Travelling, Collecting, Corresponding, Seeing, Classifying, Settling, Publishing, Charting, Associating, Governing. Those Victorians sure were busy. So too are recent historians of science. Flagging the turn to ‘practice’ after the 1980s, the gerund has now replaced ‘structure’ or ‘anatomy’ as the word of choice in history-of-science book and article titles. We now have lots of performances.
One of the most satisfying performances of the last few years has got to be Jim Endersby's remarkable new study of the practices and institutions of Victorian botany. Endersby follows the career and context of the premier Victorian botanist, Joseph Hooker (1817–1911). Where previous generations were attracted to the collective biographies of those ‘Hookers of Kew’, Joseph and his father William, Endersby's work is much more than mere biography. It greatly expands our notion of what it is to be science, to be imperial and to enrol nature in the modern period.
Hooker, of course, is perfectly suited for a study of Victorian practices of natural history. He started by voyaging, as second fiddle to naturalist Robert McCormick, on the Antarctic expedition of Clarke Ross. He collected with the best of them in the Himalayas, Wales, Morocco and the United States, honing his techniques of spotting, collecting and marshalling the natural world. He participated in replacing the Linnaean edifice with the strategically named ‘natural system’. ‘Inheriting’ the head of the Royal Botanic Gardens from his father in 1865, Hooker rode high as Kew solidified itself as a premier institution of the life of imperial Britain. With his army of collectors and correspondents, Hooker stood in the middle of much of what was happening in Victorian science, and surely botanical science. And for those thinking of anniversaries, Hooker was also best pals with Charles Darwin, both before and after the publication of On the Origin of Species. Indeed, Hooker is famous for shepherding Darwin through the thorny potential accusations of plagiarism when he received the famous ‘scoop’ from Alfred Russel Wallace in 1858. Pointedly, Wallace and the controversy do not even get a mention in the index of Endersby's book. Quite so. As recent historians of science have revealed, the real intricacies of Victorian (and hence, modern) science lay not in these grand theories of life, but in the tangled rhizomes surrounding them: collecting, naming and classifying.
Earlier historians of science, one generation removed from the poor maligned positivists, would find at best much theory-ladenness in these processes. The issue of ‘essentialism’ was the supposed spectre haunting the life sciences (reinforcing the idea, happily promulgated by Carl Hempel, that classification and natural history were merely ‘pre’-science.) Yet Endersby beautifully shows that the so-called ‘species question’ of the nineteenth century was anything but theory. It was really one of stability, authority and naming – not fixity, transmutation and the great chains of being. By following Hooker closely through his day-to-day exchanges, agonies, skills and contingencies, Endersby carefully examines the vicissitudes of pulling together a large imperial collection, establishing it as an authority and, most importantly, replicating that authority – all of which required more than mere theory, and certainly a lot of energy and networking. For example, while Imperial Nature highlights the obvious imperial nature of Hooker's enterprise – Kew and the botanists were, after all, engaged in a colonial enterprise – Endersby resists the temptation to see this as one straight arrow of domination: the hegemony of the centre over the periphery, the utilitarian reduction of the gardens. Drawing on a mitigated actor-network model, and a huge amount of detail, he notes that to make an authority central requires a long chain of local peripheries, all breathlessly mobilizing and all centres in their own right. There is nothing a priori about this. Imperial nature does not fall from the sky, but only appears so as the result of its own success.
Of course, Hooker could indeed be a centralizing, often driven, tyrant. Hooker, as Endersby puts it, was a hybrid character of aristocrat and new ‘professional’ scientist – echoing Kew's own hybrid character as recreational gardens and scientific utilitarian instrument. And what Hooker did at Kew, the zoologists did at the British Museum (one only hopes that the next ‘practical’ biography of Victorian naturalism will concentrate on that indefatigable keeper of the British Museum, John Edward Gray – and be done with our fascination with his superior at the museum, Richard Owen).
Here the very entities of Victorian botany and science are located and given affect. Endersby's central chapters on the various strategies of naming and necessity – and exchange of species, types and boundary objects – easily provide the very best account of powerful new views of biological kinds and meanings being produced by the ‘practical turn’. I have no hesitation recommending them to my philosopher friends who are still bogged down in scholastic debates about the meaning of meaning and natural kinds. Yet Endersby's book is much more than this. He also tells us definitively about the vexed meaning of ‘professionalization’ in the Victorian period, the place of experiment and observation in natural history, the role of mapping and publishing and publicizing – all supported by astonishing detail from published and archival material. A short review cannot come close to doing Imperial Nature justice.
But what is all this busy-ness, this classifying, collecting, naming: of what? The recent methodological turn to ‘practices’ is itself, ironically, a very modernist, late Victorian concern (‘all that is solid melts into air’). In the midst we face a slight danger of losing some things along the way, things that are not reducible to practices. Social constructivists of a previous generation came very close to doing that. Now that practices are well covered – and Endersby's book is the zenith of methodological sophistication on that score – we are slowly turning our attention to objects, to things, giving them a chance and following them around a bit. They are not always reduced to practices. Imperial Nature, to its credit, contains lots of things too. Taking such things seriously, Endersby's other fine book is A Guinea Pig's History of Biology (London, 2007). Gerundheit!
