Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T06:15:58.011Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Time-delayed characteristics of turbulence in pulsatile pipe flow

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 January 2024

Xu Liu
Affiliation:
School of Naval Architecture, Ocean and Civil Engineering, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, PR China
Hongbo Zhu
Affiliation:
School of Naval Architecture, Ocean and Civil Engineering, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, PR China
Yan Bao*
Affiliation:
School of Naval Architecture, Ocean and Civil Engineering, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, PR ChinaState Key Laboratory of Ocean Engineering, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, PR ChinaKey Laboratory of Hydrodynamics of Ministry of Education, Shanghai 200240, PR China
Narakorn Srinil
Affiliation:
School of Engineering, Newcastle University, NE1 7RU, UK
Dai Zhou
Affiliation:
School of Naval Architecture, Ocean and Civil Engineering, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, PR ChinaState Key Laboratory of Ocean Engineering, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, PR ChinaKey Laboratory of Hydrodynamics of Ministry of Education, Shanghai 200240, PR China
Zhaolong Han
Affiliation:
School of Naval Architecture, Ocean and Civil Engineering, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, PR ChinaState Key Laboratory of Ocean Engineering, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, PR ChinaKey Laboratory of Hydrodynamics of Ministry of Education, Shanghai 200240, PR China
*
†Email address for correspondence: ybao@sjtu.edu.cn

Abstract

Direct numerical simulations are performed to study temporal variations of the wall shear stresses and flow dynamics in the turbulent pulsatile pipe flow. The mechanisms, responsible for the paradoxical phenomenon for which the amplitude of the oscillating wall shear stress in the turbulent flow is smaller than that in the laminar flow for the same pulsation conditions, are investigated. It is shown that the delayed response of turbulence in the buffer layer generates a large magnitude of the radial gradient of the Reynolds shear stress near the wall, which counteracts the effect of the oscillating pressure gradient on the change of the streamwise velocity and hence reduces the amplitude of the wall shear stress. Such a delayed response consists of two processes: the delayed development of near-wall streaks and the subsequent energy redistribution from the streamwise velocity fluctuation to the other two co-existing components. This is a dynamical manifestation of the viscoelasticity of turbulent eddies. As the frequency is reduced, the variation of the friction Reynolds number results in a phase-wise variation of the time scale and intensity of the turbulence response, causing the hysteresis of the wall shear stress. Such a phase asymmetry is amplified by the increase of the pulsation amplitude. An examination of the energy spectra reveals that the near-wall streaks are stretched in the streamwise direction during the acceleration phase, and then break up into small-scale structures in the deceleration phase, accompanied by the enhanced dissipation that transforms the turbulent kinetic energy into heat.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Cases with different pulsation parameters, namely the pulsation amplitude $A$, the frequency $\omega ^+$. Here, $l_s^{+}$ is the laminar Stokes thickness; $W$ is the Womersley number; $A_{\widetilde {\tau _{w}},t}/A_{\widetilde {\tau _{w}},s}$ is the amplitude of the wall shear stress normalized by its laminar Stokes value; and $Re_b=U_bD/\nu$ and $Re_w={A_{\tilde {u}_{cl}}}^2/\omega \nu$ are the bulk and oscillatory Reynolds numbers, respectively.

Figure 1

Figure 1.(a) Variation of the amplitude of the wall shear stress $A_{\widetilde {\tau _{w}},t}$ normalized by the laminar Stokes amplitude $A_{\widetilde {\tau _{w}},s}$ with respect to the laminar Stokes thickness $l_s^+$. (b) Laminar–turbulent transition boundary (dash-dotted line, Lodahl et al.1998) and parameter combinations considered by previous studies. The critical Reynolds numbers $Re_{b,tr}$ and $Re_{w,tr}$ are denoted by the dashed lines.

Figure 2

Table 2.Summary of the grid information. Here, $\Delta x^+$, $\Delta y^+$ are the normalized streamwise, wall-normal grid resolutions; $\Delta (r\theta )_{wall}^+$ is the normalized circumferential grid resolution at the wall; $P$ is the number of Lagrange knot points along the side of each element, corresponding to a polynomial order of $P-1$; $N$ represents the number of Fourier expansion planes in the circumferential direction; $H$ denotes the number of elements in the streamwise direction, which is associated with the streamwise $h$-refinement strategy in the spectral element method.

Figure 3

Figure 2.Comparisons of the phase-averaged wall shear stress $\langle \tau _w\rangle$ between different mesh-independence validation cases: (a) Case 3 ($A=0.1$, $l_s^+=14$); (b) Case 7 ($A=0.4$, $l_s^+=17$).

