Amid the recent wave of protest, repression, and political changes underway in the Middle East, I was more than excited to receive the book by Jarrett Lovell. On the one hand, the well-written, engaging book provided an excellent call to arms regarding a topic that has not been well understood: What happens to people that challenge the status quo, why do they do what they do, and how should we think about it? This is achieved through the integration of numerous fields—criminology, sociology, and justice studies—as presented within books, as well as through seemingly semistructured interviews with a snowball sample of activists. On the other hand, however, the book provides a limited and occasionally fragmentary characterization of what we actually know. This is attributed to generally ignoring both what is found within academic journals and important theories within the social movements and state repression literatures.
In many respects, the book is exactly what one would expect given the topic and initial framing. Lovell outlines the major problems of the contemporary period, focusing largely on the shortcomings of globalization as found within the United States: e.g., deindustrialization, unemployment, poor wages, and reduced health benefits. He quickly moves to how these issues resulted in diverse forms of resistance being undertaken by a wide variety of actors: e.g., those concerned with labor, the environment, and immigrants. For a variety of reasons, he argues, these problems cannot be resolved through the electoral or judicial systems, and in this context, people are led into the streets to find justice through dissent. While there are a variety of techniques used, Lovell tends to highlight some of the strategies that are most common to Americans (e.g., the protest/demonstration, march, boycott, sit-in, and petition) but also some that are less well known (e.g., the theatrical parody, the trespass, and tax resistance).
The book is no simple justification for challenging the status quo, however, for it deals with the problematic nature of “taking on the system.” For example, the title of the book comes from the author's correct and insightful view that much of what is considered political dissent is “certified” or labeled by authorities as being criminal in nature—presumably in an effort to dissuade participants. This raises an important tension; Lovell remarks that while criminality falls under the domain of political authorities, those engaged in dissent are frequently doing so because of their responsiveness to a higher law. Instead, these individuals appeal to international standards of human rights or to “god's law” regarding the proper treatment of his/her/its subjects. As such, Lovell takes us into a discussion of anarchism (the systematic disregard of state authority and unquestionable deference/obedience) as being the grounding point for understanding why people challenge their governments. Held accountable to the higher standards of morality (internationally, religiously, spiritually, or individually provided) and under the opinion that no one should stand around waiting for the government to address wrongs, at the sight of injustice, these individuals are nobly called to act. More than that, these individuals are called to act in a manner that invites public attention to that which is wrong and must be corrected; this is the essence of civil disobedience. Here lies the basic tension that the book seeks to explore: what is illegal to one (the government) is righteous and necessary to another (the dissident and citizen).
In an effort to protect the status quo, challengers are frequently met with government coercion—in this book, with protest policing. Again, Lovell focuses on techniques that are quite familiar in the United States, including ticketing/fines, verbal and physical harassment, beating, tear gas, and arrest. But he also highlights some that are less well known: penning/fencing/barricading, crowd infiltration, long periods of detention, free speech zones, and enhanced militarization of population management. Again, he follows conventional wisdom, which maintains that these strategies move from being highly aggressive in the early 1900s to a position of negotiated management in the 1970s only to return to a more aggressive posture by the mid-1990s.
Unlike for many researchers, for Lovell, the conflict is not ended after arrest. No, there is still more resistance/rebellion to be observed and understood. The struggle for change and order continue in jail/prison and still later in court. At each turn, challengers and authorities go at it. Indeed, this is a major strength of the book: it takes the reader through all stages of contention.
The book ends with some attention to the issue of social movement outcomes: how well challengers do in their challenging. Here, Lovell relies on the activists that he interviewed to reveal the strengths and weaknesses of their struggles, but in some form of phenomenological reflection, he appears to suggest that this cannot be known (pp. 180; 195) and that essentially, it is worth it to just fight the good fight.
While useful for mapping a specific terrain and bringing attention to a wide variety of neglected issues, the book has some weaknesses that largely stem from the fact that Lovell seemed to ignore some parts of his audience: e.g., academics that study social movements and state repression.
For example, concerning dissent, it would have been useful for Lovell to address the arguments of rationalists such as Mancur Olson and Mark Lichbach, who argue that the decision to pursue collective benefits through collection action is largely a function of individual benefits that could be derived from the pursuit. Lovell appears to argue that this is not the case, preferring to maintain that individuals not only seek collective benefits to help other people but they also consistently reframe costs (repression) into benefits when he states that some dissident acts seek punishment in order to be validated (p. 67). Any challenge to the rationalist argument would have to be filtered through a discussion of exactly what and who Lovell used as subjects for his investigation, something that is not well discussed. Indeed, there is no discussion made about the implications of relying on the opinions of individuals that have been arrested fifty times. It is possible that the hardcore serial activist is not at all representative of those who join most protest actions (something analyzed by Karl Deiter Opp). Lovell needs to acknowledge that there is no systematic work that suggests police strategies have changed over time. Additionally, the book could have drawn on the now growing research on social movement outcomes (e.g., Edwin Amenta, Sarah Soule, Doug McAdam, Rory McVeigh, and Paul Almeida). This work would provide some assistance in trying to figure out how success could be defined as well as how it could more convincingly be examined.
Concerning repression, Lovell's account suffers from an imbalance in source material: while he offers tremendous insights into the challenger's side of the conflict, he presents hardly any at all into that of the authorities. I do not simply fault Lovell on this one but the fields of political science and sociology more broadly. We know very little about what authorities do to those under their charge, but we know even less about why they do it.
Unfortunately, Lovell tends to limit his focus to specific aspects of socio-political conflict (i.e., those challenging authorities) and what the actors here have to say. Both Lovell and the broader discipline of social science could greatly benefit from further extension and integration of the issues at hand. There is much to be learned from studying not only those who challenge authority but also those who attempt to protect the state. That said, Crimes of Dissent is a thought-provoking, innovative, and worthwhile trek through a neglected area of social science. Recent events in the Middle East ensure that we will be reflecting on the questions Lovell raises for quite some time.
