In historical writing about science and technology as well as about material culture, instruments have long been at the forefront. Only recently, however, have historians begun to pay serious attention to the role played in instrumental contexts by material substances. Exploring the ways in which materials spurred inquiries into nature, technological ventures, innovations of the market and new habits in everyday life, these studies have considerably enriched our understanding of the relation between science and society. In the early modern period, and well into the nineteenth century, the vast majority of material substances isolated, produced and studied in such sciences as mineralogy, botany, agronomy and chemistry were also used as commodities. Historical studies of material substances thus can provide insight into a broad range of different practices and forms of knowledge of the past, cutting across the sciences, technology, medicine and the consumer market. As editors Hasok Chang and Catherine Jackson put it at the start of this fascinating volume, an ‘object-focus is very effective in highlighting connections that are obscured by the usual focus on ideas, institutions, and individual scientists’ (p. 1).
An Element of Controversy looks at the ‘life’ of chlorine, from its first, innocent appearance in 1774 in the laboratory of the Swedish-German apothecary and chemist Carl Wilhelm Scheele, up to its use as a chemical weapon in the First World War and an ingredient some decades later in the production of pesticides and herbicides. The book demonstrates exemplarily that studies of activities involving material substances can open up new ways to do history – and to teach it. For teaching was an important incentive for this book, which is the product of an ambitious educational experiment at the Department of Science and Technology Studies at University College London, aiming at a full integration of teaching and research at the undergraduate level. The eleven studies contained in the book were put together by five successive groups of undergraduate students, each year's group making improvements and additions to the work of the previous one until publishable essays were produced. An epilogue by Chang vividly describes and discusses the pedagogical agenda of this pilot project.
Each chapter deals with a particular aspect of chlorine, using controversies as an analytical tool to unravel practices and historical actors' understanding of those practices. All the chapters also establish fruitful links among historical, philosophical and sociological questions. Four deal specifically with chlorine as an object of scientific inquiry. These include accounts of chlorine's isolation and the complicated means for identification developed by Scheele during the upheavals of the Chemical Revolution; the debates on the chemical nature of chlorine until around 1820, when chemists reached consensus that it was a chemical element; the struggles to determine the atomic weight of chlorine and their consequences for theories of matter (especially Prout's hypothesis); and a twentieth-century physical experiment involving a compound of chlorine and aiming to detect neutrinos emerging from the interior of the Sun. Throughout, the actors' interpretations of their experimental results are embedded in the concepts and theories of their time. I was particularly impressed by the authors' close reading of texts, their formulation of historically contextualized problems and their critical philosophical questions. Their work demonstrates that the philosophy of science can indeed be very useful for the history of science.
These chapters on the science of chlorine are joined by seven focusing on technological activities involving chlorine and its various practical applications. The issues studied range from the introduction of chlorine bleaching and chlorine disinfection around 1800, to the use of chlorine as a chemical weapon in the First World War (and the subsequent ethical and political debates), to the bizarre story of the ‘chlorine chamber’ and chlorine therapy in the United States after that war, all the way to the military use of chlorine-based herbicides such as Agent Orange in the Vietnam War and the debates following the broad application of DDT and other chlorine-based herbicides and pesticides after 1940. The discussions throughout are sensitive to the obstacles and problems that emerge in transfers of scientific results into useful technologies. In their chapter on ‘Obstacles in the establishment of chlorine bleaching’, for example, the four co-authors argue against a simplified linear model of the technological application of science, showing that there was not only a quite complicated path from the isolation of chlorine to industrial chlorine bleaching, but also a significant difference in accepted bleaching techniques in Britain and France.
Charting the extraordinary ‘life’ of chlorine, this volume is an excellent example of a history of material objects and practices which does not lose sight of their many links with concepts, theories, beliefs and social and economic interests. It is to be hoped that the highly innovative combination of research and teaching behind this volume will stimulate many similar projects.