Figure 4

Figure 3.Contours of the instantaneous inner-scaled streamwise velocity $u^{+}$ in the meridional plane for Case 7 ($A=0.4$, $l_s^+=17$) at (a) $\varphi \approx 0$, (b) $\varphi \approx {\rm \pi}/4$, (c) $\varphi \approx {\rm \pi}/2$, (d) $\varphi \approx 3{\rm \pi} /4$.

Figure 5

Figure 4.(a) Time evolution of the oscillating component of the streamwise velocity $\tilde {u}_{cl}$ at the pipe centreline. (b) Wall-normal profiles of the mean streamwise velocity $\bar {u}^{+}$. (c) Wall-normal profiles of the components of the Reynolds stress tensor. Note that the curves for the steady pipe (no pulsation) overlap completely with those for Case 2 in panel (b,c).

Figure 6

Figure 5.Phase-wise variations of the oscillating component of the wall shear stress $\widetilde {\tau _w}$ for $A=0.1$ (the black lines), with the corresponding fundamental Fourier mode represented by the red solid lines. The blue dashed lines correspond to the laminar Stokes solution. The vertical arrows denote the phases where the phase-averaged wall shear stress $\langle \tau _w \rangle$ reaches its maximum or minimum. (a) Case 1; (b) Case 2; (c) Case 3; (d) Case 4; (e) Case 5.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Phase-wise variations of the oscillating component of the wall shear stress $\widetilde {\tau _w}$ for $A=0.4$ (the black lines), with the corresponding fundamental Fourier mode represented by the red solid lines. The blue dashed lines correspond to the laminar Stokes solution. The vertical arrows denote the phases where the phase-averaged wall shear stress $\langle \tau _w \rangle$ reaches its maximum or minimum. (a) Case 6; (b) Case 7.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Phase-wise variations of (a) the laminar Stokes velocity $\tilde {u}^{+}$, (b) the turbulent streamwise velocity $\tilde {u}^{+}$ and (c) the Reynolds shear stress $\widetilde {u'v'}^{+}$ for Case 3 ($A=0.1$, $l_s^+=14$). The magenta contours in panel (c) represent the term $\wp$, with the values (divided by $10^{-3}$) marked on the contour lines. The magenta dash-dotted straight line indicates the laminar Stokes thickness of $l_s^{+}=14$.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Phase-wise variations of (a) the streamwise Reynolds normal stress $\widetilde {u'u'}^+$ and (b) the radial Reynolds normal stress $\widetilde {v'v'}^+$ for Case 3 ($A=0.1$, $l_s^+=14$). Phase-wise variations of the production terms in (4.1) for Case 3 ($A=0.1$, $l_s^+=14$): (c) $P_{uu,1}^+$, (e) $P_{uu,2}^+$, (g) $P_{uu,3}^+$, (d) $P_{uv,1}^+$, (f) $P_{uv,2}^+$, (h) $P_{uv,3}^+$. The magenta dash-dotted lines indicate the laminar Stokes thickness of $l_s^{+}=14$.

Figure 10

Figure 9.Phase-wise variation of the dissipation rate $\widetilde {\varepsilon ^+}$ of the TKE $k=\overline {u'_{i}u'_{i}}$ ($i=1,2,3$) for Case 3 ($A=0.1$, $l_s^+=14$). Note that the time-averaged dissipation rate $\overline {\varepsilon ^+}$ is negative, thus a negative value of the oscillating component indicates the enhanced dissipation rate. For the definition of $\widetilde {\varepsilon ^+}$, we refer the reader to Eggels et al. (1994) for further details.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Schematic of the flow dynamics leading to the damping of the wall shear stress. The vertical arrows indicate whether the quantities increase or decrease. The vertical lines denote the absolute values.

Figure 12

Figure 11.(a) Phase-wise variations of the Reynolds shear stress $\widetilde {u'v'}^+$ and the shear strain rate $-\partial \tilde {u}^+/\partial r^+$ at $y^+=15.8$ where the overall absolute value of $\widetilde {u'u'}$ reaches its maximum for Case 3 ($A=0.1$, $l_s^+=14$). (b) Phase-wise variations of the term $\wp$ and the oscillating pressure gradient $-\partial \tilde {p}/\partial x$ at $y^+=6.5$ where the overall absolute value of term $\wp$ reaches its maximum for Case 3 ($A=0.1$, $l_s^+=14$). The red solid and dashed lines represent the respective fundamental Fourier modes that are used to calculate the phase difference.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Phase-wise variations of (a) the turbulent streamwise velocity $\tilde {u}^+$, (b) the Reynolds normal stress $\widetilde {u'u'}^+$, (c) the Reynolds normal stress $\widetilde {v'v'}^+$ and (d) the Reynolds shear stress $\widetilde {u'v'}^+$ for Case 4 ($A=0.1$, $l_s^+=17$). The data are duplicated and then spliced such that two periods are presented.

