Most scholarship covering the Balkans during the late Ottoman period focuses on the nationalist aspirations of distinct ethnic groups. Even those studies that do not assume 500 years of Ottoman oppression often present the ethnic group in question as predestined to emerge from Ottoman control to establish a nation-state. In his concise study of the western Balkans from 1800 to 1912, Isa Blumi successfully challenges this framework to show not only that most Ottoman subjects of the region were not anti-Ottoman but also that the emergence of post-Ottoman nation-states was far from inevitable.
The book focuses on the region of the Ottoman Empire inhabited largely by Albanians, some of which would become the nation-state of Albania. However, throughout the work the author uses the term Albanian with some hesitancy (he always places it inside quotation marks) since most of those later dubbed Albanians did not see themselves as part of a unified ethnic group. Blumi provides the reader with a detailed and nuanced understanding of the diversity of the Albanian people, be they Toskë or Gegë, Muslim or Christian, Sunni or Bektashi, Orthodox or Catholic. Self-identification was complex, and it would make the creation of an Albanian identity challenging. In addition to these multiple religious and ethnic identities was the fact that the intellectual and political elites of the western Balkans also considered themselves Ottoman. This Ottoman identity is one that most Balkan studies, especially those dealing with Serbian, Greek, and Bulgarian histories, but also those that focus on Albania, have tended to ignore. The central aim of Blumi's study, as suggested in its title, is to reinstate the Ottomans into Balkan scholarship, especially into studies of the historical self-identifications of the empire's Balkan subjects. Reinstating the Ottomans argues that questions of identity in the western Balkans during the late Ottoman period brought together the local and the imperial.
The book opens with a compelling critique of Balkan nationalist views of history. Blumi uses photographs to contest the rewriting of Balkan histories to fit nationalist agendas, asserting that photographs can present a clearer picture of daily life in the region than textual histories. In contrast to the well-defined ethnic and religious divisions that historians have often presented as the defining reality of the late Ottoman Balkans, Blumi's visual sources illustrate diversity and cooperation among groups as varied as çeta (guerrilla bands) celebrating the Young Turk victory in 1908 and Albanian intellectuals celebrating the creation of an Albanian state in 1912. When the existence of such evidence undermines or contradicts a nationalist agenda, Blumi explains that interested parties can merely airbrush the photo to better serve the desired end (as depicted on the book's cover).
The bulk of the work is a close study of the Albanians. Starting with Tepedelenli Ali Pasha of Yanya (Janina), Blumi's analysis takes the local—whether local administration or local loyalties—as its frame of reference. With this focus, the author is able to show the uniqueness of the various people generally placed under the Albanian umbrella as well as the absence of unity among these diverse communities. From the Toskë effendiyya who distanced themselves from their “uncivilized” Gegë cousins to the Bektashi polemics against Sunnis, identities and loyalties among the Albanians were local. Throughout the 19th and early 20th centuries, Albanian leaders, regardless of their self-identification, looked to benefit their local regions, rather than the Albanians at large. This was demonstrated by the Tanzimat-era actions of the well-placed Toskë elite in Istanbul, a group that successfully appealed to the Porte for funding and modernization projects for their hometowns even as they ignored the needs of neighboring communities. These actions also underscored the Toskë elite's attempt to tie the local to the imperial, creating Ottoman Toskë or Ottoman Gegë, rather than Albanians or even Ottoman Albanians.
Blumi provides biographical sketches of figures who hold prominent places in the pantheon of Albanian nationalist heroes, further revealing the complexity of self-identification during the late Ottoman period. Pashko Vasa, the Frashëri brothers, Isa Boletini, and Ismail Qemali, among others, all identified themselves in ways that do not conform to the later ethnonational identity of the Albanian nation-state. A key to all of their identities was that they considered themselves Ottoman. It was impossible to separate being Albanian from being Ottoman. This notion is also true for elites from elsewhere in the Ottoman Empire, regardless of ethnicity or religion.
One way in which this Ottoman connection was solidified was through the incorporation of provincial subjects into the Ottoman bureaucracy, as illustrated in Chapter 5, on educational reform. The Porte struggled for much of the 19th and early 20th centuries to secure greater attachment of provincial elites by making it advantageous for them to align themselves with the state. One of the key means by which the Ottomans sought to achieve this goal at the end of the 19th century was through the expanding educational system. The establishment of state schools brought significant funding opportunities as well as prestigious titles to the provinces, allowing local elites to gain political and economic leverage in their region at the expense of rivals.
Blumi has produced a valuable study of the western Balkans during the late Ottoman period, challenging others to examine the interaction of local and imperial identities elsewhere in the empire. This work is essential reading for anyone interested in this period and in the establishment of ethnonational Ottoman successor states.
