This omnibus edition of four books by the New Zealand scholar W. H. McLeod of Sikh studies first appeared in hardback in 1999. Its welcome reissue as an Oxford India paperback is itself striking testimony to the unique position that he has come to occupy in the field of studies relating to the Sikhs and to Sikhism. As a result of the numerous scholarly publications on the subject, which he has produced with sustained industry over a remarkably productive scholarly life, McLeod has done more than anyone to shape Sikh studies in the West and to give these studies a wider academic prominence than might otherwise have been guaranteed by their relative size within South Asian studies as a whole.
Although widely admired for its clear presentation of Guru Nanak's teachings, the author's 1965 London PhD dissertation, GurūNānak and the Sikh Religion (1968), caused great controversy through its dismissal, after careful examination, of most of the claims of the early hagiographical accounts or janamsakhis to provide solid historical evidence for the details of the first Sikh guru's life. If there is a criticism to be made of this pioneering study, though, it is less to do with its scholarly challenge to cherished beliefs than with the somewhat unsophisticated way in which the book itself gave evidence of a rather naive understanding of the relationship between hagiography and historical biography. This weakness was recognized by McLeod himself, who provided a powerful revision of his argument in Early Sikh Tradition, a detailed textual study of the various janamsakhis. Although written in 1971, it unfortunately was not published until 1980, when Sikh affairs were overtaken by the crisis in the Punjab, and so this book, rightly rated as his best by McLeod himself in the short preface to this edition, never quite received the attention it certainly continues to deserve.
The other two books included in this collection range more widely in theme. Both are collections of essays first given as lectures in British universities. Based on lectures given in Cambridge in 1969–70, The Evolution of the Sikh Community (1976) again attracted controversy through touching on a particular sensitive issue in Sikh sacred history, in this case through its cautious approach to the historicity of the traditional account of Guru Gobind Singh's institution of the Khalsa at Anandpur. The focus of the collection as a whole, however, is in accordance with its title on broader issues of historical development. These issues are taken up and explored more systematically in the volume's fourth book, Who is a Sikh? (1989), prepared as Radhakrishnan Lectures to be given in Oxford 1987.
The hardback edition of this omnibus volume has already established itself as a standard work of reference, and its reissue in this economical formation should help secure these classic studies the continuing readership that they collectively deserve to attract amongst a new generation of students. Those whose particular interest lies in the questions relating to the historical basis of Sikh identity raised in the last two books reprinted in the omnibus will then certainly need to turn to McLeod's latest word on the subject, his substantial monograph Sikhs of the Khalsa: A History of the Khalsa Rahit (New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2003), which presents the relevant evidence, principally the codes of conduct called rahitnama, with his usual carefulness and close attention to textual detail. Yet another recent title is now available for those who would like to know how he first got into the field and how it has since shaped his career. Readers will gain much from the characteristically understated account presented in Discovering the Sikhs: Autobiography of a Historian (New Delhi: Permanent Black, 2004).
