralized forms of self-organization and hierarchies. She emphasizes the effect that such decentralization has on coordination, functionality, and international governance.
The substantive chapters tell important and interesting stories about networks. They illuminate different structures, functions, and outcomes. They use the network vocabulary and important concepts in network analysis (including network power as various centrality indices, models of network formation, some specific forms of network structure, etc.). They provide information about aspects of international relations that are emerging as increasingly important forces in global politics. These include humanitarian organizations, terrorist and other illicit organizations, and the Internet, makeing the book interesting and informative reading.
At the same time, several problems limit the value of this book to students and scholars with more analytical inclinations. First, most network analysts would view the “networks as structures” versus “networks as actors” dichotomy as fundamentally flawed. The various chapters actually demonstrate this point. Even those authors who study networks as actors focus on the structure of the network and its effects on outcomes. Network analysis is capable not only of distinguishing between hierarchies and decentralized forms of connectivity but also of measuring them in quite precise ways. Second, critics of the use of network analysis in political science have often claimed that this perspective is primarily descriptive; it lacks meaningful analytic and explanatory power. Those critics will find that Networked Politics vindicates this claim. The substantive chapters—even those using network analysis—are primarily descriptive. They tell interesting stories, but the standards of evidence leave a lot to be desired. Third, almost all of the authors claim that networks enable actors to accomplish things that they could not have accomplished in their absence. However, they do not present meaningful evidence to that effect.
These problems suggest that while the book is a useful contribution to the literature focusing on the organization and activity of transnational actors, its contribution to the systematic study of international networks is more limited.
