Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T11:28:50.989Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Averaging theory for heat transfer in circular hydraulic jumps with a separation bubble

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  18 January 2024

R. Solana Gómez*
Affiliation:
Institute of Heat and Mass Transfer, RWTH Aachen University, Augustinerbach 6, 52056 Aachen, Germany
T. Bohr
Affiliation:
Department of Physics and Center for Fluid Dynamics, Technical University of Denmark, DK-2800 Kgs. Lyngby, Denmark
S. Nielsen
Affiliation:
Department of Physics and Center for Fluid Dynamics, Technical University of Denmark, DK-2800 Kgs. Lyngby, Denmark
W. Rohlfs
Affiliation:
Department of Thermal and Fluid Engineering, University of Twente, Drienerlolaan 5, 7522 NB Enschede, The Netherlands
R. Kneer
Affiliation:
Institute of Heat and Mass Transfer, RWTH Aachen University, Augustinerbach 6, 52056 Aachen, Germany
H. Askarizadeh*
Affiliation:
Institute of Heat and Mass Transfer, RWTH Aachen University, Augustinerbach 6, 52056 Aachen, Germany
*
†Email addresses for correspondence: solana.gomez@wsa.rwth-aachen.de, askarizadeh@wsa.rwth-aachen.de
†Email addresses for correspondence: solana.gomez@wsa.rwth-aachen.de, askarizadeh@wsa.rwth-aachen.de

Abstract

Analytical investigations of heat transfer during the vertical impingement of an unsubmerged axisymmetric liquid jet on a horizontal plate have been limited to the regions ahead of the jump. This limitation is due to the complex flow physics in the jump region arising from sudden changes in the flow field. This is addressed in here by extending the averaging theory (AT) introduced by Bohr et al. (Phys. Rev. Lett., vol. 79, issue 6, 1997, pp. 1038–1041) which was further developed by Watanabe et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 480, 2003, pp. 233–265), to describe the heat transfer problem in circular hydraulic jumps including separation. The applicability of the resulting theory to determine the temperature field in the jump region is evaluated using the data available in the literature and also by means of fully resolved numerical solutions. Good agreement is observed for moderate Prandtl numbers. However, for sufficiently high Prandtl numbers, deviations become notable. The reasons for the deviations according to their relevance are (i) monotonically decreasing temperature profile inherent to the AT, whereas the fully resolved numerical solutions exhibit a local maximum in the temperature profile away from the plate; and (ii) inapplicability of the concept of dividing the flow field into a region affected and a region unaffected by heat transfer according to the thermal boundary layer thickness. This concept leads to the overestimation of the temperature close to the wall and to the existence of a threshold Prandtl number, for which the thermal boundary layer thickness does not meet the free surface anymore. Around this threshold Prandtl number, the temperature field shows a discontinuous behaviour.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic illustration of a circular jet impinging vertically upon a horizontal plate subjected to a constant heat flux (CHF) $( \dot {q} )$. Various flow structures, type 0 to type IIb, can occur depending on the strength of the jump. Finally the jump can also become unstable with air entrainment.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Streamlines in the region of the hydraulic jump determined by the AT. The working fluid is water: $\rho =998.2 \ \mathrm {kg}\ \mathrm {m}^{-3}$; $\mu = 10.03 \times 10^{-4} \ \mathrm {kg}\ (\mathrm {ms})^{-1}$; $c_p = 4182 \ \mathrm {J}\ (\mathrm {kg}\ \mathrm {K})^{-1}$; ${Pr}=6.991$. The volume flow rate is $Q = 15 \ \mathrm {ml}\ \mathrm {s}^{-1}$.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Flowchart of the solution method for the heat transfer problem.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Comparison of the heights (a) and the Nusselt number profiles (b) predicted by the AT to the results presented by Sung et al. (1999). The working fluid in all cases is water: $\rho =998.2 \ \mathrm {kg}\ \mathrm {m}^{-3}$; $\mu = 10.03 \times 10^{-4} \ \mathrm {kg}\ (\mathrm {ms})^{-1}$; $c_p = 4182 \ \mathrm {J}\ (\mathrm {kg}\ \mathrm {K})^{-1}$; ${Pr} = 6.991$. Results for four different volume fluxes $Q = 15$, 20, 25 and $30 \ \mathrm {ml}\ \mathrm {s}^{-1}$ are shown. The solutions were initialised at a radius of $r_{{i}} = 10\ \mathrm {mm}$ with an initial height of $h_{{i}} = 0.2 \ \mathrm {mm}$ and constant temperature and radial velocity across the film height. Accordingly, the range of the entrance Reynolds numbers is ${Re}_{h_{{i}}} = Q/(2 {\rm \pi}r_{{i}} \nu ) \approx 237.59\unicode{x2013} 475.18$. For the AT, apart from the initial height, the final heights were fixed at a radius of $r_{{end}} = 100 \ \mathrm {mm}$ for the four different cases in the order of increasing volume flux as $h_{{end}} = 1.55\ \mathrm {mm}$, $1.60 \ \mathrm {mm}$, $1.63 \ \mathrm {mm}$ and $1.68 \ \mathrm {mm}$, respectively. Sung et al. (1999) used the definition of ${Nu}_{h_{{i}}} = q_{w} h_{{i}} /[ ( T_0 - T_{{i}} ) k ]$ for the Nusselt number, where $T_{{i}}$ is the temperature across the film height at $r_{{i}}$. According to the notations in this study, the equivalent definition for the Nusselt number reads ${Nu}_{h_{{i}}} = h_{{i}}/(\theta _0 )$, with $h_{{i}}$ denoting the non-dimensional height at $r_{{i}}$. Note that the ICs for the temperature field determined by the ATHT in the order of increasing volume flow rate for the case of a CPT are ${Nu} = 5.12$, $5.44$, $5.53$ and $6.11$, respectively. These hold for a radius of $r = 10.8\ \mathrm {mm}$, because the Nusselt number at the initial radius, $r_{{i}}$, was not exactly extractable from the original work by Sung et al. (1999).