Figure 14

Figure 13.Phase-wise variations of the term $\wp$, the oscillating pressure gradient $-\partial \tilde {p}/\partial x$, the streamwise velocity $\tilde {u}$ (divided by a scale factor of 5) and the quantity of $-\partial \tilde {p}/\partial x+\wp$ at (a) $y^+=6.1$ where the overall absolute value of term $\wp$ reaches its maximum, and at (b) $y^+=12.2$ where the overall absolute value of $\widetilde {u'u'}$ reaches its maximum for Case 4 ($A=0.1$, $l_s^+=17$).

Figure 15

Figure 14.Definitions of the quantities associated with the time scale of turbulence response: $t_{T,max}$, $t_{T,min}$, $t_{D,max}$, $t_{D,min}$. The data of the curves are taken from Case 4 ($A=0.1$, $l_s^+=17$) at $y^+=12.2$. The values of $\widetilde {u'u'}^+$ are divided by a scale factor of 30.

Figure 16

Figure 15.Wall-normal profiles of $t_T$ normalized by the pulsation period $T$. Solid lines, $t_{T,max}$; dashed lines, $t_{T,min}$. Note that $-\partial \tilde {u}/\partial r$ approaches zero close to the centreline and numerical errors occur when determining $t_T$. The regions where the magnitude of local maximum $\lvert \partial \tilde {u}/\partial r \rvert$ drops below 10 % of the overall maximum are considered to be accompanied by certain numerical errors, which are marked by the black dots.

Figure 17

Figure 16.Wall-normal profiles of inner-scaled $t_D^{+}$. Solid lines, $t_{D,max}$; dashed lines, $t_{D,min}$. The meaning of the black dots is the same as that in figure 15.

Figure 18

Figure 17.Temporal evolution of instantaneous space-averaged wall shear stress $\tau _w$ over all the pulsation periods that are used to perform the phase average. The red solid lines represent the corresponding laminar Stokes values. (a) Case 3; (b) Case 4; (c) Case 6; (d) Case 7.

Figure 19

Figure 18.Phase-wise variations of the turbulent streamwise velocity $\tilde {u}^{+}$, the Reynolds stresses $\widetilde {u'u'}^{+}$, $\widetilde {v'v'}^{+}$ and $\widetilde {u'v'}^{+}$ for $A=0.4$. (a,c,e,g) Case 6 ($A=0.4$, $l_s^+=14$); (b,d,f,h) Case 7 ($A=0.4$, $l_s^+=17$).

Figure 20

Figure 19.Phase-wise variations of the term $\wp$, the oscillating pressure gradient $-\partial \tilde {p}/\partial x$, the streamwise velocity $\tilde {u}$ (divided by a scale factor of 5) and the quantity of $-\partial \tilde {p}/\partial x+\wp$ at (a) $y^+=6.5$ for Case 6 ($A=0.4$, $l_s^+=14$), (b) $y^+=5.8$ for Case 7 ($A=0.4$, $l_s^+=17$) where the overall absolute value of term $\wp$ reaches its maximum.

Figure 21

Figure 20.(a) Wall-normal profiles of $t_T$ normalized by the pulsation period $T$. (b) Wall-normal profiles of the inner-scaled $t_D$. Solid lines, $t_{T,max}$ and $t_{D,max}$; dashed lines, $t_{T,min}$ and $t_{D,min}$. The meaning of the black dots is the same as that in figure 15.

Figure 22

Figure 21.Wall-normal profiles of the inner-scaled $t_T$ and $t_D$. (a) Case 6 ($A=0.4$, $l_s^+=14$); (b) Case 7 ($A=0.4$, $l_s^+=17$). The meaning of the black dots is the same as that in figure 15.

Figure 23

Figure 22.Normalized streamwise pre-multiplied spectra $k_x\phi _{uu}$ of streamwise velocity fluctuations, where $\lambda _{x}=2{\rm \pi} /k_x$ is the wavelength. The contour levels are set to be the same for the fixed amplitude. The wall-normal location, where the spectra data are taken from, is at $y^+=14.7$ for (a) Case 2, (b) Case 3, (c) Case 4, (d) Case 5, and at $y^+=16.9$ for (e) Case 6, (f) Case 7. The black arrows indicate qualitatively the variation trend of the energy spectrum.

Figure 24

Figure 23.Normalized circumferential pre-multiplied spectra $k_\theta \phi _{uu}$ of streamwise velocity fluctuations, where $\lambda _{\theta }=2{\rm \pi} /k_\theta$ is the wavelength. The contour levels are set to be the same for the fixed amplitude. The wall-normal locations, where the spectra data are collected, are the same as those in figure 22. (a) Case 2, (b) Case 3, (c) Case 4, (d) Case 5, (e) Case 6, (f) Case 7.