Peter Marx's book begins with the story of Harry Domela, the Latvian social impostor who successfully passed as a deposed German crown prince, and later cashed in on his gamble by starring in stage and screen adaptations of his own memoir. Domela's case is a prime example of the performativity of social identity which Marx associates with the ‘theatrical age’ of turn-of-the-century Germany. Marx's book closely resembles recent studies of the American ‘scene’ in the same period by authors like Sabine Haenni (The Immigrant Scene, 2008) and Esther Romeyn (Street Scenes, 2008). The greatest difference between Marx's study and that of his US counterparts is that the German book prioritizes social class where the US studies are more concerned with ethnicity. While all of these scholars interrogate issues of social mobility, Marx's conclusions are much more somber: Haenni and, in particular, Romeyn see the social stage as a playground, whereas Marx seems to view it as a brutal game of chess where the possibilities of movement are strictly circumscribed. The theatre, according to Marx, provides either a carnivalistic pressure valve that enables the perpetuation of social hierarchies, or a liminoid space that leads to final reconciliation with the status quo.
The key concept in Marx's book is the idea of Bürgerlichkeit – that untranslatable noun which means both the middle class itself and middle-class identity – and the transformation which Marx claims it underwent in this period. Marx is tracking the same process of social change that Jürgen Habermas first identified as the dissolution of the public sphere. As in Habermas, consumption (especially the consumption of symbolic goods) becomes the primary mode of ‘performing’ social class. As it becomes more premised on symbols, however, the public sphere itself becomes largely symbolic, and no longer a field of political action. Marx's approach to social theory is complex and syncretic. He pays attention not only to the currently ‘fashionable’ critics, but also to authors of the period he examines, like Georg Simmel and Harry Kessler, who were both critics and products of Marx's ‘theatrical age’. He also uses a variety of visual material, including some striking portraits of different ‘Shylocks’ in the chapter on ‘authenticity’.
The eclecticism of Marx's examples might seem haphazard at first: he treats both classical German drama and the lighter fare of the period (his analysis of Meyer-Förster's Alt-Heidelberg is both original and compelling), both acting and dramatic literature, and all aspects of reception. An explanation of how the examples were chosen might have strengthened Marx's case. Nevertheless, the type of large, complex, ambitious social ethnography which he is attempting justifies the apparent lack of focus. It also means that he looks at a much wider range of examples than other volumes on this period which restrict themselves to the usual modernist suspects – Hauptmann is merely mentioned, and Wedekind is entirely absent. The book combines both a compelling approach to social history and a sophisticated contribution to theatre history.
