Rene Reeves' book on the social, economic and ethnic transformations that took place in the Mam region of the department of Quezaltenango between the 1830s and 1880s is a solid regional history. He provides background information on how the small region (much of which became a major coffee production area in the period he studies) took shape in the post-conquest period in the first substantive chapter, a useful addition because relatively little is known about the Mam of the area. But the main issue the book addresses is the wider question of when and how liberal market reforms took place in the region and how they affected social and political relations there and more widely in Guatemala.
In the introduction Reeves introduces his problematic by asking why Guatemalan subalterns so widely contested the Liberal reforms pressed upon them in the 1830s (to the extent of overthrowing the Liberal government and replacing it with a Conservative one for more than 35 years) and yet protested very little against codification of very similar economic reforms in the 1870s. What he wants to question is the inevitability of liberal market reforms in Guatemala, the argument made by most historians of nineteenth-century Guatemala, whether traditional-nationalist or revisionist. The answer he provides is essentially that Rafael Carrera's ‘conservative’ government, an unusual type in nineteenth-century Latin America, was not so conservative in key economic policies, insofar as it relentlessly introduced market reforms for export producers, facilitated indigenous wage labour and expanded state institutions over its 35 years in power. It was able to do so without provoking peasant rebellion, he suggests, because it handled individual cases tactically, doing little to change municipal governance, the Church's powers, and other customary practices – changes attempted by the failed Liberal government of the 1830s. As market reform developed, together with growing ladino control over the economy, Reeves suggests that the indigenous population most harmed by it simply became used to it. With no distracting attacks on the Church, radically revised municipal governance or cholera epidemics, subalterns did not rebel against the gradual if ultimately far-reaching economic reforms of the Conservative government.
While Reeves' thesis is not entirely new, it is more closely depicted for this small region than the work of an earlier generation of revisionists: David McCreery, J. C. Cambranes, Ralph Lee Woodward, Gudmundson and Lindo-Fuentes, and Arturo Taracena, important historians of the nineteenth century whose work Reeves notes. Chapter 2, on property relations, shows that the 1870s leader usually credited with the liberal ‘revolution’, Justo Rufino Barrios, had little to do with the ‘transformation of land tenure and agriculture that allowed the Costa Cuca to achieve dramatic production levels [in coffee by 1880]’ (p. 39). By examining municipal archives, Reeves describes the process whereby indigenous communities became divided over how to handle encroaching ladino agriculturalists, who promised but rarely paid rents on indigenous communal lands. By the time Barrios took power in 1871, much communal land useful for coffee production had already been taken over by ladino renters. Formal re-titling of the alienated land did not take place until Barrios took over, one of the reasons why earlier historians, who mainly consulted property ownership archives, misinterpreted what had happened under Conservative rule.
Chapter 3 deals with debt and other forms of labour coercion and shows that such means of harnessing indigenous wage labour for coffee plantations were not newly introduced in the 1870s or especially oppressive, but did expand in that period. Ultimately, wage labour was not based on coercion, but grew mainly because peasants had insufficient land to feed themselves – in Reeves' words, they ‘entered the labor force for purely economic reasons’ (p. 74). In documenting the phenomenon, Reeves notes that the market dependence of large segments of the indigenous population had already grown considerably by the end of the colonial period. Advancing money to potential workers early was simply the normal way of making a labour contract in the post-colonial period, as helpful to the worker as to the employer: ‘Debt usually did not initiate a life-long or even multiyear cycle of servitude … [and thus] the practice of cash advances … does not appear to have been an interim step on the march to proletarianization’ (pp. 88–9). Forced labour drafts (mandamientos) were rarely used for any kind of agricultural labour, though they were common for road and other building projects from the colonial period through the early twentieth century.
Chapter 4 is devoted to policies concerning the sale of aguardiente (illegal liquor) during the entire nineteenth century. Policy changed at various times but throughout the period the favoured government policy was that of selling to the highest bidder a monopoly on legal production and sales, making all local competitors illegal. Reeves demonstrates conclusively that women were the main producers and sellers of aguardiente, that the ethnic numbers appeared proportional to the sizes of the local ethnic populations – though monopolists were typically ladinos (usually the highest bidders for the business) – and that reinforcement of the current laws was erratic. While this is an interesting chapter, it is not exactly clear what it adds to the analysis of market reforms in the contrasting ‘conservative’ and ‘liberal’ eras. Perhaps the most interesting point made is that Barrios' support for ‘free trade’ in liquor may have made subalterns less restive about his takeover from the conservatives.
Subtitled ‘From Ladino State to Ladino Nation’, Chapter 5 contrasts the colonial-conservative with conservative ideologies concerning state and nation, especially after 1871, when a strong state apparatus fully imposed Liberal rule. Colonial-conservative rulers viewed the Maya as a protected class of subjects owed judicial protections by creole-ladino rulers, kept in the position of perpetual minors. Reeves argues that the Liberals in the post-1870 period considered ladinos to be true citizens, and granted similar status only to those few Maya who had ‘separated themselves from indigenous society … [U]nequal treatment had been justified by a legal caste system under the conservatives [whereas the new Liberals treated] the Maya as an inferior class and single[d] them out with coercive state policies inconsistent with Liberal notions of equality’ (p. 156). He continues: ‘The new Liberal project unified non-indigenous Guatemalans, rich and poor, by asserting their historic role as the bearers of national progress and by according them a privileged position as the true citizens of the nation, in contrast to the indigenous “other”’ (p. 162), leading to an exclusionary ladino nation. Reeves goes on to assert that the new Liberals were successful in this endeavour and encountered little difficulty in imposing it because ‘many of the planks of the Liberal agenda already had been nailed into place’ by Carrera. He concludes that the ‘military conflict between Liberals and Conservatives … and its associated rhetorical grandstanding’, masked a great deal of underlying continuity between the two parties particularly with regard to land and labour policies.
In his conclusion (Chapter 6), Reeves attempts to theorise his arguments concerning indigenous rebellion and quiescence using such notions as hegemonic processes and ‘overdetermination’. Here he does little to alter or refine the theories of Gramsci, Althusser or even Florencia Mallon for the case. And by worrying these questions, in addition to those of state making and nation formation, his conclusion loses sight of his initial question – whether market reforms were inevitable in Guatemala, the classic assumption of historians dealing with developments in nineteenth-century Guatemala. On the basis of his evidence, one could in fact argue that he proves that once coffee offered Guatemala a produit motor, market reforms were inevitable! Despite this flaw, Reeves's regional history very much amplifies our understanding of the relationships we now have about Conservatives, Liberals, indigenous rebellions, and Guatemala's export-oriented development on the backs of indigenous workers.