Figure 4

Figure 5.Comparison of the height profile (a) and the Nusselt number profiles in the case of a CHF (b) and in the case of a CPT (c) predicted by the AT with that of the FRNS following Askarizadeh et al. (2020). The working fluid is ethylene–glycol (antifreeze) mixed with water with a kinematic viscosity of $\nu = 10^{-5}\ \mathrm {m}^2\ \mathrm {s}^{-1}$ and a volume flow rate of $Q = 30 \ \mathrm {ml}\ \mathrm {s}^{-1}$ emerges from a nozzle with a diameter of $d = 5 \ \mathrm {mm}$. The entrance Reynolds number of the jet is ${Re}_d= 4Q/{\rm \pi} \,d \nu \approx 764$ and the Prandtl number is ${Pr} \approx 164$. Comparisons were carried out for four Pr numbers: $Pr = 7$, 50, 100 and 164. For the AT, the BCs are $h_{{i}} = 0.60 \ \mathrm {mm}$ at $r_{{i}} = 5 \ \mathrm {mm}$ and $h_{{end}} = 3.1 \ \mathrm {mm}$ at $r_{{end}} = 40 \ \mathrm {mm}$. Askarizadeh et al. (2020) used the definition of ${Nu}_d = \dot {q}(r) {\cdot } d/[ ( T_0 - T_f ) k ]$ for the Nusselt number, where the inlet diameter of the jet ($d = 5 \ \mathrm {mm}$) was used as characteristic length. The equivalent definition with the notation used in this study is ${Nu}_d = d/(\theta _0 z^{*} )$. Figure 5(a) also shows the variation of the shape parameter, which indicates sudden changes of the radial velocity profile in the jump region. This is used in § 4.3.2 to describe the convective effects in the jump region. The abscissa and ordinate are made dimensionless applying the nozzle diameter. The ICs for the temperature field determined by the ATHT in the order of increasing Prandtl number for the case of a CPT are ${Nu} = 22.35$, $43.33$, $54.70$ and $64.63$, respectively. These hold for a radial position of $r/d = 2$. This point was chosen because the flow field predicted by the FRNS for $r/d < 2$ is still influenced by the stagnation zone.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Comparison of the thermal BLs (a) and Nusselt number profiles (b) predicted by the ATHT for two Prandtl numbers slightly higher and lower than ${Pr_{th}} = 52$. The flow conditions are the same as in figure 5. The abscissa and ordinate are made dimensionless applying the diameter of the nozzle ($d = 5 \ \mathrm {mm}$), from which the jet emerges.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Comparison of the streamlines (a,c) and velocity profiles (b,d) in the jump region. Streamlines are plotted on the temperature field: FRNS (a); AT (b). Temperature field is presented for the case of ${Pr} = 164$, for which the AT does not properly capture the temperature field. Velocity profiles in the jump region and at the centre of the separation bubble obtained by the FRNS (c) and AT (d) signify the differences in the captured flow fields. The abscissa and ordinate are made dimensionless applying the nozzle diameter $d = 5 \ {\mathrm {mm}}$, from which the jet emerges.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Comparison of the temperature fields and profiles in the jump region obtained from the AT (a,b), and from the FRNS (c,d). The flow conditions are the same as those given in figure 5 for ${Pr} = 7$ and ${Pr} = 164$. The abscissa and ordinate are made dimensionless applying the nozzle diameter $d = 5 \ {\mathrm {mm}}$, from which the jet emerges. The temperature profiles resulted from the AT (a,b), regardless of the Prandtl number, are monotonically decreasing from the plate onwards, while those of the FRNS (c,d) exhibit a local maximum away from the plate for high Prandtl numbers. In the FRNS $\delta _T$ is defined as the line where $\theta = 10^{-6}$ holds.

