Analisa Taylor offers a thought-provoking analysis of indigeneity in Mexico through an interdisciplinary approach which draws on anthropological, literary, political, cultural and visual texts. She explores the problematic representation and construction of indigenous identities during the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, populations which are at times vilified, at times romanticised. She also outlines the policies of post-revolutionary governments regarding the ‘Indian problem’ and questions who represents whom, how and why. These governmental policies seek to assimilate the indigenous populations into the nation-state, and she points out the problematic nature of this acculturation process in that it refutes indigenous identities.
The book is divided into five chapters. The first introduces the PRI's official representation of the Indian in post-revolutionary Mexico. Taylor explores how state institutions (the National Indigenist Institute, the National Institute of Anthropology and History, and the National School of Anthropology and History) privileged the concept of mestizaje as holding the future for Mexico. Thus, following this strategy, indigenous peoples were to be assimilated into the new project of nationhood and into modernity.
The following four chapters are more culturally based and explore the representation of the Indian in literature and film, following a chronological sequence. Chap. 2 examines three novels which focus on indigenous communities, written in the 1930s by non-indigenous people who are external to the cultures they portray and who regard themselves as superior. Taylor argues that these novels are foundational indigenist fictions, characterised by an ethnographical slant and an omniscient narrator. Sympathy is shown towards the Indians, but there appears to be no salvation; either the Indians are fated to die by government-sanctioned violence or they are allowed into the lowest level of capitalist society and thus become participants in a modern Mexico. The next chapter analyses three mid-twentieth-century texts written in the first person and which often follow the linguistic nuances of non-Spanish speakers. These texts are ethnographic or ethnohistoric, the indigenous voices again being mediated by non-indigenous authors. These ethnographies show an increased concern for the indigenous populations as individuals and participants in both their own personal history and that of the nation. Chap. 4 shows the transformation of Indians into participants and agents of their own historical processes through testimonial fiction. It also offers a critique of official indigenismo, the policy of which is to assimilate indigenous populations into the nation. Here, citing the Zapatista Army of National Liberation movement, the indigenous populations seek their autonomy, cultural renewal and their own identity, thus offering an alternative to being absorbed by the nation-state. The final chapter examines how the accounts of indigeneity shown in the previous chapters fit in with ideologies of gender. Through film, photography, painting, and travel essays, it looks at the representation of Zapotec women, sexuality and family relationships in the town of Juchitán. Taylor argues that this depiction stands as a stark contrast to the dominant narratives of national identity.
The book is not an attempt to interpret indigenous beliefs, nor is it a portrayal of indigenous cultures. Rather, it is a study of the post-revolutionary state's representation and construction of the Indian within a Mexican cultural and economic modernity. There are inevitably difficulties inherent in such an analysis – for example, the problem of defining the Indian is never properly addressed, and confusion exists as to the difference or overlap between an indigenous and a peasant community. It is surprising that there is no mention of the effects of seasonal migration on rural communities or of indigenous populations living in large cities, and where or how they belong. Furthermore, although different indigenous communities are portrayed, it is only in the Conclusion that the author notes that there are 62 different indigenous languages in Mexico. In chap. 3, an Indian's annoyance when he is termed generically is mentioned. At times it feels as though the author falls into the same error and follows the still contemporary treatment of Indians as a homogeneous group, as seen in the recently opened (2006) Museum of Popular Art in Mexico City's centre, where all ethnic groups are amassed together without distinction. My other quibble would be that Taylor sees the Mexican Revolution as a founding myth for the search for a national identity and the mestizo as the future, when this was something which had been proposed in the nineteenth century by various intellectuals who sought the spiritual roots of Mexican identity and proclaimed the mestizo as Mexico's future then.
Despite these shortcomings in her analysis of the problematic nature of indigeneity in Mexico, Taylor highlights the way in which indigenous identities are refuted and the autonomy of indigenous communities is at odds with governmental development policies. This is an important study as it brings together for the first time a multidisciplinary analysis of indigeneity and looks towards a future of Indian identity wherein indigenous people represent themselves on their own terms.
