This edition of Gavin Hamilton's letters enters a landscape populated over the last few years by a number of books on the antiquarian and dillettantist environment of eighteenth-century Rome, Italy and Greece, and perhaps more specifically the British patrons and dealers who were its articulators. Hamilton, as an artist who also operated as an archaeologist and an agent of others’ collecting instincts, is an important focus for research into that world. As Brendan Cassidy says in his preface to this substantial tome, it is strange that so little has been written about him, not least in view of the quantity of surviving primary material, much of it the result of regular correspondence with his prospective buyers and agents. He is an obvious point of reference in studies of the Grand Tour and the history of collecting, but has not received the level of attention he clearly deserves. C. contrasts his focus with that of the late Ilaria Bignamini's Digging and Dealing in Eighteenth Century Rome (2010), published while the current volume was in press: her book is interested specifically in the British contribution to the trade in antiquities; he takes a wider view of Hamilton's activities, and one which is supported by the letters he has included here. The 333 letters presented and fully annotated here range in date from the first to the art historian Ignazio Hugford in 1748 to the last one to Charles Townley in 1796. Their content shows us Hamilton as art critic, painter, exhibition designer, dealer, excavator and not least as a networker of persistence. The contextual research which supports the introduction allows C. to firm up much of the detail of a career which has certainly been under-reported.
Hamilton was born in Lanarkshire in 1723, and matriculated at the University of Glasgow in 1738, where he was a contemporary of Adam Smith, among others. His undergraduate studies included the ancient Greek culture which evidently fed the taste for Homer which surfaced later in his series of paintings based on incidents in the Iliad, as well as the interest in antiquities. What is less clear is where the transition from word to image came from, and where Hamilton trained as a painter in the absence of formal provision in Scotland at that stage. He was in Italy by 1744, and probably trained in the studio of Agostino Masucci; C. suggests that he also made use of life classes at the French Academy, and progressed his skills further by copying after old Masters and the antique. He shared an apartment with Stuart and Revett between 1748 and 1750, and went on trips to Naples and Venice with them. A visit to Paris and a period in London from 1751–56 with excursions to France and Italy gave him some of the contacts on which he built a painting career; he settled in Rome for good in 1756–7, and eventually died there in 1798.
During that forty-year period he operated as a painter accepting commissions for portraits and historical paintings, and enjoyed a considerable international reputation as an interpreter of classical material: he was elected to the Accademia di San Luca in Rome in 1761. In a letter to James Boswell in 1768 he says, ‘My painting days pass like dream and tho' I sleep with Homer under my head, yet I don't forget my country, my Queen and my friend’. Boswell's commission, The Abdication of Mary, Queen of Scots, took almost ten years to complete. It was not alone: much of Hamiton's time was even more profitably engaged in building a successful business as a dealer in Old Master paintings and drawings and in the antiquities for which he recognized an insistent demand. Later he also became known as an excavator of ancient sites, not least Ostia and Hadrian's Villa at Tivoli, primarily in search of sculptures which would supply some expanding collections, including those of Charles Townley and the Vatican. His reputation as a painter was on rather shakier ground: he was much less appreciated in Britain than in France and Italy. C. traces, among others, the reputation of the painting of Andromache Lamenting the Death of Hector, praised for its taste and classical calm by Winckelmann, who saw it in Rome, in a letter of 1761; it was exhibited at the Society of Artists in London in 1762 and was dismissed as ‘middling’ by Horace Walpole, and as ‘moderately executed’ by the critic of the St. James's Chronicle. This and other examples display a reception pattern in which their novelty and emotional power is appreciated in Rome, and Hamilton is highly regarded by some of the most important cultural influences of his time, Goethe, Canova and Winckelmann among them, but have a lukewarm audience in London. C.'s analysis of the reasons for this, and for Hamilton's success in selling in Rome to British patrons is a fascinating section of an Introductory overview which should do much to trigger further reappraisal of the artist's career in his varied occupations. There has been a notable revival over the last twenty years or so, in Britain, France and Italy, of interest in the Settecento art world, and a recognition that Hamilton sat at the centre of it. His letters are key material for research, not only into his own career, but those of his patrons, the environment in which they operated, and the histories of the objects and collections to which they gave passionate attention. This substantial and attractively presented and illustrated edition should significantly further the enterprise.
