No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 31 January 2005
In Affirmative Action Around the World: An Empirical Study, Thomas Sowell, a well-known critic of affirmative action in the United States, extends his critical lens to four other countries around the globe: Malaysia, Nigeria, India, and Sri Lanka. The book is organized into seven chapters. The first chapter provides a broad overview of affirmative action and related policies in different countries and advances the central thesis of the book—that these policies, though varied, produce similar negative outcomes. The next five chapters focus on individual countries—some in greater depth than others. For example, the chapter on the United States is 50 pages long whereas the chapters on Sri Lanka and Nigeria are each less than 20 pages. A final chapter summarizes the author's conclusions. Despite the book's subtitle, the chapter on Malaysia is the only one with any tables, charts, or graphs and the reported data are not original to the book.
A text on affirmative action in five nations is an ambitious undertaking, particularly if one strives for a balanced and thorough examination of the available scholarly research. But Sowell does not bind himself with such constraints. Instead, he presents only the unfavorable evidence. His arguments are familiar: affirmative action leads to the admission at universities of less qualified students or the hiring of less qualified workers than would have happened in the absence of these policies, affirmative action increases racial and ethnic animosity, and affirmative action benefits only the most privileged in the targeted group and thus exacerbates income inequality within that group.
These are potential costs of affirmative action, but a sound economic analysis requires that these costs be compared with potential benefits. One potential benefit is the improvement in the allocation of resources that might result from the reduction of discrimination against the targeted group. Although Sowell admits to the existence of historical discrimination, he does not discuss its contemporary manifestations either in the United States or in other countries. Thus, a reader might easily think that a problem does not exist. In the case of India, there is ample evidence to the contrary as summarized by Ashwini Deshpande in a recent essay “Recasting Economic Inequality” (Boundaries of Clan and Color: Transnational Comparisons of Inter-group Disparity edited by William Darity, Jr. and Ashwini Deshpande. London and New York: Routledge, 2004).
Potential benefits of affirmative action such as greater social capital among the targeted groups, greater integration of a society's elite, and greater ability of all students to function in a multicultural society are not discussed. Sowell emphasizes the cream-skimming features of affirmative action policy—that the beneficiaries tend to come from the upper income strata of the targeted groups—without acknowledging any spillover benefits to the larger community.
In contrast, a recent book by Thomas Weisskopf Affirmative Action in the United States and India (London and New York: Routledge, 2004) accumulates evidence on both costs and benefits of affirmative action policies citing empirical studies not referenced by Sowell. The case of reserved seats at Indian universities for scheduled castes (SC) and tribes (ST) offers an illustration of the differences between the two books. Citing a 1986 paper by Suma Chitnis (“Measuring Up to Reserved Admissions,” in Reservation: Policy, Programmes and Issues, edited by Vimal P. Shah and Binod C. Agrawal. Jaipur, India: Rawat Publications, 1986), Sowell writes, “None of the students preferentially admitted to six highly selective engineering schools progressed through these schools on schedule and most did not maintain a high enough grade average to continue in these institutions” (emphasis added, p. 31). Citing a 1999 study by Kirpal and Gupta (Equality Through Reservations, Jaipur, India: Rawat Publications), Weisskopf reports that the graduation rate for preferentially admitted students at the prestigious Indian Institutes of Technologies (ITT) was 84 percent compared with 94 percent for general entry students and concludes, “Clearly, and not surprisingly, SC and ST students lag well behind general-entry students in their performance on ITT examinations. Moreover, those who graduate as a rule take more years to do so than those general-entry peers. Still, the fact that graduation rates for SC and ST students are now over 80 percent at the elite ITT suggests that these beneficiaries of reserved seats—and the institutions that are admitting them—are achieving important successes” (emphasis added, pp. 171–72). Weisskopf acknowledges both the positive and negative information about affirmative action, whereas Sowell uses an old statistic to present a particularly bleak perspective on affirmative action's impact.
Affirmative Action Around the World: An Empirical Study might have been more accurately titled The Case Against Affirmative Action Around the World. The book succeeds in establishing the costs of the policy are similar around the world, but it fails as an overall assessment of affirmative action. It is sure to provide fodder for conservative pundits, but it offers little to advance economic scholarship on this issue.