From the surge in black market antiquities occasioned by the war in Syria, to the heated public debate surrounding artifact repatriation from western museums to their countries of origin, we are once again reminded of the intimate relationship between archaeology and politics in the Middle East. From the perspective of scholarship, this intersection is emerging as an interdisciplinary field in its own right, but accounts of archaeology's role in the encounter between empire and nationalism in the Arab region remain rare. This makes the contributions of Donald Malcolm Reid on the politics of antiquities in Egypt all the more significant. Reid's first book on the subject, Whose Pharaohs? Archaeology, Museums, and Egyptian National Identity from Napoleon to World War I (University of California Press, 2002), remains seminal in the field. It is pacey, artfully constructed, and meticulously researched, offering unique insights on the emergence of professional archaeology in Egypt during an age of European imperial expansion. Crucially, it writes Egyptian archaeologists and museum curators back into a narrative which had focused almost exclusively on their European counterparts, and makes the important argument that the material culture of Egypt's distant past came to play a significant role in the construction of its modern national identity. This is the premise taken up and further developed in Contesting Antiquity in Egypt: Archaeologies, Museums and the Struggle for Identities from World War I to Nasser. It is the second book in what is intended to be a trilogy, ultimately tracing archaeology's role in the evolution of modern Egypt from the late eighteenth century all the way to the late twentieth.
Contesting Antiquity draws on the framework and themes which Reid first outlined in Whose Pharaohs?. The book is organized with reference to the four main archaeological museums founded in Egypt between the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries: the Museum of Egyptian Antiquities, the Graeco-Roman Museum, the Museum of Arab Art, and the Coptic Museum. Reid uses these institutions as ways into a discussion of the many archaeologists and curators—European and Egyptian—who worked with and within them. He also seeks to articulate the connection between these museums and the emergence of various strands of nationalism in Egypt during the interwar period. Again drawing on a premise introduced in Whose Pharaohs?, Contesting Antiquity is in part an attempt to reinforce the connections between archaeology and Egyptian nationalism which Reid signaled, but did not fully explore, in his first book. Certainly, Reid's choice of time frame, from 1914 to 1952, indicates a special focus on the rise of nationalism, for this was the precise moment when the habit of Empire—political, cultural, and academic—came up against a rising tide of anti-colonial nationalism in Egypt. The museums and excavations which had long been a symbol of European cultural, scientific and civilizational dominance were, almost inevitably, contested, reinterpreted and ultimately repossessed by Egyptians looking to assert a national identity rooted in the legacy of the Pharaohs.
Unquestionably the strongest aspect of Reid's scholarship is his research. It is rigorous, genuinely transnational in scope, and incorporates a rich tapestry of material culture and archival sources, as well as dozens of interviews conducted by the author with specialists in Egyptian antiquities over the course of several decades. As a result, Contesting Antiquity is a gold mine of primary material on Egypt, regardless of whether one is interested in archaeology, cultural history or Egyptian politics. That said, it will best serve those seeking insight into the politics and personalities of Egyptian antiquities in the interwar years, and their intersections with European empire and Egyptian nationalism.
However, Contesting Antiquity struggles to live up to the groundbreaking achievement of its predecessor. The same institutions and many of the same protagonists are under examination as in the first book, and while the narrative has moved forward in time, there is nevertheless a significant amount of overlap in terms of subject, research and argument. Much of the theoretical and methodological framing in Contesting Antiquity is borrowed from Whose Pharaohs?; indeed, many paragraphs, particularly in the introduction, are almost identical to the earlier volume. What makes this all the more perplexing is that Contesting Antiquity tends to assume knowledge of Whose Pharaohs?, occasionally to the detriment of reader understanding.
This would appear to be a problem emerging at least partially from a change in publishers between the first book in the trilogy and the second. Whereas Whose Pharaohs? is published by the University of California Press, Contesting Antiquity is published by the American University in Cairo Press. Unfortunately, the second book seems to be caught between, on the one hand, its reliance on the first book's research agenda and methodological framework, and on the other, the need to treat Contesting Antiquity as a stand-alone work, given the new publisher. Nevertheless, a good editor might have found a way around this dilemma, while preventing obvious repetitions in the text: covering 40 years in 390 pages, Contesting Antiquity is a significantly heftier manuscript than Whose Pharaohs?, which dealt with the eventful “long century’ between 1798 and 1914 in an economical 296 pages.
In spite of these issues, Reid's intensive and interdisciplinary historical method continues to offer an exemplary model to his colleagues. The third and final volume of this ambitious study promises to take up the story of Egyptian archaeology from the emergence of Gamal ‘Abd al-Nasser, and carry it through to the revival of Pharaonism during the Hosni Mubarak era. It may reasonably be hoped that, moving into a starkly differentiated period of time, and with a new generation of Egyptian archaeologists and political ideologies to explore, this third installment will provide Reid the opportunity to again break new ground, this time on the intersection between archaeology, nationalism, and the post-colonial state.
