This is a significant book, the first to provide an overview of a territory that must have tempted many of the readers of this journal: the vast array of early twentieth-century popular-science publications, that byword for happy hours spent in the back rooms of provincial second-hand bookshops. Like many of its subjects, this is a natural history of a field, and it lays out the territory in a series of different ways, the book having been divided into three substantial parts dealing with topics and themes, publishers and publications, and authors.
In the first part, Bowler suggests that a useful generalization can be drawn distinguishing two kinds of popularization. On the one hand were books that stressed science's moral character, as an alternative to the Classics in inculcating values and an emphasis on higher, more abstract, thought. On the other was the rhetoric that emphasized the material benefits that applied science and technology could deliver to individuals and societies. The invitation to the lay reader was to like and support science because it was good for them either intellectually or materially. He shows that the new sciences – atomic physics, cosmology, relativity, evolution and the new biology, human origins and materialistic readings of human biology – were all popular themes explored as morally uplifting. On the practical side, science and industry, radio and electricity, astronomy and natural history were all popular.
Before a series of chapters on different categories of publication – best-sellers, series, encyclopedias and magazines (acknowledging the work of Peter Broks) – the second part opens with a useful chapter on ‘creating an audience’. This is concerned with how publishers responded to a perceived demand for popular-science publications. Here there is a summary of the new phenomenon of mass literacy, the arrival of legislation in favour of universal secondary education, the Workers’ Educational Association (on p. 83 called the ‘Workers’ Educational Authority’, which the copy-editor should have spotted) and the University Extension movement. Bowler accepts that ‘popular science writing … is a complex process of interaction between the scientific community, the publishing industry, and the public’ (p. 77). But Science for All has little to say about this last category, ‘the public’, because, as he says, ‘what the public actually did with the content of books and magazines is a complex story I am not in a position to tell’ (p. 12). All the same, the readership is not entirely absent from this book – there are many passing statements about them, but these are often frustratingly under-footnoted. For example, ‘popular science publishing … exploited a widespread feeling that science was now an indispensable part of any programme of self-improvement’ (p. 77). It is not clear whose feeling this was, and how many people ‘widespread’ denotes. Again, he states, for example, that ‘as far as most readers were concerned, science and technology were indistinguishable’ (p. 55). This may well be a sound judgement, but there is no support given for it. The risk is that we simply assume that the reader shared the mindset of the publishers and popularizers – which is the evidence that is mainly under discussion – when we know that cultural consumption is much more complex than that. Bowler is not alone here, of course, as most authors in this fledgling sub-discipline of studies of the public culture of science have found it easier to analyse the production than the consumption of popularizations. But we need to remember that knowing that some volumes sold well and others poorly tells us no more about the place of science in lay culture than knowing that Hawkings's Brief History was a best-seller gets us beyond assuming that many readers have an aspiration to be, or to appear to be, brainy. Also, from work in our own discipline, such as Jim Secord's, and from outside, such as Jonathan Rose's, we know that it is possible to mount serious analyses of readership.
The last section, on authors, has as its core one of the book's best chapters, an analysis of a biographical survey (a list compiled by Bowler which is included as a fifteen-page appendix). This analysis shows the wide range of individuals who were writing popular-science literature, ranging from ‘hack writers willing to dash off a short sensationalized article’ to Bertrand Russell with his ABC of Relativity, from FRSs to small numbers of scientists working in industry. This follows a chapter on ‘the big names’: Julian Huxley, J.B.S. Haldane, Arthur Keith and J. Arthur Thomson (Arthur Eddington and James Jeans are dealt with earlier in the volume and ‘Professor’ A.M. Low is exiled to the more general chapter). These short, vivid, summaries provide useful comparisons of different kinds of scientific publishing career. In combination, these sections usefully lay the ghost of the idea that many scientists feared that popularization would limit their careers, except for those in hot pursuit of an FRS to add to their name. Even then, as most clearly in the case of Huxley, the coveted fellowship was awarded, as Bowler shows.
The book's approach to its subject, looking at essentially the same material from a series of different angles, does mean that there is a degree of repetition between its different sections and chapters. Initially something of a puzzle to the reader, this may well prove to be the book's strongest suit, aided as it is by an excellent index, detailed bibliography and biographical list of authors. Whatever the angle favoured by future scholars, this book will provide a starting point. For its virtues, Science for All will prove essential to all who come to study published popular science from the first half of the twentieth century, especially those who chew on the matter that this volume quite sensibly has not bitten off; namely trying to find out what difference all these publications made to how ordinary people really understood science in the first half of the last century.
