No one could accuse Douglas Kellner's new book, Cinema Wars, of pulling its punches when it comes to the theme of Hollywood and politics in the first decade of the 2000s in America. The author of such groundbreaking works as Camera Politica and Media Spectacle: The Crisis of Democracy is about as unequivocal as you can get when he suggests at one point that “by 2006 it was clear that the Bush–Cheney administration was a world historical catastrophe of the highest order.” And his ire is not just reserved for the “Bush Gang,” as he frequently refers to them in the book. In an introduction that delves into the cinematic battle mid-decade between the disciples of Michael Moore's agenda in Fahrenheit 9/11 and supporters of Mel Gibson's right-wing-appropriated The Passion of the Christ, Kellner offers us this:
Both Bush and Gibson are morally self-righteous and champion redemptive violence in the struggle for good. Both are extremely megalomaniac, seeing themselves as chosen vehicles of God, yet often appear addled and inarticulate when confronted by difficult questions, possibly due to years of excessive drug and alcohol abuse that impaired their cognitive faculties.
With such comments, it's a wonder the lawyers did not get involved at some stage!
In an equally strident chapter entitled “Confronting the Horrors of the Bush–Cheney Era,” Kellner sets out a damming list of indictments, all of which in one form or another have been documented and/or exposed by films in the 2000s. Apart from being a thoroughly entertaining, if sometimes depressing, read for its account of duplicity and malfeasance that, in Kellner's eyes at least, has barely ever taken place on a grander scale – and he significantly mentions Richard Nixon very little until late in the piece when he quotes John Dean as saying the Bush regime's crimes were worse than Watergate – this is an important document of the way Hollywood, film, and filmmakers came to the table and delivered critiques, opprobrium and outright accusation in a series of movies and documentaries during the Bush years. If one had a minor quibble it would be that in the aforementioned chapter 1 Kellner covers a huge amount of ground and rightly acknowledges the renaissance of political documentary as a force for dialogue and debate, but not all of those films were associated with Hollywood. Indeed he hints at the fact that mainstream Hollywood has been possibly more restrained in its outlook than some “independent” filmmakers and that overall some of the industry's most pertinent critiques have been at the level of allegory (the Star Wars prequels seem to work uncannily accurately as resemblances of the Bush–Cheney takeover happening in a galaxy far, far away), rather than outright political attack. The at-times delicate relationship between Hollywood and independents deserves more consideration, therefore, but the power of their message remains undiluted in Kellner's assertive analysis. One factor he could not have anticipated is that two mainstream political thrillers (one of them, ironically enough, with Mel Gibson) subsequently emerged in the post-Bush era, both of them adapted from British television, and have possibly done more to underline the surreptitious and devious nature of Bush's America than some of the other prominent movies he mentions. Both State of Play and Edge of Darkness mixed political, economic, cultural and authoritarian ideologies into a noxious mix of deceit, unaccountable power and the politics of exploitation, and they are a significant coda to the venomous attacks here.
Kellner's book came too early for an account of these movies, but that does not detract from the powerful critiques on offer. His position is never less than emblazoned in bold letters, but it does not mean that his assessment of, for example, Moore's filmmaking, 9/11 movies, and new political biographies is not couched in anything other than analytical and observant tones that tease out illuminated meanings with each scene and sentence. Kellner's provocative style might not always appear to sit easily with the reader, and this book more than his others sometimes tries to bridge a dangerous ravine between Moore-like polemical accusations and, shall we say, a somewhat more crafted academic style. But that does not detract from the fact that Cinema Wars is provocative and infectious film history and it deserves a wide readership in an important political era.
