Thinking as You Play is intended for piano teachers and students of piano pedagogy and is the product of Sylvia Coats’ many years of experience as a piano teacher and tutor of student teachers. Not surprisingly, Coats is able to tap into a rich store of knowledge and understanding of this many faceted area of musical activity. While the book is strongly rooted in the American teaching tradition and style, its basic tenets are universally valid and worthy of wider consideration. The somewhat prosaic subtitle – Teaching Piano in Individual and Group Lessons – masks the fact that there is also much here that could be of interest to the non-pianist. It is therefore worthwhile giving a short résumé of each chapter.
In the Introduction, Coats clearly communicates her passion for her subject and sets out her aims in writing the book. These are encapsulated in her opening sentence: ‘Our goal as music teachers is to prepare students to understand music and to skilfully play an instrument so they can enjoy music for the rest of their lives’. Following this, she identifies what must surely be a principal goal of all teachers – to guide their students towards independent learning. She then makes a convincing case for the book being a practical guide towards helping teachers not only to be able to identify problems in their students, but also to find solutions that maximise the learning process.
Chapter 2, Lesson Planning, seems oddly placed at the beginning of the book in that its full appreciation requires the reader to be acquainted with topics contained in later chapters. Nevertheless, in some ways it does deserve its place there; in a refreshing bottom-up approach, it conveys principles and strategies that will guide teachers towards effective and individual lesson planning, where decisions are generated by the needs of the pupil, rather than the format of the plan itself. The somewhat formulaic lesson plans now in common use in UK education systems can discourage both individuality and flexibility, rightly advocated by Coats as an integral part of student-centred learning. Dealing as it does with fundamentals, this chapter may give teachers a useful and welcome guide towards managing the all too familiar gap between identifying a problem and actually finding a workable and stimulating way of helping the student to solve it. My main reservation, which applies to some extent throughout the book, is that the examples provided from Coats’ pedagogy and her own students’ experiences do seem unnecessarily numerous and repetitive. This has the effect of interrupting the coherence of the main thrust of the chapter, making it potentially confusing for student teachers outside Coats’ own educational environment, and to some extent de-valuing its potential appeal as a work of general instrumental pedagogy.
Similar presentational problems occur in Chapter 3, devoted to Developing Creativity and again reflecting Coats’ student-centred approach. This chapter does seem very much the material of a pedagogy class and although the able student teacher may well regard its ideas as useful pointers for developing creative work, many will need further support and guidance in order to explore these ideas further. Imaginative techniques and strategies are presented here (often tantalisingly briefly) together with glimpses of supporting psychological principles, but this important topic is covered in relatively few words, with the result that many critical elements are only lightly touched upon.
It is Chapters 4 and 5 that are at the heart of the book and where its real value lies. These chapters are on Musical Concepts and Musical Principles, both described as ‘The Real Basics of Music’. Concepts such as pitch, rhythm, texture, dynamics and tempo are organised methodically and mostly explained in a straightforward way so as to form a very useful teaching resource. The chapter on Musical Principles is perhaps the most advanced from a pedagogical perspective. It advocates recognising the value of a broad perspective of principles such as those pertaining to style, technique, phrasing or musical memory and the specific role of these more overall generalisations as the building blocks for independent learning.
Chapter 6, entitled ‘Designing a Curriculum’, provides no easy answers for those hoping to find a blueprint or outline for a curriculum that would be transferable and instantly useable in their own situation. It is more an exposition of principles that underpin curriculum design, together with examples of how these might work in practice. This chapter seems a little out of place at this point in the book and might sit more comfortably after the chapter on lesson planning. (My own preference would have been to put both these chapters towards the end of the book, logically following the material in the other chapters that is likely to inform decisions associated with planning and design.)
Chapters 7 and 8 (‘Communication between Student and Teacher’ and ‘Learning Styles’) deal with psychological aspects of teaching and should be of great interest to student teachers. These chapters could be confusing to read in that sound psychological theory is at times obscured by retrospective narrative concerning applications in practice. This is presumably intended to clarify, but I do feel that an opportunity has been lost since the topics selected for inclusion, particularly regarding matters of communication, are highly relevant and worthy of expansion. An experienced and perceptive practitioner such as Coats will, by definition, have extensive case studies to call upon, but if illustration is deemed necessary, examples presented as hypothetical rather than autobiographical might give more focus. Readers should persevere, however, since there is sound advice here.
The latter part of the book (Chapters 9–12) is devoted to group teaching. This must be regarded as a valuable contribution to existing literature, which for group instrumental tuition is very limited. Coats suggests in fact that at the time of writing there is no literature available on group teaching, but in the UK both The Associated Board of the Royal Schools of Music (2004) and Trinity Guildhall (2005) have recently published material that specifically addresses this area of teaching. It is now common for pupils to be grouped together for instrumental lessons and the novice teacher really does need a good working knowledge of appropriate strategies and techniques in order to cope with the specific demands of group teaching. Coats suggests a variety of strategies that will be of help to teachers, one of the most useful of which is to plan lessons around concepts rather than specifics, thereby giving flexibility for problem solving. She also maintains a balanced view in that although she stresses the benefits of learning in groups, she fully understands potential areas of difficulty and addresses the detail of these in a way that will reassure the less experienced teacher.
Each chapter is followed by a list of Suggested Reading; certainly a worthwhile addition to the book, but readers may find that not all suggested books and scores are either familiar or readily obtainable outside the USA. There are also suggestions for ‘further thought’. These are well chosen; an excellent way of testing to what extent the preceding material has been absorbed and understood. Student teachers might well find them useful as a focus for reflection and to underpin the development of their own teaching skills and style.
There are many aspects of Sylvia Coats' book that make it a welcome addition to the literature. I do, however, have distinct reservations about the organisation and structuring of material within chapters. While Coats is able to explain often quite complex individual concepts and principles with admirable clarity, the ordering of these does not always seem as helpful as it might be and they are often obscured rather than enhanced by numerous reminiscences of their application with her own pupils. There is undoubted value in a thoughtful pedagogue such as Coats setting down her own experiences, but I do feel that a balance towards expanding her ideas would have made for greater accessibility. One example of this is in the three passing references to Dalcroze Eurythmics, where the one slightly more substantial mention (p. 35) is still very restricted in scope. Further explanation and possibly musical (rather than teaching) examples might have been a more productive way of conveying this and a number of other concepts and strategies throughout the book.
Given that Coats expressly tells us that the book is intended as a work on piano pedagogy rather a book about the pianistic elements of piano teaching, I feel it might have been more satisfactory to have gone a stage further and extrapolated ideology and practice in a more purposefully structured way, unencumbered by experiential narrative. A few well-chosen case studies might then form an Appendix, or even a supporting volume, if the book were to be used as a resource for teaching classes. Musical concepts and principles in themselves are generally logically presented and clearly explained and as such, could form a reliable source of guidance for instrumental teachers. Only a small amount of space is given to specifics of piano technique and most of the book would certainly be more generally applicable. It might then have become a much more significant contribution to the currently limited literature on instrumental pedagogy. While it lacks the organisational coherence necessary for a serious text or reference book, I do recommend Thinking as You Play as an enlightening and often stimulating read.
