Inside 1960s Folk Music
Joel and Ethan Coen’s Inside Llewyn Davis (2013) is one of the best feature films about a musician I know, neither sentimentalising nor romanticising the musician’s life, showing how difficult it can be to make a living, not flinching—in American independent film tradition—from representing the disturbing or discomfiting.
It is important to have a sense of American culture in the 1950s and early 1960s to understand what folk music revival was about, and what the Coens so brilliantly capture. That the 1950s was a period of conformity and drabness is well known, a prosperous era for many, when mothers did not work outside the home and families could survive on the father’s income. Women who had boosted the war effort by working in factories now had to be content with staying at home and tending to the children as the baby boom took off in 1946, women having been bribed with a plethora of new technologies that were supposed to make them feel supported and in command as housewives. A 1951 ad in the Ladies’ Home Journal for International Harvester refrigerators shows a young woman dressed to the nines, including jewellery, spread out on the floor with different colours of refrigerator door handles, exhorting women to “Pick a colour from the rainbow!” There were ten available colours, with changeable door handles to match one’s kitchen décor: “They’re femineered!®” (International Harvester 1951). The average house size began to creep up in a second wave of consumption, formerly discouraged by the Depression and then by wartime austerity (see Cohen Reference Cohen2003). Suburbs grew, taking people out of familiar ethnic neighbourhoods and support systems.
Not just kitchen technologies but science more generally was championed in this period, since it was science that was thought to have won the war (see Taylor Reference Taylor2001). Scientistic modes of composing music, best represented in integral serialism, became seen as the most prestigious. Outside of the realm of high art, there was a growth in do-it-yourself electronics kits, a fascination for space and space-age pop music, and the newly popular field of psychology.
All of these cultural trends created for many a sense that something was missing: women were unfulfilled (Betty Friedan’s Feminine Mystique was first published in 1963), greater consumption did not lead to greater satisfaction, and the growth of science and technology led to fears of alienation. Lewis Mumford wrote in 1952, “our inner life has become impoverished: as in our factories, so throughout our society, the automatic machine tends to replace the person and to make all his decisions—while, for its smoother working, it anesthetizes every part of the personality that will not easily conform to its mechanical needs” (Reference Mumford1952:10).
The Beat movement offered early and potent critiques of this new culture, but this movement was later eclipsed by the rise of the counterculture in the 1960s, and it is the glimmerings of this protest that the Coens depict. The U.S. folk music scene did not have a bona fide star in the early 1960s (music stardom having been recently redefined by Elvis Presley); there were plenty of musicians who were well known, but no one as famous, or notorious, as Presley.
Into this vacuum viewers are swept, witnessing the travails of a struggling folksinger in February 1961, loosely modelled on Dave Van Ronk, some of whose songs are used in the film (and who released an album in 1963 entitled Inside Dave Van Ronk). The Coen brothers (who are also credited as screenwriters) portray Davis not just as a struggling folksinger, but as someone who did not attempt to make a music that articulated the social critique demanded of folk music, or at least avoided articulating this critique so forcefully or clearly that it precluded economic success.
And it is this that Bob Dylan, who appears near the end of the film, found a way to do. The best analysis of Dylan that we still have appears in Simon Frith’s classic Sound Effects, where he argues that Dylan moved away from what was perceived as the collective form of R&B to the more individualistic mode of expression championed by later rock musicians. Dylan, says Frith, symbolised the new argument articulated by 1960s folk singers, that if folk were a simple form that could be sung and played by anyone, not just anyone could do so with originality (Frith Reference Frith1981:30). Dylan’s music represented the apogee of the “authentic” folksinger whose art was truthful to himself, not the truth of a movement or audience, a strategy that folksingers brought with them as they shifted from communal to commercial ways of making music (Frith Reference Frith1981:32). “If it was never new and never gets old then it’s a folksong,” Davis tells a folk club audience. This characterises his music, but not Dylan’s, which did sound new, while giving the appearance of having tapped into something primordial.
Davis remains stuck in the earlier mode of folk singing. His music is still communal, something one could sing along with. In one scene, he sings a song that he used to perform with his deceased musical partner and a friend joins in during the chorus, which upsets Davis, who halts and departs in anger. Viewers are given to understand that he is upset by the reminder of his friend’s death, but it is striking that the two times Davis sings with others in the film are problematised (the other instance being a novelty song about John F. Kennedy’s space initiative).
And Davis’s music is too frequently irrelevant to its postwar, anomic moment. “The Shoals of Herring”? “The Death of Queen Jane”? Lovely songs (hats off to Ewan MacColl for the former and Irish singer Dáithí Sproule for the latter) and beautifully performed by Oscar Isaac as Davis, but very far from being relevant to victims of racism or the patriarchy, or increasingly restive baby boomers. The scene where Davis sings “The Death of Queen Jane” for Chicago folk club owner Bud Grossman, played by F. Murray Abraham, is a beautiful musical moment, spoiled by Grossman’s reaction: “I don’t see a lot of money here.” One could understand this to mean that there is not a lot of money in folk music generically, but I think Grossman means that that sort of folk music was not profitable.
An interesting aspect of the film concerns social class, which is less thematised than inadvertent on the part of the filmmakers, I think; as educated, middle-class people themselves, middle-classness is normative. They clearly represent Davis as working class (there is a scene where, desperate for cash, he tries to rejoin the Merchant Marine Union but no longer has his card and cannot afford the fee for a new card). The musicians for whom Davis has contempt all seem to be higher up the class ladder. In a recent study of social class in the indie rock scene in Los Angeles, I was struck by how willing middle-class musicians were to make aesthetic compromises in order to try to make a living, while it was musicians further down the class ladder who articulated positions of uncompromisingness and loyalty to their artistic visions; they claimed they were happy to be pure to their musical ideals and remain hobbyists rather than professionals who had compromised (Taylor Reference Taylor and Ian Peddie2020).
Davis is uncompromising when it comes to his music (though he is willing to be a musical gun for hire, recording the novelty song about JFK). There are a couple of scenes where Davis displays contempt for other folksingers who are too polished, precious, not possessing the kind of earthy authenticity that he thinks true folk music is supposed to represent. His disdain for musicians who are not folk-pure or highly skilled leads to a beating he takes at the hands of the husband of a woman whom, his assailant claims, Davis had heckled during her performance.
The Coens, in the indie film tradition of advocating darkness against the Hollywood grain, go out of their way to deromanticise the life of musicians. Davis is not just unlikeable but is something of a cad in the way he treats his ex, borrowing money, taking advantage of friends’ generosity. Two moments in particular stand out. One, the audition of “The Death of Queen Jane,” which elicits that dismissive response; the other, a rendition of “The Shoals of Herring,” sung for Davis’s nursing-home-confined father, who reacts with an episode of incontinence. Anything romantic about making music or the artists’ life is either negated, ridiculed, or left unrepresented. Ultimately, the Coens—who themselves have found great success at being indie-film edgy and yet commercially successful—tell us that artistic purity is not just unrewarding: it is for chumps.