Figure 8

Figure 9.(a,b) Temperature fields and profiles determined by the ATHT using the flow field determined by the FRNS. (c,d) Nusselt number profiles for $Pr = 7$ and 164 determined by the FRNS, by the FRNS and ATHT (FRNS–ATHT), and by the ATHT alone. Nusselt number profiles over the entire radial range (c), and over the jump region (d).

Figure 9

Figure 10.Comparison of the Nusselt numbers determined by the FRNS and ATHT using a third-order and a fourth-order polynomial for the case of a CHF condition and ${Pr} = 7$. Details on the flow conditions are given in the caption of figure 5.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Comparison of the temperature fields/profiles determined by the ATHT using a third-order and a fourth-order polynomial for the case of a CHF condition and ${Pr} = 7$. Details on the flow conditions are given in the caption of figure 5.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Comparison of the AT with the numerical study by Higuera (1997). The dimensionless start and end radii and heights are $r_{{i}} = 0.13$, $r_{{end}} = 1$, $h_{{i}} = 0.008$ and $h_{{end}} = 0.4$, respectively. The non-dimensionalisation was performed according to Higuera (1997).

Figure 12

Figure 13.Comparison of the AT with the experimental study by Duchesne et al. (2014). Details on the experimental data are given in § C.1.5. For the AT, the start and end radii and heights are $r_{{i}}/d = 1.33$, $r_{{end}}/d = 44.22$, $h_{{i}}/d = 0.15$ and $h_{{end}} = 0.5$, respectively. The diameter of the nozzle is equal to $d = 3.2$ mm, from which the jet emerges.

Figure 13

Figure 14.Verification of a constant Froude number at the jump exit claimed by Duchesne et al. (2014). Except for the values of the volume flow rate $Q$, all other conditions of the flow are given in § C.1.5.

Figure 14

Figure 15.Comparison of the velocity profiles determined by the AT in upstream (a) and downstream (b) of the jump region with the analytical approximations of Watson (1964) (a) and a Poiseuille-type flow (b).

Figure 15

Figure 16.Variation of $h(r)$ and $\lambda (r)$ for a flow extended close to the singularity in the AT.

Figure 16

Figure 17.Computational domain and BCs together with the qualitative grid cells distribution in axial and radial directions.

Figure 17

Figure 18.Independence of the interface profile (a) and the Nusselt number profile for the case of $Pr = 164$ (b) from the grid resolution. The parameters of the grid study are the dimensionless nozzle-to-plate distance $H/d = 2$, dimensionless plate radius $R/d = 8$, dimensionless obstacle height $h_{{o}}/d = 0.2$, entrance Reynolds number ${Re}_{{i}} = 4 Q / \nu {\rm \pi}d = 764$, entrance Weber number ${We}_{{i}} = {Re}_{{i}}^{2} \rho \nu ^{2} / \sigma d = 288$ and a parabolic inlet velocity profile. Further details on the flow conditions are given in figure 5.

Figure 18

Figure 19.Comparison of the fully resolved numerical simulations with the experimental study by Duchesne et al. (2014) for the interface of a laminar oil jet. The working fluid is silicon oil at room temperature ($\nu = 20$ cSt, $\sigma = 20\ \textrm {mN}\ \textrm {m}^{-1}$ and $\rho = 0.96 \ \textrm {g}\ \textrm {cm}^{-3}$). The oil jet emerges from a circular nozzle with the diameter of $d$ = 3.2 mm as a fully developed flow. The volume flow rate is $Q = 17 \ \textrm {cm}^{3}\ \textrm {s}^{-1}$ and the jet impinges normally on a circular plate with a diameter of 30 cm, which is located 4 cm below the nozzle. The entrance Reynolds number of the oil jet is ${Re}= 4Q/{\rm \pi} \,\textrm {d} \nu \approx 338.204$.

Figure 19

Figure 20.Comparison of the Nusselt numbers averaged over the surface from the jump onwards determined by FRNS and ATHT for the case of (a) a CHF and (b) a CPT. In the case of a CPT, the IC for $\dot {q}(r)$ has been chosen such that ${Nu}_{r/d=2} = {Nu}_{r/d=2,{Pr}=7}{\cdot }({Pr}/7)$, where ${Nu}_{r/d=2,{Pr}=7}$ is the value for the Nusselt number at the position $r/d=2$ determined by FRNS for ${Pr}=7$. When required, the initial value of $\theta _{{s}}$ is set to $0$. For all Prandtl numbers, for which FRNS were carried out, the ATHT was also determined fixing the Nusselt number at $r/d =2$ to the value determined by the FRNS. The results are represented by the blue crosses. Different scenarios for the determination of the IC have no influence on the final results.